8 ms·
An important point to keep in mind when talking about MMT in a policy setting is that the people who will implement it don't care about theory and will make a s
by roenxi 5y ago
An important point to keep in mind when talking about MMT in a policy setting is that the people who will implement it don't care about theory and will make a series of short-term politically expedient and/or vaguely corrupt decisions. If they implement MMT, there are good odds that it will just look like money printing.
It doesn't really matter what the academic plan is, the policy isn't going to follow it. Much like how interest rates were supposed to rise after being dropped to emergency levels a decade or so ago and instead a 25 bps rise is front page news.
All the politicians/relevant voters are looking for is a green light to hand out money and some buzz to say that it'll make everyone better so ignore the doubters. If they cared about good economic policy the last few decades would look very different. The dominant ideology is that centrally planned interest rates are a good idea, and that is questionable.
- SkyMarshal 5y agoYeah, happened with both monetary policy as you observe, and with Keynesian fiscal policy - deficit spend to cushion and shorten downturns, then contract govt spending and pay down the debt during good times, so that you can afford to deficit spend again in the next downturn. Makes sense in theory, but the second half doesn't always happen b/c politicians like buying votes with govt spending (either via under-taxation or over-spending, to the extent those aren't the same thing).
- mjevans 5y agoOr alternately raise taxes in the good times (rather than interest rates) and pay down that debt... which at least in the US we've got one political party dead set against at all costs.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- lumost 5y agoA generation ago, progressive cycles of deficit spending and taxation had put the top tax bracket in the US at 90%. Still, there was persistent inflation - and worse high unemployment. The belief was that the Federal Government had grown too large in the economy and needed to be "starved". To what extent government austerity vs. new monetary policy moved the needle for the US economy is unknowable. However many Americans of that generation feel that the starve the beast approach was correct. If you talk to Americans opposed to new taxes, their opposition is usually based on the idea that the government will waste the money in one way or another. Even those on the left in favor of taxes are often in favor of taxes for redistribution purposes. It's rare that anyone pitches the government as competent outside of military spending, and even then there are many asterisks on 10k light bulbs in submarines. If you want Americans to agree to taxes you'll need to change the perception of government competence.
- jnsie 5y ago> It's rare that anyone pitches the government as competent outside of military spending Genuine question - do people see military as competent when it comes to spending?
- inkeddeveloper 5y agoThe $2000 leather chair and multiple $3000 tvs my commander ordered for his office to be delivered to Kabul during a war would say no.
- lumost 5y agoNope, but the military gets a pass in most years as at least being competent. Most Americans believe that most government agencies are both incompetent and profligate.
- lupire 5y agoThe US military hasn't won a war in about 20 years.
- StevePerkins 5y ago> "raise taxes in the good times..." Oh, I know which party he's talking about! > "...and pay down that debt" Huh, nevermind.
- lupire 5y agoEven the extremists admit (thought they try to hide it) the Bill Clinton paid down the debt by raising taxes and cutting military spending by not starting large new wars. Caro insulted Clinton for proposing a $200B/ye deficit, right before Bush 2 issued a one-year addition of $1T in new military spending for his personal vendetta against Saddam Hussein launched on false pretenses. https://www.cato.org/commentary/no-bill-clinton-didnt-balance-budget# https://www.cato.org/commentary/no-bill-clinton-didnt-balanc...
- StevePerkins 5y agoThe 90's sure were great, I miss voting for Bill! But those days are long over, and most partisans today seem brutally disappointed in Biden because he's only spent $1 trillion instead of $3 or $4.
- briHass 5y agoI assume you're taking a swipe at Team Red, but do remember that the recent TCJA had a provision that removed the ability to deduct state/local (SALT) taxes from your Federal taxes due, above a certain amount. One could consider this very fair: if you argue for higher (Federal) taxes, you should pay what's owed, regardless of what you paid to any local governments, especially since you have much more control over where you live and the taxation policies at the local and state level. The uproar about this change from Team Blue was palpable; this was clearly a targeted attack on liberal, high-tax areas. The cutoffs for the changes were well above an income level of $150K, which meant it went after the 'rich' that Team Blue always positions as the enemy, but none of that mattered. Nobody wants more taxation when it actually hits their pocketbook. If there's anything the constituents of the two major political parties can agree on, it's that.
- lupire 5y agoSomehow the Red "cut the taxes and spending" never give back the net inflows they take from Blue states.... Blue states have higher taxes to care for their citizens so they have to take less in Federal handouts.
- TrispusAttucks 5y agoThere aren't really blue states. Only blue cities. https://miro.medium.com/max/1127/1*86sURhsiwekHqCuqjbFnkQ.png https://miro.medium.com/max/1127/1*86sURhsiwekHqCuqjbFnkQ.pn...
- pugz 5y agoWhat's the distinction? I always assumed "blue states" meant a majority of voters in that state voted blue, likewise for red states. Otherwise you might as well say "there's no blue cities, only blue neighbourhoods" and keep getting more granular down to the individual voter.
- AnthonyMouse 5y agoThe distinction is that cities are blue and non-cities aren't, as a rule. "Blue states" are just states where the majority of the population lives in cities.
- CPLX 5y agoI mean it did make everyone better. The COVID pandemic could have really wiped out a lot of people and we printed money and it helped. It’s the austerity people that have never cared about anything but their ideology. Austerity for austerity’s sake has caused unfathomable human misery in the globalization era. Right now the labor market is good for workers. That is good. Getting there has always opposed by the ruling class interests though which is why we haven’t pursued it. MMT at it’s heart is just an increasingly large number of voices screaming out “fucking STOP” and actually try to get to a relatively tight labor market, because on the whole doing so is better for most people. Yeah sure inflation is an issue but as we are seeing now it’s always been something that can be addressed by putting on the brakes a little. And for the record I have a degree in economics. I get the other side of the argument. My point of view is that the other side of the argument and elite economists have been fundamentally corrupt in their analysis for decades.
- e4e78a06 5y ago> Right now the labor market is good for workers It is good _nominally_. Real wages are basically flat. Meanwhile, for everyone who didn't get a raise or can't currently find a new job for whatever reason, they're losing purchasing power. On top of that, the housing market has been completely destroyed by the Fed printing money and shoving it into mortgage backed securities. In many nicer areas of Southern California you used to be able to get a starter home for $600k (manageable for someone in a working class profession like a nurse or mechanic), now nothing on the market is less than $1.2M. Also you forget that a big reason the labor market is so tight is because a couple million Boomers retired early during the pandemic.
- lumost 5y agoI'd highly recommend the historical fiction "Red Plenty" which followed the trajectory of Academics in the soviet union trying to compute idealized prices - meanwhile administrators, consultants, and realists had to just make the system work. At one point a quota increase leads a factory to sabotage it's old equipment, so that they may get a new machine to hit the quota. The administrator in charge of approval determines as much - and arranges for a new machine. Unfortunately a pricing reform introduced by the same plan leads to an inability to build the new piece of equipment as equipment was priced by the ton. Requiring the intervention of "well connected" individuals to solve the problem... Systems adapt - any reform will introduce exploits, and pathologies. To pretend that MMT based central planning yields a different outcome in the long hall is folly.
- selimthegrim 5y agoRed Plenty's mathematically illiterate treatment of mutations makes me doubt the rest of the book.
- somenameforme 5y agoThe exact same thing happened with Reaganomics/Supply Side Economics. The economic brains behind these ideas was Milton Friedman, and while he did strongly and aggressively advocate for supply side economics, he also had quite a lot about to say the consumer side of things and advocate for, among other things, a negative income tax [1] that in practical terms is essentially a basic income that solves many of the major problems with things like welfare. I'm not advocating for a basic income (or supply side economics), but simply emphasizing that what you said is completely true and one of the many risks of MMT. Even if MMT might be theoretically viable, in practice it's going to be interpreted as something not far from a pseudo-intellectual justification for arbitrary levels of debt/monetary inflation. [1] - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xtpgkX588nM https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xtpgkX588nM
- raxxorrax 5y agoI also don't see the positive result to be honest. We will get high prices and high interest charges? That is only a beneficial development for a very select group of people. So if that is the result of such a monetary theory or not, maybe it does not have beneficial goals?