12 ms·
Why the Black MacBook Cost More
- Overtonwindow 5y agoThe article seems to be trying to not say it's not market forces, but that's just Apple. Want to increase the value of something? Just put an Apple logo on it and people will think it costs more. Apple marketing is brilliant and disingenuous at the same time.
- jon-wood 5y agoThere was definitely a period over the last five or so years where Apple went back to largely trading on their name and macOS, for laptops. With the M1 they're now firmly back in the realms of shipping significantly better hardware than the rest of the market. The M1 Pro MacBooks are ridiculous - fast, silent, and the battery will comfortably last 10 hours unless you're compiling software non-stop. Throw Apple's industrial design, which is back on form, on top of that and you've got a great machine. The fact it doesn't actually costs significantly more than an equivalently powerful Intel laptop is icing on the cake.
- kyleblarson 5y agoBecause people will pay more?
- jzebedee 5y agoA marginal increase in utility makes it easier to rationalize paying a premium for style.
- ben1040 5y agoSite seems down. https://archive.ph/LmBlM https://archive.ph/LmBlM
- MPSimmons 5y agoYou're not missing much.
- lemax 5y agoWhen I was in middle school a friend gave me a black macbook that she said no one in her house used anymore after my iBook g4 was on its final leg. It was like, the nicest thing ever and I used the hell out of that thing. I was in near disbelief the day she came into school and pulled it out of her backpack, the fact that it was a black macbook.
- gnabgib 5y agotl;dr because Apple felt like it, but they did sweeten the device with a larger HDD https://archive.ph/LmBlM https://archive.ph/LmBlM
- poolpartee 5y agobut it's actually price discrimination. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Price_discrimination https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Price_discrimination
- svnt 5y agoIn the first line it says price discrimination requires different prices in different markets. While I’m sure there are examples of Apple doing this, how is changing the color and charging more for it in the same market an example of price discrimination?
- calebegg 5y agoIt's a definitional distinction. The "black laptop market" is different from the "white laptop market", in much the same way as luxury good markets work (see also: the Apple Watch Edition). It's the same as with haircuts -- women have proven by and large to be willing to pay more for haircuts than men, so women's haircuts cost more, in general. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gender-based_price_discrimination_in_the_United_States https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gender-based_price_discriminat... Price discrimination gets a bad rep because of the name I think, but as Wikipedia points out student discounts are probably the best example and are basically uncontroversial.
- Raineer 5y agoSuch a desperate, veiled attempt.
- shiftpgdn 5y agoI had a black macbook in 2007 which I sprung the extra $200 for because I didn't want to be one of "those people" with a gloss white macbook and the extra $500 for a macbook pro was just too much. It was my daily driver and I got a lot of mileage out of it until 2015 (with some upgrades along the way) or so when I replaced it with a chromebook. I was really hoping this article would have something insightful but it literally just says: "Was this modest storage upgrade worth the $200 premium? Absolutely not; Apple was charging more for the black enclosure because it could."
- crossroadsguy 5y agoSo saying the same thing in an insightful way would have been acceptable? Because that’s literally what it is. One can say “Apple prices are exorbitant”, or “Apple offers its customers a premium and select pricing line”.
- simonlc 5y agoI thought the cpu was faster too?
- Forgeties79 5y agoSame specs except 250gb HDD instead of 160gb which, in my opinion, isn’t something to scoff at in 2007/2008. Overpriced? Sure. But $200 wasn’t exorbitant for the upgrade. The blog dismisses that a little too readily IMO.
- stingraycharles 5y agoYeah my initial thought was “because people are willing to pay more for it”; I’m happy to hear that that was somewhat the conclusion of the article. People are irrational, they value things that don’t necessarily cost more to make, and sometimes even the fact that they need to pay extra for it, is in fact why they want it. I’m reminded of that silly $1000 app in the beginning of the AppStore: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/I_Am_Rich https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/I_Am_Rich
- 5y ago
- onpensionsterm 5y agoA bargain compared to paint colours for cars.
- johnmorrison 5y agoI would pay a huge premium on a current day MacBook Pro if it were black, and not "space grey", metal - even with no additional utility. Why are they all so bright?
- oceanghost 5y agoThis article has some weird colored glasses. I bought the black macbook because IT WAS THE ONLY ONE IN STOCK, the cheaper ones were unavailable anywhere. The thing was initially unstable (bad firmware but apple patched it). I used it for years and then gave it to a friend who used it for a few years and gave it to her sister. I think it literally lasted a decade.
- pram 5y agoI had the black MacBook. Yes the “upgrade” was pretty much just because it looked cool, still does imo. Probably one of my most memorable computers, since I played World of Warcraft on it 10 hours a day for like 3 years lol
- robohoe 5y agoAfter 15 years, my black MacBook is in a closet. I will admit that it's still looking good compared to my spouse's 2007 white MacBook (that we still have). Running Linux on those was painful due to trackpad driver issues :(. Otherwise they would still be doing something in my household.
- paulywog 5y agoAn interesting thing about these trackpads, the hardware was actually pretty bad. It can only move the cursor in the X or the Y axis at any given time, i.e. the hardware does not support diagonal cursor movement. Apple's driver did a great job of masking that with fuzzing and (I believe) predictive movement, that's the reason it seemed good in Mac OS X. But you can even tell in OS X if you're really looking for it! https://ubuntuforums.org/archive/index.php/t-813884.html https://ubuntuforums.org/archive/index.php/t-813884.html
- pjerem 5y agoI wasnt yet using Macs when those macbooks were sold. But I really liked their design. I never got this "premium black" thing because i largely preferred the white one. Really iconic. I'd love if Apple (re)released computers with this design.
- agloeregrets 5y agoAside from the color, The new 14 inch screams late 00's MacBook in-person. It is so subtle but I guess I'm so used to the tapered designs that it is like the uncanny valley, you can see it so clearly. Check the profile vs the G4 Ti: https://forums.macrumors.com/attachments/3e0fffde-93dd-4bb2-919b-3f01aabe3bb0-jpeg.1871375/ https://forums.macrumors.com/attachments/3e0fffde-93dd-4bb2-... And then the Last gen: https://help.apple.com/assets/6062258EBFC7E7487E19DBB0/60622592BFC7E7487E19DBC1/en_US/9ac78cfcac4a18d853406ee013751231.png https://help.apple.com/assets/6062258EBFC7E7487E19DBB0/60622... It is a dramatically different shape.
- jon-wood 5y agoThe new MacBook Pros hark back to those late 00's ones in more ways than just the appearance. You can tell that Jobs' permanent drive for being ever thinner, lighter, and less adorned with ports is finally losing its grip on the pro end of the range. I bought a 14" Pro recently and its so nice to be back in a world where the MacBook Pro is designed to get work done - the keyboard works properly, its got HDMI out, MagSafe is back, and its got a screen proportioned for work rather than watching films.
- microtonal 5y agoYou can tell that Jobs' permanent drive for being ever thinner, lighter, and less adorned with ports More Jony Ive. MacBooks had useful ports during Jobs' reign and several years thereafter (until the MacBook Pro 2015). It's only after Ive left Apple in 2019 that the ports came back (well, in 2021, but products are in the pipeline for a while).
- pjerem 5y ago
- iambateman 5y agoI had the 2008 black MacBook and it was wonderful. Worth every penny. That was the last computer I “loved” to use.
- dkarl 5y agoBecause it looked like a ThinkPad, obviously.
- Stratoscope 5y agoAt least until you opened the lid and searched in vain for the missing TrackPoint!
- timbit42 5y agoThinkPad Different.
- numpad0 5y agoSomehow I remember this to be the answer. First generation of ThinkPad devoid of IBM logo shipped the same year, and the black MacBook sort of signified death of the PC platform which Apple had been competing against.
- jgwil2 5y agoI always thought the white one looked cooler when it was fresh but aged much more poorly than the black one. Same with white sneakers, too much work to keep them icy white.
- unglaublich 5y agoIt's the same with the black Magic Mouse and Magic Keyboard: an extra $20 for the color. Most people will choose the regular silver accessories. That makes the black accessories stand out even more. And as we know, being unique is very valuable in a secular and individualistic time.
- dnissley 5y agoCan't believe no one has mentioned the original black apple laptop - the PowerBook G3. Also crazy to think what $1500 in the original macbook's era (2006-2008) will buy you today. Almost an entry level 14" MacBook pro! ($2000)
- wlesieutre 5y ago$1500 in 2006 is equivalent to about $2100 today, so go ahead and buy that 14" MacBook Pro!
- fetus8 5y agoThose 14" Pros have been known to go on sale for $1750 USD at some larger electronics retailers in the US! I just grabbed one myself.
- zlkjlk43tlkj34 5y ago
- erickhill 5y agoI was really searching for the "Why," since the title implied the article held an explicit answer beyond, "Because."
- raldi 5y agoBetter headline would be, “The black MacBook cost $200 extra in part because it came with $150 of additional storage”
- ents 5y agohttps://web.archive.org/web/20220331154333/https://512pixels.net/2022/03/why-the-black-macbook-cost-more/ https://web.archive.org/web/20220331154333/https://512pixels...
- srvmshr 5y agoThe only bummer of owning a black MacBook was the charging Magsafe unit was still white. It's a (tiny) shame that Apple did not choose to color-coordinate it, like it does nowadays. The contrast was tough sell when considering the 'premium aesthetic' angle Apple was making. It looked pretty cool nevertheless by itself and the size/weight felt quite right. Good old memories of running Snow leopard on it in early grad school days
- mdmglr 5y agoThe white 2006 Intel MacBook was my first Mac. Family members opted for the black one. Personally I never liked the black one. A lot of laptops from that era had cases in shades of black/grey/beige. Apple’s all white glossy case was very unique. However the black case did seem to be less prone to scratches. At certain angles small scratches were very visible on the white case. As the article points out the black model came with more storage but during this era of Apple computers the HDD/RAM was user upgradable. So for me at least the black model was not justified. Both of these models irked me because the plastic used was prone to cracking. The bottom case started forming hairline cracks near the screen hinge/sharp corners. The case had a lot of flex. The screen did not perfectly align with the bottom case. The top cover of the keyboard started cracking off where you’d rest your wrist. I was very happy to replace it with a unibody aluminum design in 2011.
- bovermyer 5y agoI bet a MacBook with a Vantablack or similar exterior would be pretty darn cool.
- bookofjoe 5y agohttps://www.apple.com/shop/product/MM6F3AM/A/polishing-cloth https://www.apple.com/shop/product/MM6F3AM/A/polishing-cloth
- newaccount74 5y agoCorrect me if I'm wrong, but I think it's the only time an Apple product cost more than the same configuration in another color. (Except for the Apple Watch, but they are made from different materials) The Jet black glossy iPhone 7 wasn't available in the cheapest configuration, but it cost the same as the other colors at the configurations it was available in. I think the black glossy iPhone was one of the most beautiful phones Apple has built. It was the closest they got to a truly seamless, monolithic phone. And it didn't have a stupid glass back that always breaks!
- hbn 5y agoThe jet black iPhone 7 was also so insanely scratch-prone that Apple suggested you keep it in a case at all times if you don't want it to scratch[1] I remember seeing reports of people who had micro-scratches all over the back of the phone after a day of use, just from keeping it in their pocket. https://www.theverge.com/circuitbreaker/2016/9/7/12836762/iphone-7-announced-black-scratch https://www.theverge.com/circuitbreaker/2016/9/7/12836762/ip...
- KennyBlanken 5y agoThat's spectacularly impressive given anodizing (done properly) makes aluminum much harder.
- tonyedgecombe 5y ago>Correct me if I'm wrong, but I think it's the only time an Apple product cost more than the same configuration in another color. The space grey versions of the Magic Keyboard and Magic Mouse were more expensive.
- dmicah 5y agoThis actually isn't true, one example off the top of my head is that currently the black Magic Mouse, Magic Keyboard, and Magic Trackpad all cost $20 more than their white counterparts: https://www.apple.com/shop/mac/accessories/mice-keyboards https://www.apple.com/shop/mac/accessories/mice-keyboards
- deleted 5y ago
- weinzierl 5y agoA while ago there was thread that argued (amongst other things) that you must be crazy if you make your product white. It said that white is always more expensive to produce because of more rejects along the whole production chain. It also argued that just because Apple could pull it off you couldn't.
- ftio 5y agoI worked at the Apple Store when these were available. Anecdotally, a lot of people bought the black MacBook because of how it looked. Although I thought both colors were beautiful, the MacBook's screen wasn't ideal. It was highly glossy and had pretty poor viewing angle, especially compared to the MacBook Pro of the time (which was still available with a matte screen on certain models). After using them for awhile, the palm rest on the black model would develop a nasty-looking sheen. The white one suffered from durability issues — the palm rest would chip in the place where the top case met the bottom case. Those issues aside, I remember that time at the Apple Store with extreme fondness, especially the pre-iPhone days. We were slinging iMacs with Parallels and Windows XP to comfort the legions of switchers, all the while reassuring them that, yes, Macs had plenty of great software, even though its library paled in comparison to that of Windows. And, of course, iPods were the cash cow. Funny how things change.
- thom 5y agoYeah, the quality of the plastic was dreadful. I got the black one and my wife got the white one. Out of the box, I still think mine was the most beautiful machine I've ever owned. But my wife's went brown, and both cracked round the edges.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- KennyBlanken 5y agoThe Macbook was a fragile piece of shit, much like the iBook that proceeded it...though the iBook wasn't just fragile, it was also a lemon. Both were built down to a price and it showed, including the creaky, flexing, cheap frame. Dropping the "cheap, shitty version of a Macbook Pro" line was an excellent decision on Apple's part.
- pigtailgirl 5y agomy first experience with apple support came via the black macbook. One day a giant bubble appeared on the outside of the lid it grew and then eventually popped leaving a glossy black layer exposed under it. At that time most people took their laptops to an authorized computer store not apple store - i did- and they refused to do anything because it was physical damage. I was young and didn't complain - just went home and was sad. About a week later someone from Apple called and said they would ship me and new one if I'd agree to send them the damaged one. I agreed, week later a new laptop showed up, I sent the old one right to apple HQ in my country.
- wetpaws 5y agoThe article actually does not explain why black macbook costs more.
- fuzzfactor 5y agoSometimes products cost more to produce so an increased price is based on that. Even for products that are already overpriced, not just merely expensive by nature. Other times a more highly overpriced product is desired for sale. Then specs or (sometimes otherwise hidden) features can be nudged upward to be perceived as justifiable premiums. As long as an appropriate portion of those having higher disposable funds can appreciate that.
- joezydeco 5y agoThe blogger here is 100% positive that the black case material was precisely the same cost as the white material? What Apple engineer gave them this information?
- Raineer 5y agoStephen Hackett worked at Apple. And the cost of the material has nothing to do with the argument. I don't know why you'd imply that it "costs precisely the same", as no two materials would ever be exactly the same. But you don't adjust your pricing 39 cents either direction - you decide on a price based on what people will pay.
- rootusrootus 5y agoShouldn't the answer be obvious? This is Business 101. So many people put real effort into analyzing materials cost and then try to extrapolate that to what a product ought to cost at retail. Aside from situations where the materials are too expensive, they are basically not related.
- ddingus 5y agoYES!! There is a ton that goes into products that goes well beyond materials. I've seen the BOM + retail argument made many times regarding Apple computers. Interestingly, I also hear, "I wish DELLHPLENOVOACER would make a machine that's more like a Mac." And that's what people are paying Apple for!! If DELLHPLENOVOACER were to make a machine more like the Mac, their prices would come up to Apple pricing, and that would happen because delivering a product is more than the BOM materials cost. There is a BOM for hardware and software There is a Bill of Processes And a Bill of Services Often, and should be pretty much always, there is also a Bill of Requirements used for quality and compliance too. Each of these things involves people, who need to get paid so they can continue to exist and show up for work. And they involve processes, materials, information, all of which are required to ship the product as intended. Now, all that said, it's not like the BOM cost markup to retail is wrong. For what I'll call reference, or baseline products, it's often close! Those products are lean and mean, with as few processes and materials and information as possible included. And those products are a good deal for those people who don't need a lot of extras. One example I can think of is the many video signal devices I see on Amazon. Things like VGA to HDMI boxes, for example. I've purchased a few, some being $20 to $30 and others approaching $100. The PCB is almost the same! The cheap ones often leave a feature out, and I can see the components not populated on the PCB. They also come in rock bottom packaging and have plastic cases, connectors that are not reinforced, and on it goes. My more expensive one has a nice metal case, all the features are present, included nice cables, not "will work at least once" cables, was packaged well, and the overall build quality was significantly better. I own an expensive one because the connector work is not good enough on the cheaper ones. I bet the number of BOM items differs by less than 10 percent, yet the product cost difference is 2X plus a little. Quality components vs shoddy ones, or ones that may fail more, or were not quality checked at the source make a big difference in product cost, and that's just one example. This is why Apple computers cost more. Apple simply does not ever ship a rock bottom, stripped down product. Most of the time, they ship exemplary products (in a given product class), and they add a lot of value, and most importantly, they ask that value be funded with purchase price dollars. And in most cases, that value added is reasonable. If it were not, the people would not be buying the products.
- imwillofficial 5y agoThis doesn’t cover the different matte finish or how that could cost more at all. Shallow article.
- adamc 5y agoPretty much an example of Apple being evil and trying to squeeze their customers rather than serve them.
- adamc 5y agoYou can downrate it, but charging more just because you can is not admirable.
- michelb 5y agoIt’s also why the red Magimix appliances are more expensive.
- gnicholas 5y agoThe matte finish was also great because it didn't show scratches like the glossy white case did.
- ianferrel 5y agoI remember that when first released it was possible to configure a white Macbook with the same specs as a black one for $50 less. So you were paying $50 for black, assuming you wanted the stats that were baseline on the black one.
- pwython 5y agoWait until these tech bloggers hear about Rolex, or any other luxury brand having limited color releases marked up higher than the "base model" sharing the same exact components.
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 5y agoBecause Apple produces luxury fashion accessories and not computers.
- skibble 5y agoFascinating take. So I'm typing on a scarf right now? The future is truly wild.
- pwython 5y agoSome people buy watches to simply see what time it is. Some buy 100x more expensive watches that also happen to display the time. All I'm saying is, there's nothing new about a brand marking up variations of their products because they are "limited edition" or whatever. It's just surprising to see the sentiment of some that are shocked that this is even a thing.
- cannam 5y agoWe had a black MacBook at work that was reserved solely for demos. Perfect device for that. Work was a university department, so we would never have bought them for individual employees. I do think the glossy white MacBook was also a pleasing object, more so really than the aluminium ones.
- kelsolaar 5y agoThere is not a single sourced fact in this article giving a reason for the more expensive price beyond the increased storage.
- achairapart 5y agoI really wonder who came up with the black macbook idea/experiment (it was from Jobs?) and especially why it was never replicated again. At least from the people I know, most of them were just happy to spend a bit more for the black model. Maybe Apple was expecting a lot more?
- filmgirlcw 5y agoMy 2007 BlackBook was, I think, my favorite computer of all time. As a college student, it was such a huge upgrade from my previous Sony Vaio (that while beautiful, quite literally burned/discolored/cooked my upper thigh -- it took almost two years for the area to stop being discolored) and I gladly paid the Black Tax, with the justification that it was really just $50 if you compared it to a CTO price with the same size HDD. But honestly, the color WAS worth the price difference for me. To this day, I think the plastic Black MacBook design is just perfect. I will always love the 12" PowerBook G4, but for me, that black plastic is just timeless in a clean and excellent way. A side-effect of the Black Tax was that the cracked palm wrest issue that impacted a lot of white MacBooks, didn't seem to impact the Black models nearly as much (Apple replaced the top component I believe for people with yellowed or cracked palm wrests). As much as I love my 14" MacBook Pro Max, if I could have it in solid black, I would love it (that or bring back the true rose gold color and give it to the Pro machines, cowards!).
- AceJohnny2 5y agoApple follows many of the practices of the fashion industry. For example, the fanfare for announcements of new colors (which are highlighted during keynote announcements, as opposed to being a footnote), and having different sets of colors for different colors. It fits the "luxury consumer electronics" segment they've created (how they've managed to create and maintain that is, I'm sure, a case study in business schools). Charging more for an exclusive color whose only difference is that it costs more is classic fashion business sense. See also, the origin of black pearls as a desirable item, which were originally thought as defective pearls until one savvy person started marketing them as exclusive and expensive. Or also Parmentier making potatoes appealing in France by having his potato patches surrounded by (easily bribable) guards.
- hollander 5y agoWhen I bought my first Macbook in 2009 (the unibody) it had a 160GB harddisk. The 250GB upgrade would cost €150 more I believe. I bought the 160GB version, went to the nearest IT shop and bought a 320GB disk for €120 and got that 160GB as a spare.
- dkjaudyeqooe 5y agoSometimes Apple's overpricing works in your favor. I killed the cdrom in my black MacBook with unfortunate drink spill. Out of warranty, I took it to Apple to get a quote for fixing it, which was a ridiculous $400. I then made a claim on my credit card extended warranty for that amount which they paid and got a free drive from someone and fixed it myself. I remember selling it and overall making a profit on it after 2 or 3 years of use.
- eatbitseveryday 5y agoIf the black were metal, and used as part of the cooling, it might provide better thermals than white.
- tosh 5y agoI remember the white Macbook plastic shell would turn beige and disintegrate after a while. I wonder if the black models had the same issue.
- zekyl314 5y agoI had one of these back in the day and I loved it. I sold it just a few years ago. Still one of my favorites. My one complaint, the white power cord and power brick. Come one apple, you're supposed be a leader in design. I realize cost justification was probably the reason for this.
- killjoywashere 5y agoTesla charged an extra $5k for red paint. The entire jewelry industry and most of the fashion industry exist by upcharging for the look. $50 for black. The US Department of Defense famously reduced eye injuries in Iraq and Afghanistan when they started issuing "stylish eyewear" (1). Most engineers have no idea how much misery they inflict on the world by indulgently claiming that ignoring UX is the higher road. (1) https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/27215881/ https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/27215881/
- UncleSlacky 5y agoI bought one for €25 about 4 years ago. Ironically for an Apple product, it's just about the easiest machine to modify for Libreboot (no need to tinker with RasPis or other hardware): https://libreboot.org/docs/hardware/macbook21.html https://libreboot.org/docs/hardware/macbook21.html Mine's now fully "libre", running Trisquel Lite. If anyone else has trouble installing 64-bit distros on these, this page is useful: https://mattgadient.com/2016/07/11/linux-dvd-images-and-how-to-for-32-bit-efi-macs-late-2006-models/ https://mattgadient.com/2016/07/11/linux-dvd-images-and-how-...
- more_corn 5y agoApologies if swearing is not allowed here but “Because, fuck you. Pay me.” Which seems to be apple’s pricing/product/customer service strategy.
- brailsafe 5y agoIf I was hypothetically in the market for a new Macbook Pro, I'd really like even more colour options than the Air. I'd pay at most $50 - $100 cad more for a really boss colour like the green on the new iPhone, but tbh grey and silver ain't cuttin it, idc how spiffy the internals are. I'd be pretty annoyed if I had to upgrade for some reason, but they still didn't have those options.
- scyzoryk_xyz 5y agoThis article says nothing of value. Certainly doesn’t answer the question “why”