11 ms·
Germany mulls extending nuclear plants' life-span
- fuoqi 5y agoI guess, "greens" in the coalition will be really "happy" about that.
- urthor 5y ago"Robert Habeck said" "It is part of my ministry's tasks to answer this question. I would not reject it on ideological grounds - but the preliminary examination has shown that it does not help us." "Because the preparations for the shutdowns are already so far advanced that the nuclear power plants could only continue to operate under the highest safety concerns and possibly with fuel supplies that have not yet been secured," Habeck said." Unexpectedly, I feel like I have to call fake news on Reuters for this. The headline looks nothing like what the quotes in the body imply.
- tpush 5y agoYou mixed up the first quote I think: "It is part of my ministry's tasks to answer this question. I would not reject it on ideological grounds - but the preliminary examination has shown that it does not help us." But your point is absolutely true: Germany doesn't mull it at all.
- The_rationalist 5y ago
- throwoutway 5y agoI’m flagging the article because of this. The headline gives a false impression
- pyuser583 5y agoMany news outlets don’t hold headlines to editorial standards. They’re considered marketing, not journalism.
- zx85wes 5y agoPretty smart ;-) https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30426934#30427548 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30426934#30427548
- jacquesm 5y agoNot so simple though to restart the ones that are already down.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- rmbyrro 5y agoI don't get it. A nuclear accident halfway across the world and Germany decides to shut down. A war halfway across the continent and it decides to keep on? Both threats (nuclear accident and Putin's madness) have always existed. What changed? Did they suddenly discover Putin is not trustworthy to depend on for half of your energy supply?
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- markdown 5y agoIn a democracy, you need public support for this sort of thing. The anti-nuclear movement has been behind the shutdowns. With Russia invading Ukraine, nuclear proponents might be able to sway public opinion in the opposite direction for once.
- pbhjpbhj 5y agoThis is like Brexit, the populous are too easily led away from reason when nuclear power is mentioned. I'm not sure what the solution is. People were freaking the F out in South Wales, UK, because sand from Sizewell development (near Bristol) was being dumped a mile offshore, sand with one or two banana-equivalent doses per tonne (IIRC). Like maybe if you spend every day at the beach eating sand then you might be able to cause yourself some harm but there's no beach in Cardiff, the sand is way offshore and UK needs more non-fossil baseline power sources. I think perhaps the public information giving preparedness guidance for nuclear war did a number on us in the 80s. Chernobyl didn't exactly help, mind you.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- spockz 5y agoWhat changed is that to move away from nuclear the dependency on Gas has increased. This alleviated the immediate stress levels generated from the nuclear disasters around the world. Then a more immediate threat popped up by Russia invading Ukraine. This makes the gas dependency a liability again. This makes the far away risk of something might go very wrong with nuclear palatable again compared to the gas is risky right now.
- woodpanel 5y ago
- nest0r 5y ago
- Traster 5y agoI know this article isn't great, but is there anyone on HN who lives in Germany who could explain why there's such a scepticism of Nuclear power there? I'm from the UK and we have largely transitioned away from Nuclear for one clear reason - there was no political appetite to spend a tonne of money on an expensive form of energy that wasn't likely to pay off in the current parliamentary term. The german response to Nuclear seems to have been far more extreme though.
- guerrilla 5y agoWho stands to profit the most from decommissioning them all? I mean besides Schröder and Russia.
- fsflover 5y agohttps://www.ans.org/news/article-1392/robert-anderson-antinuclear-financier/ https://www.ans.org/news/article-1392/robert-anderson-antinu...
- okl 5y agoChernobyl disaster, fears stemming from nuclear weapons stationed in Germany, no viable solutions for waste disposal. Mostly that. Of course it's also not economically sensible if you factor in externalised costs. I'm also concerned about sloppy work and engineering, neglect and human mistake with catastrophic consequences. For example, there is one incident documentend where some idiotic fools drilled a hole into the containment to hang a fire extinguisher. [https://www.badische-zeitung.de/panne-in-leibstadt-arbeiter-bohren-loecher-in-sicherheitshuelle--87160425.html https://www.badische-zeitung.de/panne-in-leibstadt-arbeiter-...] However, if it would help to bring down the sick Putin regime in Russia I would support a limited extension. EDIT: Russian trolls be downvoting me. Idi nahui.
- quattrofan 5y ago
- raymond_goo 5y agoWe still have mushrooms that radiate more than normal due to Chernobyl. Then we witnessed the Fukushima catastrophe from afar but with great shock. And we have no state who wants to store the nuclear waste. We believe the future is renewables and we invest heavily into it.
- RivieraKid 5y agoFinally! I really hope this will happen.
- brazzy 5y agoIt will in fact most definitely not happen, as the article makes pretty clear. Not that it would be a good idea, at all.
- acidburnNSA 5y agoExtending the life of low-carbon baseload power that is being prematurely shut down for purely political reasons wouldn't be a good idea in light of the climate crisis and this new wartime threat?
- joshe 5y agoHere's better, more numerate coverage: https://twitter.com/energybants/status/1498005296299622408 https://twitter.com/energybants/status/1498005296299622408 Also the whole thread covers other nuclear topics the press is a bit lost on. Remember, the number of nuclear engineers at reuters is 0.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- stdbrouw 5y ago“As Energy Ministries across the EU become "ecology" Ministries led by people who don't even know the units used to quantify energy, Finance Ministries become the adults.” This is not more numerate coverage, it’s semi-informed snark.
- joshe 5y agoHere's the CV: https://www.linkedin.com/in/mark-w-nelson-484b0713 https://www.linkedin.com/in/mark-w-nelson-484b0713 Considerably more numerate coverage, it's WELL-informed snark. Is snark the exclusive domain of journalists? They are certainly the world's main supplier of it. But it seems like everyone else should get to play too.
- rossdavidh 5y ago"Weather: famously indifferent to German wartime needs." Ouch.
- joshe 5y agoI really like that line too.
- Schlaefer 5y agoKeep in mind that this persons appears to be a pro nuclear industry lobbyist. So the number of objective nuclear opinions on this twitter account is 0.
- throwaway4good 5y agoSurely a better idea than building LNG terminals.
- aerosmile 5y agoWhen Putin was first elected two decades ago, a lot of my Austrian friends correctly saw in him a threat to Europe. I don't buy it that the German government didn't know him better than the average citizen did. They are just trying to ride whichever wave presents itself at any given moment. In the days of the Fukushima crisis, being against nuclear would get you the most votes. In the days of the Ukraine crisis, being against gas would get you the most votes. While Germany is the one looking bad here, it's actually a structural problem of every democracy in the world. The other option is to put too much trust in the hands of dictators. Over the course of hundreds of years, that actually seems to work less well (eg: China - given their potential, they should have never had to play catch up). But every once in a while, there are a few decades where an individual comes along that plays all of their cards right and engages in a long game that vastly outperforms the 4-year back and forth circus of democracies. But I don't trust myself to reliably recruit a front desk colleague, let alone someone with nuclear codes. So democracies it is.
- Ecko123 5y ago
- NoPie 5y agoThis will be a big change in policy. I suspect that it is related to current war in Ukraine. Could be that finally Germany has seen the true face of Putin? I speculate but in relation to other big announcements today by the EU (providing fighter jets to Ukraine, promising Ukraine accession to the EU), it only makes sense.
- Gravityloss 5y agoIt would be still worth doing even if it's only helping 2 years from now. One can't expect gas to flow smoothly maybe ever anymore. One can go with coal and LNG for a while. Completely new nuclear plants take many years even for the permits and a decade to build.
- croes 5y agoWill the energy suppliers then also pay back the compensation they received because of the (deliberately) badly done exit from exit from the nuclear phase-out?
- sydbarrett74 5y agoMaybe Germany can fund TerraPower's travelling wave research and leapfrog Gen IV and -V conventional reactor technology.