7 ms·
MIT Chose Ethereum’s PoS as Top Technological Breakthrough
- adenozine 5y agoCompact fusion reactors exist and are functional… and they chose griftcoin junk tech.
- pacoWebConsult 5y agoDon't get me wrong, plenty of griftcoin junk tech exists, but Ethereum is the most capable platform and moving away from Proof Of Work is a significant step.
- cuteboy19 5y agoThey may be grifters and scammers but at least they are not burning down the planet. But I am curious about this: Etherium is not the first crypto to go PoS. Are there any significant technical advantages compared to other PoS implementations?
- yokem55 5y agoSure - They have a novel BLS signature aggregation that allows for a much larger number of participating validators (roughly up to 1M) then other POS systems that top out at a couple thousand. - It's slashing mechanism creates 'economic finality'. Any validator participating in a reorg beyond that ~12 minute economic finality window would find themselves slashed and forced exited from the validator set. - Lengthy entrance and exit queues mean that the validator set can't be shifted faster then the community can adapt should an attacker try manipulate the network. - Multiple independent client teams have implemented a publicly agreed upon specification (there are 6 known at the moment). This keeps insider developers from sneaking in adverse changes without causing a huge hullabaloo. Getting all this right is why it's taken so long to roll out.
- anonporridge 5y ago> Bitcoin’s Energy Usage Isn’t a Problem. Here’s Why. https://www.lynalden.com/bitcoin-energy/ https://www.lynalden.com/bitcoin-energy/
- cuteboy19 5y agoSo then PoS was pointless right? This whole article was bullshit too right? Or maybe, just maybe, the author holds a not insignificant amount of Bitcoin and is working overtime to dismiss criticism.
- anonporridge 5y agoHere's her thoughts on proof of stake, https://www.lynalden.com/proof-of-stake/ https://www.lynalden.com/proof-of-stake/ > Or maybe, just maybe, the author holds a not insignificant amount of Bitcoin and is working overtime to dismiss criticism. No shit Sherlock. This is a ridiculous point to make to try to dismiss someone's argument. If you believe something is a good investment, then of course you're going to own a lot of it and promote your reasoning to think it's good and alternatives are bad. Literally everyone one the planet does that and you're deluding yourself if you think anyone who has put in enough time and effort to understand the complexity of things is going to be bias free.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- rvz 5y agoI don't see why someone needs to wait 'years' on a coin for such a move when others already exist that are neither Proof-of-Work or Proof-of-Stake, unless you just plan on speculating on the cryptocurrency.
- dcolkitt 5y agoBecause creating a new network from scratch is easier than safely transitioning, without downtime or breaking backwards compatibility, an existing network that secures hundreds of billions of dollars in value.
- rvz 5y agoAre you saying me I should tell users to wait 7 or more years for this desired functionality while they lose more money trying to figure out how to use it? I also don't think there is a cryptocurrency network that is widely used that has operated without network halts, downtime or congestion so I do not expect any network to have such a 'smooth' transition either.
- thebean11 5y agoLike which coins? As someone in the industry, I highly recommend taking claims like that with a grain of salt.
- kordlessagain 5y agoPeople who write articles, submit articles, admin articles and comment on articles can't buy fusion reactors and profit from them. So, we have biases with cryptocurrency. Opinions about unknowable consensus mechanisms aside, I have serious doubts about PoS given there's no clear associated PoW presented alongside the staking. But what do I know? I have grey hairs. I still like Bitcoin and Lightning because the PoW and PoS work with each other to deliver similar functional properties. This is a personal opinion based on reading and trying to imagine how the Yapese managed their stashes of huge coins. Fun fact: One particularly large coin dropped off an outrigger on the way back from being mined and instead of taking it out of circulation, a few of the consensus makers went out and dove on it to confirm it was indeed sitting on the bottom of the ocean floor. I've set intent to go dive it and see it for myself.
- happytoexplain 5y ago>One particularly large coin dropped off an outrigger on the way back from being mined and instead of taking it out of circulation, a few of the consensus makers went out and dove on it to confirm it was indeed sitting on the bottom of the ocean floor. What does this mean? A cursory Googling isn't shedding light on this metaphor for me.
- adenozine 5y agoIt almost reads like a GPT-3 bot wrote it, I thought I was having a stroke trying to understand it.
- kordlessagain 5y agoI've provided a link to ease your stress.
- adenozine 5y agoIt seems rude now, what I wrote. I do apologize, I chose not to overlook a clunky sentence, you did not deserve that! You're a very understanding person for replying this way, despite my remark.
- bpodgursky 5y agoI am 100% confident that the first commercially available compact fusion reactor will win this prize too.
- adamsmith143 5y ago>Compact fusion reactors exist and are functional Functional as in works as intended? Maybe but certainly not functional as in "Useful as powerplants"
- jpm_sd 5y agoTechnology Review is not "MIT", it's an attempt at competing with Wired and Popular Science.
- top_sigrid 5y agoThis should totally be adjusted in the title I would suggest.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- nostrademons 5y agoIt is wholly owned by MIT though, even if they're editorially independent and the format has changed in recent decades to compete with Wired and Popular Science. Their reputation is still pretty good. I would consider Wired a decent publication as well.
- anonporridge 5y agoMIT is a brand. If the owners of MIT are attaching their brand to the Technology Review, then yes, it is MIT. If the people who actually do the hard science and education work that has made MIT a valuable and trusted brand don't like this dilution and selling out of the trust they earned, then they have a responsibility to either push against it or vote with their feet and their attention and stop contributing to the continuation of trust in the brand.
- thrill 5y agoNo, if it was MIT then it would be an official communique from the Office of the President of MIT. It's MIT Technology Review, and the distinction exists for a reason.
- anonporridge 5y agoThat distinction is meaningless to the masses for whom "MIT" is a mark of trust.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- kop316 5y agoIf possible, could the title be modified to spell out what "PoS" means? PoS aliases to "Piece of S***" and "Point of Sale", both of which give the headline a bit of a different impression on what to expect. Though I understand the general consensus is to send in the headline unmodified.
- anonporridge 5y agoLol. Ethereum is far from the first cryptocurrency to use proof of stake. Even before modern top 10s like Cardana and Solana, there was Peercoin as the original PoS coin, which at one point was a top 3 coin by market cap. If anything, Ethereum has been dragging it's feet on this. They originally planned to roll out PoS within a couple years after launch, and we're still here 7 years later. That's years of "wasted" proof of work when plenty of other coins rolled out PoS day one. This isn't actually about choosing the most impressive technological innovation. This just a cheap political attack on bitcoin's PoW, in some kind of attempt to shame it into transitioning to PoS too, which is never going to happen. The bitcoin mindshare is completely locked in to PoW as a mission critical feature of the system, which would destroy the entire endeavor if transitioned away from.
- capableweb 5y agoThe title is "MIT Chose Ethereum’s PoS As Top Technological Breakthrough", not "MIT declares Ethereum’s PoS As First PoS". Implementation matters more than "first!!11!". Obviously, starting with PoS is gonna be easier than creating a network and currency on PoW and then enabling the transition from PoW to PoS. "Dragging their feet" is a funny way of saying "taking their time to implement it correctly". None of this stuff is easy and since most of the work is novel, it makes it extra hard to make sure everything is ok implemented. If you take a closer look at Ethereums implementation of PoS, you'll notice there are a couple of novel ideas, which I'm guessing is why they got mentioned here. Another user in this submission already expanded on it too: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30515423 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30515423
- anonporridge 5y agoI think the real problem is that PoS tokens have a huge legitimacy problem. Even Ethereum continues to be plagued with their 60% premine and presale to early investors, of which we have little visibility into who those investors were. There is some evidence floating around of Vitalik and company working with very wealthy clients to obscure the size of Ethereum presale purchases. Years of PoW mining helps a bit to legitimize things, because it potentially diluted initial investors. Legacy PoS tokens, like the USD, achieved legitimacy initially by backing with real money (gold) before eventually cutting ties and trying to stand without hard backing, but instead stand on trust in the institution that controls the consensus mechanism. Ethereum seems to be attempting a similar transition now, cutting itself from a hard energy backing that keeps large stakeholders in check. At the end of the day, it's all about trust. Ethereum has their work cut out for them to establish large scale trust both in their transition to PoS as well as trust as a free floating currency, backed only by the Ethereum consensus makers, which could secretly be a small cabal of large stakeholders with majority control.
- waffle_maniac 5y ago
- waffle_maniac 5y ago
- ketzal 5y agoAnd their website has a poll to vote for the 11th breakthrough between four choices: one being the metaverse, and another being NFTs. https://www.technologyreview.com/2022/02/23/1045416/10-breakthrough-technologies-2022/ https://www.technologyreview.com/2022/02/23/1045416/10-break... Sigh...
- capableweb 5y agoSuch a shallow dismissal. What about all the other breakthroughs? What about the two other options you didn't mention, "AI-powered robots" and "Aging clocks"? To me, all of those options seems like over-hyped choices, but I guess sometimes breakthroughs are over-hyped before they suddenly have injected themselves into our world and we can't be without them. But "AI-powered robots" feels as likely as Metaverse and NFTs to be breakthroughs, but then I'm bearish on all of the options mentioned.
- ilaksh 5y agoWell, technically this is an MIT publication, but MIT Turing Award winning cryptographer Silvio Micali along with some other MIT folks actually created a different cryptocurrency. It is also a type of proof of stake but arguably more advanced than that of Ethereum. Very fast (seconds), good programming support and documentation, very tiny fees. It seems that bots or people automatically bury my comments if I mention the cryptocurrency by name on HN, so I am going to leave that for people to look up if they are interested. EDIT: Screw it. Algorand.