7 ms·
Related to the opening of this article – it is interesting to see how one can get completely soured on certain products or experiences because, by virtue of the
by paxys 5y ago
Related to the opening of this article – it is interesting to see how one can get completely soured on certain products or experiences because, by virtue of their profession, they see the dirty underbelly of how things in that industry actually work.
Someone who has read cruise contracts in detail will never want to go on one. Cooks with experience in commercial kitchens never want to eat at a restaurant again. Someone who is familiar with standards of bridge inspections in most towns hesitates every time they drive over one. A computer security expert keeps their most valuable information under lock and key in a physical safe rather than online.
My conclusion ultimately is – everything is running on goodwill and duct tape, and ignorance is bliss.
- KarlKemp 5y agoOne of those hypotheses is easily testable: bridges can collapse and you will hear about it. And yet.. it rarely happens? There was one in Italy and one in the US recently but, to a decent approximation, it’s a non-issue. Maybe we should have more trust in people and their work. Maybe our bridges are fine, our food is kosher, but what’s rotting on the inside is society, eaten alive by cynicism and distrust.
- jkepler 5y agoBridges are usually massively over-engineered for safety.
- actionfromafar 5y agoNot over, just engineered. That's what safety is. I don't mean to be snarky, the built-in buffer is part of what makes it safe.
- yakak 5y agoThat sounds like the road to complacency. The reality is that there are many backup systems that work much of the time. Have complacency in all of them and forget society. The bridge has engineers and architects who know material stats and add tolerances. The restaurant has patrons with immune systems that survived worse times in human history, usually, unless the patron is undergoing serious medical treatment or something.
- tshaddox 5y agoI’d also like to see some evidence that people familiar with bridge construction actually avoid bridges or hesitate before using them. I suspect they might say something like that if the conversation goes in that direction, but I doubt they actually modify their behavior.
- mnd999 5y agoThere was very nearly one in central London a couple of years back (Hammersmith) and it’s still closed to traffic. But nearly is good, the situation is being rectified before it turned into a disaster. From the noises coming out of TfL this was a little close for comfort though.
- Ekaros 5y agoThe experts probably know which bridges to avoid. Those likely have sufficient number of visual clues of things like discolouring, cracks and so on.
- seadan83 5y ago"Maybe our bridges are fine" I think thus can and perhaps should be refuted as the bridges are not fine. The 2019 report of bridges in WA found 6.6% to be in poor condition and more than half of the approximate 8000 bridges need repair. https://infrastructurereportcard.org/state-item/washington/ https://infrastructurereportcard.org/state-item/washington/ Seattle has about 6 or 7 very major bridges. One of the largest, the west seattle bridge has been closed for over a year because it was suddenly in danger of collapse. This is a bridge that carried over 100k cars per day. (https://www.seattle.gov/transportation/projects-and-programs/programs/bridges-stairs-and-other-structures/bridges/west-seattle-bridge-program https://www.seattle.gov/transportation/projects-and-programs...) I think the point of grimacing while crossing a bridge is that the engineers know the problems and how pervasive they are. As a user of websites, you may think some are really solid. Having worked for one (a website virtually everyone has used), when you see the bug queues, all the outages, and all the problems, you realize it's not the steel fortress that it would appear to be from the native outsider
- Cthulhu_ 5y agoThey're only fine until they're not; there's plenty of instances of rotting infrastructure that one day will fail, and it's not like these issues are unknown, there's just not enough money or people to fix it. Meanwhile the US government is going to spend another trillion on its military.
- vinay_ys 5y agoWe know consumer software has bugs – that can make them unreliable, insecure and slow. They can become worse over time with more usage (more data/state accumulation). Unless we proactively find and fix them, they can continue to hurt users. We know this. We know critical software systems (medical, industrial, infra) have specially hardened software that are more reliable (but not yet secure). We also know buildings, bridges etc – can weaken over time due to material deterioration, foundation shifting, earthquakes, machinery induced vibrations, excess load etc. and fail (fall apart). They need to be monitored for signs of structural stress/failure (cracks, leaks, tilts etc) and corrected/repaired or else they fail. When these maintenances are not done correctly, due to incompetence or corruption, they will fail, no doubt.
- runnerup 5y agoMost people who work in restaurant kitchens eat far more from restaurant kitchens, not less. I did for quite a few years and I’m still very happy to eat at any diner, drive through, or Michelin star restaurant.
- nerdponx 5y agoI think the kitchen thing is mostly a myth. Although it's true that often the refrigerators used during meal service tend not to be as cold as they are supposed to be, because the door is constantly being opened.
- bombcar 5y agoI think the main thing I learned from my commercial kitchen work is how similar they all are behind the scenes - the equipment and often skill of the line cooks at your local truck stop and the local fancy dining are closer than you expect.
- dimitrios1 5y agoThe difference being the type of prep work being done, how good and consistent their ingredients and recipes are, and the presentation. Mechanically, yes they are all similar. Unless of course, you are at a steakhouse, and they don't have a salmander broiler. Run away!
- nonameiguess 5y agoIt's probably true in fast food, not all commercial kitchens.
- mbostleman 5y agoAgreed. I was going to say that I bet this a myth that endures only because it is repeated endlessly. I've never seen data to prove it and my anecdotal experience is the opposite.
- grujicd 5y agoAs a developer, I was shocked when at a friend's house saw that Alexa not only operated lights, but door locks and blinds. Or when another friend takes hands off the steering wheel to test lane keep assist. I don't think I can trust any software at that level.
- Ekaros 5y agoI agree with the IoT stuff, would never trust or want that... Taking hands off steering wheel. Depends on where done, but straight or slightly curving highway with no significant other traffic sure. Why not try how well it works, just be ready to grab and correct if needed. I even try how well my car goes straight line in similar conditions...
- dijonman2 5y agoI use a voice assistant for lightning control, it’s amazing when I’m walking in with hands full or lay down and want the lights off. I occasionally use it for weather but it’s annoying with such suggestions. I should know better but in this case the convenience is worth it.
- Cthulhu_ 5y agoI wouldn't mind blinds so much, but it'd have to be via a button; I dislike talking on a good day, let alone to a machine. That said, my lights are operated via RF remote(s) (two systems, one working on plugs, the other from ikea), pretty convenient without needing an internet connection. Just an awkwardly sized battery.
- OJFord 5y agoWhy not just automatic? Maybe plus a button for privacy/needing darkness for a film or whatever depending on the room, but mostly I just want curtains & blinds to open in the morning and close in the evening.
- djrogers 5y agoBecause they provide privacy in addition to light blocking. I don't have a 100% reliable schedule on when I'm going to need my windows to be blocked.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- watwut 5y ago> Someone who is familiar with standards of bridge inspections in most towns hesitates every time they drive over one. I don't think this one is true. > Cooks with experience in commercial kitchens never want to eat at a restaurant again. Sometimes yes, but definitely not always.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- WalterBright 5y agoOnce I learned how airplanes were actually designed and built, I felt much safer on them. Especially the 757, which I worked on.
- JonChesterfield 5y agoHow about helicopters? I definitely feel less willing to get on one after working near them.
- tzs 5y agoI've never worked near helicopters, but they went on my "never take a job anywhere near these things" list after the third time I accidentally stuck my hands into the whirling blades of the ceiling fan in my living room.
- david422 5y agoI once had a chance to take a job related to navigation. I got significantly lost on the way to the interview. The job didn't work out, probably for the best.
- WalterBright 5y agoHelicopters are subject to single failures causing a fatal crash. Hence helicopters rely heavily on rigid, thorough, and very expensive maintenance. As my dad (combat pilot) said, an airplane wants to fly. It can suffer considerable damage and still make it home. A helicopter, however, wants to crash. It's a constant struggle to keep it in the air. I've never ridden in a chopper, but I doubt I'd feel safe in one.
- Cthulhu_ 5y agoA layman is shocked to find out it's a tube of pressurized aluminium, but knowing how the sausage is made makes it better.
- Xcelerate 5y agoOut of curiosity, do you feel comfortable flying on the more recent ones?
- krageon 5y ago> Cooks with experience in commercial kitchens never want to eat at a restaurant again. Having done such work, this is absolutely untrue. I got a renewed appreciation for the hard work kitchen staff put in and the stringent requirements on cleanliness that kitchen staff has. I suppose this will change based on the country you are in, if you are in a country with bad sanitary checking you will have a bad time.
- sandos 5y agoTotally agree, though it seems differ quite a bit between different kinds of kitchens here in Sweden. Producing stuff sold in stores means super-stringent checks where for example you have to swap your clothes before entering and exiting the area where you prepare the foodstuff. Now school kitchens on the other hand... sure they are checked but not at all with the same strictness it seems.
- willcipriano 5y agoI have ten years in kitchens and while I do eat out I also know how disgusting kitchens are. I have a stomach for it but if you were a regular person and knew what I knew you'd refrain from eating out. We pay back of house staff as little as we can get away with to work every weekend and holiday in hellish conditions. They just don't give a crap and who can blame them.
- krageon 5y ago> I also know how disgusting kitchens are [...] They're disinfected literally every day, and during the day all surfaces are regularly cleaned. If this isn't mandatory where you live, you live in a country with bad hygiene laws. > We pay back of house staff as little as we can get away with to work every weekend and holiday in hellish conditions. This doesn't match where I live at all, FWIW.
- willcipriano 5y ago> If this isn't mandatory where you live, you live in a country with bad hygiene laws. Are drugs illegal in your country? Do people still do them?
- Xcelerate 5y ago> Someone who has read cruise contracts in detail will never want to go on one. Cooks with experience in commercial kitchens never want to eat at a restaurant again. Someone who is familiar with standards of bridge inspections in most towns hesitates every time they drive over one... ...someone who writes software for a living is afraid to fly on airplanes (I joke, but only sort of)
- cameronh90 5y agoOn the contrary, as someone with a great interest in aeroplanes and aviation safety, I would choose to travel everywhere by airliner if airports weren't such a depressing experience. Learning more has made me extremely confident in aviation (737 MAX issue aside but even that is nothing compared to the risk of driving).
- marcosdumay 5y ago> 737 MAX issue aside but even that is nothing compared to the risk of driving I run the numbers when the second accident happened, and the 737 MAX had a similar risk profile to using a motorcycle in the city. Way higher than driving.
- peterburkimsher 5y agoThank you for the examples of a cruise, kitchen, and building bridges! Analogies are helpful :) I work as a software engineer. If you asked me to do civil/mechanical/structural engineering, I'd have the same approach: Build. And run!
- throwaway0a5e 5y ago>My conclusion ultimately is – everything is running on goodwill and duct tape, and ignorance is bliss. And the most infuriating part of it is that everyone acts like subject they don't understand in detail can and should be expected to be perfect.
- 0xbadcafebee 5y agoI get your point, but I think your initial conclusions are false. Each of those professions understands that the probability of risk is not 1. Their experience informs them that the risk is quite unlikely and therefore acceptable. They may have a heightened awareness to look for problems, but they don't stop exposing themselves to risk. Your final conclusion is half-right: ignorance is bliss. But I think it's charitable to say everything is running on goodwill and duct tape. How many people really build systems based on goodwill? And duct tape implies somebody's seen the cracks and decided to patch them. I think everything is running on apathy and incompetence, sitting on the edge of a cliff, waiting for a stiff breeze; over time, the wind wins.
- rayiner 5y agoI don’t know if I agree with this. My experience working for a federal judge made me much more confident in the criminal justice system. In the media we only see the situations where the justice system got something wrong—which is inevitable in a country of 330 million people. Looking behind the scenes made me understand that for every case where there is a conviction on shaky evidence, there are dozens of cases where a conviction or guilty plea is supported by a mountain of electronic evidence. For example, my wife handled a murder trial where the government prosecutors not only had closed circuit video of the defendant shooting the victim, but of him getting in his car and driving home through town back to his house. They just cut from one closed circuit camera to the next and the next showing the entire journey.
- xyzzyz 5y agoDid your wife's case actually go to trial, or was it also plea-bargained? If the former, why would the defendant not take the plea in such clear-cut case?
- angst_ridden 5y ago"My definition of an expert in any field is a person who knows enough about what's really going on to be scared." - PJ Plauge, Computer Language, March 1983