13 ms·
Study conspiracy theories with compassion
- nonrandomstring 5y ago> The societal forces that drive people to join a belief system matter more than the specifics of what they believe. This article by Elżbieta Drążkiewicz is good. It puts far better and with powerful examples, something I have tried to express about the decline of trust in science due to the abuses visited on people through manipulative technologies. It's surprising that many of the anti-vax crowd are well educated, middle class centrists who've just grown jaded with media lies, and also unsurprising when they then dig in deeper in response to being labelled idiots. Any actual scientific arguments vanish into irrelevance in a proxy argument that's really about past lies and injustices and the inability of the interlocutors to demonstrate their good faith. In positive influence you absolutely _must_ acknowledge and take into account people's legitimate grievances and understand why, even when you know your argument to be truthful and benevolent, you get rejected out of hand. My thoughts often turn to the Verbal Judo work of Dr. George Thompson, about letting people have ground to stand on, separating the defensive venting from the objectives you want to achieve. Don't set out to win an argument - keep the other person's best interests foremost. As for Thompson (who was a street cop), as scientists and technologists, whether in medicine, computing or whatever, we ought to recognise that a lot of people are mistrustful and angry about something they think we represent. edit: grammar
- notahacker 5y agoHow much of it is about past lies and injustices though? Are UFOs emblematic of real world suffering? Is there a long list of elections rigged in the US? Are WASPs actually the most victimised social class in the US? The grievances often take weird directions precisely because people's existence is comfortable enough for them to have to manufacture them, or latch onto the grievances of figures they feel affinity with. Superficially, theories of aliens at Roswell pattern match onto real world issues with military secrecy, but that's because of how humans tell stories more than because military secrecy disproportionately hurt people who watched a lot of alien movies. Telling people they're privileged when they feel pretty ordinary or calling them stupid when they're literally just asking questions doesn't help matters, but neither does telling them that yes, actually they really are victims of X on a significant scale but it's not quite like the only people talking about a massive problem with X say it is... And whether the underlying grievances are real or not, the trouble with "Qanon makes a very good point but..." is that not only does it not seem to win many true believers over, but it also seems to encourage lots of people that happen to have legitimate grievances (or feel like they should have some) but haven't paid the strange sounding theories the slightest attention before. Why would you trust the people admitting "yeah actually, we do lie all the time" over the people who have absolute conviction in their outlandish theories? Sometimes you have to keep the best interests of the nonbelievers in mind too.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- myrryr 5y agoEven if you do show compassion, it is usually extremely one directional. Eventually that gets hard to keep doing so, and you just give up on them. I found trying to deal with them with compassion was a cast of setting yourself on fire to keep someone else warm. Sooner or later you just have to leave them to their world views, and just accept that it will go badly for them. As Keith Ng put it "You can't just keep saying we have to acknowledge the hurt and the sense of alienation that the antivax protesters have felt without acknowledging the feelings we have about them A sense of betrayal - the idea that a national project to defend ourselves is being actively undermined by them, for either entirely crazy or entirely unexplained ("it's my choice") reasons. A sense of threat - they used violence and intimidation to assert their power. A sense of provocation - when they keep insisting that we are stupid, cowardly, blindly obedient sheeple, that they are the smart ones, the brave ones, the ones who are truly free, yeah, that makes me angry. The Big Clean-up was my way of addressing that anger and frustration without giving into it. That anger is unproductive, but it's not unwarranted. And it needs to be acknowledged, every bit as much as the protesters' feelings of hurt, isolation and abandonment. But when you acknowledge their feelings and not ours, say that theirs is legitimate at some level then be silent on ours, and not acknowledge all the things that they've done that have led us to this place of anger - that's not reconciliation, that's digging the hole deeper. "
- saiya-jin 5y agoI agree with this - its a very good approach generally to 'meet in the middle' during a conflict, but that becomes very hard when one side is scientific and another is pure outright lies, wishful thinking, fears and generally mostly negative emotions which seemingly many adults have issues managing. Same would go say for Ukraine invasion - from moderate 'alternative truth' folks weakly defending russian invasion as 'forced by the west'. I would require so much mental gymnastics to accept this as some middle ground it would break my proverbial mental neck. Entire pillars of progress of what mankind achieved till 21st century included need to be abandoned to find middle ground in such cases. Just because some folks can't handle their emotional side of their being which can be very easily used to steer them (well anybody in such situation) as needed. You want to have productive discussion with somebody like me? Let's bring out the facts, proven, peer-reviewed if possible. There is no 'alternative truth', just alternatives to truth.
- servytor 5y agoOkay, but when I claim that Dwarf Fortress teaches you how to manage artificial complexity of Japanese electronics people still get upset.
- derbOac 5y agoI've come to be disgusted by the term "conspiracy theory" in ways I used to not be. It's overused now and seems now to serve mainly as a sort of rhetorical power or status assertion. Someone's fears or beliefs are labeled "conspiracy" if they contradict some normative belief held by a dominant group with which the speaker identifies. I've noticed this on the conservative as well as liberal spectrum. What's changed my mind is realizing how often things that might be labeled as conspiracy theory actually happen. Even if something didn't happen, many of the fears are actually well grounded and labeling them as such in my opinion reflects a certain amount of lack of empathy on the part of the labeler. I'm not saying certain beliefs aren't absurd or physically implausible etc. But if they are plausible they're often coming from somewhere reasonable. Widespread conspiracy theories tell you that a large segment of the population doesn't trust something, and the appropriate response is to figure out why that thing might be untrustworthy. I agree with the linked article, and understand that they are writing to a specific audience. But it has a patronizing tone that I think just reinforces the problems involved. If there's a widespread conspiracy belief, it's not enough to say to have "empathy" for someone who holds it, as that casts the problem as being with the person rather than the things that caused them to lose trust to begin with. You need to be asking why such large parts of the population distrust the subject of the conspiracy and address that.
- aaaaaaaaata 5y ago> Someone's fears or beliefs are labeled "conspiracy" if the labeler doesn't understand the difference between conspiracy and conspiracy theory.
- nonrandomstring 5y ago> If there's a widespread conspiracy belief, it's not enough to say to have "empathy" for someone who holds it, as that casts the problem as being with the person rather than the things that caused them to lose trust to begin with. I much agree with the article on how to deal with individuals arguing from a mistrustful position, but your insight that this doesn't deal with a problem on a societal level makes sense. What has caused so much mistrust on a broad nebulous scale? Civil war and slavery are not unique of course, and every nation carries its traumas of war and disaster. But the American collective psyche is unique in relation to a series of events starting in the late 60s that seem somehow connected - Kennedy, Watergate, Vietnam, Chile, Cuba, Afghanistan, Iraq, 911, Snowden... What links these is a strong perception of betrayal by government that has failed in its duty through corruption and preference for private power interests. It is to the credit of American people that they have courage for sceptical introspection and aim to hold government to account. But something else has happened. Now, because the US plays such a big role in replication of culture, a paranoia, which is practically dyed into Hollywood output (X-Files, Enemy of the State, JFK etc) reaches around the world. Somehow this needs treating separately from there being, in reality, in actual fact, both an increase in corruption due to global financialisation and technology, as well as a much greater awareness of extant, quiescent skulduggery due to the internet. And there is one more layer to add now. That some agencies in the world, deliberately fanning the flames of mistrust and division for political gain, have their power amplified by digital technology. One has to wonder, what event would restore trust in competent and benign government? Is there such a thing as therapy for a whole culture?
- suction 5y agono
- Pearse 5y ago>Please don't post shallow dismissals, especially of other people's work. A good critical comment teaches us something. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- suction 5y agoYou need to up your linguistics game. The fact that I answered with a simple "no" instead of giving a reason in itself has a meaning.
- RGamma 5y agoA related key problem: "The amount of energy needed to refute bullshit is an order of magnitude larger than is needed to produce it." -- https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Brandolini%27s_law https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Brandolini%27s_law I also like this excerpt: "In his 1786 Letters on Infidelity, George Horne writes that: Pertness and ignorance may ask a question in three lines, which it will cost learning and ingenuity thirty pages to answer. When this is done, the same question shall be triumphantly asked again the next year, as if nothing had ever been written upon the subject. And as people in general, for one reason or another, like short objections better than long answers, in this mode of disputation (if it can be styled such) the odds must ever be against us; and we must be content with those for our friends who have honesty and erudition, candor and patience, to study both sides of the question."
- jim-jim-jim 5y agoSince being wrong is so low impact, we should have no problems entertaining crazy ideas then. Midwit Redditors who derive an inordinate amount of satisfaction from being correct all the time are ultimately stunted by their pride. When you've got a big beautiful brain, you understand that thinking is free and there's literally nothing wrong with shotgunning every schizo theory you come across and letting things work themselves out.
- slim 5y agoI think I have a better understanding of conspiracy and conspiracy theory thanks to covid. A conspiracy theory starts with a group of people who has more knowledge than everybody else. This makes the actions of the group look strange and suspicious to another group of people who have reasons to believe that this group is hiding information on purpose and start building theories about the strange behavior they observe. Notice that nobody need to be malicious or anything, and hiding information on purpose is very common. For example if you use a PR firm to get journalists to write about your startup, you are effectively conspiring with the PR firm and the journalists.
- encryptluks2 5y agoReminds me of my doctor that told me that if you take a human tooth and leave it in soda overnight that it dissolves. I'm thinking to myself that sounds like BS. Went home, looked it up and sure enough it is a myth. According to your theory the doctor has more knowledge than me and I shouldn't question what they tell me. I've had several similar experiences from multiple doctors that told me things that were flat out wrong. According to you, people that have been misled by doctors including medical malpractice, and the government performing illegal experiments should all be disregarded that and we should just immediately trust a power structure of people just repeating whatever they were led to believe. Don't get me wrong, there are actual scientists doing the work but that doesn't mean that people don't have an agenda.
- ahartmetz 5y agoThe thing about the tooth isn't completely wrong, though. There is acid in most soda and it does destroy teeth if you leave them in it, just more slowly (source: highly scientific experiments on YouTube).
- encryptluks2 5y agoA lot of conspiracy theories aren't completely wrong either.
- andi999 5y ago
- MrYellowP 5y agoWhat a bullshit propaganda this is. I'm also missing a list of all those so called conspiracy theories which turned out to be true. "Fake News is what we tell you! Conspiracy Theories are what we tell you! Believe The State! Don't trust your eyes, ears and common sense!"
- Pearse 5y agoI've read your comment a few times and I'm not sure I understand what you are saying. In the article she talks about people being suspicious of science or other authorities. She says its that lack of trust that we need to deal with not the difference in opinion. And you seem to be saying, this is bulls*it, I don't trust this person? Have I misunderstood your comment or the article?
- _Nat_ 5y agoApparently the parent-commenter believes that the article is propaganda meant to discredit conspiracy-theory. Regarding: > I'm also missing a list of all those so called conspiracy theories which turned out to be true. They probably meant to suggest that the article is obviously unbalanced as it's consistently critical of conspiracy-theories, without offering a list of counter-examples of conspiracy-theories that turned out to be true.
- Pearse 5y agoThat makes sense, thank you.
- MrYellowP 5y agoAuthorities. Who declares themselves to be one? Who are we supposed to trust? Why should we trust someone who does not earn it? Why should we trust anyone who governs us, when there is no evidence that they are to be trusted? Why should I trust "science", when "science" in any big-scale-context only means that those who govern us control what "science" is/means/gets attention? Why should I not trust my own ability to analyse and deduct what is, and is not the closest to the truth? It's not my fault that I'm literally surrounded by literal idiots. Mate. You don't understand. You have to look at all of this from a meta perspective. Most of the bullshit you get to read is propaganda simply because it is meant to steer your thinking into certain directions. It's not just about "lies", or "omission of truth/detail", it's also about you thinking only about what you're supposed to be thinking about. This includes things you read which are meant to distract from other things. Examples? By whom's authority are people declaring themselves authority, which includes the self granted privilege of telling us what is true and real? By whom's authority are those, who are being declared authority, more authority than those who disagree with them? 99% of the people reading this post will be too stupid to even consider that they could just look up a list of actually proven conspiracy-"theories" and that's not because I'm the one supposed to be doing it for them, but because they're so submissive to __authority__, they think high of themselves when it comes to those who have time and time again proven that thinking critically is the only sane way to go. If you actually were a critical thinker, as you *MOST LIKELY BELIEVE OF YOURSELF*, then you would NEVER dismiss anything at all just because a self declared authority tells you! You would INSTEAD seek out the opposing opinions. You would seek understanding of why opposing voices, regardless of experteese, are always being ridiculed and socially shunned, instead of critically listened to. So, to end this post ... We ABSOLUTELY need to deal with the difference in opinion! The difference in opinion is what makes sure that ... *... we don't all think the same!* Our core problem is that 99% of the people do not think critically at all and are seriously just mindless morons parrotting what's being presented to them on a massive scale. A lie only has to be repeated often enough until it is being accepted as truth! Get it now?
- nathansherburn 5y agoAs someone who's spent a bit of time dealing with fringe views, this take resonates with me. It's a nice companion piece to this: https://astralcodexten.substack.com/p/a-modest-proposal-for-republicans https://astralcodexten.substack.com/p/a-modest-proposal-for-... tl;dr Trump's power came from the fact that he was a big "fuck you" to smart and cultured people. His voters were sick of being looked down on and treated like shit.
- drunkpotato 5y agoSome of his voters were sick of feeling like they were looked down on and treated like shit, a message that was repeatedly amplified and propagandized. It’s an important distinction. Perception is not reality. Are there “coastal elites” who look down on “flyover country?” Sure. No group is perfectly free of prejudice. It works the other way too; I have family that sneer at educated idiots, latte drinking city liberals and so on. Try to keep in mind, who or what is emphasizing and amplifying these fault lines, and why? Why is it important to keep insisting on binary labels and othering? From keeping people angry and, thus, engaged?
- bittercynic 5y agoSome of the messaging that stuck with me was more focused on "flyover country" being forgotten by the coastal elites, and I think that message resonated with people because it taps something very real. It seems plausible to me that trade liberalization has contributed to the rising wealth of Americans living near the coasts while simultaneously damaging large parts of the economy in the middle of the country. I do believe trade liberalization has important benefits, and may even contribute to increasing the total wealth of the planet and alleviating extreme poverty, but that doesn't mean we shouldn't be aware of the costs, and to mitigate damage and ensure that huge swaths of the country aren't insulted in the process.
- WaxedChewbacca 5y agoA creepy and arrogant suggestion that's actually a sterling example of the main problem over on the non-"conspiracy theory" side: the assumption that they are correct combined with a complete unwillingness to talk about specific topics and specific objectively existing artifacts. Pretending to be nice and reasonable as a cover for intellectual dishonesty and ignorance of the arguments on the other side. Have you read Peter Duesberg's "Inventing the AIDS Virus?" No? It'll take you 10s to find the PDF. Engage with that, and then we'll have something to talk about. Don't just look down your nose like I'm crazy while refusing to listen.
- historia_novae 5y ago[flagged]
- asimpletune 5y ago> pushing a drug that was obviously not working What do you mean by not working? It seems that the two choices are a.) getting covid and building some immunity or b.) getting a covid vaccine and getting some immunity, in the end a and b both provide some immunity. To me the downsides of a are clear, but I'd be interested in hearing why you think there are no upsides to b. > remember the lab leak hypothesis? I'm not expert but I think the most recent thing I heard about the origins of COVID is that is some natural origin is back on the table as the most likely scenario. > definition of vaccine was modified to fit that new drug Please tell me if I'm mistaking what you mean, but I don't think the definition of a vaccine was modified? Instead I think the public had a working lay definition, based on the success of previous vaccination efforts. I think the definition was always something like a medicine that enhances immunity against a disease. > The whole thing is sickening. This I agree with, but for me it's been more that people start with conclusions, work backwards to find evidence, and then call it research.
- rascul 5y ago> > definition of vaccine was modified to fit that new drug > Please tell me if I'm mistaking what you mean, but I don't think the definition of a vaccine was modified? Instead I think the public had a working lay definition, based on the success of previous vaccination efforts. I think the definition was always something like a medicine that enhances immunity against a disease. The CDC did modify their definitions of "vaccine" and "vaccination" on their web site, and some people have taken that to mean various things. I think it was changed early May, 2021. https://www.cdc.gov/vaccines/vac-gen/imz-basics.htm https://www.cdc.gov/vaccines/vac-gen/imz-basics.htm https://web.archive.org/web/20210412182439/https://www.cdc.gov/vaccines/vac-gen/imz-basics.htm https://web.archive.org/web/20210412182439/https://www.cdc.g...
- ComradePhil 5y agoThere is so much wealth and power inequality in the world, why would there not be active conspiracies by the rich and powerful? They are confirmed every now and then. The elites vilify and ridicule conspiracy theories precisely because some of them are or will be true. In a healthy world, they would be welcomed.
- vt85 5y ago[dead]
- ahartmetz 5y agoMost conspiracy theories are too vulnerable to the usual screwups that happen in the real world (a large group needs to keep a secret for a long time), others are too obviously contradicted by things that we really know to be true. The few where that isn't so are worth consideration.
- peteradio 5y ago"It's too hard to keep it under wraps therefore it doesn't seem likely" seems kind of ridiculous in the face of all that man has accomplished.
- BiteCode_dev 5y agoConspiracy theories are interesting: - they show you which parts of society inspire distrust (COVID is more a trust crisis than a health one IMO). - they can show a lot of creativity (lizard people, come on!). - they may point at something that will turn out to be in need of examination (remember before snowden how the gov spying on everyone was tinfoil hat BS?). - they force public debate, and raise attention to important questions (e.g: how social network apps influence our society). A like the article says, they show you in which way people secretly suffer. And that deserves compassion.
- eterm 5y ago> remember before snowden how the gov spying on everyone was tinfoil hat BS? No, not at all. Before Snowden people regularly talked about the government spying on everyone, we just didn't know any details of how it worked. I remember there was absoultely no shortage of discussion among conspiracy theorists and regular people alike about "echelon" in the nineties for example. Pretending that everyone thought the government was innocent and not spying on everyone before the Snowden leaks is an attempt to rewrite history and place a false narrative.
- BiteCode_dev 5y agoWe were a minority discussing it, and if you brought it at a diner table you would have been the definitly labelled as paranoid. I think you are the one rewritting history here.
- _teyd 5y agoI’m not sure. I also definitely remember everyone thinking that it was very likely the government was spying internally also. The scale was a surprise, but not that spying happened internally. It was quite in the popular culture as well, with shows like X-Files and movies like Hackers and Sneakers and others touching on it. It was anyway for sure not limited to Art Bell types.
- 5y ago
- revskill 5y agoConspiracy theory is similar on how we're debugging until we find out the root cause. It's the nessessary skill every developer needs to actually learn how to debug software.
- tremon 5y agoI disagree. Debugging starts from a (usually testable) problem statement and then tries to narrow down to the root cause. Conspiracy theories start from a (usually untestable) assumption based on convencience and then try to expand the root cause until the whole world is against them.
- bob2222 5y ago[dead]
- olivermarks 5y ago'The societal forces that drive people to join a belief system matter more than the specifics of what they believe.' This is unalloyed nonsense and the commonly used ploy of implying anyone with an inquiring mind is in some way a weak minded person easily influenced and desperate to join like minded souls. One persons 'conspiracist' is another persons investigative journalist...
- _def 5y agoGreat article. I think this is an super important statement: > I understand and share concerns that a more empathetic approach has risks. In my impression trying to understand people to make everything better for everyone is definitely the harder way, and therefore often dismissed by people. For most of the time no one will thank you for doing something that way, and still this is what we need the most imho.
- FinanceAnon 5y ago> For most of the time no one will thank you for doing something that way That's still would be a good outcome. More likely, is that conspiracy theories would appear about that person's work and they would start facing abuse. You could cure cancer, and there would be a number of people who would hate you for it. You just can't make everyone happy.
- lordnacho 5y agoConspiracy theories are the price of freedom. Either we crack down on whatever the government thinks is wrong, and then they either get it right or they use it to push their own propaganda, or we let people say whatever they want and allow that some people can't figure out the facts. We could go after flat earthers, burn their books, and imprison their prophets. There wouldn't be many flat earthers if we did that. But we would probably also be oppressing people who have the wrong opinions about how to run the economy, along with a number of other issues.
- donatj 5y agoI’ve never understood the whole thing about “conspiracy theories” being an existential “threat to democracy”. People voting based on their beliefs is the definition of democracy. The argument that people believing things you believe are wrong is a threat to democracy is the actual danger here. Make a better case for what you believe. To your point they are literally saying freedom of belief is a threat to democracy, I don’t think they actually want democracy.
- FinanceAnon 5y agoLet's say that you live in a democratic country, where over hundreds of years you regularly hold democratic elections. One day, a new presidential candidate says that if he wins, he will turn this country into a totalitarian state - this country will never have another democratic election and a chance to vote him out. 51% vote for him and he wins. Is that fair or a loophole in democracy? A lot of conspiracy theories these days are anti-West and anti-democracy.
- lordnacho 5y agoWell if we're right about the free and open society being better, they won't vote that way. Of course it can and has happened. You have to ask yourself whether those societies were actually free and open, which I know sounds like a cop-out.
- 5y ago
- donatj 5y ago> Another counterproductive tendency, in my view, is the quest to create a profile of ‘those people’ who engage with conspiracy theories, obsessing over characteristics that make them distinct — especially from the researcher. This othering is, in part, a legacy of a field that has frequently opted to study people drawn in by, say, fantastic stories of alien abductions You know why people don’t trust science? It’s this, the whole article should be about this and not a footnote at the end. It’s condescension, belittling and othering. You don’t get people to believe you and trust you by treating them like they are stupid for not already doing so. Particularly not people on the right, where respect is of more value than social acceptance. You start a conversation with insulting them, why would they listen to anything else you have to say?
- _Nat_ 5y agoSeems like a rough thing for folks who'd want to promote social-unity. Because scientists work by aggressively cutting down bad ideas. The basic mindset calls for being efficient-and-ruthless in identifying-and-eliminating low-quality thinking. If the world were a simpler place where there wasn't much complexity to deal with, then presumably scientists could afford to move along at a slower, more polite pace that doesn't leave anyone behind. But in a complex world where every answer just leads to more questions, scientists simply can't afford to show respect to bad ideas -- even if they would otherwise want to be respectful to others. The result seems to be social-fragmentation: there's not just one cohesive social-group that involves everyone, but rather differing groups with differing standards. This can then be a problem for social-mobility. Because, personally, I like the idea where groups are accessible; for example, I like the idea that anyone who's willing to adopt a scientific-mindset could do so, without barriers-to-entry keeping them out. However, if other folks tend to find scientific-thought caustic and degrading, then this same openness would seem to expose other groups to scientific-thought even if they don't like it, possibly promoting animosity. Worse, this problem isn't simply dichotomous, but rather occurs many times over. For example, not all scientists are working on the same level; there's a lot of fragmentation within the scientific-world, too. A funny consequence of this can be that scientists would reject more advanced science, too. For example, folks around Newton's time might've found ideas from quantum-mechanics and general-relativity to be absurd.
- Epiphany21 5y agoMy main gripe with articles like this is the use of the term "conspiracy theory" in supposedly serious research articles and papers as a derogatory blanket label for everything that's false or unpopular, or merely disagreeable to the author. I know the author means well here but I think it provides a very frail framework for explaining the underlying issues behind vaccine refusal in Ireland or anywhere (yes, refusal, not "hesitancy"). Dismissive and inflammatory wording prevents effective appeals to anyone on the other side of the fence. If something is false, please just say it's false and provide your evidence and/or reasoning.
- lngnmn2 5y agoBut only on your own funds. No taxpayers money for abstract bullshit. You missed the whole putin hair-splitting abstract bullshit.
- nova22033 5y agoMaybe you should lookup what the infowars crowd did to the parents of the kids who died at Sandy Hook.
- temptemptemp111 5y ago
- gverrilla 5y agoIt's only natural conspiracy theories exist: a lot of people don't believe academy anymore, because it sold itself to the market, which cares mostly only about profit, and also they have very poor education which is reinforced by distasteful ill-informed video content mostly (and also reddit). Absurd unlogical theories are the consequence. But they are always rooted in inadaptation/opression/fear.
- teekert 5y ago"Let me be clear: I am in no way arguing that conspiracy theories are harmless." This annoys me. As was the case with the pervasive NSA spying pre-Snowden (your phone can listen in!) and early Covid lab-escape hypotheses, "conspiracy theories", can also simply be true (or likely), and denying them is harmful. Read "Confessions of an Economic Hitman" for example, and you'll get another look on "conspiracy theories" and what the USA as a country is willing and capable of doing. Strange that this angle is not covered in this piece. By not acknowledging this you are pushing people with non-mainstream hypotheses even further away, it is indeed counterproductive. Simply defining conspiracy theories as theories that are not true or not held by the majority is too simple and an impossible definition.
- tough 5y agoThe real conspiracies, are just unproven yet conspiracy theories, and they are just not proven/known enough about because they will kill anyone trying to expose them. or shut them down. The rich rule the world. They do not answer before anyone. They can start wars, profit from them, and then get to be peacemakers. They get to pay less taxes, even if they earn much more than regular citizens. See current forms of governments, which is mostly a parody of choice between red/blue team, and with the only expectancy of each team -looking- for each other. They're the same thing. In the US you can legally -lobby- someone in congress or whatever into doing what you want. That's called bribery everywhere else... All the bull shit is there so the fog is bigger and the real shit can't be prosecuted or condemned. Divide et impera, as long as they can feed us bullshit to divide us against ourselves, they won't be the target.
- alephr 5y agoIs there any story you can't justify with this reasoning?
- DaltonCoffee 5y agoPick two: Justice, rich people, America (see Will Smith)
- alephr 5y agoWhy do you think this is a response to my question?
- legulere 5y agoYou mean real conspiracies. They usually get to the public as it’s impossible to keep everyone’s mouth shut. People usually don’t do much though when things come out. But you’re right that the rich are often above the law.
- tough 5y agoYeah you're right, fixed it in the parent. Thanks
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 5y agoI just got a Qanon postcard in the mail today: https://www.wcvb.com/article/qanon-postcards-delivered-in-boston-usps-response/39609842 https://www.wcvb.com/article/qanon-postcards-delivered-in-bo...
- fithisux 5y agoBlah blah blah
- MrAwesome 5y agoFolding Ideas on YouTube put out a documentary on YouTube which I think is a great example of this approach (complete with a nifty and thorough visual experiment on the roundness of the Earth, and a still-topical plot twist halfway through): https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JTfhYyTuT44 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JTfhYyTuT44
- motohagiography 5y agoImportant to almost recognize it's on institutions and the people in them to be trustworthy, and yet - not. I also know Romanian ex-pats who would not get vaccinated for similar reasons stated in the article. I would even take it further, where the prime minister in canada called people racists and sexists for not trusting his mandate policies, and as hallucinatory as that seemed, he was accurate for potentially the wrong reasons. What makes him and his cabinet untrustworthy are that they do not represent or signal virtues that are known to be trustworthy in western culture. Everything about them is an artifact of power narratives that people from the traditional culture interpret as "fake." As an example, the PM himself is an actual actor, a cultural symbol that means "do not trust, this is an act." But this is the divide in society, where the old way of thinking is that there is distance between the represented and the real, where the new progressives have only the represented and power. The reason we have "conspiracy theories," is that the people in instutions are in fact not trustworthy, and interestingly, they may even agree enthusiastically with that statement, because trustworthiness itself is a traditional and patriarchical concept. In the progressive view, requiring administrators to be trustworthy means requiring them to conform to traditional identities with trust signals relative to a culture they have been educated to dissolve for progress. When we talk about racism and "whiteness," it's not biological or actual skin colour, it's an abstraction or umbrella to describe the culture that is the target of criticism in marxist theory, wherein white still represents the Whites and the traditional society being dissolved, but intersectional identities are the new Red. Conspiracy theories are the expression of mistrust of elites who are not recognized as legitimate (honest, trustworthy, annointed, etc.) because they do not conserve, reflect, or preserve the culture of the people. Elites and their allies can't say this part out loud, but they don't care, because yes, they are making permanent change, so you are either a part of the change, or you are the subject of the change. Conspiracy theorists are in fact very accurate in placing their mistrust, because if they value stability and continuity of their culture and see their elites as not reflecting their values, and so they are a reaction to the change - hence they are the direct targets of change agents. In this sense, yes, if you demand that they be trustworthy, they are absolutely out to get you. A lot of conspiracy theories are dumb, and many are even invented as confusion and chaff to prevent people from aligning to a coherent belief or truth that would politically activate them. However, if you have an intellectual understanding of power and politics, you understand what should be mistrusted. If you want to understand the mechanism, what is actually happening is a new progressive elite is politically activated, and spending its effort on keeping any conservative resistance effectively neutralized using aggression, deception, and confusion to install levers for permanent change (read:control). Theory is neutralizing, and so spreading it means clouding discourse and making people give up on any truth that they could organize around and resist the change from this small cadre who are activated. That is, so that good men do nothing.
- kazinator 5y agoI'd say, firstly know what "conspiracy theory" is. Not everyone who disagrees with a mainstream hypothesis is believing in a conspiracy. Example, hmm. OK, I got one. The idea that the WTC buildings were blown down with explosives is not a conspiracy per se. The terrorists could have done that. To be a conspiracy, you need some wacky element, like the US government itself was behind it. "Conspiracy" isn't a synonym for "unlikely" or "false".
- funstuff007 5y agoWhat's most famous example of what was once considered a "conspiracy theory" by the elites, but in the end turned out to be true (or largely true)?
- carapace 5y agoI'm not sure it's exactly what you're looking for, but MK-Ultra? Or the Tuskegee Syphilis Study. Those are the kind of things that you would never believe really happened but did. Robert Anton Wilson points out that over half of the regime changes in the 21st century happened as the result of some kind of coup. By that measure conspiracy is the norm.
- MildlySerious 5y ago> What's changed my mind is realizing how often things that might be labeled as conspiracy theory actually happen. Part of the reason this happens is that the people who are constantly peddling conspiracies say whatever they can spin together from today's news, even if it contradicts itself from one sentence to the next. The Venn diagram of people who said COVID doesn't exist, COVID came from a lab to depopulate the planet, COVID is a ploy to steal Trump's presidency and COVID is just the flu is pretty much a circle. Now that one of these claims is getting some more serious consideration they go around saying "I told you so", patting themselves on the back and using their supposed early insight to add weight to the next round of fabrications, completely neglecting the fact that you would have had to ignore 95% of what they said. A coin toss would be a more credible source, but they were "right" so who cares anyway. I don't want to speak for the conspiracy as a singular, but these clusters of conspiracies, most notably Q/anon, are just an amalgamation of weaponized cherry-picking, contrarianism and new-age gullibility, not to mention thinly veiled fascism.
- kkfx 5y agoHonestly such publication is not something to show on Nature website. Narrative exists since ever, some people have observed some others and discover common patterns to bend those others wills, that's nothing new, the term and the meaning "conspiracy theory" is just a way to label adverse narratives, the official is named "pravda" or "the real truth" or "facts checked contents" etc. What it matter is: - identify patterns that push so many following narrative, not just to abuse/steer them but also to moderate all narratives in public to avoid dangerous paths; - learn to reason, teach to reason. For instance we read about something depicted as really good and something else depicted as really bad. Do we just follow written emotions or we analyze the writing trying to imagine those written thing in reality? Unfortunately essentially no "élites" or "common people" want that, the first just because they need to label adverse narrative, but they do want "common people" trust their own; the seconds just because facing truth and trying to determine is something can be true or false demand effort and might be unpleasant to a point so many prefer follow one who promise the Paradise on Earth in a snap of his/she's fingers than someone who say "we need to face harsh situations and work toward a better future for years". However, people of culture, who happen to gravitate around Science should and MUST be not of the same kind of the above mentioned cohorts...