3 ms·
> "Google has explicitly and repeatedly instructed its employees to shield important business communications from discovery by using false requests for legal ad
by paxys 5y ago
> "Google has explicitly and repeatedly instructed its employees to shield important business communications from discovery by using false requests for legal advice"
Considering the DoJ is expecting to use these documents for their own case against Google, I don't see how they can argue that it was improper for the employees to get lawyers involved.
- ceejayoz 5y agoYou can't just CC legal on pretty much everything to subvert regulatory action. If legal's openly ignoring these CCs, I don't see why attorney/client privilege should necessarily apply.
- mountainb 5y agoIt doesn't apply. It's not even a clever workaround. It has to be a communication that requests or involves legal advice. If you just forward a public email to your lawyer or CC the attorney on normal business communication it is not privileged. If you forward such an email to the attorney and ask something like "thoughts? what are the risks here?" that ensuing email chain is privileged. If emails are CC'd to a lawyer to evade discovery and the other side finds out, that's a big problem, even bigger problem if the other side is the feds.
- colinmhayes 5y agoSo what if you added an email header that said "P&C, any risks here?" to every email and had a lawyer who set up an auto reply that said "everything looking legal here"?
- vkou 5y agoThen you better pray to whatever deity you hold dear that the judge presiding over this case, and the attorney litigating against you are both absolute idiots, who won't see what you are trying to do. Generally speaking, judges don't like it when you try to hack the law.
- mountainb 5y agoCorrect. Any sensible judge will lynch the attorney.
- ceejayoz 5y agoBoth parties might want to non-automatically engage a third lawyer in your scenario. They'll be needing one.
- Melatonic 5y agoJust create a fake username and email called "John Lawyer Man" and CC him on everything - Government regulators HATE this!
- late2part 5y agoThis X 100!!
- joshenberg 5y ago"Get lawyers involved" certainly shouldn't include situations where you simply CC them and they don't respond. No legal advice is given.
- SkyBelow 5y agoCould we answer this by removing email from the question? If I go to a lawyer and ask them a question in person, seeking legal advice, even if they don't response and just show me the door, is what I am saying protected? I would think yes. If I ensure my lawyer is in every single discussion I ever have with anyone else, just to say all my discussions are protected, what would happen? I assume that wouldn't work and there is already a standard on how to handle this for in person meetings. Shouldn't that same standard be applied to discussions happening through email?