6 ms·
Apple's new M1 Ultra isn't faster than an RTX 3090
- jitl 5y agoOf course - their single chip M1 Max GPU performance got ~30-40% of high end desktop GPU, so it sounded impossible that a dual-GPU solution could do 100% of high end desktop GPU. When Apple omits actual direct comparison it sounds and looks so bad for them. Especially on these fake graphs! If they are confident in their numbers, use numbers. So silly.
- awestroke 5y agoDo the benchmarks utilise unified memory and other features of the Apple chip?
- smoldesu 5y agoIt's a test of raw GPU performance. Testing bandwidth would be difficult to synthesize, and also irrelevant for the vast majority of "real world" workloads besides maybe GPGPU computations which are almost always always written with CUDA anyways.
- johnklos 5y agoThis is click-bait. There really isn't all that much software that does the same exact thing on both NVIDIA and Apple hardware, so benchmarks will largely favor the hardware that has had more integration. Unlike AMD & Intel, which are easily directly compared, I think there'll be many big differences between Apple and NVIDIA. They do many things in completely different ways. It'll be interesting to see more comparisons as more software is adapted and written to fully take advantage of Apple hardware, the way much of it is currently written to fully take advantage of NVIDIA.
- dekhn 5y agoThis article is responding to a very specific slide that Apple showed claiming they were faster than the fastest GPU. This article demonstrates that along a wide range of expected functions for a GPU, Apple's slide was misleading (in multiple ways). While it is definitely true that Apple's new system is a hog for multimedia problems, it's not a "3d-GPU-rendering" system, it's a "2d-GPU-rendering" system, and that's a secondary market for GPUs that nvidia didn't optimize for. Further, I'm fairly certain if nvidia and adobe did optimize more for GPUs, that their products would be significantly faster. However, at that point we start to get into some very interesting issues about whether the GPU should be a bus-attached, or core-attached device.
- wildrhythms 5y ago>a very specific slide that Apple showed claiming they were faster than the fastest GPU That is not what the slide showed. The slide shows Apple's chip reaching the same performance numbers given the same amount of power delivery on each GPU. The Verge, this PC Gamer article, and you, are conveniently missing that clearly presented metric.
- guiambros 5y agoYeah, Apple's slide seems carefully cropped to show discrete GPU limited going to 320W, so the M1 comes on top on a performance vs. power ratio. But the 3090 Ti has TBP of 450W [1], which likely explains why its raw performance easily beats the M1. [1] https://www.hardwaretimes.com/nvidia-made-the-rtx-3090-ti-as-a-testbed-for-rtx-4080-4090s-high-power-consumption-of-over-500w https://www.hardwaretimes.com/nvidia-made-the-rtx-3090-ti-as...
- dekhn 5y agohey clipped that data to manipulate the graph. Note also "GPU performance" is a metric that includes many things. What did they test, specifically, here? ML training? Gaming? Or 2D ops used commonly in photoshop? I found this review useful: https://www.theverge.com/22981815/apple-mac-studio-m1-ultra-max-review https://www.theverge.com/22981815/apple-mac-studio-m1-ultra-... TL;DR: many professionals who work in 2D or psuedo3D could buy this and immediately be more productive than they were on their previous Apple device. But that chart is still extremely misleading.
- caycep 5y agothat's kind of my beef w/ the 3000 series gpu's in general. Yeah, they're fast and all. But at significantly more TDP and with default coolers larger (> 300 mm) that can fit into my (previously perfectly fine "full size GPU") case? Are they really that much better than my 1080?
- dekhn 5y agoI'm aware of that (it was covered already in the press), and it's clear what the slide intended to show. This is standard apple reality distortion field. I work in the field of high performance computing and we know how to interpret a graph that is intended to deceive the naive.
- dundarious 5y agoIt’s fair if “better” means “better for end-users”, which is all that matters in practice. It’s especially fair given that Apple is generally credited for having a capabilities focus rather than spec focus, i.e., they are credited for the same end-user focus. I think the article is poorer for not explicitly making this argument, but it’s right to focus on end-user capabilities, IMO.
- mytherin 5y agoBetter for end users depends entirely on their workloads, and is a moving target. Presumably as Apple’s new chip gets more adoption more games will be designed and optimized for it. There are already games (partly) optimized for it, so why not run those? Why is Tomb Raider more representative of an end-user workload than World of Warcraft?
- dundarious 5y agoI agree it's a moving target, but the point is that the current capabilities matter most, potential future capabilities matter less, and spec sheet or artificially constrained benchmark comparisons matter least. I'm bullish on Apple Silicon, but it is far more likely for your average gamer or GPU compute coder to think that the M1 Ultra is not better than an RTX 3090. It's not being "unfair" if you don't highlight a game that has been specifically optimized, if such games are few and far between, and it is far from assured that that will change. A really good comparison would highlight those cases where AS-specific optimization does improve things significantly, but even there, it should really emphasize that the comparison of M1 Ultra to an RTX 3090 is only favorable given an artificial power constraint on the latter (Apple mention it rather than emphasize it, but a good journalist will emphasize it). So is AS more technically impressive, and does it have more growth potential in the hardware and software (as adoption hopefully grows)? Absolutely. Is it currently materially "better"? For a desktop, by almost any measure, no.
- jacknews 5y agoThe point is, it's getting there, and probably is faster than eg a 3060. Putting CPU, RAM, and GPU all on a single chip, or a multi-chip integrated package clearly has massive advantages. I think this is another signal that the the era of of the modular computer is over, unfortunately (I love modularity, standards, diy tinkering, etc)
- beebeepka 5y agoThis is hardly a surprise. Look at what consoles can do with a much, much smaller and cheaper AMD SoC
- caycep 5y agoI'm of mixed minds...my PC is useful for certain things. But my Apple laptops w/ iGPU's did not require as much hardware debugging, sketchy firmware downloads/updates, less fans to clean, large PSUs that blew and had to be replaced etc...
- jacknews 5y agoI agree, my patience also wears thin getting 'standard' parts to work together when they don't want to. On the other hand, how far can you trust proprietary all-in-one solutions? At least with the modular stuff you have some control over the system, and a choice in selecting a preferred configuration - the all-in-one is a black box.
- caycep 5y agopresumably, a lot of technical info has been coming out of Apple (and hopefully like minded companies) re vetting of chips, mobo, OS-built security, T2 chip encryption etc. Vs. the modular stuff - I'd be more confident if security was part of the norm, but I don't get the feeling it's a priority on the like of a lot of 3rd party vendors like Asus or Gigabyte etc.
- wildrhythms 5y agoLook at the chart. The question isn't about "max power" performance as much as it is power consumption: Apple claims its chip is reaching similar performance numbers to its competitor given the same amount of power. In fact, the Verge's article[0] that this PC Gamer article is shamelessly and effortlessly reposting, does not dispute that, but is moving the goalpost to "well what if the competitor had more power?" Yawn [0] https://www.theverge.com/2022/3/17/22982915/apple-m1-ultra-rtx-3090-comparison-specs-charts-cpu-gpu-performance https://www.theverge.com/2022/3/17/22982915/apple-m1-ultra-r...
- benreesman 5y agoThe M1-era is a very difficult time for the crowd who just wants to criticize Apple for the sake of it. I use both an M1 and an M1 Max every day alongside Threadrippers and Xeons and while Apple misses a lot, they fucking killed it this time.
- HellDunkel 5y agoWhat are you using the machines for?
- benreesman 5y agoThe M1s are my desktop and laptop respectively, the Xeons are for deployment scenarios, and the Threadripper box is used mostly for big builds. I don't have my current project building on `darwin-aarch64` yet so I haven't been able to do a comparison, but I suspect that once I can get my hands on an M1 Ultra that it will build a big C++/Haskell application faster than the 64-core Threadripper does. 800GB/s of memory bandwidth is insane. You write programs differently for a computer where your main memory is effectively an on-die L3 cache at 128GB.
- HellDunkel 5y agoThank you! I had no idea that building software would require such processing power. Does the bulid/compile process make any use of the GPUs?
- beebeepka 5y agoDid anyone say m1 ultra is faster than 3090? If they did, surely they didn't mean games. Productivity is not gaming. Fast overall is not the same as delivering 144+ frames each second.
- zbobet2012 5y agoApple did directly in their product speech...
- smoldesu 5y agohttps://youtu.be/BCvL8O0-Qwo?t=342 https://youtu.be/BCvL8O0-Qwo?t=342
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- willis936 5y agoThey did, while having 10% less memory bandwidth and a fifth of the power budget. It was an obvious lie. Compute benchmarks just demonstrate it.
- GeekyBear 5y agoFirst, Why post an article that just refers to testing done at The Verge instead of linking to The Verge's own article? Second, the article at the Verge is based on running an x86 game under Rosetta's x86 emulation instead of testing the performance of a native ARM and Metal game. Strangely, The Verge's Mac Studio review covers the fact that the Adobe suite of software had to be updated to support ARM and Metal before you could see the full performance of the hardware without emulation, but they completely ignore this for games. >With many recent professional Mac reviews, the story has been: Apple makes great hardware, but the software — specifically Adobe’s Creative Cloud — isn’t optimized for Apple’s ideas. But at this point, Adobe has had quite a bit of time to catch up. Apple has sold a whole bunch of M1 devices — the demand is here, and Adobe has responded. Premiere, Photoshop, Lightroom, Audition, Media Encoder, and more are running natively on Apple Silicon (and After Effects is available in beta). And the story has basically flipped: the Mac Studio now appears to be one of the few computers that can unlock the full power of Adobe’s software. https://www.theverge.com/22981815/apple-mac-studio-m1-ultra-max-review https://www.theverge.com/22981815/apple-mac-studio-m1-ultra-...
- smoldesu 5y ago> Strangely, their review covers the fact that the Adobe suite of software had to be updated to support ARM and Metal before you could see the full performance of the hardware without emulation, but they completely ignore this for games. When do you reckon that Tomb Raider is getting updated for ARM?
- RobertMiller 5y agoIf a game isn't relevant enough to port to new hardware, is it really relevant enough to benchmark with?
- falsenapkin 5y agoYes because consumers want to know how the hardware performs for their existing catalog of games, many if not all of which won't be ported? Obviously depends on what you play etc
- martini333 5y agoThis is so fucking stupid. Of course the 3090 is faster at gaming, which it was designed for.
- ohgodplsno 5y agoNo. It's faster at _literally everything else_. So is a 3080. So is a 3070, most likely.
- oldstrangers 5y agoThere's a reason why GPU supercomputers exists and it's not to play videogames.
- GeekyBear 5y agoThe technically interesting bit about the Ultra's GPU is that it makes multiple GPU dies look like one physical GPU to software: >if you could somehow link up multiple GPUs with a ridiculous amount die-to-die bandwidth – enough to replicate their internal bandwidth – then you might just be able to use them together in a single task. This has made combining multiple GPUs in a transparent fashion something of a holy grail of multi-GPU design. It’s a problem that multiple companies have been working on for over a decade, and it would seem that Apple is charting new ground by being the first company to pull it off. https://www.anandtech.com/show/17306/apple-announces-m1-ultra-combining-two-m1-maxes-for-even-more-performance https://www.anandtech.com/show/17306/apple-announces-m1-ultr...
- gnabgib 5y agoBiggest discussion was on the TomsHardware submission[0] (170pts, 215comments), the verge was also submitted[1], but no real traction (7pts, 2comments). [0]: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30719654 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30719654 [1]: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30715759 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30715759
- bdz 5y agoIt's not about PC gaming though, more like the consoles. Apple can absolutely disrupt the market of Sony and MS (not so much of Nintendo). The MSRP of PS5 and Xbox are $399/$499, if Apple can target this segment they would have a field day. The Apple TV already exist and maybe not now but 1-2-3 years down the line they can fit the next generation M1 Ultra there. BUT you need a very strong game back catalog (see the PS exclusive games and the GamePass on Xbox which is a killer deal). I'm not sure Apple is willing to go that far, just by judging their Apple TV exclusive line up for example compared to Netflix and Amazon. To me it seems they rather have the iOS games on the Mac than have actual AAA games on the Mac. But that might change in the future, who knows. In the end it's all wishful thinking (or not) but I'm pretty sure competition is only good for the consumer market.
- oldstrangers 5y ago>$399/$499, if Apple can target this segment they would have a field day. Target it with what? A controller from Apple would run $399-$499 and it would be sold separately.
- eezing 5y agoLooks like Apple’s claim is that the M1 is more efficient, not faster. I’m no GPU expert. What does this mean long term?
- fortran77 5y agoWow! Posting a source that challenges an Apple benchmark gets you flagged and deleted from Hacker News. Who's behind this?