13 ms·
China Is Not Russia. Taiwan Is Not Ukraine
- cosmiccatnap 5y ago
- hulitu 5y agoThere is an institute of peace in US ? It hasn't been active in the last 80 years. As G. Orwell said: war is peace.
- schleck8 5y agoPer Orwell you wouldn't even know the phrase is ironic, so apparently it does not apply.
- wizzwizz4 5y agoIt's a good, if horrifying, book; you should read it. But no, the point of doublethink isn't that people don't know that they're doing it; it's that they betray themselves and support the Party.
- schleck8 5y agoYes, exactly. If you tell yourself something often enough it's hardly distinguishable from a fact.
- readthenotes1 5y ago80? It has been about that long since the last official declaration of war by the United States, however... https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/thumb/5/58/US_presidents_timeline_and_wars_they_started.pdf/page1-1135px-US_presidents_timeline_and_wars_they_started.pdf.jpg https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/thumb/5/58/US...
- hef19898 5y agoFormal declarations of war are so early and mid 20th century...
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- xiphias2 5y agoThe finishing sentence tells everything: ,,Beijing’s calculus vis-à-vis the use of force against Taipei can change, so the world must continually monitor the situation and remain alert to warnings and indicators. Part of this monitoring must include scrutinizing Chinese assessments of Russia’s performance in Ukraine in the coming weeks, months and years.''
- stickfigure 5y agoThe invasion of Taiwan would require a massive amphibious assault across a sea full of hostile submarines. You couldn't hide all the ships required from satellites. And China's economy depends heavily on trade with the west-aligned world.
- manachar 5y agoRussia didn't hide their military buildup, they just lied and gaslit the world via their various disinformation channels into believing that Putin would have to be insane to actually invade.
- Eupolemos 5y agoAs it has indeed turned out to be. It is very worrying to me that China tones down the invasion in their media (if that is indeed true, I don't follow Chinese media myself). Better to let people know what war really is. Unless you want it.
- Lio 5y agoWhat's more worrying still is if they start toning it down in the West's media. This weekend China has refused to show Premiership Football because of protests at matches against the Russian invasion[1]. Right now the English FA and clubs are just ignoring that but it's a big market. How long will they ignore that revenue stream? Already the way Disney, Netflix, Apple, NBA and Hollywood cozy up to the CCP is pretty worrying. 1. https://www.msn.com/en-gb/sport/football/china-blocks-broadcast-of-aston-villa-and-wolves-matches/ar-AAUBWGS https://www.msn.com/en-gb/sport/football/china-blocks-broadc...
- daniel-cussen 5y agoYeah he puts these videos on Youtube designed to make him look bad on first blush, but then you think it over and what he responds to crappy questions makes perfect sense, so because it occurs to you the viewer "spontaneously" it makes these thoughts more convincing. But that's a double-bluff you see, in some cases quadruple-bluffs, I think I even saw one sextuple-bluff, even-numbered bluffs.
- Mountain_Skies 5y agoChina would very much prefer that Taiwan ask to reunite with the mainland. Forcing them back one day might be in the cards but setting the conditions to where Taiwan sees being part of China as being the better option than relying on the United States for its safety is what China would like to happen. Finding ways to drive wedges between the US and Taiwan is a part of this strategy.
- bllguo 5y agoUS has no interest in being beholden to TSMC in the long-term. once that dependency is removed the only reason from a realist perspective to support Taiwan is to provoke Chinese violence, which hopefully never happens.
- Eupolemos 5y agoNot so, AFAIK. It is equally as much about free trade in the South China Sea.
- T-A 5y agoFixating on TSMC is for myopic tech geeks. Yes, it's important, but not nearly as important in the grand scheme of things as: - A thriving Chinese democracy showing the mainland that no, they are not intrinsically incompatible with freedom. - The credibility of the US as an ally to other Asian countries. - Taiwan's strategic location.
- bllguo 5y agoI'd counter with your opinion being exceedingly naive.. "thriving" is quite generous considering their economy and reliance on foreign powers. And culturally they're making the same mistake as Hong Kong in alienating mainlanders. don't think we have reconcilable opinions on US motivations but hey I'll gladly be wrong as long as there's no war
- T-A 5y ago> "thriving" is quite generous considering their economy https://www.statista.com/statistics/727592/gross-domestic-product-gdp-per-capita-in-taiwan/ https://www.statista.com/statistics/727592/gross-domestic-pr... https://www.statista.com/statistics/263775/gross-domestic-product-gdp-per-capita-in-china/ https://www.statista.com/statistics/263775/gross-domestic-pr... > and reliance on foreign powers ?
- rdtwo 5y agoMaybe Taiwan should try to join NATO. See if that speeds up the invasion
- bbotond 5y agoHow could Taiwan - a country the US doesn’t recognize - join NATO?
- IanDrake 5y agoHow could Taiwan - a country not in the North Atlantic - join NATO?
- umvi 5y agoPresumably by agreeing to the terms of the treaty and by being accepted by existing members. It's the North Atlantic Treaty organization, not the North Atlantic Organization
- rufus_foreman 5y agoGood point. When I think of Turkey, the first thing that comes to my mind is "North Atlantic", same as you apparently.
- vkou 5y agoThe Mediterranean is technically part of the North Atlantic. If Greece can be in NATO, why not Turkey? But no, most of Europe isn't interested in spilling blood over Taiwan, just like it isn't interested in spilling blood over Ukraine.
- jacquesm 5y agoIt probably isn't so much the spilling of blood that it isn't interested in rather than the chances of wholesale evaporation but otherwise your point stands.
- 5y ago
- 627467 5y agoBut it is so much more entertaining to think they are the same. Just like it is entertaining that the west allowed the current war to happen.
- antattack 5y agoInteresting, I have not heard of USIP before: "USIP was established by Congress in 1984 as an independent institution devoted to the nonviolent prevention and mitigation of deadly conflict abroad." In 2011 they almost lost their funding. Although, with budget of 39mln and 300 staff they are pretty lean operation it seems. Their staff seem to be mostly active in the Middle East, Africa and East Asia. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_Institute_of_Peace https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_Institute_of_Pea...
- bufferoverflow 5y agoBut this war in Ukraine showed one simple truth: if you arm the population, the invasion can only destroy the infrastructure. You can't win over people's minds by killing their loved ones, their neighboors. And you can't keep it under control if every citizen has a gun. You install a puppet government, they will be dead within a week. This is the only way to protect Taiwan. Give them guns and ammo. And teach them that killing invaders is the only way to keep their freedom and not fall under the totalitarian communist regime of China.
- toxik 5y agoThey have guns, the two parties warred before. In fact, there was never a formal peace agreement so the war is technically still going on. The asymmetry is in the economics. Taiwan can realistically be strangled by China. This has seemed like the plan from Beijing. Once politically weak, you can take over with sock puppets.
- anonporridge 5y agoSo, more trade with Tawain from the west, and give them more guns.
- stickfigure 5y agoTaiwan cannot be strangled as long as the rest of the world is willing to trade with them. A naval blockade of Taiwan would not be tolerated by the west, and the first US-flagged ship that gets sunk would start real war.
- temp8964 5y agoMuch of these analyses are useless unless you put domestic politics into calculation. If Xi wants to invade Taiwan, 90% is based on his power fight within the party, not the geopolitics. One crucial part of Xi's ruling is that Xi has not appointed his successor yet. Xi wants to stay. Does invading Taiwan help or hurt him to stay longer? That's his calculation.
- ctvo 5y ago> If Xi wants to invade Taiwan, 90% is based on his power fight within the party, not the geopolitics. Citation? Which part of the communist party does NOT want Taiwan back if it could get it without massive geopolitical consequences?
- temp8964 5y agoMany high officials have strong financial interest against this. In Xi's eyes they are corrupted. But there are too many of them and Xi need some of their support. That's why anti-corruption campaign is crucial to achieve party's (Xi's) political goals.
- posnet 5y agoChina's anti-corruption campaigns have nothing to do with corruption and are just populist pretext for removing political enemies.
- pstrateman 5y agoI think you're agreeing with the parent.
- xwz7611 5y agoNot true. Now those that were taken down are too low in their position, so can not be Xi' political enemy. Why do they want to be Xi's enemy?
- ctvo 5y ago
- narag 5y agoThis sounds pretty much like good cop, bad cop. Also the bottom line: is it wise to have deals with someone that's not accountable to their own people? What about Xi being replaced by someone with a different personality? While it's about a country's interests, there's another kind of stability.
- KaiserPro 5y agoI suspect china is looking at this and thinking a number of things: 1) It needs to control banking infra (it has a messaging system similar to swift already) 2) Putin is acting even more boldly than normal (I suspect it was assuming that he would try and fully annex donbas & Luhansk and a bit more, then wait another few years to try again) 3) The Russian bear that is it's land army really isn't that great. The modernisation hasn't stretched to tactics or maintenance. 4) Russia shares a decent land border with china, might need to think again about the security there. Sure Xi and Putin are "best buddies" but real politik > than friendship for dictators.
- FpUser 5y ago"best buddies" but real politik > than friendship for dictators. Not just for dictators
- tablespoon 5y agoChina's not Russia, and Taiwan is not Ukraine, but there are still some important messages being sent: 1. The West's main tool still seems to be economic sanctions. Even unprecedented sanctions didn't prevent or halt Russia's invasion of Ukraine, and good luck sanctioning China. 2. The West is too scared to get involved militarily in ways that could actually prevent an invasion from succeeding, even when its adversary is fumbling and vulnerable. So that's something China probably doesn't have to worry about now, if it wants to go to war over Taiwan.
- atlantas 5y agoThis is where the rubber meets the road. Let's register some predictions: If China invades Taiwan, will Apple and Disney exit China as they did with Russia?
- fatjokes 5y agoIf apple exited China, it'll be America that will no longer have iphones.
- davidjytang 5y agoI think Tim Cook will pick up the pace to diversify the plants so that he would have the option.
- DFHippie 5y agoRussia benefits from disruption and chaos: it causes fuel prices to spike. China benefits from stability: it ensures people can and want to buy all the stuff they manufacture. Russia asserts the right of strong nations to meddle in any nation that can't resist them. China asserts the right of every nation to territorial integrity and freedom from internal meddling by, e.g., democracy and human rights activists. (To be fair, Putin also hates these people, but clearly thinks Russia itself should be free to meddle in other nations' internal affairs.) They are drawn together by their opposition to the West and in particular the US, and by their contiguity, but they aren't otherwise natural allies.
- hackerfromthefu 5y agoSuch as the Tibetan nation?
- credit_guy 5y agoOne thing is sure: if China still wants to invade Taiwan, they certainly have postponed their plans by a few years, maybe a decade, maybe even more. The attempted invasion of Ukraine by Russia just reminded people that the best war plans don't survive the first contact with the enemy (apparently stated by the Prussian general Moltke), or in the more folksy words of Mike Tyson, everyone has a plan until they get punched in the face. In 2014, Russia achieved a military miracle: they took over Crimea so quickly and without loss of blood, that they delivered a "fait accompli". Oh, how much would China like to replicate that in Taiwan. And that's what they were preparing for. But now, in 2022, the latest example of an attempted invasion shows that things can still go astray. Why? No doubt China will analyze everything and try to see if they are in danger of experiencing the same problems. But the overall learned lesson will still be that no matter how much you plan, you can still encounter huge obstacles when you start a war. And the world response in terms of economic sanctions was unbelievable. Definitely, not something China wants. If anything the prospect of WW3 because of a Chinese miscalculation vis-a-vis Taiwan went down considerably.
- kerneloftruth 5y agoOne thing is sure: if China still wants to invade Taiwan, they certainly have postponed their plans by a few years, maybe a decade, maybe even more. How can you be so certain? This reminds me of people saying just 14 days ago "I don't think Putin is going to invade." Taiwan is not Ukraine, indeed -- Taiwan would be easier to capture because it is an island. There aren't land borders across which supplies and weapons can be brought. They would have to come by ship or plane, which are easier to defeat. It would be easier, militarily, to take Taiwan. China certainly has the will, and it has learned that the worst it would face would be some sanctions.
- kingcharles 5y ago> some sanctions Some sanctions? The entire Russian economy has disappeared overnight. The only reason it has not been felt yet is due to inertia. There are still just about enough goods in the pipes to support things for weeks or months. But once computers start breaking, planes start breaking, shelves start to empty, and nothing is arriving to replace them, shit is going to hit the fan.
- chrchang523 5y agoOne significant omission from this comparison: the Ukraine:Russia population ratio (~0.285) is almost TWENTY TIMES as large as the Taiwan:PRC ratio (~0.0163). The Ukraine:Russia ratio is almost as large as the ratio between the Confederacy's non-slave population and the Union's population at the time the US Civil War broke out; and I suspect that some overly optimistic Russian military planners did not properly account for this. So, although it is harder for the PRC to invade Taiwan than it is for Russia to invade Ukraine for a number of reasons, I expect it to be more difficult for Russia to keep most of Ukraine pacified even if they do achieve their primary military objectives.
- tharne 5y agoMeh, I'm getting very tired of these types of articles. Why is it so hard to simply admit that it's really hard if not impossible to predict complex things like this? The types of people that write these articles also believed at one time: - China becoming capitalist would cause it to become a liberal democracy - Globalization would be amazing for everyone everywhere - The Afghan army would be able to stand up to the Taliban - Russia would not invade the Ukraine, but on the off chance they did, they'd roll right over the country in no time at all. The fact is when it comes to this kind of stuff, we just don't know and we probably never will. That's just the nature of complexity. You miss one minor detail or some tiny assumption or some "unknown unknown" is off and the whole intellectual scaffolding comes down.
- steve76 5y ago
- mrlonglong 5y agoBut the only thing they have in common is that their leaders are arseholes.
- mk81 5y ago
- cudgy 5y ago> One popular contemporary analogy is between Russia’s actions vis-à-vis Ukraine and China’s approach to Taiwan. Is this really a popular analogy?
- hereme888 5y agoI don't need an analysis to know that China already has planned its invasion, but waiting for the right time. Russia, China (CCP), Iran, Belarus, Venezuela, Cuba...the modern axis of evil. What do they have in common? Communism: the most deadly and hypocritical ideology in human history. For those unfamiliar with Belarus: the leader Lukashenko is a communist that wishes the revival of the Soviet Union. For those unfamiliar with communism, it's basically a few power hungry leaders that tell the people they'll build a fair and equitable utopia, but end up with absolute power, and killing or torturing all opposition.