11 ms·
Reddit's website uses DRM for fingerprinting (2020)
- nerdbaggy 5y agoHis other article is really interesting in what data they collect https://smitop.com/post/whiteops-data/ https://smitop.com/post/whiteops-data/
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- TechBro8615 5y agoHas anyone done a MITM analysis of 3rd party clients like Apollo? I assume that using them affords a significant level of protection from any client-based Reddit tracking measures, but that’s only assuming Apollo doesn’t do something like add a unique User-Agent to each user’s request (and of course, Reddit can still collect the server-side IP/networking fingerprints).
- shostack 5y agoI'm likewise curious. I'm terrified to update for fear of what has been ruined next. But likewise am not sure putting this trust in a 3rd party is any better.
- nimbius 5y agooof. running IE11 exploits (feels illegal here...), elevating to vbscript, testing the boundaries of the JIT, checking for screenshotting, observing for brave browser and communicating with two shady blank page sites... not since the port scanning from ebay have i seen something this reprehensible
- lawl 5y ago> not since the port scanning from ebay have i seen something this reprehensible That was the same company/script btw.
- saruken 5y agoWhiteOps/HUMAN was behind the eBay thing too?
- amanzi 5y agoI know this may seem like a technical nit-pick, but it wasn't eBay specifically going out of their way to port scan your local machine. It's just that they decided to use one of the many third-party products in the marketplace to scan for bot activity that uses this technique. Protecting against bots is big business and the companies offering these services do all sorts of seemingly shady things to figure out if it's a bot or human visiting a site.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- eternityforest 5y agoThat's an amazing analysis!
- superasn 5y agoWouldn't somebody running an actual Chrome/FF browser in Xvfb pass most of these tests - while use them as bots anyway? Pretty sure a t3 micro spot instance can run those so cost may not be an issue. Also, why would anybody running a bot use IE11 - which this code is trying to exploit? Pretty sure this bot is just an excuse for ads and retargeting.
- kyleee 5y agonot a surprise, a lot of the fingerprinting code attempts to use every feature possible, that's why you'll see random messages in the console sometimes saying "site tried to access $feature' where feature is location, canvas, etc. etc.
- can16358p 5y agoIs it the reason that all the pages on "modern" reddit are extremely bloated, laggy, and resource-draining even on fast systems?
- attilaperez 5y agoNope, just a side effect of the move towards PWA.
- tehbeard 5y agoI've built multiple PWAs for clients. None of them have anywhere close to the performance or loading problems reddit has (Safari related bugs however? Probably on par). It's slow and bloated to force you out of chrome/firefox and into the app they control.
- phailhaus 5y ago> It's slow and bloated to force you out of chrome/firefox and into the app they control. Yes, but nobody makes a slow and bloated app on purpose. It's slow and bloated because they have deprioritized the web app.
- kevin_thibedeau 5y agoThe interstitial propeller pages on mobile browsers are definitely purposeful delays to degrade the web experience. Switch to the desktop site and all of a sudden pages reload immediately.
- Philip-J-Fry 5y ago
- oversocialized 5y ago
- lizardactivist 5y ago
- moron4hire 5y agoWhat are some examples of wrong opinions?
- dijonman2 5y agoAnti lockdown. Capitalism.
- XMPPwocky 5y agofwiw these are wrong opinions, not "wrong" opinions. the people who are clueful about things and have already understood enough about social engineering to understand those issues just don't have the dopamine to explain it to you or anybody else you mislead, so it's useful to just push those goofy ideas down in the sort order. For what it's worth, if you actually want to discuss those issues with me, feel free- ping @mimir:xmppwocky.net on Element. Make a throwaway account if you're worried. I'll explain why those ideas are wrong, one-on-one, in private, off-the-record. It's fun to think about "scary" and "dangerous" ideas (you know this already), but it's just not useful to do in public. Doesn't work. So it goes.
- jtbayly 5y ago> I know how this works: someone will show an example and someone else will say that decent human beings don't think like that and that they deserve to be silenced.
- XMPPwocky 5y ago1. yes, "decent human beings" (which don't exist) don't think like that, because it's not ideal to believe things that are not predictive of future expected sense-data. Sorry. 2. People don't deserve to be silenced. They don't deserve to be happy, either. They don't deserve anything. (But they don't deserve nothing, either). In physics, as in hacking computers, as in metalinguistics, all models are wrong, and some are useful. This way of thinking has an excellent use: it feels very good, and you get to be happy. But is it Wrong? Crazy? Too Radical? Thinking this about yourself hurts, a lot. Am I broken? Is everybody else broken? (yes.) Is the world inevitably doomed? (yes.) In our lifetime? (probably not, but act carefully to make sure that doesn't happen! yes, this can involve Participating In Politics. It's okay, you have my permission.) Questioning your own beliefs is absolutely terrifying, but once you do it and realize you're still fine, you 1. realize you can question other peoples' beliefs and 2. start posting comments Like This. On the one hand, I could turn off these weird text quirks. On the other hand, I could shoot myself and not have to worry about feeling bad about 'em. On the third hand, there's a weird little sockpuppet. That's me. Hi! Anyways, anybody who isn't comfortable enough with who they are to have these conversations with 'emselves and trusted others will inevitably either 1. break important things or 2. break themselves to avoid breaking other stuff. That sucks to see, y'know? They'll never be able to be any sort of halfway-decent hacker, even though they clearly had that potential growing up. I could try to fix 'em (and do a decent job of it, the vast majority of the time), but, eh, it's kinda fun to watch itself squirm. Puppets are for playing with, after all. Just... careful with identity and social engineering. Like handing a knife to a child. But it's fun to whittle, and important to share that experience once you know how cool it is to have a weird little duck or something you made yourself. Anyways, here's a cool knife I've found. No, you can't use it. Make your own. Just get some metal and sharpen it or something? Maybe not even metal. Damn near anything will work if you just want to cut stuff. Hell, chip some obsidian if you have to. Any port in a storm.
- oh_sigh 5y agoJust a few weeks ago, I had multiple of my 15 year accounts permanently suspended from reddit, for no apparent reason*, with no recourse. A few days later I tried to create an account, and it was immediately permanently suspended as well. Then, I cleared all of my cookies/autofill/local storage data, connected to my phone's hotspot (which I had never done before), and made another account, and it still got banned shortly thereafter. I have to guess this is why they are fingerprinting. * They said it was for ban evasion, but I wasn't banned anywhere as far as I knew. The only thing I can guess is that their systems grouped my accounts with someone else's accounts(maybe we connected via the same coffee shop hotspot at one point, or something), they got banned, and then it looked like they were evading the ban with my accounts.
- akomtu 5y agoSame IP + same User-Agent already tells with high confidence that it's the same user. And that's without JS.
- dylan604 5y agoSame IP + same User-Agent is not unique at all. I know nothing about big data unique identification of visitors, but I do know that much.
- jeromegv 5y agoPhone hotspot would have been a different IP.
- tinus_hn 5y agoOr it's two people in the same McDonalds with an up-to-date iPhone. Not exceptional at all.
- benibela 5y agoDo they still use it or was that A/B testing only?
- splonk 5y agoI would speculate that this is mostly meant to be used for identifying bot rings and ATO (account takeover). Brand new accounts on a site with open signups are, on average, quite a lot more suspicious than older accounts. There's a significant demand for aged accounts to use for various banned activities (mostly spam first and vote manipulation second), and fingerprinting is likely a high value signal in combating it. Two easy ways to generate aged accounts in bulk - create a whole lot of them and wait (and optionally do some activity on them to make them look real), or take over abandoned or compromised accounts. Fingerprinting is very good at identifying clusters of the former, and at least helpful for the latter. EFF appears to have rebranded Panopticlick as "Cover Your Tracks", but it's usually a fun thing to look at in discussions of this type as an example of what can go into a fingerprint and the informational value of various parts: https://coveryourtracks.eff.org https://coveryourtracks.eff.org
- rhizome 5y agoI'm under the impression that there's one thing that works almost 100%: nominal payment for account creation. A few bucks. Or more, if you also want it to help run the site. Bonus for the latter case is that you're also helping to protect your users from advertisers running a train on their browsers.
- ajsnigrutin 5y agoYeah... this makes you lose all your privacy, and exclude all the people in the world who either don't have a credit card, or don't want to use one. Thank you, but no.
- rhizome 5y agoThat's a separate problem. The topic is about running a site that crawls up your browser's ass as far as possible.
- ajsnigrutin 5y agoThis is assuming, that they wont profile/fingerprint you, if you pay. Surely no service like that would ever double dip
- lnxg33k1 5y agoAnd the most frustrating thing is that even if I don’t actually use Reddit I find myself ending up on it just because a lot of times it happens that a lot of dev related interesting material has been posted on it: so a call to any dev out there, can we stop posting stuff on Reddit please (and also discord ) Make forums great again please
- soheil 5y agoI feel the same about GitHub issues. We’ve regressed to a place on the internet that the only way to know what the right answer to a problem is by painstakingly scrolling and counting the number of heart and thumbs up emojis.
- nathancahill 5y agoStill sounds like progress considering we came from this: https://xkcd.com/979/ https://xkcd.com/979/
- plazmatic 5y ago
- throw_m239339 5y agoYou can block Javascript for reddit domain by default and still use old.reddit.com url if you're just browsing the website. There is absolutely no need to run Javascript for that. It's true there is a need for a programming focused community that is outside reddit. Reddit host objectively depraved material along with scientific or programming subs, and has been caught spreading revenge porn or grooming minors multiple times. Never used discord.
- beeboop 5y agoI'll never stop finding it hilarious that the very first step of the "Reddit crackdown" was the subreddit fatpeoplehate. They left up all the subreddits about abusing women, people getting murdered, revenge porn, outright racism and targeted harassment groups. But making fun of fat people? Gotta stomp that right out.
- pleb_nz 5y agoDoes the browser allow sites to check for installed extensions? If yes, is there an extension to block extension checking
- jazzyjackson 5y agoIt's not something you can query, but many extensions inject JS or markup into the DOM, and you could scan the DOM for such changes. For instance, password managers inject a "fill password" button into login fields that you could detect.
- dylan604 5y agoWhile I agree that PW managers alter the DOM elements that could be identified, I've never seen 1Pass inject a button like this. I have however seen it add data attributes to elements though. What PW Managers add a button like that?
- dang 5y agoOne past thread: Reddit's website uses DRM for fingerprinting - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23774394 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23774394 - July 2020 (540 comments)
- qwerty456127 5y ago> ... Checks if devtools is open ... Detects installed text to speech voices ... Detects if some Chrome extensions are installed ... No web code should be given technical means to do such things in the first place. A big part of the problem is browsers are too liberal in exposing various unreasonable APIs.
- technobabbler 5y agoIt's almost like the browser was made by an advertising company.
- qwerty456127 5y agoLike Mozilla? :-) I use Firefox happily (and have DRM support disabled completely) but doubt it differs seriously in this aspect.
- technobabbler 5y agoMozilla is a Google funded project whose main driving force is keeping up with Chrome, isn't it? It's not like they determine browser standards... Google and Apple set those and everyone else follows or dies. Edit: Even in the IE days they were always playing catchup. Firefox is just the poor/free man's alternative to the corporate browser of the moment. They don't really steer the ship, just follow trends. And these days Mozilla is basically an adware company anyhow. They just keep bundling random crap with their browser.
- PawBer 5y agoJust don't visit websites you don't trust. There is nothing wrong with exposing useful functionality.
- iakov 5y agoYou can’t be serious. Does this mean not clicking on any links in the search that dont lead to a “trusted” site? Not following any links that your friends send you? I think fixing the browser is a less tedious task than limiting useful internet surface like this.
- corford 5y agoAll the leading anti-bot companies do similar things (see: Shape Security, Datadome, Imperva). I often wonder what the GDPR implications might be for these providers; given the amount of invasive, uniquely identifying telemetry they hoover up.
- IYasha 5y agoWith this Reddit lost at least one reader, me.