4 ms·
Why Werner Herzog thinks human space colonization “will inevitably fail”
- 5350-uiop-1130 5y agoWhat is the point of colonising (not exploring) Mars. It just seems a dead, barren wasteland that is only of interest to geologists and other highly specialized scientists.
- qgin 5y agoThe longer term idea would be to make it into a non-dead, non-barren place. The main purpose would be to take the first step towards protecting human civilization against being completely wiped out in a planet-scale disaster, whether human-caused (nuclear war) or natural (supervolcano, giant asteroid hit)
- 5350-uiop-1130 5y agoI know it's not either or but seems that money is better spent protecting the Earth. The idea of terraforming Mars is kind of beyond even science fiction. I think the money would be better spent building larger, more comfortable space stations. Think something between the ISS and DS9 :D
- flembat 5y agoThere are bilions of us, we can do more than one thing at a time.
- flembat 5y agoMars is a lethal desert, but it has gravity, some atmosphere, and water, making it better than most places for a species with our current level of technology. Floating cities in the atmospheres of gas giants, or underwater cities on ice moons might be better long term, but we can't do that sort of thing yet. Life may be rare and unusual, we need to ensure it does not end with Earth.
- erulabs 5y agoI love Werner Herzog - but he’s never been an optimist. As for the content of the complaint: habitable planets are too far away, Mars is very much not a nice place to live, and we must protect the earth instead of abandoning it: well - of course. Does anyone disagree? Just because mars isn’t great and the stars are far doesn’t mean inevitable failure. And as for “moving on like locusts” - there will most likely never be the means to get more than even a tiny fraction of a fraction of the human population off the planet. Becoming multi planetary isn’t some economic frontier - it isn’t a new world to colonize - it’s a required backup for the survival of life itself. Deer and trees stand little chance to reproduce if the early is destroyed (by us or by something else). We do have some chance - it’s our responsibility to life itself to not perish. Forget humanity - let’s save the penguins. Anyways - I can’t believe someone as clearly intelligent is Herzog does the “but we can’t just abandon earth!” Argument. No one is abandoning earth - we’re all stuck here - as if we’re all one mind and decided “eh, fuck it”. Thank god humanity takes thousands of different courses simultaneously. I hope one of those courses doesn’t go extinct. Let’s fix earth and get some folks off it just in case. If it’s testosterone that saves humanity - so be it - what’s so wrong with testosterone anyways?
- datatrashfire 5y agoSo living on Mars would suck, and Alpha Centauri is too far away to be a real option. What's the point? So we can mine some asteroids? That seems so limited compared to the vision of people like Elon Musk and gang promoting the idea the survival of humanity depends on leaving Earth.
- erulabs 5y agoIt wouldn’t matter if there were no resources in space (which obviously is not true). Nothing has to be brought back ever. It does not have to be profitable. What it has to do is allow life (maybe not even human life) to survive if either humans or anything else ends life on earth. It’s more than the survival of humanity - we’re the only life that has ever evolved to the point of being able to leave. It’s about the survival of life itself.
- Shadonototra 5y agospace colonization? we are still acting and living like apes, and you think we ready to go explore space? we'll begin space exploration the day capitalism will die, it'll be about scientific research, well being, preservation and ascending humankind, something the market doesn't give two shit about
- cuteboy19 5y agoI wouldn't be so confident. Some of the most exciting developments in space xploration are coming from private firms. Anyways why do you want a inefficient state bureaucracy to do something the market can do for half the cost?
- Shadonototra 5y agolies, with public tax payer money greatest medical research/advances came from public institutions same for mathematics, same for chemistry, same for energy space exploration stopped because of military and the market didn't want it
- Ekaros 5y agoGetting there might be one thing. I think there is entirely enough made up wealth in economy and to get to that point. Staying there after harsh reality of living in communal shoeboxes for years and decades, plus shipping things in at horrible expense however...
- NoOneNew 5y agoI'd love to see a filmmaker also sign off on the engineering plans to a bridge since everyone is so enthralled by, essentially, an art major's opinion on a scientific, geopolitical, and sociological endeavour.
- malermeister 5y agoWhat is filmmaking, especially in Herzog's style, if not applied sociology?
- NoOneNew 5y agoApplied? Applied means real world. A script and movie set is not the real world. There is zero push back and change from unexpected real world vectors to test ideas on paper and on stage.
- malermeister 5y agoA movie is a real world construct, an application of sociological principles.
- 1123581321 5y agoThis documentary (and the interview) is more about how our human nature prevents us from taking the problem seriously, and threatens any major efforts due to either our behavior in space/on colonies or due to relations between space and earth breaking down. A bridge engineering analogy might be a documentary about how we are incapable of funding infrastructure or how we struggle to design and build new kinds of bridges where they can’t currently exist.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- QuadmasterXLII 5y agoWhen a dandelion releases seeds to the wind, this does not save the mother weed.
- sterlind 5y agobut it does keep dandelions from extinction.
- viburnum 5y agoHumans colonizing space is essentially a religious belief and people freak out if you challenge it. Just keeping people in low earth orbit requires a tremendous amount of resources. Every person who goes up depends on the efforts of thousands of people on the ground. It will never be self-sustaining. It’s not like walking across the land bridge from Asia or setting out on your canoe in the South Pacific. But people freak out when confronted with the obvious facts.
- 8bitsrule 5y ago>Humans colonizing space is essentially a religious belief 'The market' is essentially a religious belief as well. What it has called 'the Conquest of Space' is unlikely until the lack of wisdom in exploiting one's fellow man and home planet causes that religion to do itself in.
- gumby 5y agoWhy the obsession with "drinking recycled urine?" That's already part of the drinking water we consume every day. Recycled horse sweat too. Regardless, I have long believed that space is the natural domain of our children the robots. They don't need to drag the earth biosphere around with them but can adapt to whatever the local environment may be, as long as it isn't the "surface" of the sun. Leave space travel to them and make this planet a paradise instead.