4 ms·
Assuming this is a real problem, wouldn't you just put your geothermal power plant well outside of any city? Doesn't even have to be somewhere where there are
by eru 5y ago
Assuming this is a real problem, wouldn't you just put your geothermal power plant well outside of any city?
Doesn't even have to be somewhere where there are no buildings. Just somewhere where hardening the few existing buildings against small earthquakes etc won't be too expensive.
- Fiahil 5y ago> Just somewhere where hardening the few existing buildings against small earthquakes etc won't be too expensive. So, expending twice on a bad idea ? Seriously, what do you think will happen ? And even it was technically possible, how do you insure a company like that ? Will the plant operator be responsible for the repairs and damages when they destabilize an entire region ?
- eru 5y ago> So, expending twice on a bad idea ? Seriously, what do you think will happen ? What do you mean? A few really minor earthquakes are all that was reported by the comment I was replying to. So I'd assume more really minor earthquakes. > And even it was technically possible, how do you insure a company like that ? The usual way of paying an insurance company? > Will the plant operator be responsible for the repairs and damages when they destabilize an entire region ? Depends on the jurisdiction. But sure, you can make the plant operator responsible for that and responsible for having gigantic insurance coverage. (Just look at whatever liability people who operate dams have today. A breakage of a major dam would also devastate entire regions. So whatever arrangements are good enough for that use case are probably good enough here.)
- Dylan16807 5y agoI don't think the "entire region"s involved would be big enough to make insurance difficult to implement.
- Stevvo 5y agoMany countries have almost no wilderness left; everything is either urban or agriculture or mountains with no convenient place for an earthquake.
- pm90 5y agoSeismic disturbances are generally a concern for dense urban areas. It seems unlikely that agricultural areas would care that much.
- topspin 5y agoIs there any conceivable burden urbanites don't imagine the people and land outside urban areas can tolerate? We don't live in grass yurts you know. Bridges and dams are a thing. Earthquakes are a problem. Deep fracking operations have demonstrated this already.
- pm90 5y ago> We don't live in grass yurts you know. Bridges and dams are a thing. Earthquakes are a problem. Deep fracking operations have demonstrated this already. What percentage of rural areas are situated in close proximity to large dams and bridges?
- masklinn 5y agoYour statement is unclear, are you saying it doesn’t matter if dams and bridges get destroyed, or that it doesn’t matter if rural habitations get destroyed as long as they’re not destroyed near infrastructure?
- pm90 5y agoIt’s perfectly clear if you read it without trying to be deliberately obtuse.
- re6fae5Wied5tha 5y ago> Is there any conceivable burden urbanites don't imagine the people and land outside urban areas can tolerate? The burden of wealth.
- eru 5y ago
- modeless 5y agoIt seems like this is a real problem: https://news.stanford.edu/2019/05/23/lessons-south-korea-solving-geothermals-earthquake-problem/ https://news.stanford.edu/2019/05/23/lessons-south-korea-sol... That said, it also seems like this proposed technique is very different and probably wouldn't have the same issues.
- masklinn 5y ago> Assuming this is a real problem, wouldn't you just put your geothermal power plant well outside of any city? The US’ fracking experiments show ”well outside of any city” is nowhere near enough.
- eru 5y agoWhy? How much damage has been done?
- masklinn 5y agoIn every state where fracking got authorised, earthquakes above 3.0 have increased by an order of magnitude (or even appeared where they were considered essentially inexistent). Hundreds if not thousands of buildings have been damaged across OK and TX because they’d been built with no quake resistance as they’d been built in zones considered inactive, insurers have jacked up their rates and the USGS had to revise their risk maps. The risk to populations is also non-negligible, because aside from a lack of quake-proof constructions the populations are not trained for or aware of quake safety for the same reason that the areas are historically stable. I don’t think that’s happened yet in the US (as no fracking quake has exceeded 5.0 yet), but in 2019 fracking started killing people in china: the Sichuan basin, historically a geologically very stable region, got hit with 4 quakes between 4.9 and 6.0, at least 15 died and hundreds were injured.
- eru 5y agoThanks! Seems all pretty manageable on the humongous scale of 'this could be our main source of energy'. Eg burning coal or oil kills a lot more people directly and indirectly.
- Glawen 5y agoThe goal of the plant was to provide heat for Strasbourg, so it has to be near the city.
- eru 5y agoYes. Originally I typed a longer version of my comment that had a section on heat vs electricity. Basically, the idea I proposed would only work for generating electricity, not for using the heat directly.