10 ms·
M1 Ultra About 3x Bigger Than AMD's Ryzen CPUs
- gbolcer 5y agoMy favorite quote: "It's sort of like arguing that because your electric car can use dramatically less fuel when driving at 80 miles per hour than a Lamborghini, it has a better engine -- without mentioning the fact that a Lambo can still go twice as fast." https://www.macrumors.com/2022/03/17/m1-ultra-nvidia-rtx-3090-comparison/ https://www.macrumors.com/2022/03/17/m1-ultra-nvidia-rtx-309...
- stavros 5y agoRight, but if I can strap two electric cars together and go as fast as the Lamborghini for less fuel, isn't that still better?
- jayd16 5y agoThat link was about GPU power and according to the benchmarks it can't go as fast with two.
- stavros 5y agoI did read the link, this indicated to me that it sort-of can: > Apple's M1 Ultra is essentially two M1 Max chips connected together, and as The Verge highlighted in its full Mac Studio review, Apple has managed to successfully get double the M1 Max performance out of the M1 Ultra, which is a notable feat that other chip makers cannot match. Unless you're talking about power per watt? GPU workloads are generally inherently parallelizable so performance per watt is actually what generally matters, rather than raw FLOPS.
- pengaru 5y agoIn the analogy the Lamborghini would be an RTX 3090, and the macrumors article makes it abundantly clear the Ultra isn't even half of the RTX 3090 performance.
- stavros 5y agoRight, but rather than getting bogged down with the analogy, do we agree that performance per watt is what matters? It doesn't matter whether you need 2 or 2.43 of them to match an RTX 3090, if it has better performance per watt, it's better.
- pengaru 5y ago> Right, but rather than getting bogged down with the analogy, do we agree that performance per watt is what matters? No, I am not in agreement with you, the RTX 3090 is clearly better at being a GPU.
- hunterb123 5y ago> clearly better better is subjective, it depends on your needs. sometimes performance per watt is more important especially when you're mobile or trying to be conservative w/ electricity.
- pengaru 5y ago> sometimes performance per watt is more important especially when you're mobile or trying to be conservative w/ electricity. There is an obvious implicit context when you're comparing performance to an RTX 3090, and it is not mobility or your electric bill.
- hunterb123 5y agoThere may be only one implicit context for you, which is why I said "better" is subjective. Personally the M1 Ultra would be better imo as a desktop GPU than RTX 3090 in certain contexts. Putting it in a van, traveling with it, etc. I'll probably wait until the next go around of them, but I'm loving nearing desktop performance w/ reduced loads.
- readams 5y agoIt doesn't go as fast as a 3090 even with two. It does go about twice as fast as an M1 Max.
- jayd16 5y agoFirst graph with geekbench scores. RTX3090: 215,034 M1 Ultra: 102,156
- arecurrence 5y agoThe GB Compute test is widely viewed as worthless for the m1 Ultra chip because it’s too fast for the chip to ramp up. It’s even too short for the m1 Max.
- mikhailt 5y agoGeekbrench has already been debunked a long time ago by Anandtech as not sustaining the full load enough to show the real pref. The CPU and GPU tests finishes too fast for the system to ramp up to the full power load. That's not to say that M1 Ultra is equal or better than 3090, just that Geekbench isn't the right test for this. You can see more detailed analysis here: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pJ7WN3yome4 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pJ7WN3yome4
- smoldesu 5y agoIs that an indication that the M1 has latency issues vis-a-vis power delivery, then?
- g42gregory 5y agoThat’s nice to know, but for me the M1 Ultra performance is not very relevant. Apple has a history of introducing proprietary architectures, not-quite-compatibles interfaces and non-standard software. MacOS has nice UI? Great, I will use it. Anything computationally intensive? - Why bother? I would use only Linux on the back end. It’s very easy to couple mid-range Apple product with high-end Linux workstation at your desk. I don’t need to run compute-intensive Deep Learning load while I am at the coffee shop.
- jayd16 5y ago>I don’t need to run compute-intensive Deep Learning load while I am at the coffee shop. Well they're putting it in a desktop and claiming desktop performance... If Apple is going to put up graphs saying they beat i9 and 3090RTX machines, it's worth investigating even if I plan to put Linux on it. In this instance it seems like the reality doesn't match the hype as well as in the laptop space, but if it had I would surly consider the option.
- ohgodplsno 5y agoNo. You have two electric cars both going at 80 mph, with twice the weight. Strap them together aaaaaand.... They're still two electric cars going together at 80mph. But if you're counting wheel rotations, well now you have 8 spinning wheels. Top speed will still not match the Lamborghini.
- stavros 5y agoWhat's it called when you make an analogy for convenience and someone stretches it way past its breaking point as if it still applies to the original point?
- ask_b123 5y agohttps://english.stackexchange.com/questions/305332/is-there-a-word-or-expression-for-extrapolating-an-analogy-way-beyond-the-point https://english.stackexchange.com/questions/305332/is-there-... > overstretched or overblown analogy / reductio ad absurdum
- rocqua 5y agoWeight barely matters for top speed. Air drag is the real factor.
- phyalow 5y agoI am quite happy with my Macbook Pro M1 Max, which remains virtually ice cold even running heavy compute (I am still yet to hear the fans spin up) and having a battery life that can accomodate easily 12+ hours of real work. Any Windows laptop with a 3090 inside it, will be a hot and loud brick in comparison. Granted I dont play video games, and my ML compute is run in the cloud it fits my needs nicely. I would argue in terms of sheer generalised productivity nothing else comes close.
- aenis 5y agoSame here. Great computer. The only thing I am missing is a bit more reliable support for waking up external monitors. Between my now two m1/m1 max macs and 6 screens I use, one (an Asus 2k display which is slow to wake up from sleep) often requires unplugging to wake up. That is not a m1 issue - its been like that with macos since... forever, but it's irritating.
- Osiris 5y agoI use a 4 monitor setup for my workstation. I switched to a desktop computer in part to not have to deal with this exact issue with a MacBook.
- srcreigh 5y agoWhat is your monitor layout?
- aenis 5y agoI have those 6 screens plugged to two different macs, so just 3 on each. Big screen in the center, and two in portrait mode on the sides. One uses 43" 4k for the center screen, the other uses a 34" ultrawide. The m1 max drives its displays directly, the m1 via a starlink tripple 4k displaylink hub. The problems, in my case, are specific to monitors that take a good few seconds to come back from standby. Macos seems to be impatient and considers them dead. I am down to just 1 screen with this problem, and will replace it at some point.
- 5y ago
- mikhailt 5y agoAccording to Max Tech analysis here, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pJ7WN3yome4 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pJ7WN3yome4, the GPU seems to max out at 60-70w at the moment for full load, even if the heat is well-managed. If Apple let it go up to 100-120w, we could see much more performance out of the GPU but for now, something is not set up correctly on macOS. So, we may have to wait to see what Apple says or if they'll unlock the full performance in future software updates. They did do this in the past with M1 hardware a few times. Same result here from another channel where it appears GPU isn't at full power atm: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0CUoHwMtRsE&t=1172s https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0CUoHwMtRsE&t=1172s
- GeekyBear 5y agoThe strategy of creating a large die with lots of execution units, then running the chip at a lower clock speed for power efficiency has been Apple's way of doing things for a while now. >Apple has built a wide enough GPU that they can keep clockspeeds nice and low on the voltage/frequency curve, which keeps overall power consumption down. The RTX 3090, by contrast, is designed to chase performance with no regard to power consumption, allowing NVIDIA to get great performance out of it, but only by riding high on the voltage frequency curve. https://www.anandtech.com/show/17306/apple-announces-m1-ultra-combining-two-m1-maxes-for-even-more-performance https://www.anandtech.com/show/17306/apple-announces-m1-ultr... This strategy is something that Anandtech's been calling out since the iPhone 5s chip. >Brian and I have long been hinting at the sort of ridiculous frequency/voltage combinations mobile SoC vendors have been shipping at for nothing more than marketing purposes. I remember ARM telling me the ideal target for a Cortex A15 core in a smartphone was 1.2GHz. Samsung’s Exynos 5410 stuck four Cortex A15s in a phone with a max clock of 1.6GHz. The 5420 increases that to 1.7GHz. The problem with frequency scaling alone is that it typically comes at the price of higher voltage. There’s a quadratic relationship between voltage and power consumption, so it’s quite possibly one of the worst ways to get more performance. https://www.anandtech.com/show/7335/the-iphone-5s-review/2 https://www.anandtech.com/show/7335/the-iphone-5s-review/2
- mikhailt 5y ago> The strategy of creating a large die with lots of execution units, then running the chip at a lower clock speed for power efficiency has been Apple's way of doing things for a while now. > This strategy is something that Anandtech's been calling out since the iPhone 5s chip. Not sure that applies to M1 Ultra that's clearly marketed as a desktop SoC, not a mobile device or laptop SoC. Optimizing for energy efficiency or battery life is not the same as optimizing for performance first, which is what M1 Ultra is designed for. Not to mention, there's a reason Windows and Linux have multiple power profiles that changes how schedulers and power loads work. macOS has "high power mode" for m1 on laptops and yet strangely, it is not even available on the Mac Studio. Keep in mind that Apple showed a graph that clearly shows the GPU was at 100-110w. Why do that if they won't run it at that wattage or even talk about 3090 in the first place? Why ruin their reputation over a silly little thing? Everyone on the planet will easily debunk that. Also, why even bother adding a high-quality cooling system that the Mac Studio clearly don't need since both CPU/GPU are going to be capped at lower power wattage? We'll find out eventually one way or another.
- mrtksn 5y agoYou know what, Mercedes uses Renault engines in some of its cars that are intended for luxury daily use. Better != Faster or Better != More powerful Better means closer to fulfil the goals and often the goals are inversely proportional(i.e. cheaper, faster, cooler are the goals but faster meaning less cheaper and hotter). Apple might be guilty of misrepresentation of raw computational power but with M1 the experience of using computers has become significantly much better.
- marcodiego 5y agoActually better depends on the criteria. A Volkswagen Beetle can be better than any of the listed cars if you consider the type of road an easy of repair.
- homarp 5y agofor the curious https://luxurycarsa2z.com/which-mercedes-have-a-renault-engine/ https://luxurycarsa2z.com/which-mercedes-have-a-renault-engi...
- davewritescode 5y agoMercedes only uses Renault engines in its absolute bottom of the barrel products. Mercedes, unlike BMW with Mini and Audi with the VW parts bin has to outsource the low end stuff.
- oxplot 5y ago> without mentioning the fact that a Lambo can still go twice as fast To be picky about this analogy, top speed in a car is an attribute that bears little on everyday utility. In fact, past the 110km/h here in Australia for instance, the only place you can enjoy the extra speed in on a track. %99.999+ of people won't be able to take advantage of anything for entire life of their vehicle. On the contrary, instant acceleration is something every driver takes advantage of numerous times per day, when changing lanes, correcting for others mistakes, etc. Fuel cost savings and low maintenance saves every driver money. These are the attributes to pay attention to in a car in general, not the top speed. Point is to pay attention to characteristics which are of utility towards the use case. Obviously, if you are getting a car to go as fast as you possible can on a track, you want a car with higher max speeds so there is that.
- rowanG077 5y agoWithout delidding both you can't really tell anything. It might very well be that 80% of the area of the ultra is just SDRAM.
- readams 5y agoSDRAM is not located on the chip die for either. The memory controller is on-die for the M1 though. My understanding is that making SDRAM is a pretty different process than making a CPU, so it's hard to do it on the same die.
- monocasa 5y agoThis article is comparing package sizes, and DRAM is on package for the M1s.
- Flankk 5y agoThe CPU is the same size as the thermal paste residue shown in the pictures. The remaining space is for the two RAM chips. The author should be embarrassed.
- trdtaylor1 5y agoYou know, there's a few articles out on this size difference subject; if they can make my CPU 10% faster by doubling the physical size -- all other things being equal I'd take that.
- uluyol 5y agoCost increases super-linearly with size. One reason for this is defects: if a single defect ruins a whole chip, then for a constant number of defects per square inch, you'll get more usable square inches of silicon when you have small chips than big ones. Of course you can build chips that can tolerate a few defects, but the principle holds. This is also why high quality TVs are harder to manufacture than high quality phone displays. You have a lot more waste when you need to throw out/recycle a TV screen compared to a phone screen. And both are considered bad when they have just one bad pixel.
- adtac 5y ago>for a constant number of defects per square inch Is this assumption true?
- Qub3d 5y agoIts more the geometry of the process than the rate of failure. The post is just saying, "if the rate were constant". Basically, throw a dart at a wafer. Wherever the dart hits, the whole circuit/chip containing that point is now worthless. Assuming you threw the same number of darts (failures) at a board with a smaller chip, and a board with a large chip, the larger process wafer loses more total silicon (as a percentage of usable area). With smaller chips, you have a smaller "grid" for your dart to land on. So the total number of failures (darts) being the same, you still end up with less usable silicon, since the bigger grid means you throw away a lot more surface area with a failure. Take a look at this picture of a failure map, if you would like some visuals: https://ars.els-cdn.com/content/image/1-s2.0-S095219761200084X-gr4.jpg https://ars.els-cdn.com/content/image/1-s2.0-S09521976120008...
- 5y ago
- ajaimk 5y agoM1 Ultra has a 3x larger heat-spreader than Ryzen. That’s the entire package and not the silicon chip itself. Also, let’s not forget that this heat-spreader includes the RAM under it. Here’s the funny bit: the silicon die for M1 Ultra is actually more than 4x bigger than Ryzen 5000 series. M1 Max was 432 mm2; implying 864 mm2 of silicon. Ryzen 5000 has a 84 mm2 CCD and 124 mm2 IO die.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- redisman 5y agoI’m guessing the price scales at least linearly with the size. I do hope the new trend isn’t giant chips because the price and availability would be horrible
- mcronce 5y agoIt's generally superlinear due to yield effects - this is a bit oversimplified, but in particular, with lithography defects being more or less randomly placed throughout the wafer, a defect in a 100mm2 die impacts a far smaller percentage of the dies in the wafer than a defect in an 800mm2 die. Assuming a constant defect rate per wafer, you'll end up with drastically less usable wafer area with large dies than with small ones. This was a major reason that AMD was able to price Ryzen so aggressively even at the high end - a high-end CPU is just made of more of the same small dies used in low-end CPUs, albeit requiring a better bin, instead of having to make a much larger single die. The constant defect rate isn't typically a correct assumption across different products (e.g. different CPU or GPU dies) - different feature designs will have differing defect rates. Maybe Apple was able to design the M1 Ultra's features so that defect rate is very very low, though - I don't really know much about that silicon.
- imachine1980_ 5y agoprobably this is why they decide to do it as last m1 product, in genera the more you use a process -> less error in the production process happens.
- slayerjain 5y agoI wonder about the size comparison between the M1 Ultra and surface area of the equivalent 'Ryzen CPU + Radeon GPU + RAM :D'
- ohgodplsno 5y agoA 5950X is 285mm² in total (and made with TSMC 7nm). An RTX3080 is 682mm² (and made with Samsung 8nm). A 16GB DDR5 die seems to be about 75mm². RAM aside which is Apple's actual performance differentiator, all of these eat the M1 Ultra alive in their respective categories.
- lhl 5y agoGoing a bit further, since the chips are all on different processes (Apple on TSMC N5, AMD on TSMC N7, and Nvidia on Samsung 8N), it might also be worth looking at transistor counts. The M1 Ultra has 114B transistors, a 5950X has 19.2B transistors, and a 3080/3090 (GA102) has 28.3B transistors. (at 864mm2 (2 x 432mm2 M1 Max's), that's a density of ~130MTr/mm2, which is in the ballpark for TSMC's max density for N5 (est. 170MTr/mm2) - N7 max density for reference is ~90MTr/mm2)
- Brian_K_White 5y agoBut would you even buy the equivalent when the gpu and ram were "hard-coded"?
- kutenai 5y agoyeah, because it does not operate as a space heater. I can buy one of those for like $100, and that's a high end model.
- oblak 5y agoI saw this earlier but since I can only see the main image and reading didn't net an answer - what, exactly are they measuring? I am not expert but to my understand part of ryzen success is high yields due to small size. Having a thing 3x its size, while impressive, is not super surprising. Soon it will be 6x, then more. Zen 5 small cores are supposed to be just zen 4 cores iirc.
- GeekyBear 5y agoThe technically interesting bit about the Ultra's GPU is that it makes multiple GPU dies look like one physical GPU to software: >if you could somehow link up multiple GPUs with a ridiculous amount die-to-die bandwidth – enough to replicate their internal bandwidth – then you might just be able to use them together in a single task. This has made combining multiple GPUs in a transparent fashion something of a holy grail of multi-GPU design. It’s a problem that multiple companies have been working on for over a decade, and it would seem that Apple is charting new ground by being the first company to pull it off. https://www.anandtech.com/show/17306/apple-announces-m1-ultra-combining-two-m1-maxes-for-even-more-performance https://www.anandtech.com/show/17306/apple-announces-m1-ultr...
- smoldesu 5y agoYou've posted this maybe 3 times in the past week, all on articles that have nothing to do with the multi-die nature of the M1 Ultra. What is the salient information here that we couldn't ascertain from watching Apple's keynote or scrolling through their landing page?
- GeekyBear 5y agoThis is literally a point made in this article too. How is it not relevant in this thread?
- tedunangst 5y agoSo why not quote this article instead of linking and quoting a different article?
- GeekyBear 5y agoIsn't this a terrible choice of websites if you are upset by discussion that calls out a genuinely new technological feat in the computer industry?
- 5y ago
- sofixa 5y ago> The drives use a proprietary form-factor, which is logical as the SSD controller resides in the SoC, and the drives themselves do not need to carry one No, it's not logical, they still could have used a common form factor like M.2.
- Eric_WVGG 5y agoWhat, make a socket matching the M.2, that M.2s would be incompatible with?
- formerly_proven 5y agoIntel actually does just that with wifi cards (CNVio/2 cards only work with specific chipsets and don't use PCIe/USB, while using the same keying as normal wifi cards).
- wmf 5y agoAn M.2 2230 slot should be able to take Wi-Fi or NVMe since they're both PCIe devices. In practice there aren't many 2230 SSDs.
- Tijdreiziger 5y agoCNVi isn't PCIe; non-CNVi platforms can't take CNVi Wi-Fi cards. > CNVi or CNVio ("Connectivity Integration", Intel Integrated Connectivity I/O interface) is a proprietary connectivity interface by Intel for Wi-Fi and Bluetooth radios to lower costs and simplify their wireless modules. In CNVi, the network adapter's large and usually expensive functional blocks (MAC components, memory, processor and associated logic/firmware) are moved inside the CPU and chipset (Platform Controller Hub). Only the signal processor, analog and Radio frequency (RF) functions are left on an external upgradeable CRF (Companion RF) module which, as of 2019 comes in M.2 form factor (M.2 2230 and 1216 Soldered Down). Therefore, CNVi requires chipset and Intel CPU support. Otherwise the Wi-Fi + Bluetooth module has to be the traditional M.2 PCIe form factor. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/CNVi https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/CNVi
- whatever1 5y agoI am very curious about the production yields of these monsters. Things can go wrong at the cpu, the gpu, the memory etc and any of these reasons will lead a chip to the trash bin.
- ch_123 5y agoThe M1 Ultra is essentially two M1 Max joined together. I suspect most of the things which can go wrong are at the M1 Max level. I'm sure a certain percentage where fusing two dies together kills one or both dies, but I suspect that's probably a manageable percentage.
- sysbot 5y agoin general the lower yield ones ended up being the lesser model such as M1 Pro using the same die
- deergomoo 5y agoOn the latest episode of the Accidental Tech Podcast they were discussing a patent related to this fancy interconnect stuff, and it sounds like not only do they need two fully functioning M1 Max's, but they also need to be adjacent on the wafer. Although I guess at least they can still use the non-defective M1 Max in any pair.
- Applejinx 5y agoThat would be an interesting approach: don't know if it's what they're doing, but if they're like 'make M1 Ultras predominantly, but then if they break you're making M1 Max with an attached bit that has to be trimmed off', that's pretty ingenious.
- grishka 5y agoI think I've seen a picture of a decapped M1 Max and it had this extra part on the side that never appeared in Apple renders. It was back then when this speculation of it having multiprocessor interconnect started. It was then also confirmed by Asahi Linux people from the software side of things. So no, they don't even bother to trim it off.
- shiftingleft 5y agoDoes the M1 Ultra use a chiplet design like the Ryzen series? Otherwise the yields have to be awful.
- addaon 5y agoThe ultra uses two identical dice in a single package, with an EMIB-style interconnect. This is fewer, larger, and more uniform dice than the Ryzen approach, but still not monolithic.
- olliej 5y agoI'd rather see the delidded version as this is comparing a CPU, to CPU+RAM and without delidding we don't know how much space is taken by the ram dies. As it is, this is a kind of clickbaity article
- dpedu 5y agoIsn't the M1 Ultra more comparable to a SoC than the discreet cpu Ryzen chips are?
- rfoo 5y agoRyzen chips are more of less, SoC.
- DiabloD3 5y agoAMD internally refers to the finished product as the SoC, and the chipset (no longer a northbridge, the NB is on die) as a socket extender (a term also used by most SoC vendors) in internal documentation. Also, arguably, the IO Die is the SoC, the chiplets are external to the SoC even though they all live on the same interposer.
- Groxx 5y agoFair. I think we can probably consider them to be less of a SoC than the M1 Ultra though - Ryzens do have a lot in them, but not all the system's RAM for example. (which is a good thing. all-in-one for specialized stuff is fine, but I don't want it to become the norm - upgrading one component is cheaper than upgrading multiple, and tends to support longer hardware cycles)
- olliej 5y agoI didn’t think Ryzen included on package ram?
- MaxMoney 5y ago
- _8j50 5y agoLooks like a great platform but you can't have it as a daily driver if you use anything that depends on amd64 from what I have been able to find out.
- Decabytes 5y agoI always heard that the reason we don’t just make chips bigger is that it increases the distance the electricity has to travel which translates to more latency. But somehow rhe M1 Ultra is able to get away with being huge with out this being a problem. I wonder if we will start seeing more physically large chips in the future because of this?
- rocqua 5y agoThis die includes RAM. On a traditional motherboard the ram is further away from the cpu than in here. Same story for GPU.
- Maursault 5y agoSo not only is AMD Ryzen smaller and less densely packed, with 112 billion fewer transistors, it doesn't have any RAM on it? What else is the M1 Ultra bigger than? Are we gonna need a bigger boat?