11 ms·
It should be kept in mind that almost any material used in contact with food will leach something, especially when it is used during cooking, i.e. at high tempe
by adrian_b 5y ago
It should be kept in mind that almost any material used in contact with food will leach something, especially when it is used during cooking, i.e. at high temperatures, and, in the case of metals, when the food contains fruit juices or vegetable juices, which are acidic.
So what matters is the hierarchy of the materials from this point of view, i.e. which are better and which are worse.
The best material for food-contact is glass, but glass, while perfect for storage, is not suitable for most types of cooking (even if it is quite possible for someone to eat only food cooked in a microwave oven, in glass cookware).
The next best material is titanium (commercially pure titanium, not the frequently encountered Ti-Al-V alloy). Titanium cookware exists, but it is normally too expensive, unless it is used in some activities where its low weight can justify the high price.
After these 2 cookware materials, which unfortunately are not an acceptable choice for most people, comes the stainless steel.
Yes, stainless steel will leach a little nickel and chromium. However this leaching will be large only for new cookware and it diminishes a lot for used cookware. Even in the case of people with nickel sensitivity, most of which are women, the quantities of nickel leached from used stainless steel cookware are far too low to have any effect.
All the other materials that are used for cookware, including ceramics, can be sources of much more dangerous leaching than stainless steel (excluding glass & titanium).
Ceramics and plastics are the worst (this includes any non-sticking coatings), because, unlike for metals and glasses, their chemical composition is usually kept secret by their manufactures, so you never know what they may leach.
- hawski 5y agoWouldn't iron be the best at least for pans? Also what about enamel?
- adrian_b 5y agoAny kind of iron cookware leaches in food a quantity of iron that is many orders of magnitude greater than all metals leached by stainless steel. Fortunately, excessive quantities of iron in food are not dangerous for most people, even when the quantity is great enough to give an unpleasant taste to the cooked food. In any case, iron cookware is preferable to ceramic/plastic/non-sticking cookware of unknown chemical composition.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- Etherlord87 5y agoI like the way you think. If you have a pan made of food, does it matter if some food leaches to your food? For a person with iron deficiencies it's hard to argue additional iron is bad, however... Once your iron gets into contact with oxygen, you will no longer consume iron, you will consume rust...
- amelius 5y agoSolution: don't use "unsafe" Rust.
- Synaesthesia 5y agoI think a lot of the iron in the body is already in ionic form, so it's not a huge concern.
- Spivakov 5y agoI am not an expert but it seems that the form of iron absorbed by human body is ferrous sulfate, iron in +2 oxidation state. Iron rust of iron pan is in +3 state, which is chemically a different thing.
- adrian_b 5y agoActually what you need in your body is rust, i.e. iron ions. Metallic iron cannot be used in any way by living beings, before it is oxidized to rust. The leaked iron from cookware is already in the form of "rust", more precisely the iron is leached after it is oxidized to iron ions. The ions with 2 elementary charges remain dissolved in the water, and they may be absorbed by the body, while the iron ions with 3 elementary charges (these are the components of rust in the strict sense, i.e. of red iron oxide) will normally precipitate into red rust crystals, which will pass through the digestive tract mostly without being absorbed (a few might be reduced to ions with 2 charges, and then be absorbed).
- adrian_b 5y agoAbout enamel, that is a complex mixture of various oxides. All colored enamels have undesirable components. White enamel can be made perfectly safe for food contact. Unfortunately, being white is not a guarantee for that. Manufacturers are tempted to include in the enamel composition various oxides that improve the manufacturing properties, e.g. which increase the fluidity of the melted enamel, or which enhance the adherence of the enamel to the base metal, and so on. These additives may leach unwanted substances. So one may use cookware with white enamel, if they trust that the manufacturer was not too greedy to reduce their costs. Ideally there should be a law to force all manufacturers of cookware to publish the precise chemical composition of any material used for food contact, like there are laws for labels with the approximate food composition. Until then, it is safer to distrust any kind of coatings, plastics, enamels or glazes with secret compositions, because in the past there were many bad surprises whenever any of these were analyzed.
- bagels 5y agoIs iron cookware really just iron, or is it alloyed slightly?
- Bud 5y agoA little bit of carbon (2-4%) and silicon. Otherwise it's just iron. It should also be noted that with a properly seasoned cast iron pan, the food isn't interacting as much directly with the iron, since the seasoning layer (polymerized fats) is in the way.
- cjg 5y agoIron pans are not the best for those with hemochromatosis (iron overload).
- cycomanic 5y agoThe issue with iron cookware (and I'm a big fan) is cooking acidic dishes in them (which are the ones that mainly cause the leeching) you destroy the seasoning and they become a bit of a pain to clean after that.
- eternityforest 5y agoI'm not entirely convinced that plastics are categorically bad. I suspect they are better than stainless for long term storage of certain things. There's a lot of plastics that don't commonly get used but are food rated in industrial applications, it would be cool to see them thoroughly evaluated and if they are safe, made into consumer items. Ceramics are scary because a few have lead in them, but there are safe ones(Just not that you can afford), they're used for surgical implants. I wonder what the possibilities are with magnesium. It can be extracted from the ocean and is nontoxic enough to just put back where you found it, so it seems to be the closest we have to a renewable metal. There's also laser etched lotus effect patterns. Do metals still leach after you make them hydrophobic like that? Could you make magnesium corrosion resistant enough?
- kmmlng 5y ago> I suspect they are better than stainless for long term storage of certain things. I'm confused, how is that relevant to the topic at hand?
- adrian_b 5y agoThe base components of many plastics, e.g. polypropylene, polyethylene, acrylic glass, are perfectly safe for food contact. The problem is that all plastics contain various additives, which are normally not disclosed by the manufacturer, even in the plastic grades that are approved for food contact. The risks caused by unknown plastic additives are especially large when the plastics are used above room temperature, e.g. for heating food in a microwave oven. Storing food in polypropylene vessels or polyethylene bags in a refrigerator is likely to be perfectly safe.
- grecy 5y ago> The base components of many plastics, e.g. polypropylene, polyethylene, acrylic glass, are perfectly safe for food contact. We fully believed BPA was "perfectly safe for food contact" for many, many years. Now of course we know that's not true. It's always worth remembering to add as far as we know today. There are hundreds of such examples. What we know today isn't necessarily a hard fact, it's just as good as we know with today's knowledge.
- dataflow 5y agoWhere does Teflon fit in this hierarchy? And by "ceramic" I assume you mean the faux-"ceramic-coated" ones that don't actually contain ceramic, right?
- adrian_b 5y agoPure ceramic is porous, so it is never used in direct contact with food, because the food will be absorbed in the pores. In all cookware where the body is ceramic, the surface is covered with some glaze, enamel or plastic coating, which is the material that really counts for food contact.
- ftrobro 5y agoUnglazed clay pots have been used for thousands of years, I have one myself. You soak it in water for 15 minutes before putting the food in. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7EbdBty-40I https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7EbdBty-40I
- adrian_b 5y agoYou are right that unglazed pottery had been used for many thousands of years, before glazing was invented. The information about soaking is interesting. I was not aware of it, because there are many countries were unglazed pottery is no longer used, at least I have never seen any of it used for food contact, but only for different purposes.
- morganslaw 5y agoSo is ceramic cookware safe? This stuff here: https://www.goodhousekeeping.com/cooking-tools/a26078798/best-ceramic-cookware/ https://www.goodhousekeeping.com/cooking-tools/a26078798/bes... Basically you are saying we have no clue what is actually in contact with our food?
- mschuster91 5y agoThe problem with modern Teflon is mostly that people overheat their non-stick pans. The stuff is chemically inert otherwise. Older Teflon pans and cookware have the problem of PFOA contamination, but that's IIRC been banned for years now.
- api 5y agoWhat about cast iron? It’s very nice to cook with and popular with chefs.
- mrspuratic 5y agoWhen correctly used it only leaches about the last 100 meals into your next meal :)
- Maursault 5y ago> glass, while perfect for storage, is not suitable for most types of cooking Such as? Could be I'm simply unaware of "most types of cooking."
- curiousllama 5y agoWouldn’t a glass frying pan shatter?
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- jdironman 5y agoIt would indeed. I know this, because I left a glass casserole dish on a hot stove eye when I was young. A while later it exploded and the kitchen floor was marred with little burns from glass "meteorites " from the explosion. Thankful no one was in the kitchen to say the least.
- unfocussed_mike 5y agoPyrex made a range of "flameware" frying pans that you can still sometimes find on eBay, using an "aluminosilicate" glass. Sold them for forty years. There are a few details about Flameware here. https://gizmodo.com/the-pyrex-glass-controversy-that-just-wont-die-1833040962 https://gizmodo.com/the-pyrex-glass-controversy-that-just-wo... You can find them on eBay still. I definitely wouldn't use one; they seem utterly impractical. They must be heavy, they are small, and the clip-on, rather than bolt-on handles are going to be rusted and dodgy at this point. You can see why they chose that strategy (to avoid a heat stress point around a bolt) but it can't be without its risks.
- Werewolf255 5y agoI've got a 'flameware' saucepan and it works great. Very light and visually interesting, but I put it away for special because I'm always worried I'll break it. The strap and clip handle is fine on my pan but it does seem like it needs to be tightened up every so often,so I could see it being a common point of failure.
- AlgorithmicTime 5y ago
- morganslaw 5y ago> Ceramics and plastics are the worst (this includes any non-sticking coatings), because, unlike for metals and glasses, their chemical composition is usually kept secret by their manufactures, so you never know what they may leach. Again, when you refer to ceramics, are you referring to the tons of ceramic coated cookware that is now immensely popular as a replacement for Teflon? Is this stuff just as bad? https://www.goodhousekeeping.com/cooking-tools/a26078798/best-ceramic-cookware/ https://www.goodhousekeeping.com/cooking-tools/a26078798/bes...
- adrian_b 5y agoIt is not clear from the advertisements of the vendors what kind of material is used for the so-called "ceramic" coatings. I believe that they use the word "ceramic" to say that the coating is not made from an organic polymer, like Teflon, but from an inorganic oxide or mixture of inorganic oxides. The correct meaning of ceramic is a material that before processing is soft and plastic, so you can give it any form you want. Then, after heating at very high temperature in an oven, a.k.a. burning, the finished ceramic product becomes hard. I am pretty certain that this is not how the so-called ceramic coatings are made. The cookware that I have seen with "ceramic" coatings had bodies made of aluminum. So I assume that the "ceramic" coatings are mostly of aluminum oxide, probably grown electrolytically or chemically. True ceramic products consisting mainly of aluminum oxide are very common, so I assume that this is why the "ceramic" coating vendors use the word "ceramic". Alumina, a.k.a. aluminum oxide, is inert enough in most conditions to be safe for food contact, even if not as safe in contact with acidic juices as glass. As always, the base material is less concerning than the possible existence of undisclosed additives. It is possible that the so-called "ceramic" coatings are perfectly safe, but nevertheless I would not buy one unless the vendor would state clearly the composition of their "ceramic". I have seen too many contrary examples in the past, so that I cannot trust anyone who says "Trust us, it is good for you", without providing additional relevant information.
- clsec 5y agoI believe the process that you're describing is called powder coating [1]. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Powder_coating https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Powder_coating
- samatman 5y agoThe distinction you're trying to draw between glass and ceramics doesn't exist, ceramics are generally glazed, which means "covered in a coating of glass". Enameled pans aren't going to leach anything if you buy them from any reputable manufacturer (which is at least all of the European, American, and Japanese ones) because any colorants added to the glaze will be rated as food safe. In fact, you mentioned titanium: that's what's used to make the inside of white enameled pots look white. Enameled cast iron (or enameled anything) is a fine choice, it comes with its own limitations culinarily (and advantages) but it isn't going leach anything into your food.
- adrian_b 5y agoYou are right that glaze is a kind of glass. Nevertheless, most glazes have a much more complex composition than the standard borosilicate or soda-lime glasses. Glazes usually contain colorants and various additives that improve certain properties useful during manufacturing, which do not exist in the glasses used for vessels. It is possible to make glazes that are perfectly safe for food contact, but historically there were many examples of glazes with harmful components. Unless a manufacturer provides the composition of the glaze used by them, you cannot know how safe it is. Moreover, glazes and enamels have a problem that does not exist for stainless steel vessels. The glazes or enamels may crack and expose the base material to the food. However that is somewhat mitigated by their lower price, which facilitates the replacement of the cookware.
- samatman 5y ago> Unless a manufacturer provides the composition of the glaze used by them, you cannot know how safe it is. Or you could just buy from any EU country: https://www.european-enamel-association.eu/certification.html https://www.european-enamel-association.eu/certification.htm...
- AlexandrB 5y agoAll this says about leeching is: > 4.8 Specification and determination of the release of toxic elements > The specification and determination of the release of toxic elements must comply with the requirements specified in the national laws of the country. Most of the other requirements are about the mechanical properties of the enamel. There's also this: > 4.32 Determination and control of Lead and Cadmium release for hot water tanks But that doesn't apply to cookware. There's nothing here about requirements for the composition of the enamel or the making public thereof. And what constitutes a "toxic element" (and presumably the dosage) is left to the laws of each country. Most of these countries would consider stainless steel to meet their leeching requirements as well. So we're back to square one. There's no way to tell what the enamel is leeching. You just have an assurance that it's considered safe.
- b112 5y agoWhat bothers me is, people washing and scrubbing their frying pans. I cook in stainless, and after done just put it in the sink with water. After I eat the food, maybe a half hour later, just dump the water and wipe it with a rag. Point is, why remove the grease, why remove the seasoned crust on pan. Do people take soap and scrub brush to their bbq too? You don't need to soap wash, or scrub a frying pan. This sort of behaviour likely keeps leeching to a minimum, compared to vigorously scrubbing and cleaning each use.
- dtagames 5y agoDid we skip cast iron? Iron leeching into your food is actually a good thing. There are several brands of excellent cast iron cooking products which should be safe. Staub is one I like.
- christophilus 5y agoI love my lodge pans. If you properly clean and oil them, they are as easy to use as non-stick alternatives. For a long while, I didn't believe this, but then I used my parent's pan one weekend, and it was a revelation. Turned out I'd never properly seasoned / kept my pans seasoned.
- humanlion87 5y agoCan you point to good a guide on how to use cast iron effeciently. I have been trying to use cast iron more regularly but end up getting frustrated. I feel like I am not taking the right steps to keep it seasoned. Whenever I cook food gets charred. For context, I do most of my cooking in non-stick cookware.
- dtagames 5y agoThere are million anecdotal methods on how to care for cast iron, but this TL;DR works for me: Use some kind of oil when you're cooking. Hand wash them and never put them in the dishwasher. And coat with a thin spray of olive oil (the "oil only" sprays are great) after use and buff with a paper towel. Never leave anything on the iron surface except a light coating of oil. Don't let them air dry. That works for me! :-)
- boilerupnc 5y agoAfter a lake vacation in western NC, I stumbled across my first Griswold Cast Iron pan. The bug hit me and I've collected a couple of others since then. My favorite so far is the Colonial Skillet Griswold 666 (aka Satan's Helper). Makes an amazing mix of eggs, potatoes and bacon. I started looking up the best way to season these pans and found [0] and [1] very insightful. [0] https://sherylcanter.com/wordpress/2010/01/a-science-based-technique-for-seasoning-cast-iron/ https://sherylcanter.com/wordpress/2010/01/a-science-based-t... [1] https://sherylcanter.com/wordpress/2010/02/black-rust-and-cast-iron-seasoning/ https://sherylcanter.com/wordpress/2010/02/black-rust-and-ca...
- ramijames 5y agoCurious where copper falls in this list.
- giaour 5y agoCopper is more reactive than steel. Copper cookware (with some rare exceptions) is lined with another metal to prevent food from direct contact with copper during cooking. Traditionally, a thin layer of tin is used for this purpose, though modern copper cookware can sometimes use steel or anodized aluminum.
- formvoltron 5y agoAlso cast iron and carbon steel both leach iron into food. Iron is now known to cause stress to cells and can even initiate a special form of cell death.
- giantg2 5y agoIron is also known to be essential for human health and intentionally added to many foods. I can't tell, but maybe your comment was calling that out sarcastically.
- clsec 5y agoNot OP but many people (1 in 300 Caucasians [1]) need to closely watch and minimize their iron intake because they have hereditary hemochromatosis. With hemochromatosis ones body cannot process iron. There is no cure and the only way to deal with it is to minimize iron intake and, if iron levels are too high, blood letting (phlebotomy). [1] https://www.cdc.gov/genomics/disease/hemochromatosis.htm https://www.cdc.gov/genomics/disease/hemochromatosis.htm edit: forgot URL
- kube-system 5y agoMany more people (1 in 7) have iron-deficiency anemia.
- a9h74j 5y agoSo many multivitamins, etc, omit iron out of fear of iron poisoning, that one can easily err on an individually-deficient side. (The optimal window also appears narrow enough -- even people with temporary anemia must limit supplements -- that I would not attempt to rely on cookware to supply my iron requirements.)
- kube-system 5y agoI'm definitely not suggesting that iron pans should be a dietary supplement. I'm just doubtful that they're responsible for much iron poisoning.
- giantg2 5y agoAnd nonstick coatings can also off-gas and be damaged or deteriorate over time. My big thing about this study is that they claim to use realistic cooking parameters. Some dishes may be cooked 6-20 hours, but how common is that? Wouldn't most dishes be under 1 hour and contain less acid? Seems like they're targeting worst case scenarios, which are plausibly realistic but not typical.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- eatbitseveryday 5y agoWhat of cast iron?
- TAKEMYMONEY 5y agoIt leaches iron. Not "heme iron" (like that found in meat), it isn't absorbed as easily. This is affected by a number of factors including the acidity of the food, how new the pan is, and how the pan is seasoned https://ift.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/abs/10.1111/j.1365-2621.2002.tb09582.x https://ift.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/abs/10.1111/j.1365-2... https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/10073514/ https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/10073514/
- aeternum 5y agoIron from the pan is not absorbed as easily as the iron in foods but it is still generally good for you rather than bad for you (like chromium). If kids are low in iron, doctors still recommend cooking using iron pots & pans (in addition to supplements).
- TAKEMYMONEY 5y agoI found this related study interesting: > Ethiopian children fed food from iron pots had lower rates of anaemia and better growth than children whose food was cooked in aluminium pots [1] And to your point about Chromium, the type of iron leached by cast iron may not contribute to cardiovascular disease (the same way as heme iron) [2] https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/10073514/ https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/10073514/ https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/25439662/ https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/25439662/
- aeternum 5y agoI cannot access the full-text of the second article, but is it really thought that heme iron is the component of red meat that contributes/causes cardiovascular disease? Did the authors somehow adjust for the fact that a high heme iron intake generally implies a diet high in red meat?
- killingtime74 5y agoYou can also use glass only if you use an oven
- nayuki 5y agoEven then, you have to worry about glass shattering due to thermal shock. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UyhdMa1ikKM https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UyhdMa1ikKM
- KolenCh 5y agoThe list is missing one common type of cookware—cast iron.