4 ms·
You can ask the same question about self-driving cars.
by amelius 5y ago
You can ask the same question about self-driving cars.
- version_five 5y agoThis is ignorant. There is lots of information about the safety of human driven cars, it is not a high bar to improve upon, and can be verified. The technology in question is introducing a new form of potentially ruinous statistical surveillance that didn't exist before.
- kaba0 5y agoDo you mean the terribly done statistics that collect data from uneventful motorways’ miles, while people automatically switch back to manual driving when a problematic situation arises, effectively filtering out any interesting data?
- KarlKemp 5y agoYou’re ignoring the Trolley Problem of it all: is it moral to knowingly let uninvolved person X die if it saves the lives of Y and Z? Fortunately, the policy choice at issue here isn’t one where there is definitive harm on the track, just risks that can be compared.
- mejutoco 5y agoIMO It is more: is it immoral to let person X die justifying it with an unreasonable fetish for tech and its unrealized potential? I am only half kidding :)
- passivate 5y ago>There is lots of information about the safety of human driven cars, it is not a high bar to improve upon, and can be verified. That doesn't make sense. The 'average' driver gets into millions of accidents. I don't want a slight above average driver driving my family around, and I don't want slightly above average drivers around me - especially those who I can't communicate with - by honking, by shouting to get their attention, and algorithms who have no fear of their own life, etc. All software has bugs and I don't want my safety contingent on developers making mistakes. The self driving car must be orders of magnitude above the BEST human driver, and there must be punitive damages in place as a deterrent, to compensate aggrieved parties, etc. At present, self-driving cars are unproven dangerous technology that is being rightfully scrutinized.
- sebzim4500 5y agoCurrently you are surrounded by average drivers. Why are you worried about them being replaced with slightly above average drivers?
- passivate 5y agoNo, I am not. I haven't gotten into an accident, nor have I witnessed one that resulted in a fatality or any major injury. The distribution of skills amongst drivers isn't geographically even , nor is it static.
- Schiendelman 5y agoWhat makes you think it’s not geographically even (at least in a country like the US)?
- passivate 5y agoBecause I haven't seen it proven in any domain, it sounds too naive to believe that people have equal abilities and skills by geography (or any other random metric). Population centers will have greater access to training, also in this example more cars on the road will co-relate to more opportunity to practice driving skills, but also more opportunity for accidents, etc, etc. In any case, if you look at outcomes in terms of car crashes/fatalities, the data also shows what you would expect - https://worldpopulationreview.com/state-rankings/fatal-car-accidents-by-state https://worldpopulationreview.com/state-rankings/fatal-car-a...
- bastawhiz 5y agoWhat measure are you using for "slightly above average" that also equals "unproven dangerous"? If the above average technology is dangerous, surely the average driver is even more dangerous. Otherwise it's not really above average, no? I.e., how can you make fewer errors and be a measurably better driver but still be worse than the thing that you're measurably better than? Either you're making this argument in bad faith because you just don't like self driving cars, or you don't believe in statistics as a concept.
- omginternets 5y agoSelf-driving cars have the potential to reduce serious harm by a significant margin. Are you saying the same is true with Apple's CSAM-detection measures? If so, how is curbing CSAM consumption going to prevent children from being raped, exactly? And I do mean exactly. The only arguments I have heard thus far appeal to some vague link between producers and consumers, predicated on the idea that CSAM producers are doing it for the celebrity/notoriety, or for financial profit. Both of these claims are highly suspect, and seem to rest on a confusion between trading CSAM online and paying traffickers for sex with children. You may be correct, but it's going to take more than a superficial comparison to convince anyone.
- passivate 5y ago>You may be correct, but it's going to take more than a superficial comparison to convince anyone. Well you just hand-waved the idea the self-driving cars can reduce harm by a "significant" margin - based on what exactly?
- omginternets 5y agoIf that isn't true, then yes, we should seriously consider abandoning the idea of self-driving cars. I don't understand, though. Are you saying that this is a reason to accept Apple's CSAM-detection?
- passivate 5y agoOh, I'm with you on the CSAM. I just wanted clarity about the self-driving cars, its a pet peeve of mine.
- mejutoco 5y ago> If that isn't true, then yes, we should seriously consider abandoning the idea of self-driving cars. I wanted to share a (I found) controversial thought: Self-driving cars are the US response to trains. No taxes for railways are palatable, but private vehicles on special roads and profit to be made, great for the car industry. That, IMO, is what drives (pun intended) self-driven cars.
- ggreer 5y agoSelf-driving cars substitute for human-driven cars, which currently kill over a million people a year. If the first mass-adopted self-driving cars have half the fatality rate per mile of human-driven cars, then slowing their rollout by a day causes 1,800 deaths. Current prototype self-driving vehicles already have a lower fatality rate per mile than human-driven vehicles. Obviously this isn't an apples-to-apples comparison since current self-driving cars are constrained to certain locations and weather conditions, but if the goal is to minimize deaths, then we should be more gung-ho about this technology than we currently are. In contrast, CSAM scanning substitutes for... I'm not sure what. In addition to the risk of false positives, there's also the risk that the scanning technology will be used for other purposes in the future. I could easily see governments forcing Apple to scan everyone's hard drives for hate speech, 3d models of prohibited objects (such as gun parts), or communications sympathetic to certain groups. Once that door is cracked open, there is no closing it.
- simion314 5y ago>Obviously this isn't an apples-to-apples comparison since current self-driving cars are constrained to certain locations... It is much more worse, current so called self driving cars have human drivers that intervene most of the time and saved the idiot AI from crashes but Elon will not count this near crash as an actual crash. >but if the goal is to minimize deaths, then we should be more gung-ho about this technology than we currently are. We should maybe try to maybe to also do the obvious quick fixes at the same time? it would be much cheaper instead of forcing AI cars on people to force say a drunk/tired/talking on the phone detector , enforce better driving tests before giving licenses to drivers, put a tax for vehicle mass toe promote less heavy cars, enforce speed limits with tech. Do you think Bob will prefer to be forced to buy an expensive self driving car to reduce the car crashes stats or better to buy a safety device(black box) that he must install in the car.
- cuteboy19 5y agoIf the AI and the Human both try to correct each other's mistakes wouldn't that make a significantly better system?