6 ms·
That has to happen. The government cannot deficit spend for free. The cost is inflation, and guess who pays - you and me.
by WalterBright 5y ago
That has to happen. The government cannot deficit spend for free. The cost is inflation, and guess who pays - you and me.
- jupp0r 5y agoYou make it sound like a law of nature when it really isn't. Look at Italy for a prominent counter example.
- WalterBright 5y agoIt is a law of nature. There ain't no such thing as a free lunch. That stimulus check you got? Now you have the hangover. Didn't Italy get the Germans to take the fall for their deficits a few years ago?
- bruce511 5y agoDeficit spending benefits from inflation. The value of loans decrease as a currency value decreases. So a govt can get $1 of value with each $ spent now, and pay less paying off the loan later. Put another way, if inflation is 10% then you get 10% more tax dollars in, to offset the loans. Of course _never_ actually paying them back is even cheaper :)
- anonuser123456 5y agoSure, for past loans this is true. But for governments that run perpetual deficits, they have to go out to the market to service ongoing obligations. As some point the market catches on and interest rates snap upward, leading to increased real costs of financing debt.
- gizmo686 5y agoInterest rates are a policy decision by the federal reserve. Maintain a debt instead of printing money is a policy decision by Congress. In practice the government going into debt denominated in its own currency, and printing more of its own currency are essentially the same thing. Mechanically, when the interest rates go higher the Fed policy, the fed just buys the debt itself, driving up the market price (therby down interest rate). In effect, this converts US debt into cash. Similarly, they can sell treasury debt, driving up the interest rate. It is just a quirk of bookkeeping that the we keep track of how much money the treasury owes the federal reserve.
- labster 5y agoWait. That’s a double negative, so there is free lunch after all?
- chitowneats 5y agoHow clever! You really showed him.
- labster 5y agoThank you. I am so smart.
- nemothekid 5y ago>That stimulus check you got? The stimulus check represented 804 billion dollars in direct to citizen spending of the government's 6 trillion dollars in spending. If your argument is "giving money directly to individuals causes inflation" we can start there, but government spending alone does not cause inflation; the Emergency Economic Stabilization Act did not meaningfully grow inflation. We probably would not know fully in 5-10 years, but my own hypothesis is that America had it's own dark labor pool of incredibly cheap labor and when (1) Citizens were allowed to have some breathing room and look for better oppurtunities and (2) the CBP used Covid to massively ramp up deportations, labor became more expensive which clearly affected the rest of the economy.
- WalterBright 5y ago> but government spending alone does not cause inflation I didn't say that, either. I was clearly talking about deficit spending.
- nemothekid 5y agoThis isn't a meaningful distinction. The United States has been deficit spending since 9/11, and the last large deficit spending was the 2008 crisis, which did not lead to any meaningful inflation.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- WalterBright 5y agoI seem to recall many of those giant loans were paid back. That isn't inflationary.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- nemothekid 5y agoThis seems like its going to be a continual moving of goal posts until there is no data to back any position. Before the loans were paid back, inflation went negative. To be clear, I'm not arguing that the government can and should spend their way out of any crisis; the point I'm trying to get across, which you keep evading is that there is no data to back your claim that government spending led directly to inflation, especially when there are so many other obvious factors. In fact, before 2020, there is no modern economy where you could clearly point to and say "the government overspent, and caused massive inflation". Japan desperately tried to spend it's way to inflation and failed. For something that is a "law of nature", there seems to be so few data points to back it up. As far as I can tell, it's a neoliberal talking point used to dissuade any form of direct to citizen welfare.
- bryanrasmussen 5y agogiven that payment means giving something of value you would rather not part with it is clear that at the micro-level there may well be free lunches, which I find amusing because obviously the idea of the free lunch comes from the micro-level. If Italy really got the Germans to take the fall for their deficits a few years ago and suffered no negative effects from it then there would be a free lunch at the macro level as well, although I find that unlikely.
- WalterBright 5y ago> suffered no negative effects from it Nobody said they didn't suffer negative effects from it.
- bryanrasmussen 5y agoI know, I was wondering, if they did suffer negative effects for it then it was the obvious no free lunch. Reconsidering things on the macro level I think while there may be no free lunches there are obviously lunches that coincidentally may be so cheap that they are next to free. For example: aid received from France by Americans during Revolutionary War, treaties signed said supposed to be paid off by Americans siding with France in case of war between France and England, but since French Government changed since time of treaty signing when war came America said oops sorry, we're staying out. That was a really cheap lunch.
- barrenko 5y agoDon't bother, it's easier to talk about religion.
- throwawaymanbot 5y ago
- caslon 5y agoWe've been paying with the deficit for how many decades now? The economy has pretty consistently getting better and poverty has been going down since the 70s despite increasing our deficit spend rising every single year and inflation steadily going up. Having an outlier period in inflation over the past three years because of a deadly pandemic is hardly a condemnation of the idea of deficit spending.
- chrisco255 5y agoWhat, in your opinion, are the limits of deficit spending? If there are none, then why not spend 500% of GDP and end poverty once and for all? Or is this time really different, as we approach 125% of GDP?
- WalterBright 5y agoHaving a pandemic doesn't suspend the laws of economics. I didn't condemn deficit spending. I simply pointed out that the extra money doesn't come for free - you and I are inevitably going to pay the bill.
- caslon 5y agoIf poverty is going down, how are we paying the bill? Our people are getting wealthier.
- howinteresting 5y agoThere's no such thing as "the laws of economics". There are goods and services and constraints, and there are economic models.
- WalterBright 5y agoCommunists, for example, are always trying to rewrite the laws of economics. They've failed at that 100% of the time. Wishful economic thinking never works. It's almost as if it's fundamentally a law!
- 5y ago
- dwohnitmok 5y agoIt's not a law of nature. There are many hypothetical scenarios where deficit spending does not lead to inflation (usually variations of the theme that deficit spending's wealth creation outpaces the spending amount and the deficit spending can eventually be scaled back while wealth creation continues). Whether those hypothetical scenarios are realistic and likely to happen is an entirely separate topic, but it's not an ironclad law of nature in the same way that gravity is. It is a much more contingent and circumstantial observation.
- WalterBright 5y agoYour theory is that a free lunch hypothetically exists. It does not, and the belief it does leds to the endemic inflation we have since 1914.
- dwohnitmok 5y agoFree lunch is an extremely vague term. What is your exact hypothesis?
- WalterBright 5y agoIt means you pay for it one way or another.
- slg 5y agoBut the argument wasn't that increasing the money supply doesn't have any negative repercussions. The argument was that increasing the money supply doesn't always result in inflation. Inflation is the "one way" and sometimes we pay with the "another".
- WalterBright 5y ago> The argument was that increasing the money supply doesn't always result in inflation I didn't say it did. Don't omit any of the words I wrote.
- kube-system 5y agoI think deficit spending was a very tiny part of this. I think the bigger factors are: 1. Demand experienced a little blip while supply was and still is decimated. Most of the middle class kept their jobs and kept spending, despite the fact that factories shut down for significant periods of time and crushed the supply chain so badly that it will not catch up for years. 2. Consumer spending categories changed abruptly, again, exacerbating demand issues. 3. Many service workers got a chance to involuntarily experience job hopping in a high labor demand economy. Labor is most expensive on the margin. 4. A lot of people dropped out of the job market for good. Boomers are retiring. And a nontrivial number of people died too.
- dominotw 5y ago> Most of the middle class kept their jobs and kept spending because businesses and people were given regular financial jolts via deficit spending.
- kube-system 5y agoThat was just enough to provide a month or two of head start so that the real demand driver could kick in: People working flexibly who now had no commute spending, no vacation spending, and kept their high wage office jobs. The amount of money the typical office worker has saved on just those two expenses is more than the stimulus checks.
- dominotw 5y ago>That was just enough to provide a month or two where did all the trillions of dollars go . it somehow ended up in these people's pockets one way or another.
- kube-system 5y agoWages over the same time period are about 4 times the amount of total COVID relief spending of all types combined. The dollar value of the COVID relief may be less of an impact than the fact that it prevented a larger labor market collapse and kept people earning wages. The stimulus was just a spark that kept the larger American consumerism machine chugging strong.
- neilwilson 5y agoThat's like saying people cannot save for free - because a government deficit is nothing more than the accounting counterparty of the excess savings of the non-government sector. Since when did savings cause price changes? What we have is less stuff being produced because of an increase in bureaucracy and shirking. If we got rid of the bureaucracy and sacked the shirkers, then prices would come back under control. Or alternatively we can tax those in favour of bureaucracy and shirking, so that the transfer is 'fully funded'.
- 8note 5y agoThis does not match observations. The government has been in deficit spending for a long time without much inflation. There's something different about recent government spending(that it gives money to poor people), and the inflationary response by property owners is class warfare. Greedy responses by the rich arent things that have to happen, they're things allowed to happen by a broken market. Proper competition would limit this
- TearsInTheRain 5y ago> The government has been in deficit spending for a long time without much inflation There was still inflation due to the deficit spending. Just because inflation was low doesnt mean it wouldnt have been lower without the deficit spending
- 8note 5y agoI'm not saying there isn't a component, but you could not predict the current inflation rate based on continued deficit spending
- bko 5y agoA lot of people predicted it. It's not a novel concept that if you increase the money supply by 25% in one year, you risk seeing a rise in prices. We saw this first on asset prices. During the most uncertain and scariest time of the pandemic where we had no idea if the world was going to end, the stock market rose significantly above pre-covid levels. Later on many, including myself, thought there was a good chance it'll spread to consumer prices. I wrote a whole series about this starting on April 2, 2021 The fed should have predicted this as its pretty textbook economics. But they won't be held to account and working class people will pay the price through higher prices and lower wages. Then the remedy will be higher interest rates and a risk of higher unemployment and economic stagnation, [0] https://mleverything.substack.com/p/where-did-the-12-trillion-of-covid-c39?s=w https://mleverything.substack.com/p/where-did-the-12-trillio...
- 5y ago