11 ms·
Bizarre space circle captured in unprecedented detail
- easymodex 5y agoGigantic radio waves? Couldn't it be some alien species broadcasting it with advanced tech over millions of years?
- basicplus2 5y agothats an Orconeoid
- JetAlone 5y agoSo we have meerkats on the lookout for orcs. https://www.brightmast.com/ask-ap/ https://www.brightmast.com/ask-ap/ Also apparently ASKAP is doing double duty on payroll, taking care of the elfs for us. And the hobbitses?
- teknopaul 5y agoIf you are looking at a circle that is a cone of light. Couldn't this be is big radio burst on the other side of something with a lot of mass? A normal spherical expansion of an explosion when going past a massive object would obscure the centre and bend some light to form a circle. Don't see what that isn't one of the suggested theories. Galaxy in the middle might not be the source, just the mass that's doing the bending of the radio waves.
- Terry_Roll 5y agoI wonder if there is something, some phenomena or rare event that can cause smoke rings in space?
- ncmncm 5y agoLots of things. Question is, which one is this?
- unhammer 5y agohttps://i.imgur.com/UB2r629.png https://i.imgur.com/UB2r629.png you can tell it's pioneering science when they've used up all the fancy qualifiers like "polar" and "equatorial" and end up just saying "Another ring"
- rthomas6 5y agoAt first I didn't see the big deal, because it looks just like a nebula, just in RF spectrum. Then I processed the fact that it's over a million light years across.
- denton-scratch 5y agoThat article is rather thin. How far away is it? There appear to be some odd-shaped objects in the background that look like some galaxies from the Hubble Deep-space images. But HDS is optical, and this is radio. What RF frequencies are represented by the blue-grey haze? That info would make it possible for a layman to speculate about what material was doing the radiating. It does seem mysterious. If that thing's really a million ly across, then it's surely hard to explain. Any event at the centre most probably happened in a galaxy, and I would expect the galaxy itself to have captured most of the energy from the event. Have they tried to look at the central galaxy in optical? Does it look like an watermelon that's been blasted with a 12-bore? So we're talking about an event that occurred 1 million years ago, plus the time light took to get here. Perhaps it's a hugely energetic event that has illuminated and ionised intergalactic gas? But I can't imagine what kind of event that could be (the merger of two black holes doesn't seem to me to be right, but what do I know).
- SiempreViernes 5y agoBased on the galaxies inside the ORC, it's probably at z ~ 0.55. With those distances you don't get much detail, everything is mainly slightly squashed smudges. The observations covers the range of 880 MHz to 1680 MHz (with some gaps to avoid RFI, see their table 2), find a spectral index between -1.9 to -0.9 with a median of -1.6. Also the image is an interferometric measurement.
- dpflug 5y agoKind of looks like a lens flare.
- pmoriarty 5y agoAny chance that the James Webb telescope will have a look at this? Would we get better data/images from it than from MeerKAT?
- nikolay 5y agoWe should learn something from these pictures - we're so infinitely small and unimportant regardless of our pathological narcissism and greed. We should be humble and modest and all agree that there is so much more outside of Earth than on Earth where we wage wars and kill each other over stupidity. Instead, focus all efforts on us becoming interplanetary, and then there's more out there than our greed can ever handle!
- ncmncm 5y agoThey mention one possible cause: merger of a pair of super-massive black holes after galaxies merge. I wonder if any life in such a galaxy could survive such an event.
- stadium 5y agoGravitational lensing can make the same star appear in a circular pattern, could the same happen for these radio wave patterns?
- firebaze 5y agoThis isn't meant to sound dismissive, but do you really assume the experts in this field didn't consider this, and didn't deem it (ir-)relevant enough to (not) mention in their paper? Genuinely interested what is the reason behind questions like that. In general, it's definitely cool and understandable to me to question the competency of anyone, but if (as in this case) a researcher researches a quite deep detail of a very specific field, using a very rare resource (a space telescope, which I assume requires some credibility to even ask for observation time) how do you assume they didn't check all boxes before writing a paper?
- FredPret 5y agoOP is inquiring to learn more. I think it’s a good question and would also like to know. No need to for you to be defensive on the scientist’s behalf.
- legohead 5y ago> could the same happen for these radio wave patterns Perhaps he was just seeking knowledge. There may be an interesting reason why these radio wave patterns may or may not be affected by lensing. Also, if you have been around as long as I have, it is not that uncommon for experts to be missing something obvious, or for science articles to exclude certain details in order to appear more fascinating.
- firebaze 5y agoBut what would be an appropriate answer? Yes probably, this would mean they were wrong. No would be quite complex, I suppose. I didn't assume the GP to be ignorant or distrusting the credibility of the researcher, and the question was valid in my point of view as well from that perspective.
- h2odragon 5y ago"Space circle" could describe pretty much everything and anything outside the atmosphere, no? "Sphere" was probably too technical.
- mhh__ 5y agoWho says it's spherical?
- h2odragon 5y agoGood point! Astronomy is the study of "Space Blobs"
- bee_rider 5y agoThis article cites a paper. I was looking at one of the papers they cite in that paper, and they had a nice explanation in the introductory paragraph. > Circular features are well-known in radio astronomical images, and usually represent a spherical object such as a supernova remnant, a planetary nebula, a circumstellar shell, or a face-on disc such as a protoplanetary disc or a star-forming galaxy. They describe these things as circles because that's how they show up on the radio telescopes. They are being precise about what they detected, I think. These are hard signals to even pick up, after all, no need to introduce a made up interpretation to further confuse things.
- wolverine876 5y agoGood point. Why is so much in gravityless, directionless (i.e., no up and down) space shaped like a disc rather than a sphere? Look at the orbits of planets around the Sun - why are they mostly in the same plane? Look at galaxies.
- nawgz 5y agoSpin
- DiggyJohnson 5y agoA sphere spins in a circle <- probably the most abstract answer possible, but correct as I see it.
- pandoro 5y ago"Of the three stars, one was missing. There was a white cloud of dust in its place, like the feces of an abyss whale. It’s already been cleansed. Nothing more to do." - Death's End, Liu Cixin
- monkeycantype 5y agoI'll make my pointless comment over here with the downvoted, when I saw it I thought of the 4chan troll face
- ericHosick 5y agoAnton Petrov has a great video on this: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HRaQj_IMAjY https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HRaQj_IMAjY.
- cmroanirgo 5y agoAnton always presents great videos, but my guess is that it could also be bubbles from the breath of Great A'Tuin, the celestial turtle, as it swims through the cosmic ocean. /s
- teawrecks 5y agoEveryone knows it's turtles all the way down.
- karmakaze 5y agoTwo things immediately popped to mind. (1) 'con display' from Star Trek (2) multi-star Dyson sphere under construction. The latter doesn't make sense though, seems that many single spheres would be simpler unless it was to be concealed: (3) sub-galactic Great Wall? Can we detect single-star Dyson spheres as the disappearance of stars before their expected end?
- ianai 5y agoIf it's a Dyson-anything, it's way bigger than a single star: "The new MeerKAT radio data shows that the ORC’s large outer circle is possibly more than a million light years across, ten times the diameter of the Milky Way, with a series of smaller rings inside" It actually sounds more like the wisps of gas seen jetting through the Milky Way and being irradiated by something. That alone, I think, isn't too unnatural of a thing to see out there. Maybe someday this sort of thing will enlighten us on how matter dispersed in the early universe i.e. when these galaxies were forming out of still larger areas of matter. Who knows, maybe there's some dark energy/matter information to be gleaned in there, too.
- ianai 5y agoReplying to myself to avoid an edit - You know, if I was a hairbrained, mega-structure scientist from some future, highly advanced civilization that otherwise couldn't study or explain dark energy/matter, one way to simply gather data would be to fill huge regions of space with matter and watch how my known input evolves and changes over time. If science up to that point can explain 100% of the movements of the matter from then on, then I know my theories and data are widely in agreement. If I know nothing else has perturbed that matter and the data are off, then the disagreement tells me something about how physics works at super large scale. [If I know physics with plenty of certainty at those scales and something changes outside of my expectation then something/someone new to the scene perturbed that matter.] Which is to say, I wonder if there isn't a way to turn these oddballs into very valuable scientific data. Build radio-telescopes large enough to gather as fine grained data about these ORCs as possible and model away. Maybe something in there does translate to physics which explain dark energy/matter.
- deviantbit 5y agoWhy can't it ever be aliens?
- barkingcat 5y agoIt's always aliens.
- kreeben 5y agoHaving looked at this picture for a good ten minutes it still feels alien.
- throwaway71271 5y agotrue! but looking at some zoomed spiders and they also feel alien, so what do i know..
- barkingcat 5y agoobviously spiders are aliens too.
- dylan604 5y agoHow do you schedule a zoom call with a spider?
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- squarefoot 5y agoThat picture gives off so many Star Trek TOS vibes.
- erickhill 5y agoWe definitely appear to be approaching a spatial anomaly.
- RotaryTelephone 5y agoIt could be sentient. Let's probe it with our prime directive of non-interference
- krapp 5y agoIt's the last thing they'll expect.
- swamp40 5y agoThey should run it thru Google Brain's SR3 image enhancer. Or maybe that would give it a face?
- dylan604 5y agoBut will it be Ryan Gosling's face?
- mabbo 5y agoThere's something great about physics and astronomy when it comes to naming things. What is it? An odd circle of radio waves. What are we going to call it? Well, if we call it an "odd radio circle" the initialization is the same as the monstrous bad guys from a classic fantasy novel. ORCs it is then!
- wolverine876 5y agoAn hypothesis based on subjective experience: In the post-modern era (roughly 1945-20??) people were highly skeptical of their egos and of power, advertised humility, and consequently had a sense of humor about themselves and the world. Thus you get names like quark and Google. Now in the newly-born (reactionary?) era, ego is our God, and we get names like Uber. Physics perhaps hasn't quite joined the new era, yet.
- erdos4d 5y ago> Physics perhaps hasn't quite joined the new era, yet. I dunno, I've noticed that most physicists I've met have the "ego is God" vibe pretty well cooked in, and they will definitely let you know it.
- dddw 5y agoInteresting take. Might have something to do with the culture of science, which still adheres more to values like collaboration.
- wolverine876 5y agoAlso, the culture of science is inescapably post-modern. The new era aggressively rejects the Enlightenment bases of science such as the supremacy of fact, the weakness of subjectivity, resolving issues by reason, empowerment by our intellects, etc.
- beaconstudios 5y agoAs somebody who's interested in postmodern philosophy, I'm not sure I'd characterise it as being against reason or intellectual empowerment. It's primarily skeptical of metanarratives, like the idea of historical progress or the inevitable triumph of reason. The big one it expresses skepticism towards is the modernist project, but that doesn't mean a rejection of reason. After all, postmodern philosophy uses arguments from reasoning to make its case! Social constructivism and the like also aren't anti-facts or pro-subjectivity (assuming that's what you were implying, just a guess though) - it's about acknowledging which things we consider objectively true are actually only true by convention or tradition rather than being rooted in physical laws. Also how the human mind models knowledge and the relations between our models of reality and reality itself, so we don't mistake the map for the territory.
- MPSimmons 5y agoFor scale: > The odd radio circle’s large outer circle is possibly more than a million light years across The entire Milky Way galaxy is 100,000 light years across: https://www.universetoday.com/75691/how-big-is-the-milky-way/ https://www.universetoday.com/75691/how-big-is-the-milky-way...
- elwell 5y agoIs that photo in natural color?
- quaintdev 5y agoOdd that no one mentioned yet that those look like the Ring from Expanse.
- 0des 5y agoWhy does this stuff always look out of focus?
- afraczak 5y agoThe Trisolaran fleet
- Cannabat 5y agoThere's something about this image that almost brings tears to my eyes. It's so big. It's an order of magnitude larger than our ("our") Milky Way. And that little smear to the bottom-left? A whole galaxy with uncountable stars, but also just a few pixels. Do we humans represent something greater? Are we just a smear of pixels, a trivialising of some incomprehensibly large object? Are we really just this small? Are we a galaxy to some other being in some microscopic dimension, imaged with technology of a totally alien nature? Maybe these aren't logical questions. I mean, there are plenty of photos like this, where you can just barely begin to appreciate the scale of the visible universe, but yeah, this one just got me today.
- ycombinete 5y agoI felt the same way recently reading about galaxy filaments and walls
- ge96 5y agoI just get sad thinking about the slow travel/trapped. Maybe someone will figure it out.
- fifticon 5y agoYou might take comfort in, that it also puts a dampener on interstellar wars (my assumption).
- Hedepig 5y agoIt is sad. But, on a flip side - somewhat tangentially, I've recently become interested in molecular biology. The strides we're making within the field is incredible. Perhaps it isn't as sexy as astronomy, but it's far more within our grasp, and arguably has a far bigger impact on us, at least right now
- xvector 5y agoEventually, the human consciousness will move to a synthetic medium, and we will feel far less "trapped" as time will virtually cease to hold meaning.