12 ms·
Meta suspends Netherlands data center due to political pushback
- belval 5y ago> "This is a purely political decision," Dutch Data Center Association managing director Stijn Grove said in a reaction sent to Reuters, adding that it had been made "largely because it is Facebook." Conflicts with > After the local council approved the project, party Leefbaar (Liveable) Zeewolde ran on a platform of opposition to the data center, citing environmental concerns and a lack of local input. But then Facebook's response seems pretty reasonable to me: > “We strongly believe in being good neighbors, so from day one of this journey we stressed a good fit between our project and the community is foremost among the criteria we consider when initiating and continuing our development processes,” Meta said in a statement. To me all parties involved seemed pretty reasonable, the previous administration was favourable to the project, but got subsequently voted out of office. Now they just want time to make sure that they didn't get voted out because of that project. Facebook seems to understand.
- hetspookjee 5y agoThat data center association is just a huge lobby front. Just the website in itself is a hilarious joke and a complete cherrypicked representation of some numbers. Good luck finding any numbers there that may possible harm their case. This data center is ridiculous beyond belief in Dutch aspects and that is even got this far in voting is solely due to the prime ministers choice to push these responsibilities toward local municipalities, a village of 30k inhabitants deciding if a power consumer equivalent of 700k inhabitants would fit in their region. The way they Facebook made their case was a joke too as they, just like Google and Microsoft argued there’d be many job opportunities and rest warmth.In addition they argued they needed to have an exception to be added to the power net which is already massively overburdened and lagging, just for the sake that the reigning party can appease their consumer. Even Eric Wiebes, the then minister of economics, meddled in this business in favour of “getting it done”. In the end our prime minister Mark Rutte who was from the same party also started to chime in to move things forward. That this was shot down was only because, indeed, the entirety of the Netherlands was against this data center and the local municipality elections came by and destroyed all the parties that voted in favour. All of a sudden the powerless Huge de Groot found a way to block this thing. It is more than a political decision but that this got blocked in the end does move me slightly away from the extreme cynism that is most apt as view on the whole of the Netherlands policital theater.
- belval 5y agoTo me that's just the system working as intended, if people voted against it then that's that.
- Dylan16807 5y ago> that is even got this far in voting is solely due to the prime ministers choice to push these responsibilities toward local municipalities, a village of 30k inhabitants deciding if a power consumer equivalent of 700k inhabitants would fit in their region. I don't see why that's a problem? > added to the power net which is already massively overburdened and lagging Is that being worked on? Is there a reason the electrical payments from the datacenter couldn't be used to make the power network net better? Charge them a higher rate for the first x years if necessary.
- colinmhayes 5y agoI think a large part of the problem is that they're building renewable power as fast as they can, but are still heavily reliant on Russian gas for electricity. So building this data center would increase their reliance on Russia.
- brianwawok 5y agoSo where does the data center go instead? Is that country not reliant on Russia?
- clem 5y agoIt's Meta's responsibility to justify the existence of their data center. It's not any country's responsibility to host it.
- hetspookjee 5y agoDenmark as that was their secondary location i belief.
- Dylan16807 5y ago
- reacharavindh 5y ago> largely because it’s Facebook. Yes. If all the sorely needed renewable energy were to be used for something useful,there wouldn’t be this much opposition. Using it for doom scrolling, ads, and waste of time - sure sane people are against it. I’m happy that people see through the bullshit for once. IMO, They should be allowed in only if they produce 100% of the renewable energy they could consume. Let Facebook pay the millions in windmills and solar panels, and sure, they can be part of the society.
- user_7832 5y ago> To me all parties involved seemed pretty reasonable, the previous administration was favourable to the project, but got subsequently voted out of office. Now they just want time to make sure that they didn't get voted out because of that project. Facebook seems to understand. I'm assuming your comment is in good faith, and you're not from Facebook's PR team. I don't think you're aware of the history of the case. Local opposition to the project is nothing new - starting with how Facebook hiding its identity with the locals. The full list of reasons is much more than I can comfortably type, I'd recommend reading this wired article instead - https://www.wired.com/story/facebook-dutch-data-center/ https://www.wired.com/story/facebook-dutch-data-center/
- mistrial9 5y ago
- stingraycharles 5y agoAs a Dutch person, one of my biggest concerns with this datacenter is its green energy usage; from what I understand, it’s going to use up a huge portion of all the green energy we managed to build the last years. The datacenter is huge: 166 hectares. To me, if that concern is addressed, I would be ok with it (a more suitable location would be nice though), and planting a few extra trees is not going to cut it.
- hetspookjee 5y agoAlmost the entirety of Flevolands windmills would be used to power this beast, if not more.
- jeffbee 5y agoThis data center: 160MW Windpark Noordoostpolder: 430MW
- smartbit 5y ago“for a combined generating capacity of 429 megawatts” according to https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Windpark_Noordoostpolder https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Windpark_Noordoostpolder. I read that sentence as “under optimal circumstances” the Windpark can deliver 430MW. Whereas the datacenter will have sustained need of Power 365x24. IMHO that it a completely different thing. Please someone explain how Facebook could manage it's datacenter on local Netherlands sustainable Energy sources?
- jeffbee 5y agoI'd say that a datacenter actually has the ability to be responsive to energy market conditions more than most other kinds of loads, and no datacenter operates at its max rated power 24x7. Anyway the point is a datacenter of this size would amount to a tiny fraction of the energy load in that country. It's fine if they don't want it; it's their country, after all. But they should own the fact that they're just superficially against Facebook, and drop the stupid greenwashing argument.
- holoduke 5y agoGood thing. We don't need those (ugly power eating useless purpose) big buildings in our garden. If it were datacenters to cure cancer or something else meaningful then ok. But it's Facebook.
- belval 5y agoI get the sentiment, but it's not like the Netherlands don't use Facebook/Instagram/Whatsapp. There needs to be a data center to address those requests and it will be built somewhere. The NIMBY attitude is not really productive. Compare the DC to a landfill. Do you want one in "your garden"? Probably not, but it's not like you are going to convert to zero waste and render the project irrelevant.
- mschuster91 5y agoThe Netherlands are one of the most densely settled areas in Europe and particularly prone to floods. Better to build a datacenter somewhere in Germany or France's rural regions - the real estate is cheaper.
- openplatypus 5y ago> Better to build a data-center somewhere in Germany or France Hey hey, don't give them ideas. We don't want them here. Plus, given current European energy struggles, when Germany considers rationing power delivery, deploying Facebook space heaters sucking 200MW is not only irresponsible, but should be criminal.
- paxys 5y agoData centers are a hard sell in general because they don't really provide too much benefit to a community. They run on minimal labor, whether skilled or unskilled, so the job creation argument doesn't work. They have huge energy requirements, which is a burden on the regional grid. And residents of an area won't really care that the Facebook latency of all of Western Europe could improve by a few milliseconds because of their sacrifice.
- fivea 5y ago> Data centers are a hard sell in general because they don't really provide too much benefit to a community. The Netherlands is already the home of some FANGs (AWS has a few edge locations in Amsterdam) and dominant hosting providers such as Cloudflare. I'm sure they'll be able to overcome the loss of Facebook.
- lucb1e 5y agoI agree (aside from that AWS might think twice about where to strategically expand further given how politics treated Facehook) but I don't get how this is related to what you quoted or any other part of GP's comment.
- smartbit 5y ago> given how politics treated Facehook According to today’s NRC coverstory it was the opposite: the project failed because of the aggressive lobbying demanding an exception. And Meta refusing to discuss their datacentre design. IOW it failed because of the way that Facebook treated politics. https://www.nrc.nl/nieuws/2022/03/30/agressieve-lobby-voor-datacentrum-in-zeewolde-nekte-facebook-a4105867 https://www.nrc.nl/nieuws/2022/03/30/agressieve-lobby-voor-d...
- fivea 5y ago> (...) but I don't get how this is related to what you quoted or any other part of GP's comment. If you read about the topic you'll soon discover that Meta/Facebook has been systematically imposing demands for preferential treatment, including demanding circumventing laws to allow agricultural land, some of which they don't even own, to instead be used to build high-density industrial buildings. This, in a country where Amazon and Microsoft already operate their own data centers. In fact, Facebook rejected the location already used by Amazon and Microsoft, and instead decided to force their way somewhere else. It's also worth mentioning some of the apparent corruption aspects of Facebook's deal, abusing preferential rights of the municipality to exclude competing bids.
- hankman86 5y agoData centers are a necessity that I can accept if the services they host offer any utility. Facebook does not. It’s a net negative for its users and society at large.
- charcircuit 5y agoEven if you believe that Facebook, whatsapp, insta, quest, etc are a new negative they there can still be a subset of people who they offer utility to.
- djohnston 5y agoThere are literally billions of people whose behaviour invalidates your hypothesis.
- user_7832 5y agoI'd like to recommend the wired article from Jan 22 for understanding why Facebook is getting so much pushback - https://www.wired.com/story/facebook-dutch-data-center/ https://www.wired.com/story/facebook-dutch-data-center/
- naoqj 5y agoGood for whatever other country welcomes them.
- rpastuszak 5y agoWhy, and are you sure?
- mrsuprawsm 5y agoIf Meta were to build enough new, carbon neutral, and green energy facilities to supply triple the energy costs of their facility and sell the remainder to the grid, I don't think anyone would have much of a problem with the facility. As it stands, the data centre will use up much of the green energy that NL has created over the past few years, purely for Facebook to... sell more ads. That's not palatable.
- whimsicalism 5y ago> As it stands, the data centre will use up much of the green energy that NL has created over the past few years, purely for Facebook to... sell more ads. That's not palatable. Why do people so strongly critique Facebook for selling ads but not businesses from buying them? For instance [0] > The story of Ramon van Meer. He runs a company that sells ramps that help wiener dogs get up and down off the couch. For years, his company reached its niche audience through targeted Facebook ads. Then Apple changed the privacy settings on the iPhone, and suddenly those Facebook ads stopped working. Why don't small & medium business owners like Ramon get critiqued for feeding the beast? [0]: https://www.npr.org/2022/03/17/1087425495/tech-giants-and-tiny-dogs https://www.npr.org/2022/03/17/1087425495/tech-giants-and-ti...
- dylan604 5y agoHow many of the stories like Ramon's are real and not Facebook PR plants? I ask because of the few small businesses that I know personally that bought ads on Facebook never saw an attributable increase in sales.
- enaaem 5y agoI see a lot of medium size businesses. Im looking for furniture and I’m getting a lot of ads from smaller furniture brands on insta. Some are pretty nice. They are not as small as let’s say some local mattress store, but they are too small to be able to afford untargeted ads like tv commercials and billboards. Perhaps they could do furniture magazines, but many casual furniture buyers don’t buy magazines.
- 5y ago
- vincentmarle 5y ago“Netherlands” is not an adjective, the proper adjective is “Dutch”
- Tijdreiziger 5y agoThis can go both ways. Strictly speaking, Dutch can be taken to refer only to the people and language, with Netherlands referring to the country. Hence 'Royal Netherlands Air Force' (Koninklijke Luchtmacht) and 'Netherlands embassy in London' (Nederlandse ambassade in Londen). In popular speech, however, Dutch is also frequently used to refer to the country, i.e. 'Dutch embassy in London'. In the Dutch language, the two words are the same: Nederlands (referring to the people, language and country).
- kieckerjan 5y agoNaturally this news has gotten a lot of coverage in the Netherlands. One of the reasons mentioned for the amount of pushback is the "bullying" attitude of Meta in the negotiations and the aggressiveness of its lobbying. (See e.g. https://www.nrc.nl/nieuws/2022/03/30/de-laatste-boerin-vertrekt-maar-facebook-komt-niet-naar-zeewolde-a4105865 https://www.nrc.nl/nieuws/2022/03/30/de-laatste-boerin-vertr...) This may point to a culture clash, a misreading of Dutch values. Dutch business is widely known for its matter-of-factness not to say bluntness, Dutch politics is known for "polderen", the grinding process of seeking compromises between all parties involved. It seems like Meta may have confused the two.
- nigerian1981 5y agoYou would have thought Meta would have had employed plenty of Dutch resources with local knowledge.
- DaiPlusPlus 5y agoDisclaimer: I'm European and have worked in American tech mega-corps. And I grew up in a similar situation: my dad was an eng for a couple of American mega-corps so I'm familiar with how things work over two generations, first and second-hand. While I've never worked at Meta/Facebook I did interview twice but didn't get an offer. Incidentally, I've still never had a Facebook account in my life, ever. (I was too unpopular and friendless in uni for anyone to ask me to sign-up) ------- > You would have thought Meta would have had employed plenty of Dutch resources with local knowledge. Without doubt, the necessary US-based director-level people at Meta almost certainly did do that, as well as pulling-in expertise from the world of geopolitical consulting. And then immediately after reviewing all that input they didn't want to hear, the Meta folks very likely thought-up a quick plan that they knew for certain would outsmart those silly over-regulating and anti-business, Europeans... which clearly didn't, and hence we find ourselves in the situation we have today. Do not underestimate the ego and (not mincing my words) arrogance of people who make it to the top: as soon as you start using "I'm C-level/D-level at Meta, I'm hot shit" in your thought-processes you're in for a nasty grounding incident, much to our amusement. ----- Post-disclaimer: It's not about being American, it's about not letting your personal career success go to your head. The reason we don't see non-American companies acting like this is because eventually all companies grow big enough to re-identify (if not relocate...) as an American company (...or they get acquired by an American company), because that's the single biggest market in the world, and you can't conquer the world without owning the North American market in whatever business you do, imo.
- dncornholio 5y agoA big point was that the grid does not have the capacity for such a datacenter, and this would prevent other companies to enter the region. Local government only saw dollar bills so went through with it anyway.
- jbverschoor 5y agoBest News in a while