6 ms·
Borders of this war are drastically in Russia's favor. They control the entire north (Belarus), east (Russia) and south (Crimea and Black Sea). Ukraine could po
by paxys 5y ago
Borders of this war are drastically in Russia's favor. They control the entire north (Belarus), east (Russia) and south (Crimea and Black Sea). Ukraine could potentially use their western borders with friendly countries to their advantage, but those are long ways away from the key population centers of the country. After a strike in, say, Kyiv, they will have to drive 7+ hours to hide in Poland.
- Retric 5y agoFriendly borders do a lot even if their not close. Just having a safe place to decompress between fighting makes a huge difference. Militaries need to be on constant alert where resistance forces can train and plain in safety. It also takes a lot of manpower to defend a border and those people can’t then be directly useful in the fighting. Russia could setup barricades, minefields etc, but that stuff take time, effort and resources to setup.
- tablespoon 5y ago> Borders of this war are drastically in Russia's favor. They control the entire north (Belarus), east (Russia) and south (Crimea and Black Sea). Ukraine could potentially use their western borders with friendly countries to their advantage, but those are long ways away from the key population centers of the country. After a strike in, say, Kyiv, they will have to drive 7+ hours to hide in Poland. But if the population is friendly to the insurgents, couldn't they hide there after an operation? It seems like the border with an insurgent-friendly country would be mainly useful for supply, training, etc. IIRC, the Taliban had a kind of "fighting season" where their fighters would migrate into Afghanistan from Pakistan, then return months later. It wasn't hit and run from border outposts.
- ignoramous 5y agoThat's not a scenario you'd want in Europe. Violent struggles often turn into multiple separatist movements.
- karatinversion 5y agoNone of this is what we wanted in Europe.
- Fnoord 5y agoRomania is south as well.
- Cthulhu_ 5y agoAnd that's also assuming that e.g. Poland would allow Ukranian soldiers to cross the border; Poland is a NATO country, and NATO allowing non-NATO soldiers in can be considered a provocation and escalation by Russia. I mean if it wasn't for Russia having and threatening with nukes I would applaud NATO getting involved; the various air forces of NATO countries would make quick work of the very exposed supply lines of the Russian invaders. So far, Russia has not shown much military dominance or strategy. But it can't be allowed to escalate due to the threat of nukes.
- grey-area 5y agoThe same logic would allow Putin to take all of Europe. If not now, when?
- tim333 5y agoWell it's different for the EU/NATO bits - NATO would certainly fight if he went into Poland. Not so sure about Moldova say.
- vertis 5y agoWhat about Finland and Sweden? What about if it was just the island of Gotland, and not an all out invasion. Edit: And how much will you give up to avoid a Nuclear War. Assuming the other side is not rational and can't be trusted to protect their existence in a MAD scenario. Maybe Estonia, Latvia and Lithuania are not worth "the world being destroyed". Where does it stop.
- georgeecollins 5y agoFinland and Sweden haven't asked to be in NATO. It was clear that Germany was not even willing to send defensive weapons to Ukraine. So I don't think the NATO countries were ready to fight over Ukraine, including the US. I don't know if Germany would go to war to protect Gotland, but if Swedes think it could happen maybe they should join NATO? That would clarify the situation one way or another.
- hammock 5y agoThere are separatists in Moldova to the south as well