18 ms·
Mariupol's devastation: AP journalists document war's toll
- djrironman 5y ago
- sorokod 5y agoMaterial for future crimes against humanity trials, the leadership (aka management) page of the Russian MoD https://eng.mil.ru/en/management.htm https://eng.mil.ru/en/management.htm
- scotty79 5y agoI have no idea why anyone still talks to Putin. UN should just demand from Russian system of power that they delivered suspected war criminal mr Putin to Hague if they want to have any hope of Russia rejoining global economy any time soon.
- filoleg 5y ago> UN should just demand from Russian system of power that they delivered suspected war criminal mr Putin I don't know if your proposal was supposed to be realistic, but it is just idealistically naive at best. Putin is the Russian system of power. Unless you believe that he is going to willingly turn himself in as soon as the UN makes that demand, I don't see any good coming out of such demand by the UN. Also, don't forget that Russia is one of the 5 permanent members of the UN Security Council, and there is nothing stopping them from vetoing any such statement from being made in the first place (which is one of the major perks of being the permanent member).
- scotty79 5y agoNo, he's not. Every dictator rules only because there are people close to him who benefit from his rule. Every dictator can be replaced at any moment if people who enable him deem him bad for business. And that's the case with Russia. I think oligarchs would take him down if they got offered clear road forward from current troubles (if they believed it). Russia is a member of security council but nothing stops the rest of the world from physically not registering Russia's veto. Or not even letting Russia representative into the room where the issue is decided. Rulebook has been thrown away by Russia. There's not point of respecting anything about it.
- type0 5y ago> I think oligarchs would take him down if they got offered clear road forward from current troubles (if they believed it). They can't, in the 90s oliagarchs had power, not now. With Putin only his silovik cronies can do anything about him, but they won't because the system is set up so that their families would suffer from the hands of his other friends. I see this as completely lost. North Korea has a bigger chance to get a new ruler after the coup than Russia. Putin has more power than a Tsar ever had.
- neurostimulant 5y agoThat page has been deleted. Archive: https://web.archive.org/web/20220204230556/https://eng.mil.ru/en/management.htm https://web.archive.org/web/20220204230556/https://eng.mil.r...
- jansen555 5y ago
- mam4 5y ago
- tiku 5y agoThe side by side satellite images really show you the devastating effect of the Russian bombings. It looks like a hurricane or tsunami hit the land. How is this handled after the war, the aggressor should pay for the damages but we can't really force them.
- tomjen3 5y agoWe should pay them out the siezed Russian assets. That won't be enough, but it will be a start.
- gruez 5y agoWhat "siezed Russian assets" are we talking about here? The russian centeral bank deposits held with the federal reserve? Foreign assets of russian companies? Assets of russian "oligarchs"?
- emteycz 5y agoYes
- gruez 5y agoReally? The last item 'Assets of russian "oligarchs"' seems like a massive violation of due process. It's basically civil forfeiture 2.0.
- heartofadog 5y agoWar is, by definition, a "massive violation of due process". I get your point (that ethics and law matter -- including basic principles of law where international law is not codified), and on a certain level this is valid. But historically speaking, once things ratchet up to a certain level and scope of barbarity (as we are seeing unfold in real time) -- it's just not realistic to sit and wait for a "fair" solution to emerge (in the near term or ever). People are going to be hurt (and treated unfairly) one way or another. It's just a question of who is going to take the hit, and in what form. So if it's at least arguably plausible that measures that inconvenience a few individuals in the top .1 percent net-worth-wise might bring this insane situation to a close sooner rather than later -- I can go with that. And there's no reason we can't "rub" a bit of due process into the situation -- by saying "OK sure, you can file an appeal, and have a shot at getting your toys and baubles back -- after Russia returns to its borders, and Putin has been decisively removed from power."
- javier_e06 5y ago
- myth_drannon 5y agoHere are some other views of destruction on Mariupol streets : https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kqkJUZZpH6M https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kqkJUZZpH6M (skip to the end) https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BEdlINn2uA0 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BEdlINn2uA0 Warning that some of the videos and the account appears to be pro-russian(?).
- sorokod 5y agoThe YouTube channel associated with the first link is not "pro Russian", it is 100% Russian propaganda
- sorokod 5y agoDon't have words but it feels wrong not to have any here so awful, awful, awful...
- AnimalMuppet 5y agoI have some words about Putin that I really want to say. They're against the site guidelines, though, so I am restraining myself. He sure doesn't make it easy...
- jdrc 5y agoThe situation in that city is beyond description. The international community should really pay attention https://mobile.twitter.com/christogrozev/status/1504213961633378304 https://mobile.twitter.com/christogrozev/status/150421396163...
- AnimalMuppet 5y agoI don't think the international community is not paying attention. "Unwilling to go to direct war against Russia" is not the same as ignoring it.
- rasz 5y ago"Unwilling to go to direct war against Putin" means Putin can nibble at Europe one country at a time. "cant risk WW3 over Ukraine" "cant risk WW3 over Poland" "cant risk WW3 over Latvia" "cant risk WW3 over Estonia" etc, etc ...
- archagon 5y agoThe realpolitik of the modern world is that you can't mess too much with any nuclear nation, no matter how much it sucks. All you can do is get your own nukes and make the red lines very clear, and cut off trading and diplomatic ties to the extent it won't be treated as a declaration of war. Unfortunately, the decision of x vs. total nuclear annihilation is very heavily weighed towards x, no matter what that x may be. I'm starting to feel that our sense of morality is not well adapted to a world where a despot can end civilization with the push of a button.
- mardifoufs 5y agoThe situation is closer to 1914 than 1939. And I don't think it would be unreasonable to say that the escalation that led to the first world was a colossal mistake
- danieljacksonno 5y agoI vehemently disagree. 1914 saw large imperialist empires on both sides. There were no real "good guys" in that war, as both sides were looking to either keep and consolidate power over colonial empires (the Entente) or break up the colonial empires to get some for themselves (the Germans and Austrians). 1939 saw an ambitious despot attack democracies to brutally subjugate them. That is also what we are seeing now.
- thow16161 5y agoLooking at these photos, I think we (NATO) should intervene with troops and air support. For all the cries of "never again", we just sit on our hands and watch a Hitler like dictator destroy a neighboring country in a territorial war. Its clear Russia's army is a paper tiger, and I doubt Putin has the balls to use nukes.
- true_religion 5y agoHitler is reviled for the Holocaust, not merely invading another country in a war of conquest. This whole situation is depressing and frustrating all around, but I don’t think anyone is being hypocritical.
- yks 5y agoWar of conquest became taboo after WW2, written down in the UN chapter. The concept of "crimes against peace" itself was ironically invented by Soviets.
- thow16161 5y agoI was specifically referring to Hitler's territorial expansion prior to WWII. Putin's expansion into Crimea and Ukraine reminds me very much of Hitler's expansion into Austria and Czechoslovakia. Its my firm belief that we're at the "Peace in our time" phase, just before WWIII, and it would be better to nip it in the bud and take action now, rather than 2 years from now, when Putin has had more time to prepare, and he attempts to invade a country that we are obligated by treaty to defend.
- jltsiren 5y agoThat comparison does not make sense. Russia is not the USSR of old or Germany in the 30s. It's not a great economic power with an independent industrial base. Right now, Putin is throwing in all the conventional forces he can spare, but Ukraine – a smaller and poorer country - has managed to stop the attack with some material support from the West. Meanwhile, the rest of the world has not been idle. Europe is increasing military spending significantly. Unprecedented sanctions are in place, and their purpose is to destroy Russian economy and cut their access to many key technologies. If the sanctions remain in place, a large part of the Russian losses in Ukraine will be permanent.
- morpheos137 5y ago
- kadoban 5y agoThat's a lot of blame you're giving out to _people who didn't invade Ukraine_.
- jdrc 5y agoUkrainians themselves are fighting. Please don't parrot the russian propaganda according to which they do not exist
- brimble 5y ago> Serious question? Which intelligent people think this war is a good thing? Not a lot. Unfortunately, Russia's doing it anyway.
- morpheos137 5y agoIf you are at an ATM at night and somebody draws gun on you and says "Your money or your life." Do you (a) not take them seriously and argue about how theft is immoral on principle (b) scream and yell hoping to attract attention (c) give up some money to live another day? Sometimes stupidly standing on principle or not taking your counter party seriously can be very costly. In Sun Tzu's art of war where does it say to become so immersed in your own propaganda that you ignore reality?
- simplyaccont 5y agoin this case "stupidly standing on principle" it's trying to keep Ukraine as sovereign state and not be absorbed to be part of Russia. The costs are high, but independence wars are rarely cheap
- brimble 5y agoDude you outed yourself when you referred to Ukraine as Russia's "home turf". I guess I shouldn't point this out so I don't help, but, you're being way too obvious to be effective, unless this is actually some kind of pro-Ukraine reverse-troll designed to get us to respond to you with anti-Russian posts (in which case, you're doing fine, I suppose). [EDIT] oh and this: > What I find perplexing is how our leadership class in Washington could be so dumb to pick a fight with no possible upside. Even if the rest of your post was entirely serious and even if all the other points were valid, this is nuts. If the West did force this war on purpose, holy shit has it ever been the greatest victory for cynical realpolitik ever. Russia's decline has been accelerated by a couple decades, at least. No possible upside? In what universe?
- Giorgi 5y agoRussians will be deemed worse than ISIS for history books. All the suffering they caused to their neighbors, Moldova, Ukraine, Georgia. Millions of refugees, hundreds of thousands killed, families destroyed, hopes and dreams perished - all for Russian people imperialist ideology. I hope to some day see Russian federation dissolved into it's federal states.
- lostmsu 5y agoJust to correct, the death toll in this conflict is believed to be around 15k so far.
- bpodgursky 5y agoThat is a very low estimate, given how hard it has been to count civilian deaths in Mariupol.
- hckrnrd 5y agoGiven the authoritarian nature of country, conflating “Russians” with Putin may be detrimental toward reconciliation.
- xdennis 5y agoYou know the west is weak when we're thinking about reconciliation when they're still bombing civilians. Do you think Russians are stopping to think whether killing pregnant women is bad for reconciliation?
- zoomablemind 5y ago> "...Ukrainian television and radio were cut, and car stereos became the only link to the outside world. They played Russian news, describing a world that couldn’t be further from the reality in Mariupol." As much as the whole world wants to believe that the people of the Russian Federation are uninformed, or disallowed the information, and disinformed by the propaganda...the grim reality seems that they rather need to believe that propaganda, because it seemingly absolves them of the resposibility for these atrocities The simple folks of Russia are very much familiar with the horrors and the scale of such war atrocities as from the vast WW2 history, just as from Grozny and Aleppo times. They get how cruel and mindless this is. Just they cannot admit to themselves and their children that this time they are the aggressor side. It must be the same kind of "fear of blame" that is not that different from decades of Stalin's rule. For many citizens of the Russian Federation, it's the only place to live their lives, there's no exit, not much choice for change. The fear has simply transformed the reality, just as it has done it in times before... I have no hopes that these folks would suddenly "wake up to truth". Nor that they would attain to any collective remorse for this. Perhaps this fear could only be supplanted by their personal grief. The Russian country seems to have turned into a Federation of Fear - the main product that its rulers now want to export to the rest of the world. It's the grief that the world is already harvesting.
- jdrc 5y agoIt's no use to blame Putin's subjects for all this. They did not push for this war. They were as surprised as anyone from the invasion, but of course they will support their army now because they have spent a decade learning to hate the west and blame it for every evil[1]. But putin also calculated (correctly) that the west wouldn't react strongly , like it didnt react with syria, georgia, karabakh, libya. Invading weak countries to make a victory lap is how he legitimizes himself to his subjects and to the nearby dictators (like aliyev). This was made worse by watching how afghanistan ended, and how the US is quickly shifting to the Pacific. The US needs to set a red line to stop him, that is the only thing that delegitimizes him 1.https://ecfr.eu/article/commentary_how_russia_has_come_to_loathe_the_west311346/ https://ecfr.eu/article/commentary_how_russia_has_come_to_lo...
- packet_nerd 5y ago
- zttg 5y ago[dead]
- feoren 5y agoDoes anyone else have a problem with the phrase "war's toll"? It sounds like it's uttered by a tight-lipped posh British man talking over grainy black-and-white footage. Can we call it "Human beings choosing to just fucking outright murder innocent civilians for no fucking reason ...'s toll"? These are humans who have decided to commit war crimes and what is essentially genocide. It's not like "oh, man, war just happens, and it really sucks for the people it happens to." No, war doesn't just happen randomly -- these humans are choosing to do this. It's not "war's toll". It's murder.
- scotty79 5y agoI completely agree with you. Many small wars that happened since world war II caused the journalist to develop sort of usual war reporing routine and language. And they are applying by default the same routine to this teritorial invasion of 40mln pro-european country and very probable start of world war 3. It's infuriating that this language muddles the uniqueness of this event and lulls so many people into the sense of safe familiarity. It's not the war that your dad's war was in some remote country 'sadly tragic'.
- Barrera 5y agoWith each humanitarian crisis in Ukraine, the US comes that much closer to intervening in a direct way. Neither Ukraine nor Russia will capitulate, they're too evenly matched conventionally. So there will be many, many of these events happening in the future. Already the leadership of certain NATO countries are calling for a no fly zone, and transfer of various weapons systems. It's a simple exercise to ask yourself what humanitarian disaster would be so egregious that the US would be forced to act because if it did not NATO itself would fracture, with newly-added former Soviet republics and eastern block countries acting on their own. That event is not very far away. Mariupol is a disaster, but it's one that none of us can influence. We can, however, take steps now for the inevitable arrival of exchange of fire between US and Russian forces. I'm happy to ratchet down that stand, but until something happens with clear de-escalatory potential, the base case needs to be direct US-Russia confrontation and likely nuclear escalation. Edit: the split in NATO could come quite quickly. A low-yield nuclear first strike by a cornered Russia into Ukraine would put the entire immediate vicinity (the Baltic states, Poland, etc.) on alert that they're next on the list. The pressure on local politicians to act first and receive reprimand from NATO later could be irresistible. The US's "ironclad" commitment to Article 5 does the rest.
- ProAm 5y agoIm honestly surprised they have not intervened directly let. The US invaded Iraq for less. Here is a democratic country needlessly invaded, with obvious civilians being targeted and killed. I think the US politicians are too old and still fear their memories of the cold war. War is hell but not helping is merciless.
- gambiting 5y agoThe argument was and still is that by "helping" you'd actually cause more devastation(or, at worst - start a nuclear exchange between superpowers). But like OP said, there has to be a threshold, an attrocity so bad that NATO will be forced to intervene. I personally think seeing 18 month old babies killed by shrapnel is enough - but I'm not in charge of the policy(for better or worse).
- rr808 5y agoOne of the Ukrainian Twitter feeds I look at lists Russian soldiers Social Media and small town newspaper articles. Its depressing on their side seeing young kids and young fathers coming out of these small rural towns and dying in the army. https://twitter.com/666_mancer https://twitter.com/666_mancer. Its interesting to see the translated Russian comments as well.
- mempko 5y agoI understand Russian and have heard interviews from those who evacuated Mariupol. Many are saying Azov isn't letting them leave. A lot of those who evacuated were saved by Russian soldiers under fire from Ukraine. Unfortunately most of this content isn't available to English speaking audiences. I noticed the AP press article above doesn't even mention Azov Battalion which is defending the city. For example, they said the roads are full of mines, but didn't say who placed the mines. How do you have a report about a war in a city without mentioning the defending army? Only mention of a Ukrainian soldier was when one pleaded to people to stop looting. The article also shows a tank blasting an apartment building. I watched another video that showed Russian/Chechen troops fighting Ukrainian soldiers in the top floor of an apartment building in Mariupol. People who lived there were in the basement. In other words, the defending army takes positions on the top floor of these buildings with people huddled in the basement. This is a complete disaster and we need to give voices to the people who live there. This is a horrendous situation for the people in Mariupol and the people there deserve good reporting. It's clear both sides have blood on their hands and Urban warfare is the worst kind. It should never have led to this. EDIT: Translated Example of an interview from someone evacuated: https://twitter.com/wyattreed13/status/1504743305967554565?s=28 https://twitter.com/wyattreed13/status/1504743305967554565?s... EDIT2: I want to be very clear I am not defending Russia. I do not support this war. I am criticizing the poor reporting and that the truth of what is happening is complex.
- cloverich 5y ago“saved by russian soldiers” but does that even make sense given the thing they need saved from is attacks by russian soldiers?
- mempko 5y agoWhat's even more confusing is when they thank the Russian soldiers. Probably because some percentage of people in Mariupol are pro-russia and some percentage are pro-ukraine. Once you understand this, it becomes less confusing.