6 ms·
Hmm...buses that (per the article) cost 2x or 3x what diesel ones would. From a company that's raising a whole lotta $$$ from VC's. And (plausibly) school dis
by bell-cot 5y ago
Hmm...buses that (per the article) cost 2x or 3x what diesel ones would. From a company that's raising a whole lotta $$$ from VC's. And (plausibly) school districts will get rid of their old diesel bus fleets when they switch over...
Is anyone else suspecting an "of course we'll loose money like crazy, until we hit 'em with the massive price increase" business model?
EDIT: Wow, huge response. 3 points to add:
- Yes, kids not breathing fumes is better...but that doesn't change the company's nor the school district's finances.
- No, I have no good data on whether the "vastly lower TCO will cover the higher up front cost..." theory is 100% correct, or utter BS.
- My one not-too-close data point: A friend worked for a metropolitan bus system ~2011. She said they were getting rid of their "~1.4 up-front cost" diesel-electric hybrid buses - because the real TCO was considerably worse than the older, straight-diesel buses.
- pengaru 5y agoThe "subscribed" buses will be privately owned and operated, they'll be increasingly filled with advertising and other predatory bullshit for exploiting the passengers.
- krasin 5y agoDon't forget a snack machine with sweets right inside the bus.
- tentacleuno 5y agoOr... A cold drinks machine, with all the bus windows locked shut. I'm sure I remember something about McDonalds putting more salt in the chips [/ food] so people buy a drink.
- Nasrudith 5y agoSo like city buses?
- arcticbull 5y agoNot really, no. City busses recognize revenue from advertising and use it to subsidize fares. Being a public service, the public benefits. On the other hand, private bus fleets with private advertisements on loan to school districts will recognize that advertising revenue as profit, benefiting shareholders. Not everything needs a profit motive.
- roughly 5y agoI don't know what the split is elsewhere, but it's worth noting that for BART in the Bay Area, at least, makes something like $10m/yr, compared to nearly $500m/yr in actual fares - so, in exchange for approximately 2% of annual revenues, we get BART trains and stations covered in ads. Edit: Thought to look this up for SFMTA - 2020 proposed budget (projections as of 2019, chosen because it's the last "normal" year) - total revenue $1.2Bn, "Advertising, interest, and service fees" $54m.
- woodruffw 5y agoI think that's pretty unlikely, at least with schoolbuses. The US has laws around child privacy and advertising that companies easily flaunt online, but are much more difficult to flaunt when your product is a physical bus. OTOH, I would not be surprised to see these buses rusting in a storage lot within a decade because these firms have closed up shop and some random server somewhere is no longer responding to requests. I hope (but am not hopeful) that municipal and state governments take measures during procurement to ensure that they aren't being turned into captive customers.
- AdamN 5y agoCaptivate screens behind each seat with 'educational' content and pre-roll/banner ads. "We're giving kids extra education through new technology and they also learn about the value of chocolate sugar milk at the same time!"
- Johnny555 5y agoThe average lifetime of a schoolbus is 10 - 12 years, so if they do manage to keep this service going for a decade, that's pretty good -- in 10 years the schol district would have been ready to refresh their fleet anyway, and hopefully the reason this business can't survive long-term is that electric buses become cheaper and ubiquitous.
- adgjlsfhk1 5y agoPart of the reason for the 10-12 year lifespan is that ICE motors are really complicated and at a certain point, it's cheaper to throw out the bus than pay for motor repairs. EV motors last a lot longer and are a lot easier to maintain.
- akomtu 5y agoAre batteries going to last this long? And batteries are usually 50% of the vehicle price.
- 5y ago
- elliekelly 5y ago“You’re only two bus rides away from your next Robux reward!”
- AlgorithmicTime 5y agoLiterally all the school buses in my area are operated by private companies which contract with the local public school districts. None of them are full of advertising.
- gruez 5y ago>they'll be increasingly filled with advertising and other predatory bullshit for exploiting the passengers What's this based on ? AFAIK many school districts already contract out their school bus service. Are we seeing that in those cases?
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- sockaddr 5y agoWhile not ideal, the alternative is kids continuing to sit in buses that idle for long periods of time slowly leaking diesel exhaust into the cabin area (at least that was the case with the Bluebird models I rode as a kid), that can't be good.
- bnt 5y agoYea, here the batteries catch fire and a bunch of kids burn to death. Grim, but possible.
- Johnny555 5y agoNot likely, not without being in a serious accident. Despite the Chevy Bolt's highly publicized battery fires (which did not kill anyone), EV batteries don't usually burst into flames unprovoked. The battery will be well protected in a school bus frame.
- pavon 5y agoICE vehicles have orders of magnitude higher fire risk than EV. https://www.kbb.com/car-news/study-electric-vehicles-involved-in-fewest-car-fires/ https://www.kbb.com/car-news/study-electric-vehicles-involve...
- thehappypm 5y agoRight, because diesel buses are totally not flammable at all.
- PaulHoule 5y agoI bought a number of plastic "jerry cans" that all had stickers on them saying you shouldn't use gasoline or diesel to start fires. Oddly the reason why is different for the two fluids. Gasoline can catch fire quickly and form a fireball, whereas diesel is hard to ignite and won't help start a fire. This movie https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_5th_Wave_(film) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_5th_Wave_(film) has a scene where the kids set a school bus on fire with the fuel which isn't realistic.
- bend-or-end 5y ago>That starts with phasing the purchase and deployment of electric school buses — which still cost two to three times more than their diesel counterparts — to take advantage of expected declines in cost over the coming years, McIntyre said. Sounds like the model is to be the first mover and being entrenched by the time it's profitable without a price hike
- scythe 5y agoFrankly, if they rip off school districts in order to keep kids from inhaling nitrogen dioxide, that's still a better business model than most of the ones I've heard.
- mirntyfirty 5y agoI think that depends on the extent to which they rip them off.
- scythe 5y agoI guess you're probably right. But it seems like we're looking at a small factor (2-3) applied to the usual price of a school bus. Of course, there are also reasons it might not be a ripoff, as others brought up (lower ops costs, economy of scale). I just felt like highlighting the problems with prioritizing price over all else around the health of primary schoolchildren.
- vardump 5y ago> Hmm...buses that (per the article) cost 2x or 3x what diesel ones would. What about when you consider total life cycle costs? Diesel fuel costs often many times of cost of the vehicle over its lifespan. Fuel costs will likely increase quite a bit in the future.
- jandrese 5y agoThe upfront price difference should be offset in the long term by buying cheap electricity instead of expensive diesel.
- ZeroGravitas 5y agoThis is a fairly standard reframing when your product has lower TCO but higher upfront costs. If people just look at the upfront cost, they have that 2x or 3x gut reaction and just switch off. Some nerdier types might draw up a spreadsheet and know exactly how many months they'd expect to break even and start saving. People familiar with spreadsheets probably also don't have that much trouble getting loans and paying them back on time, and doing even more sums to see if that makes financial sense. But your average school bus buyer perhaps needs someone else to do all that for them, hedge the risk and present it to them as an immediate saving on their monthly spend. People have sold rooftop solar this way, or replaced kerosene lamps in Africa with solar and batteries, and EVs Vs monthly Car payment plus fuel.
- roughly 5y agoIt's not just the cost over time, it's the availability of capital in large clumps - also known as "the cost of being poor:" It may be 5x cheaper in the long run to pay 3x the cost today, but if you don't have 3x the cost today, well, good luck.
- JumpCrisscross 5y agoCapex <=> Opex swaps are pretty common, and it's not just a matter of poverty. (It's why airlines lease their planes.) Swap "subscribe" with "lease" and this article becomes less interesting.
- roughly 5y ago> Swap "subscribe" with "lease" and this article becomes less interesting To VCs, too
- anonymouse008 5y agoYeah, and school's budgets are cash tight, with comparatively little ability to fundraise, so any large cash transaction will be DOA. The swap should take place, and I'm now wondering why this hasn't occurred.
- ihsw 5y agoThe play is in vehicle-to-grid (V2G) electric price arbitrage, the article even mentions that a full third of the revenue from the program is coming from selling V2G power generation back to the grid.
- joe_the_user 5y agoA fair portion of school districts already contract their buses to First Student and similar bus companies. And if this company were to raise it's rates drastically, the districts could switch to First Student.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- coryrc 5y ago> She said they were getting rid of their "~1.4 up-front cost" diesel-electric hybrid buses - because the real TCO was considerably worse In my city, the original hybrids used Toyota Prius batteries and deep cycled them, which they weren't designed for, killing them and requiring regular replacements. That couldn't have been good for the budget.
- michael1999 5y agoIt is a different calculation for the school board. For them, the costs of retraining staff, retooling a shop, increasing parts inventory are all big costs. Plus the risk of buying a bunch of lemons. Leasing them with performance guarantees moves not just the costs, but also the risks to a specialist better suited to carrying them. I don’t know if this firm is legit, but the deal could make sense.