5 ms·
If I understood the parent comment, there are two kinds of leverage being discussed here: there's the leverage that individual tech workers currently have (as h
by woodruffw 5y ago
If I understood the parent comment, there are two kinds of leverage being discussed here: there's the leverage that individual tech workers currently have (as high demand, high income laborers in a hot market) and then there's the leverage inherent to collective bargaining.
I believe the GP was saying that unions can deliver when circumstances give individuals large amounts of leverage, but they don't need to. But we all know that good times don't last forever, and unionization does provide sufficient leverage when individual leverage evaporates.
- Kalium 5y agoI understood the point. My counterpoint is that if a union doesn't use the leverage of collective bargaining to deliver when it's in a good position to do so, it rather weakens the argument that the same union will decide to use its leverage when individual leverage evaporates. Organizations run on precedent, policy, and consistency. Arguing for the potential for inconsistency seems to me to be a rather weak reed. Especially since the WSJ's been a union shop for 80-ish years. More likely, IMO, is that the union as a whole did not care much about the developers and was more concerned with other parts of the membership. There's one union covering the whole shop, so this seems pretty likely.
- ethbr0 5y agoAs parent said, in good times (demand >> supply), the difference between individual optimal and union optimal is relatively small. Or negative! In bad times (demand << supply), the difference between individual optimal and union optimal is very large. Ergo, you're not going to see a lot of union benefits in good times.
- Dracophoenix 5y agoPeople don't pay a monthly subscription for a lawyer their not likely to use even though a lawsuit or criminal charge is one bad day away. You're view of supply and demand matches that of a paranoid actor rather than a rational one. If ever the market were to contract, there are alternative solutions like savings, downsizing, or looking for another job. It's not as though one company has a monopoly on all the job opportunities in the world or working in that one company is the only way to feed oneself. A union is not a panacea. For many people, unions are just as much of a hassle as a bad job and without the benefit of self-representation. And when all breaks loose, the last thing most reasonable is trade their agency
- gpderetta 5y agopeople do pay insurance (Sometimes even legal insurance) in the hope they do not have to use it. People do not pay monthly subscriptions for a lawyer because they are extremely expensive. Those that can, do have lawyers on retainers though.
- toomanybeersies 5y ago> People don't pay a monthly subscription for a lawyer That's a pretty poor analogy. Some people do keep lawyers on retainer. Also, if you don't have legal representation at the point in time you're sued/charged, you're not required to represent yourself, and can still hire a lawyer. Unions are probably closer to insurance. You can't buy insurance after you crash your car and expect them to pay out, neither can you join a union after you've been given the sack and expect representation.
- throwaway0a5e 5y ago>Unions are probably closer to insurance. I think this analogy is more apt than you realize. Internet commenters absolutely love to shove insurance down the throats of people who can afford to self-insure against or simply are not exposed to the particular outcome in question.
- chii 5y agoInsurance against what? If you (a tech knowledge worker) is unionized, does it mean that the company must not remove the tech that you use, so that you get job security? Would unions have a say in such decisions? I don't see unions as being useful, unless there's some pre-existing guarantees that the union can provide (like insurance - you pay a premium and get a known quantity of payout).
- ceejayoz 5y ago> People don't pay a monthly subscription for a lawyer their not likely to use even though a lawsuit or criminal charge is one bad day away. Sure they do. TurboTax offers for an extra fee on filing legal insurance that covers a legal defense if the IRS challenges you. One of my past employers offered a legal program as an optional perk we could opt in to, as well. https://www.abajournal.com/web/article/law-firm-subscriptions https://www.abajournal.com/web/article/law-firm-subscription...
- scarface74 5y agoAnd what’s stopping tech companies from doing the same thing manufacturing companies do when they don’t want to deal with unions - hire cheaper labor overseas? My hometown use to be booming with multiple manufacturing plants. Every time the union got involved, the plants just picked up and left.
- bigbillheck 5y agoOverseas labor is also cheaper than non-union US labor.
- ceejayoz 5y ago> Every time the union got involved, the plants just picked up and left. Unions have been around - especially in manufacturing - long before they started offshoring production. The cost of labor in China and elsewhere was simply too low, unionized or not.
- scarface74 5y agoThe unions kept pushing for increased pay. But regardless, what good would unions be to prevent outsourcing?
- ceejayoz 5y ago> The unions kept pushing for increased pay. Sure, that's their job. Individuals do the same thing; unions just mean everyone negotiates as a group instead of one at a time, with a more balanced power dynamic. > But regardless, what good would unions be to prevent outsourcing? Unions aren't magical. That doesn't mean there's zero value in such a scenario. They can negotiate rules and limits on layoffs, they can negotiate severance and healthcare coverage during such an outsourcing, etc.
- scarface74 5y agoHow are they going to “negotiate”? If they say “no” what are the union members going to do strike? The company is trying to get rid of them anyway.