9 ms·
US scientist falsely accused of hiding ties to China speaks out
- trasz 5y agoAs long as US keeps trying to antagonize China, things like this will keep happening.
- refurb 5y agoBy antagonize you mean “asking China not to secretly steal our intellectual property”?
- freeflight 5y agoGood thing then Germany ain't antagonizing the US [0] or this whole topic would look very hypocritical [1]. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ECHELON#Examples_of_industrial_espionage https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ECHELON#Examples_of_industrial... [1] https://apnews.com/article/b40414d22f2248428ce11ff36b88dc53 https://apnews.com/article/b40414d22f2248428ce11ff36b88dc53
- refurb 5y ago[flagged]
- freeflight 5y agoAnd Germans call it "Heuchler", US IP law ain't "world IP law" no matter how much Americans insist it shall be. But it's fascinating how consistently Americans can preach "Do as we say, not as we do!" without the slightest bit of self-awareness, any such shall be considered "propaganda".
- anamax 5y ago"whataboutism" is what we used to call "equal treatment before the law".
- refurb 5y agoEqual treatment of US behavior in the 1800’s to China behavior in the 2000’s under different treaties?
- coliveira 5y agoIs't that pure reality? America was fighting against the Nazi regime when at home they had the most severe apartheid regime in an industrialized nation.
- watwut 5y agoThey have been using the argument exclusively against opposition, whether domestic or not. So, you have Havel or other dissident complaining about what is going on in Czech Republic and Russia ... and they get response about America instead. The Soviet regime cared about those exclusively when using them as talking point. To shut up own critics and that is it.
- coliveira 5y agoThis might be the case, but it doesn't make the argument, per se, incorrect. In fact it is a correct argument, that's why it persisted.
- watwut 5y agoIt does make it incorrect. Argument is not "Americans lynch blacks and Americans should stop". Argument was "Americans lynched blacks in the past, therefore it is ok for us to jail internal opponents and ok to kick their loved ones from schools and work". American lynching's are no more relevant then Tibet or ancient Sparta when Havel is talking about events in Eastern Europe.
- coliveira 5y agoOh, so in the same way that the American government mentioned communist crimes to justify going around the world and killing millions of people?
- Pigalowda 5y agoThat profile lists it as a “50 cent Army member”. The profile is not really a good faith interactor.
- dtn 5y agoIsn't that just tongue-in-cheek? Considering how easily accusations of astroturfing and shilling are thrown around when it comes to this topic.
- Pigalowda 5y agoSure it certainly could be. Whether the account is shilling or shit posting doesn’t really matter though. Either one isn’t a good faith interaction.
- Fricken 5y ago
- dang 5y agoYou can't attack another user like this, regardless of whether they missed a joke or not. We've had to warn you about being aggressive with other users many times in the past. This is a pattern: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27401192 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27401192 (June 2021) https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19534285 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19534285 (March 2019) https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17734563 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17734563 (Aug 2018) https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16059003 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16059003 (Jan 2018) If you keep this up we're eventually going to have to ban you. I don't want to ban you, so please don't keep this up!
- ClumsyPilot 5y agoThis smells of hypocracy. Our companies sets up production in China to take advantage of loose labour laws and abuse workers, but cry foul when they get hit by loose IP laws. Also the US stole textile technology from the British Empire to launch it's own industrial revolution. Also your regular reminder that intellectuall properly is legal fiction that some cultures do not recognise, or see differently.
- refurb 5y agoExtending this logic, if the US said some state should stop trafficking in slaves you’d say “this smells of hypocracy! the US had slaves 160 years ago, so shouldn’t be expecting other states to not buy and sell slaves”. See how stupid that argument sounds?
- spacemanmatt 5y ago> See how stupid... You compared "intellectual property" to slavery. Try again.
- FpUser 5y ago>"See how stupid that argument sounds" Your argument sounds even more stupid. You are comparing something commonly recognized as a crime to some artificial concept forced down the throat of a country that was being exploited and was frankly in their right to use whatever means to get out of that subservient state. The west is patented everything by now. Expecting the rest of the world to serve that system and be poor forever is disgusting.
- est 5y agobrain drain was a thing before the term "steal IP" was invented.
- HarryHirsch 5y agoThere's anarchy between states - the US is spying on Chinese industries, just as China is spying on US industries, it's how the world is. That said, this man isn't a spy - the fact that the government couldn't rig a jury in Tennessee makes very clear that he is innocent.
- refurb 5y agoDid you reply to the wrong comment?
- HarryHirsch 5y agoNo. You wished China would stop spying on the US. That's just not in the cards.
- jokoon 5y agoThere was WW1 and WW2, there was cold war 1, and there will be cold war 2. I would also guess that Chinese authorities could easily "trigger" the DOJ to punish a Chinese national. Once paranoia sets in, it benefits China too.
- cik2e 5y agoI think Cold War 2 has already begun. I just don't see how the pre-invasion state of affairs could be restored in any realistic scenario. To hit the undo button Putin would have to stop the invasion, profusely apologize, pay reparations and make other concessions like returning Crimea. And of course he will do nothing of the sort. There's no scenario that I see under which which Putin is still running Russia and it stops being an international pariah.
- jacquesm 5y agoCold War 2 began in the 90's. It just isn't as public as Cold War 1.
- birdyrooster 5y agoNot sure why you are being voted down. I think it's clear that Russia's invasion of Chechnya triggered NATO to join a bunch of ex-warsaw pact countries. That was a further escalation which then caused Putin to feel excused to invade Georgia and Ukraine.
- bilbo0s 5y agoJust my own prediction, but I suspect even after Putin is gone, the position of the Russian state vis-a-vis its buffer zones will remain unchanged. I've seen this before on smaller scales in Iraq, and Afghanistan. We take out the leaders, but the perceived grievances remain unchanged. In fact I was a bit surprised because I thought that, at a minimum, the grievance would change to "you killed our leader". It didn't happen that way at all. I bet the same thing happens in Russia. I honestly hope that our policymakers have more of a plan B in place than they have had with other conflicts. Just in case this turns out to be a concern that drives a leader and not a leader that drives a concern. Because though I'm sure we all would've lost friends or family in either case, at least there would have been a chance in hell of victory against the latter.
- Santosh83 5y ago
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- freeflight 5y agoWeird to see BRICS countries recognized as such, only to fail to recognize how those have much more shared interests than opposing interests [0]. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/New_Development_Bank https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/New_Development_Bank
- unfocussed_mike 5y agoI don't see India becoming an enemy of the free world any time soon, and the second half of the 21st century is soon in a geopolitical sense (and looming in a my-lifetime sense). An inward-focussed economic superpower, yeah. (The inward focus is the part of Modi's pitch for India that makes a kind of sense). An enemy of the free world? It's the world's largest democracy with more than one seventh of the population of the free world. It might have taken Trump only four years to get really close to implementing the collapse of the rule of law in the USA, but the BJP has its work cut out achieving that in India; people will tire of the nonsense. Edited as to Russia: are you sure it'll be a single, functioning state by the end of this year, let alone for the second quarter of the 21st century? It is heading towards (within weeks of) a kind of economic status that could only be survived by a country that has never experienced modernity, like North Korea.
- selimthegrim 5y agoKashmiris and the hanged Muslim cartoon the BJP account was tweeting the other day would like a word with you.
- unfocussed_mike 5y ago"... would like a word with you" is hardly high quality discourse, but OK: Kashmir is really an example of what I mean about the likelihood that the BJP will have trouble achieving things on the kind of timescale that Trump was working to. It's an awful, very-long-term conflict in disputed territory, is it not? Things move forward and backwards. It does not surprise me that I was instantly downvoted for alluding to Trump when defending against the idea that India is going to become an enemy of the free world. I guess it's because some readers think I am "politicising" it. But you surely shouldn't automatically get to other a democratic nation of 1.4 billion people without reference to the elephant in the room -- that the USA was very recently (perhaps even still is) only one presidential term away from becoming an enemy of the "international rules-based order". You only have to look at how Trump proposed to deal with Tiktok, or how he mysteriously abruptly exempted ZTE from some sanctions, to understand what I mean -- let alone the even bigger elephant in the room, that he successfully downgraded GOP 2016 platform language about the defence of Ukraine and literally coerced Ukraine's leadership with the threatened withholding of congressionally-approved support. The reality is that this discussion about potential threats to the free world or rules-based international order simply can't be one-sided like this. It's an absurdity.
- spupe 5y agoVery sad case, glad he is somehow getting his life back together. Should get reparation from the government for this fuck up too.
- antattack 5y agoFrom what I read - he did not disclose his ties to Chinese researcher when applying for grant from NASA as he supposed to. He did it on bad advice from his university, but that came out later, during the investigation. It seems his employer, the University, owes him something. In US government owes you nothing when they make an honest mistake. Even worse, government has disincentive to exonerate wrongly accused because, as some argue, need for finality of the judgement[0] [1]https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kpYYdCzTpps https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kpYYdCzTpps
- ahelwer 5y agoAn honest mistake like blanket-targeting Chinese researchers in a wildly racist investigative policy.
- peteradio 5y agoChesterton's fence may apply.
- teh_klev 5y ago> he did not disclose his ties to Chinese researcher when applying for grant from NASA This was discussed previously, and the form made no requirements for any disclosure. This is a sub-thread from the last time this this was discussed: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30113895 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30113895 See perihelions' comment: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30116046 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30116046
- helen___keller 5y agoI think you’re confusing cases - the linked thread is for MIT professor Gang Chen, while this thread is for Anming Hu of UT Knoxville
- roflc0ptic 5y agoAdministrators and researchers at a local cancer research hospital were fired for this, too. Could someone explain what the perceived harm is? I really don't understand - isn't cancer research published in accessible journals? Isn't disseminating this knowledge something we want both institutionally and personally for the researchers?
- Retric 5y agoLike lying during an FBI investigation, even a non issue becomes an issue. Lying on a grant application can get you into serious issues. You can always be upfront and say your not going to answer a question, or you can disclose connection which is normally fine for most kinds of research. Should these questions be asked is a bigger issue than just what to do when people lie.
- thawaya3113 5y agoIn this case Hu was specifically told by UT Knoxville to not include affiliations that he had disclosed to the university. From the article at least it looks like the University was most responsible, yet they did not support him nor apologize to him.
- Retric 5y agoYea, Hu was put in a very poor situation by disclosing a connection and then being told to hide it. He probably should have disclosed it anyway on the application, but I am glad he got free.
- PuppyTailWags 5y agoHu was acquitted and cleared of all charges.
- Retric 5y agoYes. Having said that he was on the knife edge with the first trial resulting in a hung jury and he suffered greatly before and during the trial. It’s very much a situation you don’t want to be in.
- antattack 5y agoAs a side note, when does a scientist become US Scientist? It seems to me that he was Canadian scientist working in USA.
- xibalba 5y ago
- helen___keller 5y agoI found the wiki page on the China Initiative[0] enlightening: > Of the indictments, the largest group, representing 38% of the cases, charged academic researchers and professors with fraud such as failure to disclose relationships with Chinese educational institutions. None of them have been found to have spied for China. Nearly half of these cases have been dropped. [0] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/China_Initiative https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/China_Initiative
- TeeMassive 5y agoWhy did they lie then?
- fastaguy88 5y agoNot sure who "they" are, but in this case and the MIT cases, the researchers were accused of lying, but in fact did not lie.
- joshuaissac 5y agoThey may have hoped that by casting the net wide, they may catch at least some spies.
- ashwagary 5y agoThe idea of criminal justice is really devolving into witchhunts at this point. I'm surprised there isn't more pushback since there is an (unintended? intended?) chilling effect in what is otherwise branded as a free & open society.
- sct202 5y agoTFA has one example where the university he worked at told him he shouldn't disclose. Another, Gang Chen was initially charged of failing to disclose, but it was later found that he was not required to disclose on the grant in question.
- 5y ago
- j16sdiz 5y ago>>>>>>>>> A university employee requested that Hu remove the letter from the application because it would violate an assurance document the university was submitting stating that the proposal had no restricted ties to China, the court documents say. A 2011 US law prohibits NASA from funding collaborations with China or Chinese businesses. <<<<<<<<< So this is fraud ? What's the problem?
- throwaway0a5e 5y agoThe problem as I see it is that people who screech about how "just following orders isn't a defense" when people they don't sympathize with violate this or that regulatory compliance statute without harming anyone are acting as though it's a valid defense when it's someone they sympathize with. This behavior is made doubly odious because a large subset of these same people are often in favor of strict enforcement of somewhat arbitrary rules (like a disclosure requirement on an application) against people they don't sympathize with. This inability to have principals and be consistent with them is going to bite our country a lot harder than the occasional foreign scientist lying on a grant application or the occasional foreign scientist getting wrongfully prosecuted. To be clear, I sympathize with Mr Hu. I think the organization should be getting punished here. He brought the issue to their attention and they advised him to do exactly the wrong thing and the feds screwed him for it. People, especially foreign nationals who cannot be expected to be well versed in US law, need to have a reasonable expectation that they can follow orders from HR/Legal/their boss in matters of mundane statutory compliance without getting personally screwed when the actions they took in confidence violated the law. UT is responsible for what happened to Mr. Hu and in a perfect world that would be a slam dunk tort. But his plight is just a drop in the bucket of a much larger societal problem.
- NovemberWhiskey 5y agoQuite apart from anything else, there should absolutely be someone asking Hard Questions about the role of the university administration here. If lying on a grant application is a fraud, then asking someone to lie on a grant application is procuring a fraud etc. That said, I have to say that if anyone asks me to lie or omit relevant information on a document that I'm sending to the government, my first response to that is going to be "let me check with my lawyer on that".
- jcranberry 5y agoThat's odd. The university advised him to not submit his association with chinese laboratory and university, because it wasn't allowed for the position he was interviewing for? Wouldn't that be fraud?
- sigzero 5y agoThings that make you go "Hmmmmmm".
- hbarka 5y agoHarkens back to Wen Ho Lee [1]. Getting wenholee’d is now an adjective if you’re perpetually seen as that dagum fornur. [1] https://www.nytimes.com/2001/02/04/us/the-making-of-a-suspect-the-case-of-wen-ho-lee.html https://www.nytimes.com/2001/02/04/us/the-making-of-a-suspec...
- cko 5y agoThis stuff scares me a bit. I'm of Chinese descent (Taiwanese actually). It's conceivable that if China and US enter some Cold(er) War 2 that my US assets could be frozen or worse, because ethnicity. Similar things have happened in history and I don't doubt for a second that it can't happen again or that we've progressed. Especially with rising wealth disparities leading to all sorts of political tension.