4 ms·
Eventually the question becomes "if these guest fighters are successful, at what point do they consider going north through the contested border and attacking R
by dekhn 5y ago
Eventually the question becomes "if these guest fighters are successful, at what point do they consider going north through the contested border and attacking Russian (or, more likely, Belurussian) cities?"
- t0mas88 5y agoBelarus may be at a higher risk here, the local army is weak and the political opposition was quite strong last election.
- lb1lf 5y ago-At that point, of course, they'd meet resistance from Russian forces which suddenly _have_ a good reason to fight, likely also being supported by a population which will not be thrilled at a bunch of mercenaries having a go at their homeland. Kicking a poorly motivated invasion force out of the Ukraine is one thing. Wreaking havoc in Russia? Quite another. Now, Belarus, on the other hand, I could see toppling over in such a way (unless propped up by Russia)
- q1w2 5y agoProbably not at all. I doubt there will be any will to invade Russia. Crimea and Donbas would be hard enough.
- blaser-waffle 5y agoAye. Attackers need 3-to-1 to overpower defenders, unless you've got some serious force-multipliers -- or so goes the thinking. UA forces are doing a good job holding out and fighting defensively, but a genuine attack will require serious concentrations of troops and equipment. Outside of local counterattacks, or maybe special forces raids (blow up rail lines, etc), large scale assaults probably aren't feasible. You only need a few NLAWs and a yoga mat to sleep on if you're fighting in Kherzon, but you'll need a lot of fighting vehicles and gas if you want to launch an offensive. See also: Russian logistical problems.
- pmoriarty 5y agoUkraine attacking Russia would be akin to Finland attacking the USSR during the Winter War. It's like a mouse attacking a cat. The mouse might get lucky and survive an attack by a cat, but it has no chance of killing the cat. Ukraine is also likely to lose all Western support if it attacked Russia. If they survive at all (which is still very doubtful), they'll likely lick their wounds and try to rebuild their shattered country rather than go on the offensive in Russia proper.
- dekhn 5y agoExcept the cat is a paper tiger in this case. And my point was about mercenaries, not the Ukrainian military.
- euroderf 5y agoFinland did not "attack" Russia proper as such, but there were long-range ski patrols trying to cut the Murmansk railway. Also, Mannerheim kept Finnish troops out of the assault on Leningrad; the troops' remit was only to reclaim land taken in 1940. This was a wise move.
- kspacewalk2 5y agoAs a Ukrainian whose relatives are being bombed and whose friends are currently enlisted - I sure hope they won't consider that at all. The only actions performed outside the internationally recognized borders of Ukraine should be in aid of stopping the invasion of Ukraine. Bombing troops and launch sites - yes. Attacking Russian servicemen wherever they can be reached - yes. Occupying even an inch of Russia - hell no. Ukraine should even refrain from retaking Crimea militarily if things go well, unless it's virtually bloodless. This war has to end ASAP, and it won't end ASAP if Russians suddenly have a non-absurd reason to defend their land.
- axiosgunnar 5y ago> and it won't end ASAP if Russians suddenly have a non-absurd reason to defend their land. This is an important point. This is why we should keep reiterating to the Russian people that the sanctions are not to spite them and will be revoked immediately if Putin is gone.
- euroderf 5y ago... and hostilities cease.
- Isinlor 5y agoThey can not and must not be revoked. This will allow Russia to build up its army again. Give them 5 maybe 10 years and they will start a new war. We must keep Russia isolated for as long as they are a fascist state. If Russia gives up Putin to be trailed in the international court for war crimes then we can lift the sanctions, not earlier.
- mlindner 5y agoThey won't be revoked if the attitude doesn't change. If Putin is just replaced by another person like him (there are several) then that doesn't help things.
- aaronchall 5y agoI suspect Russia is going to have big problems with revenge-seekers.
- sitkack 5y agoI really really hope not. As sad as this is, revenge will only escalate things. We want to be able to have our kids talk to their grandkids about the mistake that happened and that it ended as quickly as it started.
- petre 5y agoThere's no point in attacking Russian cities or civillian targets. These are fighters specialized in sabotage behind enemy lines and highly mobile guerilla warfare. They make enemy military infrastructure go boom. Just what Ukraine needs right now: turning Russian combat vehicles into wrecks or stuck/abandoned vehicles, sabotaging supply lines.
- ChrisBland 5y agoWhen you surround an army, leave an outlet free. Do not press a desperate foe too hard
- cycomanic 5y agoI was actually reading some analysis from a military strategist who was quite critical of the foreign fighters. Essentially his arguments were that they are much more driven by idiology (and different ones) and thus less easy to follow orders and be controlled, which could lead to unwanted escalation. Not sure what to make of it, but people are definitely thinking about this.
- slim 5y agowhen you say driven by ideology, you mean they are neo-nazis ?
- CRConrad 5y ago> when you say driven by ideology, you mean they are neo-nazis ? Could be all over the ideological spectrum. Surely quite a few Neo-Nazis, yes, but: If you're a fervent anti-Nazi who sees Putin as rather equivalent to a fascist (I pretty much do; a kind of Duginian pan-Slavo-fascism), you could AFAICS go fight against the Russians on those grounds too.
- lazyant 5y agoI propose Ukraine take up 5 Km over the border for a DMZ zone, like in Korea.