8 ms·
Are legendary music catalogues worth the money?
- bagels 5y agoArticle lacks the piece of information needed to come to your own conclusion: current and future revenue projections. Obviously some think it worth it since these sales are happening.
- lordnacho 5y agoFinancial models tend to use interest rates to discount future income streams. Interest rates have been very very low lately, even rates going far out into the future. So where before a £100 income you get in 10 years might have been worth £50 now, you might get £95 now instead when rates are lower. Incomes from music would be inflated by low rates. The other thing that is very hard to model is that songs might become unpopular. This is probably more of a downside risk though I suppose it's happened that a song becomes more popular due to a new recording. If you're an artist it makes a lot of sense to cash out given these two things. Rates cannot get much lower, and chances are your songs will go out of fashion. Now why does anybody want to buy them? Well just like before the GFC people are looking for all sorts of bonds to sell, and this is one of those unusual deals you can pass by your investors that will make them feel young again, dressed up as a sound financial investment. Of course there's also actual income being made, so it's not a complete scam, but the logic is like any other financial instrument that has long and uncertain future flows.
- jmyeet 5y agoMusic has been a cash cow that seems to just keep on giving. I mean how much money does the Beatles catalogue make and will likely continue to make? As a consumer, this can be pretty annoying. Often TF shows (as one example) might only get music rights for the inital broadcast and not reruns. I've come across a few shows that are never released on DVD because th emusic rights would just be prohibitively expensive to do that. But what I'll be interested to see is in the coming years if Western governments will "allow" such catalogues to enter the public domain. They should but we're all familiar with the repeated and unjustified mouse-related copyright extensions. I mean up until Happy Birthday entered the public domain (which came down to a century-old song book and a court case [1]) it was stil generating ~$1m/year in royalties. Aren't we well beyond the point where this sort of thing is justifiable? [1]: https://www.seattletimes.com/nation-world/old-songbook-could-put-happy-birthday-in-public-domain/ https://www.seattletimes.com/nation-world/old-songbook-could...
- andybak 5y agoTF?
- everyone 5y agoTF commonly stand for "Team Fortress" a popular Quake mod.
- password4321 5y agoProbably TV.
- andybak 5y agoAh, of course.
- danmur 5y agoTelefission
- squeaky-clean 5y agoSimilarly there are some video games you can't buy anymore because music rights have expired. It's more common in racing games. The Forza series tends to go on sale dirt cheap before the music license rights expire and then can never be purchased legally again. You can still install and play the game with that music, but no new sales. https://mspoweruser.com/forza-horizon-3-no-longer-available-buy-september/ https://mspoweruser.com/forza-horizon-3-no-longer-available-...
- kingcharles 5y agoAs someone who was once a producer on a movie, the movie was cut with an awesome soundtrack, but when the movie was sold the buyers realized they couldn't afford to distribute it because the soundtrack was too awesomely expensive and so all the music got replaced with lame shit. I wonder how often music is downgraded in movies because a good royalty deal can't be negotiated for certain tracks?
- 5y ago
- racl101 5y agoI guarantee 20 years from now most of the popular music we'll hear in franchise movies will still be from the late '50s to the early '2000s. We'll still be putting The Rolling Stones, The Beatles, Zeppelin etc. as the soundtrack to these movies. I think they are worth the money.
- WalterBright 5y agoMusic from 1965 to 1975 has simply never gone out of style. In the 1970s you never heard any music 50 years old. I was listening to the radio today, and the current hit has the legendary lyrics "A B C D E" (yes, saying the alphabet) and the singer had to have the autotune turned up to 11 to apparently get on key. Though I do have to admit Gloria Estefan had a "hit" where the words were "1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 I'm gonna keep on counting" (please stop!).
- tiahura 5y agoI’m a music snob and I like that song. It’s got a catchy hook, and the pre chorus contrasts nicely with the chorus and verses. For a 17 year old girl, it’s damn impressive. As Rick Beato reminds, it’s easy to dump on modern music. True music lovers should be able to find something clever about every popular song.
- mhh__ 5y agoWhich is ironic coming from Rick Beato sometimes at least (he's talented but somewhat famous in jazz meme groups for being a grumpy old man)
- earthboundkid 5y agoThe issue for contemporary music is not that it's bad. Pop music has always been 99% bad. The issue is that it's not possible to create successful new IP anymore. We see this across entertainment. It used to be that a disc jockey in a mid-sized market could find a record, spin it a bunch, create a regional sensation that would eventually break through nationally. That just cannot happen anymore. Instead, there are YouTube and Spotify niches that go deep like Lofi Chill Beats to Study To or whatever, but they can't break out and grow. They just keep getting the same audience but deeper instead of broader.
- saaaaaam 5y agoA number of pretty important things missing from this article: 1. The administration of publishing rights is often really badly executed. Investors like Hipgnosis are really good at finding both historic uncollected revenues and making sure the catalogue is getting very penny it is due. 2. A lot of these investors are not “bankers”. The founder of Hipgnosis is a very shrewd and very successful music industry artist manager. Many of the other acquisitions are by music conglomerates. Eg Sony has spent a huge amount in the past year - hundreds of millions. 3. Aggregated data is hugely powerful in valuing catalogue. 4. Streaming is a market share game. If you have more market share you get a bigger slice of the pie. Streaming revenues from the significant platforms are not based on number of streams directly or minutes listened. 5. There are legislative changes going on just now which could radically shake up the publishers share. 6. A big big issue with publishing revenues revenue leakage and multiple commissions. A Collective Management Organisation handles local royalty collection - and takes a commission for doing so- but before those royalties hit the bank account of the rights holder there may be several other people commissioning. Rights investors can establish direct relationships on a territory level meaning double/triple commissions vanish, vastly increasing the value of the revenue streams. 7. It’s very easy to assign asset value to music rights because there’s a HUGE amount of detailed data. People aren’t simply sticking a finger in the air. 8. I personally believe that publishing rights are undervalued and will increase in value quite significantly as we enter the next phase of music consumption, linked to metaverse/tokenisation/digital fandom. There are huge opportunities around digital artefacts in the decade ahead. If you’d asked me a few months back what I thought about the metaverse and NFTs in the context of music I probably would have said “emperor’s new clothes”. I’ve spent a couple of months doing some pretty detailed research and I now believe there are really significant opportunities opening up. Kids who are 12 years old now - so younger than instagram - are growing up in “blended reality” where physical and digital existence are completely blurred, digital existence is a significant part of identity and physical artefacts may begin to be seen as inconvenient and unwieldy. That opens significant opportunities for digital exploitation of publishing rights. Want an interactive 3d music related artwork for your metaverse space? If that uses lyrics you need a licence.
- germinalphrase 5y ago“ linked to metaverse/tokenisation/digital fandom” What does this buzzwordiness mean in practical reality?
- andrewljohnson 5y agoOld music now gets streamed more than new music. https://www.theatlantic.com/ideas/archive/2022/01/old-music-killing-new-music/621339/ https://www.theatlantic.com/ideas/archive/2022/01/old-music-...
- nradov 5y agoNot surprising. As the total volume of recorded music continuously grows, new music will make up a smaller and smaller fraction.