14 ms·
Tokamak Energy sets a temperature record among commercial fusion companies
- lui8906 5y agoIs there a noobie friendly resource for following the latest news on fusion? Thinking something like Risky Biz (for IT security) but for fusion?
- dejv 5y agoThey do have great Youtube channel: https://m.youtube.com/channel/UCuSlFJbBUIj1zfJLRnGXSow https://m.youtube.com/channel/UCuSlFJbBUIj1zfJLRnGXSow Unfortunately it is not as active as it once was, but their old videos are very interesting.
- 1_player 5y agoSpeaking of, do you know any good channel/educational video that goes deep into nuclear fusion and the challenges we're facing for a layman such as myself?
- throwawayboise 5y agoFor those who know more, how meaningful is this achievement" "We are proud to have achieved this breakthrough which puts us one step closer to providing the world with a new, secure and carbon-free energy source." Seems like every fusion energy announcement, always one step closer but never quite arrived.
- elil17 5y agoI mean that is how steps work, no? This is how R&D projects work. It’s extremely difficult to estimate timelines. Someone might have said the same thing of, for instance, image recognition - we kept getting “one step closer” for years and years. You could look at Fei-Fei Li making ImageNet in 2006 and go, “she didn’t really solve anything - they keep saying we’re one step closer to image recognition but this is just some new dataset.” Of course that actually was a very significant step, it was crucial groundwork for AlexNet. There is absolutely no way to know whether getting to 100M in a spherical tokamak is really significant. Maybe this design is a dead end that will never see actual use. Maybe you will have a tiny one in your tea kettle by 2050. What’s clear, though is that the pace of fusion research is really much faster than it was. That should be exciting to everyone except oil barons.
- tempfs 5y agoIt is almost like these 'another winning step towards fusion' announcements arrive on a schedule meant to make sure that the funding isn't pulled.
- qiskit 5y agoIf it was anywhere close to being commercially feasible, you'd first see it in oil/gas futures. Money will know long before you or I or any news outlets will know.
- onethought 5y agoI’m not sure that is true. GM isn’t a penny stock when it should be, and Neo or Xpeng should be bigger, and they are not. Sometimes money wants to deny the future that is coming.
- liketochill 5y agoClearly the market disagrees with you. I’ve never heard of neo or xpeng and GM has a long history of manufacturing vehicles to North American safety standards. Whatever neo or xpeng do is GM incapable of hiring some engineers (they might already have some) to copy it and then build it in their existing factories?
- onethought 5y agoNo, GM are incapable of doing it. For a whole bunch of reasons: - ICE factories can't just be switched to be EV factories, so having an existing ICE factory is a burden not a benefit. - They don't have capacity to build batteries - Even if they did, they don't have the raw materials - Even if they did, they don't have the raw materials processing capacity - Even if they did start securing the capacity now i.e. Building Lithium mines, battery factories, EV car factories etc. By the time they come online... GM will have run out of money, because no one will be buying their cars anymore, but they'll still be paying for ICE factories/workforce/etc. Xpeng and Neo are kind of Tesla clones, but they have home ground advantage in that they are Chinese based which is where the majority of the EV market is right now, it's also where all the battery supply is. You haven't heard of them, because they haven't entered the US market yet.
- liketochill 5y agoSo GE is doomed because their strategy is to buy battery cells instead of manufacturing them themselves? There are a lot more parts in a vehicle than the cells.
- tootie 5y agoThe context here is that this is a private company who have hit an important milestone. They have managed to raise capital, hire people and build a plausible foundation for a viable reactor without billions in government subsidies and done it in a little over ten years. They are claiming grid-connected reactors will be online by 2030.
- drexlspivey 5y agoDoes temperature have a theoretical upper limit ?
- 19870213 5y agoNot a physicist, if temperature of particles is movement (I think chemical bonds will break long before the following limit), then the upper limit is just below the speed of light. To make it even hotter would require infinite amount of energy. Now what that temperature is in kelvin, I don't know.
- wiml 5y agoTemperature is more about the kinetic (and other) energy of the particles than the velocity — you can keep adding energy indefinitely, or at least until you hit some kind of planck-scale weirdness point, even though the velocity is only asymptotically approaching c.
- parineum 5y agoEnough energy in one place will create a black hole.
- jupp0r 5y agoYes, 1.42 x 10^32 K but it's not as straightforward as naming a single limit [1]. [1] https://www.popsci.com/article/science/ask-anything-whats-hottest-temperature-possible/ https://www.popsci.com/article/science/ask-anything-whats-ho...
- Keyframe 5y agoThat question has an answer in another question.. does energy have a theoretical upper limit? Lowest temperature is absolute zero, no movement.
- elil17 5y agoYes it does - the plank temperature, where the wavelength of light emitted is the plank length. Current theories predict that this would be the maximum possible temperature. Of course, this is so hot as to be totally irrelevant to anything practical.
- api 5y ago> While several government laboratories have reported plasma temperatures above 100M degrees in conventional tokamaks, this milestone has been achieved in just five years, for a cost of less than £50m ($70m), in a much more compact fusion device. Governments should only fund things. They should not actually run them.
- JaimeThompson 5y agoPrivately run, revenue optimizing police isn't something that sounds like a positive.
- elil17 5y agoThis private company was only able to move so quickly and cheaply because government labs had already shown how to do it. If anything, this case is evidence against your view.
- TeeMassive 5y agoDoes "commercial fusion" means suistained fusion?
- aaomidi 5y agoProbably net positive energy generation.
- apendleton 5y agoDepends on the meaning of "sustained," but not all fusion startup concepts are aiming for steady-state operation; some are planned to be pulsed (Helion, Zap, probably others). The important thing is that they get more energy out than in, and enough more to justify the capex. (This is probably Q_scientific of somewhere between 10 and 30, depending on the specific concept and who you ask.)
- scratcheee 5y agocommercial fusion as in the sense of the title is probably meant to mean "making profit", so significantly harder than just sustained fution, which will likely be obtained much earlier. But it doesn't really matter, for now that's just an aspirational goal, not an imminent reality.
- BonoboIO 5y agoGreat :-) Only 20 more years. Sorry, Could not resist
- weakfish 5y agoArriving the same year as the Linux desktop!
- olliej 5y agoNext year is the year of viable fusion power!
- adhesive_wombat 5y agoTo be honest, the year of fusion on the desktop sounds pretty dope. Though you could argue that was 1992[1] and KDE has has Plasma sewn up for a long time too. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fsn_(file_manager) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fsn_(file_manager)
- AitchEmArsey 5y agoWhich will arrive first - the year of viable fusion, or the year of Linux on the desktop?
- noobermin 5y agoTo be honest a lot of the fusion news recently has made me skeptical (namely, for CFS guys who kinda smell a little sus to me if I'm being 100% honest), but this on the other hand is fantastic, actual results (although they should publish a paper on it, just my bias as a scientist), meeting good plasma temps with just $70M! Not a gigabuck not even 100 megabucks, that to me is a good sign for actual commercial fusion. Bravo to Tokamak Energy.
- willis936 5y agoWhat's sus about CFS? No one else is making 20 T confinement field coils. SPARC's campus is already up and the machine is being built. ARC is expected to have ground broken this year.
- GOONIMMUNE 5y agoDo you have a source on ARC breaking ground? I follow CFS and haven't heard anything- google didn't turn up anything either. Just curious
- willis936 5y agoJust secondhand from a recruiter. I'm certain CFS will make announcements when they have something to announce.
- willis936 5y agoOh, and a friend of mine told me that Bob Mumgard (CFS CEO) mentioned the hope to break ground for ARC this Fall during a seminar last Friday. https://www.physics.wisc.edu/events/?id=6566 https://www.physics.wisc.edu/events/?id=6566
- TaylorAlexander 5y agoARC is going to begin construction before SPARC is proven? That’s actually great news I just didn’t know about it. I guess they gotta find a way to spend their new $1.8B investment.
- 5y ago
- ed 5y agoNote: they did not achieve "commercial fusion" (Q-total > 1), they set a temperature record among commercial fusion companies. (Still cool though!)
- ReptileMan 5y agoThe opposite of cool. Literally
- deutschew 5y agodamn...got all excited
- dang 5y agoOK, we've put that phrase in the title above. Thanks!
- omgJustTest 5y agoTokamaks, while cool (or hot!), are ultimately limited by materials that we know about. There are IAEA reports for fusion calling for materials that survive >100 displacements-per-atom (DPA) and > 1000deg C[1]. Additionally you might also need highly controllable super-conducting magnets as well as advanced sensing of the instabilities of the fusion plasma to ensure they are well confined (a chief requirement for fusion). There are other problems, but these are typical issues with tokamak-based fusion devices. Chiefly most tokamaks around the world do not operate in "continuous mode", ie they operate on "shot mode" or short duration experiments to attempt to ignite the plasma to fusion conditions. Achieving high-duty cycle operation with a ignited plasma is its own hurdle. Making hot plasmas is interesting, but if your technology requires the above, you are looking at around 4-5 once-per-decade material science results. Every national lab in the US is saying we are out of time, we need existing energy solutions to avoid the worst of climate change. Source: I am a nuclear engineer. [1] https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S1369702109702949#fig4 https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S136970210...
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- richardfey 5y agoIt feels like this is what Elon Musk should have invested into.
- topspin 5y agoCommonwealth Fusion (the MIT spinoff with new high temperature superconducting magnets) has raised about $2 billion in venture capital since 2021.
- mateo1 5y agoInteresting development, wrong title.
- thruhiker 5y agoThis is so hot it’s cool.
- kumarski 5y agoFusion is irrelevant. It marginally reduces the size of a fission plant, a non-problem. It presents klingon level engineering problems. The feedstock and its subsequent volatility are civilization grade problems. In the designs I've seen thrown around, you end up generating tritium and helium inside the lithium reactor cover/blanket. I'm not saying we shouldn't pursue it for research purposes, but the desire to research is politically/emotionally driven and not based on the discovery of any recent phenomena.
- drexlspivey 5y agoHow about the fact that it doesnt produce toxic waste and the reactor cannot meltdown, the two biggest problems of fission?
- kumarski 5y agoAre you comparing it to Chernobyl?
- javcasas 5y agoParent comment has a point: given a power plant and a hostile attacker/incompetent crew, it's preferable it becoming a blackout and 1 square km of rubble over a blackout, 1 square kilometer of radioactive rubble and 2600 square kilometers of radioactive exclusion zone.
- pfdietz 5y agoThose are not the two biggest problems of fission. The biggest problem of fission is that it costs too much. Fusion makes that problem worse.
- KarlKemp 5y agoThat’s fine. Unfortunately, it also doesn’t produce energy.
- Shadonototra 5y agoWhy so much lies? Chinese one reached 120m, this one just 100m (+20%) https://www.livescience.com/chinas-1-trillion-artificial-sun-fusion-reactor-just-got-five-times-hotter-than-the-sun https://www.livescience.com/chinas-1-trillion-artificial-sun...
- X6S1x6Okd1st 5y agoThat's not a commercial one