6 ms·
What was the point of all of New Zealand's draconian lockdowns then? They had all the negative lockdown effects for no reason, and still ended up with just as m
by josephcsible 5y ago
What was the point of all of New Zealand's draconian lockdowns then? They had all the negative lockdown effects for no reason, and still ended up with just as much of a COVID problem as the rest of the world that didn't have them.
- csdvrx 5y agoIt provided valuable data points for a denser mapping of the possibility space! At the beginning various strategies were proposed. A few looked utterly bizarre: IIRC the UK plan was to "keep the schools open so the kid can catch it". In retrospect, some start standing out as better - but data is still coming so it's too early to say for sure.
- Imnimo 5y agoThe alternative interpretation is that New Zealand's lockdowns avoided all the previous waves (which killed hundreds of thousands of people in the US, for example), but did not avoid the Omicron wave. So far, NZ has only reported 65 covid deaths. That number will surely rise with the current wave, but I think it's a wild exaggeration to say that they have had "just as much of a covid problem as the rest of the world".
- sjg007 5y agoRight but vaccination should mitigate omicron... I guess really this is the test of that.
- robbedpeter 5y agoVaccination didn't and doesn't reduce transmission. It protects you from serious illness and death if/when you get it. The whole transmission protection meme needs to die. It has a trivial effect at the population level wrt the spread of covid.
- ceejayoz 5y ago> Vaccination didn't and doesn't reduce transmission. This is false. It does not stop transmission. It does reduce it. https://www.cnbc.com/2022/01/31/the-new-omicron-subvariant-is-more-contagious-but-vaccinated-people-are-less-likely-to-spread-it-study-finds.html https://www.cnbc.com/2022/01/31/the-new-omicron-subvariant-i...
- EdwardDiego 5y agoIt does reduce transmission, I was reading a research paper out of the UK, and while vaccinated people who got infected hit the same peak viral load as someone unvaccinated, they were at the peak viral load for a far shorter period of time. I can try to locate the link if you're interested.
- throwaway6532 5y agoIt doesn't make transmission impossible. It makes it less probable, which most definitely does reduce transmission. To say "Vaccination doesn't reduce transmission" is to say "Vaccination has no effect on the R value". It clearly does.
- ceejayoz 5y ago> What was the point of all of New Zealand's draconian lockdowns then? Keeping deaths down. 84% of the country now has at least one dose, and half have three. Australia took the same approach - strict measures until widespread vaccination. Per https://www.statista.com/statistics/1104709/coronavirus-deaths-worldwide-per-million-inhabitants/ https://www.statista.com/statistics/1104709/coronavirus-deat..., they're at 13 deaths per million citizens. The US is at 2,916. A single nursing home in New Jersey lost more staff and residents to COVID in a few weeks than the entire country of New Zealand did in two years. https://www.nytimes.com/2020/04/15/nyregion/coronavirus-nj-andover-nursing-home-deaths.html https://www.nytimes.com/2020/04/15/nyregion/coronavirus-nj-a...
- josephcsible 5y ago> A single nursing home in New Jersey lost more staff and residents to COVID That's because Phil Murphy issued a monumentally stupid edict preventing nursing homes from barring entry by people known to be COVID-positive.
- ceejayoz 5y agoThe US is nearly at a million deaths overall. New Zealand has 65. Even normalized for population, our per capita death rate is over 200 times theirs. Many stupid decisions are involved in that, but it's hard to argue NZ didn't do a good job here.
- JPKab 5y agoHave you ever been to New Zealand, or Australia for that matter? I have. It's hard for most people to understand how utterly isolated they are unless they've traveled there. Countries like the US with land borders aren't able to isolate. The US has tens of thousands of people enter every day in unregulated fashion, across the southern border alone. New Zealand successfully locked their country down, and delayed COVID infection until a vastly milder variant that was more contagious showed up. It's hard to think a non-island nation could successfully achieve the same strategy. Every single person who enters the nation is forced to go through an airport, or far more rarely, a seaport. That confers an ability to strictly regulate entry for citizens and visitors alike.
- Arnt 5y agoNZ didn't have draconian lockdowns in the plural, their draconian policy was in the singular and applied to travellers from abroad. Children attended school and team sports as usual, for example. Also, having a covid wave with 94% of adults fully vaccinated isn't "just as much of a covid problem" as the waves in unvaccinated populations elsewhere last year.
- h12nz 5y agoNZ had two very strong lockdowns (starting March 2020 and August 2021), with an intervening period of zero covid. Whether one would consider them “Draconian”, I’m not sure, but it certainly wasn’t life as normal
- throwaway6532 5y agoLevel 4 lockdown was draconian I would say. Level 3 was like level 4 but you could get fast food, so a little less draconian. Level 2 was pretty much normal but those who could work from home had to work from home. But we all just did what we needed to do. I think we got a great result from that in the end, and the government adjusted the Covid response to the public opinion as we eventually tired of lockdowns and had access to and good uptake of vaccines. I would give our Covid response 8/10. Only thing that could have been better is we got the vaccine a few months early then it would have been more like 9/10 as we wouldn't have been rushing to vaccinate just as Delta was hitting and rushing to boost while Omicron is hitting.
- Arnt 5y agoDraconian, "excessively harsh and severe." Where I live, the pediatric psychiatry clinics are still badly overloaded due to children who coped and then, when school and social activities were harshly constrained, didn't cope. I had the impression that NZ's lockdowns, such as they were, avoided that kind of severity.
- throwaway6532 5y agoThey have definitely avoided the vast majority of deleterious effects from an overloaded health system, but it's definitely very harsh and severe to be instructed that you're now not allowed to leave your house for a month particularly when by world standards for freedom you are used to ranking right at the top. I think it meets the colloquial usage of draconian. Though I would say that word has a negative connotation indicating ones discontent at the state of things imposed on you by an authority. In my experience the vast majority of people initially supported the lockdowns and compliance was very high as we figured we just should do what we need to do and not fuss too much about it. I myself never labelled it draconian as I was in support of it, but those who were not in support of it at the time used that term.
- infamouscow 5y agoHumans so rarely get intelligent leaders that when a good one appears, we call them "the great"
- throwawaymanbot 5y ago
- thehappypm 5y ago“Just as much of a COVID problem” is a joke, right? They never had a major outbreak with an unvaccinated population. They never had a major outbreak of Delta or Alpha or any more-deadly strain. Their first experience with Covid is an outbreak of Omicron, the mildest variant yet, with a highly vaccinated population. Plus now there are viable treatments. That was the point.
- EdwardDiego 5y agoWhat was the point? Making sure people didn't die until we had viable vaccines, basically. So yep, we're hitting widespread Omicron now, but a) it appears to have far less severe health impacts compared to strains like Delta and b) 95.2% of Kiwis have had two doses of Pfizer, 72.5% the booster. https://www.health.govt.nz/covid-19-novel-coronavirus/covid-19-data-and-statistics/covid-19-vaccine-data#dhbtables https://www.health.govt.nz/covid-19-novel-coronavirus/covid-...
- throwaway6532 5y agoActually pretty happy about how our government managed it. We had 2 years of relatively calm times where there was no Covid and long periods where life was pretty normal. By the time Delta came most people managed to get fully vaccinated in time so the outbreak was tiny, then once Omicron hit and cases have started to peak we've got most the population vaccinated and a significant portion boosted, so the illness is quite mild for most people and still life here feels pretty normal. We just had a case in our household where only our son, who had gotten one dose of Pfizer already, got it and was a super mild case and neither my wife or I caught it from him. Compared to what I've seen on the news over the last 2 years from countries overseas we've had a really easy time.
- raxxorrax 5y agoThe current strain is much less lethal than its predecessor, so being infected now is the much better option. It is an illusion that many countries could have used these approaches as countries like New Zealand or Australia though.