11 ms·
Complaints mount after GitHub launches new algorithmic feed
- viswd 5y agoi can live with repo suggestions but if you want to build a social network use a subdomain or new top level i dont want to see that Bjorn876 has followed Frodo42 in my github feed!
- ape4 5y agoI took a look at mine and it might be interesting. Its in addition to the "following" feed - that's still there. It had people and projects I might want to check out based on (er, something). Why not? I might find something I like. It recommended a Rust project but I haven't posted any Rust.
- tedivm 5y agoYeah I actually like it. Besides, it's an optional new tab- you can completely ignore it if you don't like it. If they remove the existing chronological based feed then I can see why people might complain, but that hasn't happened.
- mfontani 5y agoI'm happy seeing random/algorithmically picked stuff shown on the homepage RHS ("Explore repositories") - it doesn't hurt me, and I might find something useful there. I don't want algorithmic stuff on the _main_ part of the page, which instead contains repositories and people I follow. I'd draw the line at this.
- V1ndaar 5y agoThe best part is when GitHub recommends me my own repositories in the right bar! Love that, always wanted to learn about those.
- dmitriid 5y agoWhy do developer companies keep thinking they are aocial twitter-facebook-like things? It goes from small things like hiding exact timestamps behind meaningless "2d ago" to this bullshit
- pizza234 5y ago> Why do developer companies keep thinking they are aocial twitter-facebook-like things? Because open source is significantly social in nature; it's not just an available blob of code. I don't necessarily agree with their direction, but the social aspect is certainly a foundational component.
- cassianoleal 5y agoI think the issue is not with it being social in general, but rather with it becoming a similar flavour of social to the likes of Facebook, Twitter, etc. Github has always been a social tool without the need for a newsfeed-type thing.
- chockchocschoir 5y ago> Github has always been a social tool without the need for a newsfeed-type thing. GitHub has always had various activity feeds. Here are two early screenshots from 2008: > Project and Developer News Feeds - Keep tabs on your favorite projects and the people that work on them. https://web.archive.org/web/20081113115832/http://github.com/images/modules/home/medium_screens/dashboard.png https://web.archive.org/web/20081113115832/http://github.com... > Public Developer Profiles - See what other developers are working on and how many commits they've made https://web.archive.org/web/20081113115936/http://github.com/images/modules/home/medium_screens/user.png https://web.archive.org/web/20081113115936/http://github.com... From https://web.archive.org/web/20081111061111/http://github.com/ https://web.archive.org/web/20081111061111/http://github.com...
- cassianoleal 5y agoAre any of those algorithmically selected? If not, then my argument stands. Sure, the one sentence you picked, taken out of context, makes it look like I'm generally against feeds. When you put it in the broad context of my comment though, you can easily see that it's the AI bit that's the problem.
- corobo 5y agoGitHub has finally gone full SoLoMo (ref https://youtu.be/J-GVd_HLlps?t=50 https://youtu.be/J-GVd_HLlps?t=50 )
- 0des 5y agoSocial local mobile?
- everdrive 5y agoAlgorithmic feeds are always hostile to the user. They limit what a user sees, and slowly infantilizes them by teaching them to passively consume rather actively seek information. I've never encountered a situation where an algorithmic feed made things better. At best, they make things more addictive.
- charcircuit 5y ago>They limit what a user sees No, a screen has limited real estate. There is only so many things that can be shown to you at once. So on youtube for example there maybe only be room to show 8 videos. Ideally I should find all 8 videos interesting. If I don't, that's a waste of space and a waste of my time. Algorithmic feeds serve to improve the results such that I am more likely to watch a video that is put in one of those 8 spots compared to if I was just shown trending videos or videos from my subscription box. It is not hostile to me because it saves me time in finding something to watch. You are not being turned into a baby just because you no longer have to search for stuff manually. There is a difference between wanting to find something specific and just wanting to find something interesting. >I've never encountered a situation where an algorithmic feed made things better. One of the best algorithmic feeds is TikTok. After that YouTube's is pretty good to. I suggest trying one of those sites out to just see how effective they are in finding content that interests you. I have found algorithmic feeds have at least made things net better. There is too much information in the world to have to search through all of it ourselves. These algorithms solve the problem of dealing with this large scale of data.
- epicide 5y ago> Algorithmic feeds serve to improve the results such that I am more likely to watch a video that is put in one of those 8 spots compared to if I was just shown trending videos or videos from my subscription box. Right, that's the promise from algorithmic feeds. Sometimes, for some time, it's even the reality! I think there's some middle ground and nuance to be had here, though. I agree that just because there's "an algorithm" doesn't mean it's bad or a worse user experience. Finding interesting videos is a great example. However, I think it's fair to also say that video recommendation algorithms have gotten out of hand. We have a lot of content creators who are influenced in how to make their videos by what is popular. After all, if I make a video that is obviously more successful than another one, that means my audience likes it more, right? What did that video do differently that made it so much more successful? After a long enough time, you end up inadvertently (or intentionally) catering to the whims of the algorithm and not just your audience. So the issue I have with algorithmic feeds isn't that they are outright a bad idea for users. The problem is that it is not just a feature for users. It starts to shape the content on the platform. This can be used to subtly influence content creators to make better content, but without any idea of what goes into these algorithms, we are left to make wild religious guesses. And we have to assume that these algorithms serve the (financial) needs of the companies behind them and their sponsors, first and foremost. If not now, then gradually, by the same feedback loop as happens to the content creators.
- eloisius 5y agoI look forward to the quasi-spam slurry of infiniscroll feed crap once growth hackers start trying to game the algorithm to get more traction for their project. I don’t think you can introduce a recommendation algorithm without it having a negative effect on the content it’s supposed to aid discovery of. Pre-recsys, the content is made for human consumption, but once you add the recsys, the AI itself becomes part of the audience and its opinion matters. Unfortunately its opinion matters more than the humans’, but its taste is abysmal. So content gets optimized for a brain dead AI and humans get garbage. I hate it because GitHub was one product I really loved, but since MS bought them it seems like they are doing all this random stuff to solve problems that aren’t even a problem. How about getting back to the basics, like reliable uptime, and less glitchy JS soup?
- MichaelBurge 5y agoWhat exactly does "optimizing for Github recommendations" mean? I'm not writing and debugging 10,000 lines of C just to farm Github stars. It seems crazy to think anyone would change how they work for that. Whereas, people on Youtube/Twitter/Facebook/etc. really do change their videos or writing to spread better.
- genocidicbunny 5y agoThat will really depend on how the algorithm weighs different signals. For example, lets say that projects that have a high issue resolution rate are promoted more -- that will just spur people to create small easily fixed issues to boost their ranking. Any metric the algorithm uses will be subject to being gamed in some way.
- AlexandrB 5y agoCommerce finds a way. As soon as there's potential for financial benefit, someone will figure out how to optimize repos for the feed's algorithm. Perhaps this will mean clickbaity README.md files or frequent, trivial code changes to make a repo look more "active". We'll see, I guess.
- epicide 5y ago
- naoqj 5y agoCan't you just... not look at it? github is not a social website; I see no reason to ever visit the home page.
- EsperHugh 5y ago>github is not a social website you may not like it, but Github has always been a social website, and now more than ever, just like LinkedIn.
- jillesvangurp 5y agoAlso interesting that MS owns both of those networks. Both pretty smart investments.
- da39a3ee 5y agoNonsense. GitHub is for working with git repositories. It might have some weird social feed stuff tacked on, but I've never used it in 13 years and to say it's not the main point is an understatement. OTOH social interactions is very obviously the main point of LinkedIn?
- chockchocschoir 5y agoYou might not have used it as such, but GitHub always aimed to be a social platform and launched as such. Here is their landing page when they first launched: https://web.archive.org/web/20081111061111/http://github.com/ https://web.archive.org/web/20081111061111/http://github.com... Notice how the entire page is making you believe they are building a social coding platform? That's no accident, "Social code hosting" tagline in the logo included.
- naoqj 5y agoI bet almost all users of the platform don't consider it a social platform and don't use it as such.
- Shadonototra 5y agoNo wonder why microsoft bought them, they wanted to kill github
- blisterpeanuts 5y agoWhy would MS want to kill github? It's huge, it serves a vital need, and if MS does manage to strangle it in some way, someone else will fork a similar service and everyone will flock to that, similarly to how everyone left Sourceforge for Github, as I understand it.
- Shadonototra 5y agothat kind of features turn off many developers, including me reason why i abandoned MSN messenger back in the days was because they started to mimic facebook features, same thing as skype, as people pointed in the github discussion
- blisterpeanuts 5y agoAgreed but it seems some bean counter types at Microsoft are interested in monetizing Github beyond its current subscription plans. Perhaps they didn't ask developers whether they want to be algorithmically influenced or whatever.
- prepend 5y agoMicrosoft sells MSDN subscriptions for enterprise users. And that’s more than the GitHub revenue. It’s weird in that I recently discovered a few hundred programmers who may $500-2n/year/person to Microsoft for visual Studio and more for a devops/teams foundation server/vsts and two full time admin contractors to administer the source server. There’s a lot of money in this space that Microsoft is probably losing as orgs migrate to GitHub.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- da39a3ee 5y agoI've used GitHub intensively for 13 years. I've never looked at the front page or "feed". Why would you? GitHub is for working with git repositories, it's not a social website.
- chockchocschoir 5y agoThat's great, if you never look at the front page nor the feed, you're not even affected by this change. Leave the "outrage" for people who are affected by it.
- namose 5y agoIf a sufficient number of gh users do look at the page, you’ll be affected by SEO on the repos you follow if they care about growth.
- eloisius 5y agoNo one is worried about a page you can ignore. We’re worried about the second-order effects that trying to game that page will have on the rest of the site.
- toto444 5y agoI am interested in Japanese learning and Emoji and I am actually happy that Github recommends me repos related to these topics.
- danirod 5y agoWhile I cannot trust algorithmic feeds anymore and I expect this to become an issue in the future, I have to say that based on what I've seen in my own "For you" tab, GitHub is doing a good job on showing updates from repositories that I starred and then forgot about, and I actually find that feature nice.
- toastal 5y agoNow you can easily clean up the regular feed with uBlock Origin `github.com###dashboard [aria-labelledby="feed-original"] :is(.follow, .watch_started)` will remove "someone followed something" and "someone starred something" which can help you focus on the updates that are critical aspects of updated issues and releases, and can just click over to the social media feed "For You (Beta)" for that kind of stuff if you feel so inclined (or you can ignore it). I have `github.com##aside[aria-label="Explore"]` as well to not get distracted with the recommendations I didn't ask for on the index page either.
- makecheck 5y agoI forget sometimes how good it really is at blocking. I had blocked certain things long ago and when I eventually see the original accidentally somewhere else I am shocked by the annoyances.
- toastal 5y agoLiterally turned off uBlock for something and hopped over to GitHub and it was full of so much useless nonsense and I don't even follow a lot of people.
- chockchocschoir 5y ago> as users worried the recommendations were turning GitHub into something distressingly like a social media platform. Really users? This is news? I'll echo what I've said in another comment (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30769570 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30769570) regarding GitHub being a social platform: > GitHub has always branded itself as a "social collaboration platform" rather than anything else (well, first "git hosting" but secondly the social stuff). > Here is a early version of their landing page from 2008 (the year they launched): https://web.archive.org/web/20081111061111/http://github.com/ https://web.archive.org/web/20081111061111/http://github.com... > Notice the logo says "Social code hosting" and the messaging of the page is mostly around popular repositories, collaborative features and other social elements. Anyone surprised by a "social code hosting" platform implementing new social features are in for a bleak feature, as the platform still aims (and always have aimed) to be the social place for coders.
- andrew_ 5y agoI think it's fair to be surprised by curated anything on Github as that's not been their M.O. since I can remember, and I was a first-year adopter.
- typeofhuman 5y agoHow much longer until they release GitHub Stories? /s but not really
- chockchocschoir 5y agoAgain, you shouldn't be surprised if a company who always branded itself as "social" adds any new social features.
- viswd 5y agoI think part of the fear is that they will expand it into a larger social network, that was my knee jerk reaction.
- bawolff 5y ago"Social" is not a synonym for "facebook". Github is a collaborative social platform. This still seems pointless and offbrand. There is no contradiction here.
- eminence32 5y agoI feel like I'm in the minority here: when I saw this new feature, I thought it could be useful and a better replacement for what's currently there. I don't follow many people, so the "old" feed was pretty boring and stale. However, the "new" feed is showing me things that I find interesting, like a new release of openzfs, even though I'm not watching that repo. I understand why might be worse for other people, but I disagree in general with the idea that this is categorically the wrong thing for github to do.
- JohnHaugeland 5y agonah, most of us like it, we just don't want to get into the fracas with the people talking about always-bad and inherently-evil
- dxbydt 5y ago> Algorithmic feeds are always hostile to the user….They limit what a user sees…never encountered a situation where an algorithmic feed made things better I don’t know if Github should do algorithmic feeds. That said, my literal job description is to design an algorithmic feed for a tv news app. That’s what I’ve done - written an algo that decides what news gets shown, in what order => implicitly means a whole bunch of newsclips never get shown…or they are at the end of the queue and 90% of the viewers would never get to them. Why does one do this ? Because screen real estate is finite. You turn on your tv, you have a finite rectangular canvas - I can show maybe 5 squares on that rectangle without scrolling. Each square has a newsclip with text & picture. Who gets to decide which 5 clips to show ? Well, my algo does. How else would you do it ? There are literally 100s of 1000s of newsclips per day! Can’t show every single one of them - nobody has the time, nobody would watch, most of it is not going to be relevant to the vast majority of the audience. So 10000 newsclips get filtered down to 5 clips that get shown on the screen. You scroll. 5 more. Scroll again. 5 more. So on…you cap at 50 clips…nobody scrolls that much anyways. That’s why you have an algorithmic feed - because there is too much content, but your brain real estate is finite. Your screen real estate is finite. The amount of time you have to watch news is finite. Your interest in news is finite. All of this has been measured, analyzed, sliced & diced. Your time is finite. But content is infinite. There is just too much news. Take finance news - 100s of companies reporting earnings every given day, associated commentary around buying/selling that stock, how the company is doing…1000s of newsclips! Take political news - so much footage, all the way from local municipal town hall meetings to presidential press conferences. Take entertainment news…man, there is so much music/movie/art/talent related content. Can’t show everything. Hence algorithmic feed. Now sure, you can complain that the algo isn’t showing you what you personally want - its trained on the entire viewer population, not on your personal tastes. So most algos let you personalize the feed. But without an algo…there’s just no hope.
- chockchocschoir 5y ago> Now sure, you can complain that the algo isn’t showing you what you personally want - its trained on the entire viewer population, not on your personal tastes. So most algos let you personalize the feed. But without an algo…there’s just no hope. I think that the common complain is not "it isn't showing what I personally want" VS "it isn't showing what people generally want" but rather that the algorithm is often not tuned to "what X want" at all, but tuned to "what brings company most money". For example, YouTube recommendations are biased towards channels that have monetization activated, as YouTube earns more money that way, while ignoring channels the viewer (at large, or personally) would enjoy more.
- shafyy 5y agoI like that GitHub tries to make a better feed. I like it because it could help me with my open source repos. 1) To reach new people and 2) notify existing stargazers that I've released a new update and 3) help me discover new interesting repos. It remains to be seen if the new feed proves useful. But I wouldn't say that just because they use an algorithm it needs to suck per se. There's algorithm and there's algorithm.
- andrew_ 5y agoLots of speculation in the replies here with one common theme: No one seems to know, or has yet to define, what "social coding" actually means. Not even Github.
- zerkten 5y agoIs that a bad thing? It seems to leave the door open for a lot of explorations. It seems like it doesn't affect critical functionality that much.
- chadlavi 5y agoHuh, so people actually look at/pay any attention to that feed page?
- kwhitefoot 5y agoI didn't even know that Github had any kind of feed (whatever that really means). And I don't care. I visit Github to report a bug, read about the progress of fixing it and then close the page. I never read anything else on Github, why would I?
- justinhj 5y agoGithub isn’t TikTok
- e2le 5y agoYou say that but GitHub is an expensive platform to run, how else are they going to boost engagement and increase it's profitably? Wont somebody please think of the shareholders? /s
- rad_gruchalski 5y agoYou're correct. It isn't. It doesn't push random 30 second videos.
- throwaway889900 5y agoIsn't that what gists are for?
- vivegi 5y agoHow long before GH starts pushing email spam with digests of "Projects that might interest you"? It would be great if they could instead redirect efforts to tie their recommendation engine to their search results. User intent is clearer and serendipitous recommendations surfacing in the results would actually be of value.
- rad_gruchalski 5y agohttps://cs.github.com https://cs.github.com and until that's publicly available: https://sourcegraph.com https://sourcegraph.com.
- u2077 5y agoNobody asked GitHub to become a social media platform. Why not improve search instead? When I want to find something, I will look for it, and know what I’m looking for. There’s no point in pushing a bunch of random repos in my face with an algorithm that can and will be abused.
- dawnerd 5y agoI second them improving search. If I try to search for a line of code, it doesn't consider special characters, you know the ones like everyone uses in code. Edit: somehow search autocorrected to support.
- Destiner 5y agoTheir latest code search thing [1] is pretty powerful already imo. [1] https://cs.github.com https://cs.github.com
- MrStonedOne 5y ago
- u2077 5y agoSweet! Joined the waitlist.
- rad_gruchalski 5y agoAlternatively, until that becomes available: https://sourcegraph.com https://sourcegraph.com.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- klohto 5y agoAny comparison with grep.app?
- havkom 5y agoA tip from recent experience with GitHub: Don’t rely _solely_ on GitHub for your work.
- bfdm 5y agoGitHub has a feed?
- version_five 5y agoExactly what I was scrolling though here looking for a discussion of. I'm assuming (I'm on my phone and not going to check) that if you go to github.com there is a landing page with a feed? I use github 90% of the time for interacting with my / my companies repos, and the rest to peruse a repo I've been directed to for whatever reason. I have never been to the homepage (except maybe to sign in), and I have never used it to get news or find new repos or whatever a feed is for. I can see the potential to turn it into social media, that's fine as long as it doesn't bleed in to the actual repository management functionality.
- matthewfcarlson 5y agoGitHub has a feed? Who sits down while in the bathroom and scrolls their GitHub feed?
- dbingham 5y agoI posted this to their feedback, but I'll share it here too. The new algorithmic feed gives me absolutely nothing of value - it's giving me a bunch of information I have no need for or interest in. It's just adding pure noise and no signal. The following feed might work for people who use the commit as the unit of review, but since there's no way to filter it to a certain subset of repos, it's also way too noisy to be useful. And for those of us who use the Pull Request as the unit of review, it's absolutely useless. Again, all noise and no signal. I would love the ability to construct an arbitrary number of custom feeds to surface information I actually need. I want to create new feeds, select whether they contain commits, pull request activity (PRs opened, closed, merged, and reviewed, and commented on), or both. Then I want to be able to filter which repos/organizations that feed is limited to. Ideally, I'd be able to select a set of feeds to show on the homepage as tabs I could click between to quickly scan activity in the subsets of repos I work on. So for example, I would create one feed to be my "Primary Responsibility area at Work". This would be the subset of repos I am primarily responsible for at my workplace. I'd configure it to show PR activity - new PR opens, new reviews, new comments (on review or on the PR), and PR merges or closes. This would surface the information I need and would allow me to very quickly scan to see whether there were any PRs I needed to look over or PR discussions I wanted to add my voice to. This is not a view I have right now. Notifications doesn't surface this information in a way that's easy to scan, and otherwise I have to go digging through (potentially) multiple boards or issues lists to see it. Instead being able to quickly scan down a feed of comments or reviews and reply right in the feed, I have to click through numerous screens and it's easy to miss stuff. I would then create a second feed that would be "All of work" which I would configure to be just PR activity for my work organization. This would allow me to quickly scan activity in other repos that I'm not primarily responsible for, and contribute if there are things of value I could add. Right now I can't do this at all, I have to rely on my teammates tagging me in. It's just much too time consuming to try to scan through all the activity - even though, were it presented in feed format of just the new stuff, there's probably not so much that I couldn't easily scan it every day. It's the amount of digging through screens and trying to figure out what's new that's time consuming. Then I'd create a feed for "My Stuff" which would contain all activity on repos I own (PRs and Commits). This would be mostly empty since, for the most part, I'm not collaboration with folks right now. But someday I'd like to, and this feed would be very useful then. Finally I'd create various feeds for the all the open source I follow based on what project is, how interested in it I am, and how involved in I am. Having this ability - the ability to create multiple custom feeds to surface this information I want by groups that are meaningful to me - has the potential to make collaboration on Github much easier and more efficient. One of the problems we face as a team is knowing when we need to respond to a pull request. And right now we mostly solve that with process (pinging each other, standups) and tooling (Jira/Slack). Having a feed we could quickly check for new activity would significantly grease those wheels and save us time elsewhere.
- pabs3 5y agoAm I the only one who has never really used the GitHub feed? I seem to only ever login on pages other than the front page.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- patientplatypus 5y agoThis isn't on my github - this doesn't sound real unless their beta testing on some accounts and not others. So it's a bad idea and they'll turn it off. Storm in a tea cup.
- eezing 5y agoI don’t mind the new one because I didn’t use the old one. Most of the content before contained changes to code on company projects I don’t contribute to. The new content has been mostly relevant to the code and tech I work with on a daily basis.