6 ms·
What a mess. Nothing in the student's question can be construed as offensive -- she asked in a forum why the US hasn't responded to genocide and oppression of
by tomrod 5y ago
What a mess.
Nothing in the student's question can be construed as offensive -- she asked in a forum why the US hasn't responded to genocide and oppression of the Uyghurs (her brother has been detained since 2017 by the Chinese government).
In response, the Chinese students in the audience jeered, booed, and left the room. Through a representative group, which may or may not actually represent the students: "[w]e left today’s colloquium because we felt that the atmosphere in that room was extremely hostile towards us . . . [a]t that moment, we were not sitting in a classroom; we were crucified in a courtroom for crimes that we did not commit."
If they were asked to personally answer for their nation's genocide, I could see this remark having validity. However, they weren't, but by rudely interjecting into a clear question they made it about them, and facts and morality are not on their government's side. In addition to this being extremely rude decorum, their response shows a loyalist's denial of reality.
- foepys 5y agoThis has been the Chinese MO for quite a while now. Always play the victim. Never engage in conversations, never answer anything. Just blame the other side to be offensive to Chinese culture. This is happening everywhere, all the way to the top.
- ganzuul 5y agoSo if they are always going to play the victim it's best that they actually are victimized?
- tomrod 5y agoCan you walk me through how you got from the grandparent's comment's point that they observed CCP leadership and loyalists play the victim, to your pointed question that they should be victimized? I'm confused, because the grandparent identified a thought-terminating cliched approach, and your point seems to be unrelated, so I feel like I'm missing steps between.
- kderbyma 5y agoThe CCP is offensive to Chinese culture
- tomrod 5y agoHow so?
- bko 5y agoIt was rude and incredibly offensive, but is it really newsworthy? What should the school do? Hunt down and reprimand these students? Prevent them from standing up during a Q&A? Send them to mandatory education programs on the subject? I personally don't want my university to have a public stance on these issues, no matter how one sided. Just provide educational services and a safe environment to learn (safe as in physically safe)
- ledauphin 5y agonews is exactly what it is. News is in fact the appropriate alternative to "hunting down", "reprimanding", etc. Thankfully, there isn't a binary choice between "imprison for life" and "never speak publicly about bad behavior".
- 14 5y agoHow about forcing them to sign a declaration acknowledging the genocide of their government or be expelled. We know it is happening we don’t need shitty people in our country if they want to deny it.
- bko 5y agoYeah, I would be against that as well. That sounds awful, kind of like a loyalty test. It reminds me of terrible stories after 9/11 from Middle Eastern American's getting eyed suspiciously and having their loyalties questioned. Imagine being an Arab and some school making you sign something like "9/11 was bad"?
- 14 5y agoWe already have companies cut ties with Russia I don’t see this as being any different. Cut ties with people with oppressive views. Screw them is my feelings.
- simonh 5y agoEconomic sanctions are a very, very different thing from coerced 'confessions' from individuals. There are governments that engage in such practices, but they have no place in a free society.
- bramgn 5y agoMakes you wonder how a person can get in such frame of mind that it is fine in their head te respond like that
- ashwagary 5y agoIf you believe the genocide claims are false and being amplified by a community with an agenda, that could easily result in such behavior.
- mytailorisrich 5y ago"There was audible booing and jeering going on from the Chinese students partway through her question, and during the answer they started to get up and just walked out of the room," Let's not go over the top, the reaction is not uncommon in public events when a person or a group very strongly objects to what is being said. Whether this is rude or disrespectful is another issue but the point is that this happens all the time. It's not really newsworthy. Now, a key issue here and in your comment is the choice of terms. China and the vast majority of Chinese people will object and be offended by the use of the term "genocide". The term really is pushed in order to frame the narrative, and it has proved extremely effective (as can be seen here), but is not established fact.
- mercutio2 5y agoI strongly agree. Words have meaning. Genocide is not “horrible mistreatment of a group I believe is sympathetic”. The Chinese treatment of Uighurs is deplorable, and should be loudly condemned. Russian invasion and shelling of Ukrainian cities is deplorable and should be even more loudly condemned. It’s much worse than Chinese treatment of Uighurs. Neither are genocide. Genocide is slaughtering people with the explicit purpose of eliminating a particular type of person. Attempting to suppress a culture is bad, and on a spectrum whose terminal point is genocide, but when we jump to the terminal point, we lose all ability to distinguish shades of grey in bad behavior.
- tomrod 5y agoActions considered genocide[0]: [A] Killing members of the group [B] Causing serious bodily or mental harm to members of the group [C] Deliberately inflicting on the group conditions of life calculated to bring about its physical destruction [D] Imposing measures intended to prevent births within the group [E] Convention on the Prevention and Punishment of the Crime of Genocide Uyghurs' experience absolutely qualifies.[1] Links [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Genocide#Acts https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Genocide#Acts [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Uyghur_genocide https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Uyghur_genocide
- 5y ago
- dirtyid 5y ago> can be construed as offensive ... > loyalist's denial of reality Uyghur student adopting State Department propaganda that XJ is genocide is offensive to PRC nationalist who doesn't view XJ as genocide seems pretty straight forward. One sides facts and morality is just another sides definition of useful idiot / propaganda. "Crimes they did not commit" is not about answering for their nations "genocide", it's denying there's any crimes are being committed at all.