15 ms·
How our free plan stays free
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- davidjgraph 5y agoDo a significant % of users realistically read stuff like this? We've had exactly the same ongoing problem for over a decade, and walls of text, FAQs, etc just don't allay concerns. People are just too cycnical to believe it, maybe rightly. We found the best solution was to claim that pricing kicked in at certain usage tiers, whereas everything is actually free all the time.
- mooreds 5y agoThat's funny. Are you saying you had a website or product doc somewhere that said "When you get to 20k connections, you'll be charged $X/month" and then you never bothered implementing payment logic?
- davidjgraph 5y agoYeah, it’s the google drive integration on draw.io/diagrams.net . Big companies want some cozy feeling so we tell them over 25 users per org is pay for. We don’t measure it at all, but there’s plenty of companies we know are over 1k users.
- Drdrdrq 5y agoThank you for providing such a great service! Especially love the fact that exporting to PNG allows embedding the diagram data into the image, so it can be still edited later. Genius idea and implementation!
- ketzo 5y agoWell, now they've got a well-written explanation they can link to any time someone asks "so.. how is this free?" Plus, this is a great blog post on its own merits. Someone like me (who has never used Tailscale) might find this interesting just as an explanation of SaaS economics. That might lead to me actually using Tailscale, or applying for a job there, or whatever. Even if 1% of users are satisfied by this post... that's a lot of people! And if it gains them even one enterprise client, I'm sure that's a massive ROI.
- gowld 5y agoHow does that help? people on free tier still have no reason to trust you to keep it free.
- sschueller 5y agoFree until it isn't. If anyone could eat the cost of a free tier it would be Google but they decided that the Google apps for business free tier has to go after 12+ years.
- mooreds 5y agoSure, but you can get great use of it for a long time, as long as they judge the viral growth outweighs the possible revenue they could get. I'd be more worried about the VC funding they've taken ($15M according to crunchbase). It may take years, but eventually, somehow, VCs will need to get their money back. That may be an IPO and then public market scrutiny, it may be acquisition, but if the company is a going concern, the VCs will want ROI.
- scarface74 5y agoI’ve only known one company that was customer focused that wasn’t ruined by VC funding - Backblaze.
- judge2020 5y agoCloudflare, which went public in 2019, has done pretty well with their free tier, with their reasoning being[0]: > Our free customers create scale, serve as efficient brand marketing, and help us attract developers, customers, and potential employees... So for as long as they note that free Tailscale users are worthwhile for how they are effectively free marketing and attract clientele, it shouldn't be a problem. Tailscale doesn't proxy traffic either so the overhead of having free tier customers shouldn't be huge. 0: https://github.com/judge2020/cloudflare-connectivity-test/wiki/Explanation#why-is-there-a-free-tier-in-the-first-place https://github.com/judge2020/cloudflare-connectivity-test/wi...
- dsl 5y agoThe worst thing Google did was put the highest potential source of new revenue (GSuite) and the product losing the most money (GCP) under the same executive and tie their compensation to performance. The former gets milked in every was possible rather than what would make the most sense as an individual business unit.
- aberoham 5y agoIf my enterprise network managers could buy a Tailscale Box, they'd readily consider it. As-is, this is a bit far-fetched relative to their current modus operandi -- `Advanced corporate VPNs like Tailscale can abolish concentrators completely: every server can run Tailscale directly, and individual clients can form point-to-point connections to each server it needs to talk to.` Anyone figured out how to bridge the gap from legacy here?
- mintplant 5y agoSubnet routers? https://tailscale.com/kb/1019/subnets/ https://tailscale.com/kb/1019/subnets/
- meestaplu 5y agoYes - you run one or more Tailscale subnet routers instead of your existing concentrators, then slowly migrate to running Tailscale directly from new deployments at your convenience. Running a subnet router is a matter of installing the Tailscale package on a server and authorizing it to route traffic to certain subnets over Tailscale.
- aberoham 5y agoIt's an entirely different set of teams who run anything "on a server". Besides the gap in teams or legacy demarcations of responsibility, their next disqualifier is having to think about maintaining a server. At best, the network team has just barely automated their switches & routers with Ansible. The VPN concentrators are treated as black box. And NetEng seem to prefer to stay within that box! Maybe we're just not normal? (UK/EMEA, public company)
- apenwarr 5y ago(I wrote the article.) You're not that unusual, we just haven’t had time to address that use case directly yet. I expect an ecosystem of MSPs may arise to offer physical boxes, or some such thing, since the tailscale client is open source. (Or you could buy a Synology with tailscale on it I suppose!) Many companies just run tailscale in a VM to replace their physical VPN concentrator boxes.
- Graffur 5y agoThis is the first I have heard of Tailscale. Who uses it? Is it appropriate to put something like this together for a family household?
- aaomidi 5y agoIts not great for family because the free tier is limited to one user. It's also not super great for some workplaces because tailscale kinda...gets superpowers in your network. It is definitely something smaller companies are using though.
- kevinsundar 5y agoHaving one user isn't really that bad of a limitation for a family, just share the login. Unless you want to prevent certain family members from accessing certain devices at a network level for some reason.
- detaro 5y agoIt ties to OAuth logins (Google, github), that doesn't fit soo well with "just share login", although you could make a dedicated Github account just for it I guess.
- kevinsundar 5y agoAh yeah forgot about that part, I do have a throw away google account used for these things
- aaomidi 5y agoThey limit it to auth providers, so I don't know if that'd be the best thing. https://login.tailscale.com/start https://login.tailscale.com/start
- calcifer 5y ago> It's also not super great for some workplaces because tailscale kinda...gets superpowers in your network. It is definitely something smaller companies are using though. There are banks [1] using Tailscale. If their security concerns can be addressed, I'm sure it can work for pretty much any company. [1] https://tailscale.com/customers/versabank/ https://tailscale.com/customers/versabank/
- dhc02 5y agoUsing Tailscale is like using Dropbox back when it was new: it's "just X but without the setup or maintenance", which shouldn't be so gosh darn satisfying to use, but by jove, it is. It makes you feel less shackled by the constraints that defined your world before. Awesome.
- Shish2k 5y agoI’m on the free plan at the moment, and it’s pretty neat, but I’d actually be willing to pay for a self-hosted version :P (But I guess the existence of such an option might tempt some paying enterprise customers to attempt self-hosting instead?) (I’m aware of headscale as an open-source control plane, but the iOS client is still closed-source and hard-coded to only use the first-party control plane :( )
- therein 5y agoI have been experimenting with headscale as well. I have it set up and everything works nicely but the Tailscale OSX client actually cannot automatically relogin. Headscale has the preauthkey, it is still valid even but I need to do the tailscale up --login-server ... dance every time to get it connected. Not ideal.
- SparkyMcUnicorn 5y agoInteresting. I've been running Headscale since the beginning of 2022, and haven't had any issues like this (MacOS Monterey). Have about 5-6 other MacOS users, and they haven't mentioned anything like this either. I've probably logged in a grand total of two or three times (during initial testing in Jan). Everything "just works" for us.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- kradalby 5y agoYou can get macOS specific overrides that solve this by going to /apple on your headscale instance
- therein 5y agoThank you, sounds like this will actually take care of it. I thought the /apple instructions were only for iOS since --login-server option was present on the binary already. > defaults write io.tailscale.ipn.macos ControlURL ...
- aborsy 5y agoFor me it’s the opposite: I actually don’t mind paying for a great product such as Tailscale (which I really like), but have security and privacy concerns! Mesh VPNs have substantial control over networks that they manage (they bypass firewalls by having users instal agents from within). They could add hidden nodes to networks, which is a major security concern, and see who is taking to who, how long, what service they are running, etc, which can be a privacy concern. They are targets. Is there a way to address these concerns, and make them “really” (not just on website) zero trust or at least minimal trust? Will Wireguard preshared keys as an option help (a maliciously added public key lacks a secret key exchanged among peers out of band)? What are the implications of the substantial control that Tailscale has? Or we have no way, but to trust someone? Looking at events of the past decade, I don’t have a good feeling about this!
- judge2020 5y agoYou could run your own encryption on top of Tailscale; for web properties, you can use use Tailscale's HTTPS[0] via an ACME client (thus Tailscale doesn't see your HTTPS private keys) or SSH which is inherently encrypted and verified via host identification. For anything else I don't think you can manage it much, you've always had to trust your network operator for unencrypted/unverified traffic. 0: https://tailscale.com/kb/1153/enabling-https/ https://tailscale.com/kb/1153/enabling-https/
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- aborsy 5y agoThe concern is not encryption. Wireguard encrypts the traffic, and users could indeed verify this fact before traffic leaves their machines. The concern is that, if an attacker (such as a government) compromises Tailscale, or Tailscale wants, they could probe your applications. It would be like your SSH being exposed to internet. These products bypass firewalls, which is a good thing if they are secure, and a terrible thing if they are not. There have been cases where the coordination servers have been (sometimes silently) compromised; see stories about encrypted phones. Users thought they were secure. And unfortunately small companies may not have sufficient resources to secure their infrastructure against more resourceful adversaries. That’s why it’s better to pay, so that the startups have funds to improve the product.
- genewitch 5y agoI'll probably have to look at this GTM3.0 ideal. I've found, that in the general case, it is fine to underprovision and just let stuff fall over, if no one is paying. I'll get around to fixing it eventually, even if no one alerts me. One of my goal projects is to have a 1U racked in Los Angeles or Dallas that's hiding 8-12 raspberry pi or intel celeron/atoms inside of it, including a pair of switches and all the redundant PSU you can shove in there. A nice "NAS" device for cold storage would be awesome, too. I run a pastebin server using the legacy t1.micro AWS instance - or even less, i run it on lightsail now. upon reboot, it sets up ~250MB of tmpfs, unzips the actual server code - nodejs in this instance - to tmpfs, and sets the data directory in tmpfs as well. The only way it could cost me a ton of money is someone maliciously requesting the same paste from thousands of remote machines, but my understanding is amazon would reverse the charges, and i'd probably just not run the service anymore. I can almost as easily paste and link stuff using mattermost - except full-frame images from one of my cellphones, which i can't figure out! there's no setting to allow larger format images anywhere in the configs. So i'd be out a few dollars, know that someone had it out for me or one of my anonymous users, and just walk away. I would miss being able to upload obscenely large (108MP) images and pinch zoom them forever, which is a quirk of the pastebin software i chose.
- chrisweekly 5y agoTailscale reminds me of Fly.io; fantastic tech that "just works", run by people who know what they're doing and know how to write about it. What other companies belong in this all-too-exclusive cohort?
- muhammadusman 5y agoI used to think Cloudflare was in this category but maybe not anymore?
- pestaa 5y agoWhat changed your mind?
- SkyMarshal 5y agoStripe
- mtremsal 5y agoI have the same two companies on the infra-side. A third, on the security-side of things is Thinkst (https://canary.tools/ https://canary.tools/).
- tptacek 5y agoThinkst is so great.
- technobabbler 5y agoIt's interesting that unlike most of the other loved companies, this one has no free tier. How did people come to take a chance on them without being able to demo their product?
- mtremsal 5y agoIIRC people get started for free with canary tokens: https://canarytokens.org https://canarytokens.org
- 2Gkashmiri 5y agoi dont know man.... been using zerotier quietly for like last 2 years, never i remember i have had problems or anything messed up. if i have to add a node, i install the app on the device, open the account, copy the code and authorize it and done. no config, ever. can anyone tell me what is the difference between free account of zerotier and tailscale? the configuration, management, setup, ease, limits? again, zerotier is set up once and forget. oh, no login on the clients as well, they are preconfigured because they use a key and that key gets verified in the client so no login issues even
- kevinsundar 5y agoThey discuss this here: https://tailscale.com/kb/1139/tailscale-vs-zerotier/ https://tailscale.com/kb/1139/tailscale-vs-zerotier/
- mooreds 5y agoI like how they call out that you can do this with a SaaS offering as long as you keep a handle on scaling costs with the hybrid architecture. Their system architecture enables their business model! I see the same thing with $CURJOB, which has a downloadable, self-hostable fully featured solution. The operational dynamics are different (it is harder to convince folks to run software themselves than to sign up for a SaaS, all other things being equal) but the overall dynamic is the same: offer a spectacular free product to allow for scaling customer discovery and word of mouth, then charge for things that people with money care about: > At each level, the value proposition is different, so that users use your tech differently and benefit differently from it. And at each level, the buyer is different, so the messaging is different. This is market segmentation 101, but it's nice to read about it from an infrastructure company perspective. One thing they didn't mention which I would in their shoes is how powerful $0 is in terms of letting folks kick tires and self-select their solution. (Or not select it, which is fine too.) Especially for dev focused products, a $0.01/month charge is such a barrier compared to a free solution.
- stavros 5y ago> One thing they didn't mention which I would in their shoes is how powerful $0 is in terms of letting folks kick tires and self-select their solution. (Or not select it, which is fine too.) Especially for dev focused products, a $0.01/month charge is such a barrier compared to a free solution. I was just thinking about this, I tried a hosted solution with $25 in free credits the other day and liked it, so we're now using it. It's not that we needed the $25, but if I had to talk to finance and get authorization first, we would never have gone with it. Free trials work, I guess!
- mooreds 5y ago> Free trials work, I guess! They reduce the sand in the gears, for sure. Same with educational material, especially if it useful beyond the service providing it. (See Digital Ocean's playbook, including their purchase of CSS Tricks.) > It's not that we needed the $25, but if I had to talk to finance and get authorization first, we would never have gone with it. This is it, this is the truth! Every single developer tooling company should have this tatooed on their collective forehead. Or something like that :) .
- kosikond 5y agoJust last quarter I migrated my home tiny poor stack (9 nodes) from Zerotier to Tailscale and this blog confirms it was a good call. Performance and stability especially on SMB shares and ARM based SBCs is so far way better than on zt
- linsomniac 5y agoI've been a fairly big ZeroTier fan for a year or more, playing around with it on my own machines. They do some really slick things with public networks and braodcast traffic and those "public network with an open firewall for port X" (their name escapes me), and I like their web interface (vs managing files like Wireguard or Nebula). They were on the short list for deploying an overlay network for work, and when I started thinking hard about it, I was concerned about availability if their controllers went down, I didn't want to tie our availability to theirs. So I asked their sales a question about if we could host a backup controller or something to allow our network to operate if their controllers went offline. It took (IIRC) a couple weeks to get a reply and that reply was along the lines of "It's impossible for all our controllers to go down, but if you want to self hose you lose the web UI." I replied linking to a ZeroTier tweet saying "Hosted controllers are coming back up" and asking "What was the event referred to in this tweet", and got only crickets in response. So I'm planning on going with Nebula, but also keeping an eye on DefinedNetworking. https://twitter.com/ZeroTier/status/1389766385480372225?s=20 https://twitter.com/ZeroTier/status/1389766385480372225?s=20
- OpenZiggy 5y agoIf you're looking for alternatives you might find the free, open source project I'm a dev on interesting too. you can run your own network if you want. Give us a peek? https://openziti.github.io/ https://openziti.github.io/ If you like the project just give us a star on github so we can spread the word :) Right now we also have "a single controller" but you don't lose any network traffic if you have to restart it and of course - we are right in the midst of going "distributed controller" to eliminate that spof.
- 5y ago
- muhammadusman 5y agowould using Tailscale to let my Plex server have a consistent connection be a good idea or is that a use case for this service?
- ackatz 5y agoYes! I have had zero issues throwing Tailscale on an iPad and streaming content remotely. No buffering or other weird issues to report.
- e12e 5y agoAs long as you don't need to access said Plex server from an Android TV device, like Nvidia Shield - AFAIK there's no APK build for tailscale that will install on Android TV (which is a slightly different device profile from phone/tablet).
- qbasic_forever 5y agoHad a heart skip for a moment from the headline, it reads exactly like the kind of corporate "Here's how [thing we're taking away] is actually a good thing for you" line we hear so often. Pleasantly surprised this is actually just a deep dive into how they keep their costs low and free tier still tenable.
- swyx 5y agoi like this as an emerging genre of blogposts. @andydb recently did this for Cockroach https://www.cockroachlabs.com/blog/how-we-built-cockroachdb-serverless/ https://www.cockroachlabs.com/blog/how-we-built-cockroachdb-...
- sockaddr 5y agoZerotier offers more nodes for free just FYI, and as far as I can tell they are pretty allergic to collecting user data.
- gw67 5y agoCould you share your best practices about writing documentation?
- paxys 5y agoFor pretty much every SaaS app out there with a freemium model users on the free plan aren't "the product" and their info isn't being sold to anyone. Rather, the free plans are considered a business expense to motivate a percentage of the user base to move to paid ones. So what they are saying makes sense but is very far from revolutionary.
- ignoramous 5y agoIt isn't that they have a free plan, but instead how they plan to keep it free (presumably forever), if that makes sense. To compare, logistics was Amazon's main cost driver and yet Bezos mandated to not only make it free for Prime customers but deliver orders in 2 days! This forced Amazon on a path to optimize the hell out of fulfillment and logistics so much so that they now own airports and cargo planes, build electric vehicles for middle mile and last mile themselves, have a tremendous network of distribution centers across the US / world etc. In essence, sustaining Prime drew a proverbial moat around Amazon (though, companies like Facebook, Snap, Uber, Instacart, Klarna, Alibaba, Wish have inflicted damage, inspite that). Cloudflare's doing the same with bandwidth.
- jrockway 5y ago> Next, we keep the DERP network costs under control… by trying to never use it. When using Tailscale, almost all of your traffic goes peer to peer, so DERP is only used as a backup. We continue to improve our core product so it can build point-to-point links in ever-more-obscure situations. This is mentioned in passing, but shows a very good technique. They incentivize technical excellence by tying it to a concrete cost. A free plan, with DERP, is the sacred cow that must not ever be removed. If they don't fix the "ever more obscure situations", then the cost goes up. If they pay an engineer to investigate and fix this, not only does the engineer get to do interesting technical work, and not only does the system become more reliable and "good", they can also think of it as increasing the profit margin of the product (by not increasing costs). I worked with Avery on Google Fiber, and we did the same thing. Our sacred cow was excellent US-based phone support. That is quite expensive. If there were bugs in our product, users would call in, and our call center costs would increase because we'd have to have more people working. So every week in our team meeting, we would look at summaries of calls, and take on engineering work to address the most common class of problems. That let us scale up the business and still provide friendly and competent phone support, because we were reducing the problems that people called in about. (This was things like having our Wifi access points steer 5GHz capable devices away from flakier 2.4GHz signals, or fixing "black screen" bugs where TV randomly stopped playing for software or network reasons.) Because we had that "sacred cow", every obscure bug that we spent months fixing not only made the product better and were intellectually stimulating to finally figure out, but had a concrete impact on how costly it was to deliver the service. What most companies would do here to reduce costs is simple. Don't fix DERP bugs, just charge for it. Don't fix "black screen" bugs, just hide the phone number on your website so people can't figure out to call. Avery has found the perfect balance between cost reduction, interesting engineering, and the somewhat nebulous "good product". Normally conflicting concerns, all living together in harmony. If everyone copied his technique here, the world would be a better place.
- gowld 5y agoThis is free market economics: improve the product or lower the cost, or fold.
- 5y ago
- tomjen3 5y agoI like the idea of Tailscale, because it gets us a little closer to the network where all devices are connected instead of 99% of them being behind NAT. But I don't want to use them when they don't support email based logins. I did read their explanation[0], but I am not sure how it actually makes sense - if they don't want to have passwords, why not a client cert? [0]: https://tailscale.com/kb/1013/sso-providers/ https://tailscale.com/kb/1013/sso-providers/
- tptacek 5y agoYou can imagine them getting to some fussy custom authentication scheme like client certificates at some point, but IdP-based SSO logins --- usually email-backed --- are a practically-universal security best practice for corporate security now. The goal is to make it easy to enroll and offboard people and make it difficult to miss a step in offboarding and thus leave people with undesired access, and to have a single source of authentication truth that can be regularly audited.
- jlokier 5y agoI wouldn't trust an IdP-based SSO login for any critical service that I need continuous access to, unless I control the IdP. All those stories like "Google blocked my account without recourse and don't answer tickets anyway" have put me off. I lost editing rights to a Google My Business profile that I was the sole owner of, because they gave third party input precedence over the owner's own entered data (opening times of all things) then locked the ability to update it, so I know loss of control over one's own account isn't that rare with Google. It's not just Google. So I trust my domain provider more than I trust any third party SSO, because I believe I have legal ownership of domains in case all else fails. I don't seem to have equivalent rights over SSO accounts at any third party. So, for now until something better is available, email-based accounts are a must-have for any critical service.
- tptacek 5y agoYou do you, but that first sentence puts you wildly out of step with most security practices at most companies, very much including most tech companies.
- jakedata 5y agoRunning a Tailscale POC now. Paranoid firewalls blocking NAT traversal are a pain. I am running a private DERP relay to get around public relay congestion. I also have a subnet relay running - I am watching which solution will be long-term more performant and reliable. Their ACLs definitely take some getting used to but I think I have things about where I want them. Surprising issue - conflicting address ranges between home users and corporate network prevent subnet relays from working seamlessly. Centralized logging would be a cash-worthy feature. Adoption by the team is a bit slow, most people are still using SSH tunnels despite the clumsy nature.
- chipsa 5y agoThey log to themselves centrally, and they log to the standard locations on the clients, so you can pull the logs in from there using your standard centralized logging setup. Conflicting address ranges for subnets isn't especially surprising to me. Making sure your corpnet isn't on 192.168/16 probably is the most helpful thing to do there.
- hoten 5y agoCould anyone ELI5 to me why I might use tailscale? If I don't have a use case for a VPN is there any use case for this product, or if I did want a VPN, why this and not some other service like Nord? Asking from a place of curiosity, I don't quite understand this company. I suspect it solves a lot of issues related to provisioning your own networks ... Which would explain why I don't quite get it because I've never done that.
- xanaxagoras 5y agoI've wondered this as well. Everyone seems to rave about it, but I run my own wireguard and don't find it too hard to add devices to the network. I think maybe you can use it to expose certain things to the internet easily? I don't have a lot of trouble doing that either. I've scrolled around their marketing site for a few minutes before and I just don't really get what all the fuss is about. I'm sure I'm missing something. I will say, and I think this is right, the proposition here isn't a VPN like Nord which you'd use to hide your traffic from your ISP or masquerade into a different geolocation, but rather a VPN for connecting to your own devices.
- hobofan 5y ago> I'm sure I'm missing something. Can you really not see the difference between this[0] and this[1]? This really feels like a "What's the value in Dropbox when everyone has access to rsync and bash?" situation. [0]: https://www.wireguard.com/quickstart/ https://www.wireguard.com/quickstart/ [1]: https://tailscale.com/kb/1017/install/ https://tailscale.com/kb/1017/install/
- xanaxagoras 5y agoI can see that it's easier to setup for someone who doesn't know how to use WireGuard, but not how it would benefit me personally. I guess SSO is nice. I think it's more like... "What's the value in Dropbox when I'm already running Nextcloud?"
- 5y ago
- jlokier 5y agoI already know how NAT traversal works, and I've read a lot about it before. But credit to David Anderson at Tailscale. Their NAT traversal article is excellent, the best I've seen on the topic: https://tailscale.com/blog/how-nat-traversal-works/ https://tailscale.com/blog/how-nat-traversal-works/
- pjkundert 5y agoThanks for that! I hadn't heard, before, that anyone had successfully used the "Birthday Paradox" on port numbering to successfully defeat NATs. Glad to see that Tailscale has successfully implemented and tested this -- not just at one layer, but at multiple layers of NATs!
- polote 5y ago> Tailscale’s free plan is free because we keep our scaling costs low relative to typical SaaS companies. Well no, Tailscale's free plan is free because this is a user acquiring strategy (as it is described later in the article ) not because of your low cost. You could have a higher cost and still be free and typical Saas companies have the exact same reasoning than Tailscale, that's why Notion has a free plan, that's why Cloudflare has a free plan.... That's the whole point of a freemium model. What VC call product led growth. The if you are not paying you are the product is true for free products not for freemium
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- lijogdfljk 5y agoI agree with your statement, but to devils-advocate for a moment the details matter do they not? Ie if your scaling costs are high than wouldn't you need to extract much more from each user than if they are low? Ie high enough and you're doing sketchy shit and selling every ounce of user data you can because you have to recoup some of the user costs. Low enough and users could "just" be a mind-share cost. If true, the devil is really how the user has no information here. All we can do is assume we are the product and they're fully-evil. Unfortunately.
- nickysielicki 5y agoSure. Fine. They’re solving a problem that, in the past, has caused me to be dramatically less productive. I set up Tailscale on all my devices in 20 minutes. It’s like magic. You can bet that the next time I’m working somewhere and we face a problem Tailscale solves, I’m going to advocate to use it.
- atonse 5y agoSame here. It was a no brainer to switch my company to TS from vanilla WireGuard.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- toothpicked 5y ago
- fomine3 5y agoTo minimize DERP usage, does Tailscale implement "TCP" hole punching? Or not much worth?
- robocat 5y agoFrom https://tailscale.com/blog/how-nat-traversal-works/ https://tailscale.com/blog/how-nat-traversal-works/ “First, the protocol should be based on UDP. You can do NAT traversal with TCP, but it adds another layer of complexity to an already quite complex problem, and may even require kernel customizations depending on how deep you want to go. We’re going to focus on UDP for the rest of this article. If you’re reaching for TCP because you want a stream-oriented connection when the NAT traversal is done, consider using QUIC instead. It builds on top of UDP, so we can focus on UDP for NAT traversal and still have a nice stream protocol at the end.” That article is the best article I have ever read on the nitty gritty of how NAT traversal works.
- fomine3 5y agoI've read it before, fantastic article. I agree that using QUIC is better for the purpose. Still I'm curious whether TCP hole punching worth to support direct connection for UDP blocked environment. Maybe TCP hole punching also won't work on such environment?
- robocat 5y agoFrom article, they use the relay as a fallback if UDP is blocked. “We’ll probably also still want fallback relays that use a well-like[d] protocol like HTTP, to get out of networks that block outbound UDP.” “Having relays to handle the long tail isn’t that bad. Additionally, some networks can break our connectivity much more directly than by having a difficult NAT. For example, we’ve observed that the UC Berkeley guest WiFi blocks all outbound UDP except for DNS traffic. No amount of clever NAT tricks is going to get around the firewall eating your packets. So, we need some kind of reliable fallback no matter what.”
- jerrygoyal 5y agoThere's no option to just signup via email. When you enter email it redirects to Google OAuth which asks for other permissions as well like: Know who you are on Google and associate you with the personal info you have made public
- nickysielicki 5y agoNot true, I signed up a few days ago with just my email. It may not work for Gmail addresses, but if you have another it should.
- Operyl 5y ago> We continue to improve our core product so it can build point-to-point links in ever-more-obscure situations. I'm not sure how high priority this is. We've been wanting a way to force traffic over a private network, for example, but it's still not possible. It's really the only thing we've asked for for our business, and we hope they will introduce it soon, it's easier keeping a lot of ACLs in one single place. To clarify, we are a happy paying customer.
- janikvonrotz 5y agoAs long as their server is closed source (which manages the actual key exchange) I won't use tailscale. A good alternative is: https://github.com/tonarino/innernet https://github.com/tonarino/innernet I'm not affiliated with Tonarino. But sure its interesting: https://tonari.no/ https://tonari.no/
- ptman 5y agoAlso https://github.com/juanfont/headscale https://github.com/juanfont/headscale
- bedast 5y agoThe one and only thing that keeps me from using Tailscale is the sign on options. I do have accounts with Microsoft, Github, and Google, but I'm trying to move away from Google (getting any kind of account ban on any Google property means you lose ALL of your Google access with no way to recover, just search HN for stories about this), and I don't frequently use those other services. There's no options for other 'free' identity providers, and you must pay to use any of the commercial solutions. In their support documentation, they note that they absolutely do not want to become an identity provider so they will not offer accounts directly. I don't mind paying for a service. But to use Tailscale for personal use with a commercial identity provider would get into the "prohibitively expensive" category for me.
- apenwarr 5y agoNote that you can create a (public) Github org nowadays for free, then use it with Tailscale. This is a pretty smart move on Github's part.
- grammers 5y agoI love the business model, but I'd wonder if it works forever? Can word of mouth also be enough if you want to go mainstream, if you want to hit the mass market?
- edwinyzh 5y agoI just tried and found a show-stopper that you might want to solve - it slows down my TortoiseSVN Log Messages view which connects to a local SVN server from 0.1 milliseconds to 20+ seconds.