10 ms·
HB11's hydrogen-boron laser fusion test yields groundbreaking results
- k_sze 5y ago> Its first demo has produced 10 times more fusion reactions than expected I'm not a physicist or a professional scientist in any way. But is this at all normal? 10 times means a whole order of magnitude. Is that a sign that the math is wrong somewhere or that some measurement is wrong somewhere?
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- blurbleblurble 5y agoI imagine it just means their error estimates were very conservative.
- chaps 5y ago"the only commercial entity to achieve fusion so far" ...is this true? It's pretty trivial to achieve fusion (laughabe efficiency, but still fusion!) with a few thousand dollars and a well-funded garage. Maybe "commercial entity whose goal is to generate positive-yield fusion" is what they mean..
- zardo 5y ago> Maybe "commercial entity whose goal is to generate positive-yield fusion" is what they mean.. That could be, they don't want to deal with neutron flux for no reason. It's definitely not true that no commercial entity has built and operated a chair. https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S0969804300002153?via%3Dihub https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S09698...
- apendleton 5y ago> Maybe "commercial entity whose goal is to generate positive-yield fusion" is what they mean.. Maybe, but that wouldn't be true either. Zap Energy has demonstrated neutron production in D-D reactions. I think Helion has, too (and possibly in D-T reactions as well?). Neither is particularly close to break-even, but then, neither are these people. It's a baffling claim.
- DennisP 5y agoEven LPPFusion has done it, with a tiny budget and a reactor the size of a coffee can.
- hutzlibu 5y ago"'s pretty trivial to achieve fusion (laughabe efficiency, but still fusion!) with a few thousand dollars and a well-funded garage." That still sounds like an interesting project, but I would not call it trivial. I googled a bit and found this: https://www.discovermagazine.com/the-sciences/how-to-build-a-usd1000-fusion-reactor-in-your-basement https://www.discovermagazine.com/the-sciences/how-to-build-a...
- pfdietz 5y agoC. L. Stong's "The Amateur Scientist" column in Scientific American described building a Van de Graaf accelerator capable of inducing fusion at a cost of $200 (in 1959). https://www.jstor.org/stable/24944895 https://www.jstor.org/stable/24944895
- marcyb5st 5y agoI think that the title is a bit click-baity as the Q ratio reported for the experiment is still 0.00005 (0.005 percent quoting the article). Still an impressive achievement, but would've not used the word "groundbreaking" IMHO. I believe that in the context of nuclear fusion that word is often used to allude at reaching an energy surplus out of the reaction.
- AreYouSirius 5y ago
- chii 5y agoThis video details some of the ways that nuclear fusion energy reporting gets done (both media, but also the industry) : https://youtu.be/LJ4W1g-6JiY https://youtu.be/LJ4W1g-6JiY We are not near a viable fusion reactor yet. Not close.
- yetihehe 5y agoYep. > "HB11 Energy’s research demonstrated that its hydrogen-boron energy technology is now four orders of magnitude away from achieving net energy gain when catalyzed by a laser," reads the press release. "This is many orders of magnitude higher than those reported by any other fusion company, most of which have not generated any reaction despite billions of dollars invested in the field. > HB11 claims is a "world-first 'material' number of fusion reactions by a private company So they have a result which is 10x better than they thought will be, but still way lower than stellarator etc.
- eightails 5y agoAnd still lower than other laser systems using inertial confinement. If I'm reading NIF's recent paper right, they're claiming Q_a of above ~1.4, or Q = ~0.28 https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC8791836/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC8791836/ Edit: Wikipedia suggests that they were using a different method to calculate Q, only measuring the power input to plasma vs output from fusion, not including system losses. So that figure is probably not directly comparable. > the NIF used ~477 MJ of electrical energy to get ~1.8 MJ of energy into the target to create ~1.3 MJ of fusion energy https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/National_Ignition_Facility#Burning_plasma_achieved https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/National_Ignition_Facility#Bur...
- trhway 5y ago>HB11 Energy’s research demonstrated that its hydrogen-boron energy technology is now four orders of magnitude away from achieving net energy gain when catalyzed by a laser the accelerator based fusion - like accelerating protons into a solid target - is probably among the easiest ways to get some fusion. Improving it is though a completely different thing - as even the solid targets are really mostly space between the atoms (and thus the overwhelming majority of the incoming protons lose the energy by heating the target instead of hitting the target's atoms), the density of the target to achieve break even should be on the scale of like 10x density of lead. The only known ways to get such matter densities is by compressing the matter by something like X-rays of the power comparable to that of the nuke explosion generated X-rays (like for example is done in Sandia Z-machine or NIF lasers).
- AreYouSirius 5y ago
- AreYouSirius 5y ago
- adrian_b 5y agoFor those who are not aware why this might be important, the hydrogen-boron fusion reaction is the easiest among the so-called aneutronic fusion reactions, i.e. among the fusion reactions whose products are all stable nuclei. This kind of fusion is the only kind of fusion that may be considered clean, because the risks of producing radioactive waste are negligible. The easier kinds of fusion, which are attempted by almost all fusion research projects, e.g. the deuterium-tritium fusion, produce most of the energy in the form of high-speed neutrons, which must be absorbed by some shield. The shield will soon become radioactive, generating a lot of radioactive waste, even if it may be hoped that by choosing carefully the shield material the kind of radioactive waste that is produced may be less dangerous than the waste generated by fission reactors. So any research results about hydrogen-boron fusion are far more important than the results about easier fusion reactions. Unfortunately, even with these positive news, there is no clear path towards developing some kind of fusion reactor that could use this better fusion reaction.
- moonchrome 5y ago>So any research results about hydrogen-boron fusion are far more important than the results about easier fusion reactions. That's like saying research results in exhaust filters was much more important than research into combustion engines back when we had none - how does that make any sense ? Disposing radioactive waste isn't impossible, it's just not trivial, if that was the only downside of fission plants I doubt many people would have a problem with them. Pollution produced by coal plants is categorically worse and yet we have those all over the place.
- adrian_b 5y agoIt is not just the problem of disposing the waste. Any neutron shield will be destroyed in a relatively short time, so it will have to be replaced and processed for the separation of the radioactive waste. This is certain to greatly increase the cost of operation for a fusion reactor. Also the fusion energy carried by the neutrons will be recovered only partially, because it will be transformed in heat in the shield and taken away by a coolant and then the heat will be used in electric generators, like the heat produced by fission or by fossil fuel burning. Because the products of an aneutronic fusion reaction are high-speed charged particles, it is theoretically possible to make a direct electric generator, without using heat as an intermediate, which could have a much higher efficiency. Making a small fusion reactor that produces neutrons would be always impossible if living beings are close, due to the need for a neutron shield. So you will never have e.g. a car with such a fusion reactor. There are no known size limits for a fusion reactor with hydrogen-boron, so it might be possible to make reactors small enough to power a house or a vehicle. So if it would be possible to control a fusion reaction like hydrogen-boron, it would be possible to make fusion reactors that could produce much cheaper energy than it is possible with the easier fusion reactions, for which it remains to be proven if they could become economically viable, even long after the technical problems needed to enable the production of more energy than consumed will be solved. However, many real breaktroughs would be needed to discover how to do aneutronic fusion reactions, at the scale needed for energy production. The easier fusion reactions, like deuterium-tritium or deuterium-deuterium, have so many intrinsic disadvantages and so little advantages over fission reactors that it does not seem likely that they could ever become the main method for energy production.
- pfdietz 5y agoHB11 is proposing to use an "avalanche" mechanism where alpha particles from the fusion run into and accelerate protons to energies > thermal to continue the reactions (a chain reaction). Unfortunately, this doesn't appear to work, by about two orders of magnitude. https://iopscience.iop.org/article/10.1088/1361-6587/abf255 https://iopscience.iop.org/article/10.1088/1361-6587/abf255 Their proposed direct conversion scheme is also problematic, for several reasons (electrons would short out the spherical capacitor, the necessary ion current greatly exceeds the space charge limit on the current, and the alpha particles from p-11B are not monoenergetic, meaning that ions would either not have enough energy to reach the collecting electrode or would reach it with so much kinetic energy the surface of the electrode would experience too much heating.)
- jokowueu 5y ago"Hydrogen-boron fusion doesn't create heat, it merely creates "naked" helium atoms, or alpha particles, which are missing electrons and thus positively charged. HB11 plans to simply collect that charge to create energy, rather than needing to superheat steam and drive lossy turbines. No nuclear waste is created." How is this charge collected ?
- PaulHoule 5y agoIt is not so special to get some fusion from a commercial device, Farnsworth and Hirsch did that in the 1960s. It’s getting more energy from fusion than it takes to start the reaction that is special.
- peterweyand0 5y agoSo does it produce more energy than it takes? From what I've read that's extremely unlikely.
- api 5y ago> "the only commercial entity to achieve fusion so far," making it "the global frontrunner in the race to commercialize the holy grail of clean energy." This statement does not inspire confidence. Many, many commercial companies have achieved fusion. None of course have achieved net-positive-EROEI fusion, which is what is needed for power generation.