15 ms·
How old are democracies across the world?
- lahvak 5y agoWhy is Czechia listed as 31 years while Slovakia only 27?
- version_five 5y agoI liked that the article focuses on the important distinction between democracy and liberal democracy. There are lots of places I find democracy conflated with a "free country". It's limits on government power (regardless of what a majority want) and the ability for the people to kick out the current government that imo are most necessary for a free country. The other details don't really matter if you don't have these.
- 2ion 5y agoThis is a very important point. Whereas there is "convergence" between for example the penal codes of states commonly referred to as "democratic", what is nothing in one country might be a crime to just say in the other. In fact, comparative political science has only some veeeeery basic "features" that make them say it's "a democracy"; there is a lot of freedom to tip the scales in one direction or another. Also, commonly overserved is the notion among elites that some democracy is "too much" (for example, no referendums in core governance questions).
- VictorPath 5y ago> It's limits on government power (regardless of what a majority want) and the ability for the people to kick out the current government that imo are most necessary for a free country. The other details don't really matter if you don't have these. So a country where the people can't change their own government are what you call liberalism and democracy. Got it.
- frosted-flakes 5y agoI think that should be read as > (limits on government power) and (the ability for the people to kick out the current government) not > > limits on (government power) and (the ability for the people to kick out the current government)
- version_five 5y agoYes I meant the first one, I did not expect it to get misread the other way
- hunterb123 5y agoPower corrupts, absolute power corrupts absolutely. You need checks in place against the government for that, regardless of the majority. A constitution is a contract between the government and its people how they agree to be governed. You weren't specific in your criticism so I'm not sure what you take issue with.
- version_five 5y ago> You weren't specific in your criticism so I'm not sure what you take issue with Why do you need to take issue with something?
- hunterb123 5y agoContext matters and you didn't specify what "limits on government power" you were talking about. Constitutional limits don't conflict with democracy, they preserve it. If you were talking about some other sort of limitation an example would be nice.
- avgcorrection 5y agoLiberalism and democracy are two conflicting tendencies. This is acknowledged in the literature. The most important liberty under liberalism is the liberty to pursue property, and (or as Aristotle claimed) democracy threatens that since democracy leans more towards egalitarianism. The most important rights are the negative liberties of the rich. Which of course are universal on paper. The democracy part is a concession to popular pressure and also to serve as a unifying slogan, since democracy is valued even higher than liberalism in polite discourse. But it’s really just a thin veneer. All it takes is one vote for the “wrong candidate” or for someone to read the first three paragraphs on The Republic on Wikipedia for that high-minded ideal to go out the window. Then the specter of populism looms.
- awelxtr 5y agoAs a Spaniard this is, sadly, our everyday life. Specially if you watch the news. On the flip side we also use it to make jokes.
- swayvil 5y agoI hear that "for the public health" is a historically popular justification for unreasonable dictatorial action. Do you see that justification used much in Spain?
- christkv 5y agoSpain NOT the US We had an illegal lockdown at the beginning of the pandemic. Number of people punished 0. During most of the pandemic it's been back and forth on do this, do that. Things done that flies against all science like masking outside (just lifted) and other silly things like keeping small children masked in school knowing now that there rate of infection has been the same with or without masks. Other than that we seem to have avoided the authoritarian tendencies of the us, canada, australia, new zeland, germany, austria, france etc. Compared to those countries we have not had it to bad when it comes to violating our rights. Now it's time to vote all of them out of office. I don't want a single politician in power who got used to wielding power during a pandemic.
- onion2k 5y agoWe had an illegal lockdown at the beginning of the pandemic. What law was broken?
- christkv 5y agoFree moment is guaranteed by the Spanish constitution it can only be set aside for martial law . Government never declared martial law only state of alarm (we have 3 levels of exception) so they did not have the right to restrict movement. We were all locked in our houses for 6 weeks. So yeah I want people to go to jail.
- 5y ago
- elzbardico 5y agoThere’s one very close up north, indeed.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- yalogin 5y agoAre you in a country below Russia?
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- mike10921 5y agoIt's all coming back in reverse. The young generation who don't appreciate having democracy are bulking at democracy and choosing socialism. The vast majority of immigrants from socialist countries do not vote or support socialism because they appreciate their freedom. Someone who is born with abundance doesn't appreciate his blessings, but one who is born with very little and acquires abundance appreciates it every day.
- kingkawn 5y agoSocial Democracy, where the state is used as a tool to support the populace, is not whatever boogeyman of socialism you are trying to conjure
- muglug 5y agoIt’s not the young people who are turning against democracy. It’s the baby boomers who talk ceaselessly about “fake news”, rejecting anything that doesn’t match their cloistered reality.
- SSilver2k2 5y agoOne is a form of government, the other is an economy. You can have a Socialist Democracy or a Socialist Dictatorship, just like you can have a Capitalist Democracy or a Capitalist Dictatorship.
- newaccount2021 5y ago
- ekidd 5y ago> The young generation who don't appreciate having democracy are bulking at democracy and choosing socialism. Contrary to what some people argue, "democracy versus no democracy" and "capitalism versus socialism versus communism" are separate axes. For example, there exist capitalist countries with very little democracy. And there exist socialist countries with relatively robust democratic institutions. And the opposite combinations exist. (There have not, as far as I know, been very many self-proclaimed communist countries with robust democratic institutions.) The questions that I care about are, "Can the people of the country make a comfortable living?", "Can they successfully petition the government for a redress of their greivances?", and "Does the country protect minorities of various sorts from the tyranny of the majority?" Achieving all three of these can be a challenge, and different countries may vote for more or less safety net.
- oceanplexian 5y agoThe USA is the oldest democracy in the world, and only has been that way for ~250 years (And even then, having survived one of the worst Civil Wars in history). Most European democracies have only been so for a few decades. I think some of the bias comes from the fact that people have a a short-term memory. We've had it so good in the last century that we forget that we are the exception, not the rule.
- lentil_soup 5y agoaccording to the posted website Australia is the oldest, not the USA. Edit: Actually Switzerland seems to be older in their data
- vinay427 5y agoI'm curious what the article's source is for this claim. Naturally, democracy can be defined differently, but there are reputable sources that disagree with this [1], and even if considering limited suffrage to preclude democracy, Australia and particularly Switzerland perform poorly as well. https://www.weforum.org/agenda/2019/08/countries-are-the-worlds-oldest-democracies https://www.weforum.org/agenda/2019/08/countries-are-the-wor...
- ska 5y agoThe article discusses it's sources, and also the inherent difficulty in defining "democracy".
- lentil_soup 5y agoThey seem to take their definition from here: "The identification of electoral democracies is based on the Regimes of the World classification by Lührmann et al. (2018). In electoral democracies, citizens have the right to participate in meaningful, free and fair, and multi-party elections."
- ekianjo 5y ago> ). Most European democracies have only been so for a few decades. you might want to revise this claim
- oblio 5y agoOne thing to note: a huge threat to democracy is war. Frequently autocracies invade democracies because autocracies are inherently unstable and need frequent propping up of internal support by fake "injections of popularity", such as war. Look at Eastern Europe bloom in 1990 - 1992. For all intents and purposes these countries were under foreign occupation and regimes imposed from abroad.
- qiskit 5y ago> Frequently autocracies invade democracies because autocracies are inherently unstable Simply not true. Ask north korea, cuba, etc. No democracy could withstand an enemy 1000X its size attacking it. Can you imagine the US withstanding an enemy 1000X stronger than us? Not a chance. > need frequent propping up of internal support by fake "injections of popularity", such as war. Historically, it's usually the other way around. Democracies have invaded "autocracies". In the past 100 years, most of the invasions have been by democracies ( predominantly the US and our allies ) against other nations. Actually, "protecting democracy" was propaganda we used to get involved in ww1 against the wish of the american people. And it hasn't stopped since. In the name of "democracy" we've invaded dozens of countries and set ourselves a nice little empire. That democracy is a good is modern propaganda. Go read up on what the founders wrote about democracy. Go read about what Socrates did. Most intelligent people throughout history have not been fans of democracy. For a good reason, the greatest genocides in history have been committed by democracies. Just think about it.
- oblio 5y agoYou must not be reading the same history books as me.
- qiskit 5y agoIt's possible since each country has their own history books. What countries did north korea, cuba, etc invade in your history books. Now compare that with the list of countries britain, australia, france, canada, US, etc invaded. List the countries currently occupied by "autocracies". Now list the countries we occupy. List the nations genocided by democracies. It's rather shocking. So on and so forth. Not saying autocracies are good. Just that the idea that democracies are necessarily good is simply not true. Democracies have committed the worst crimes against humanity. It wasn't an autocracy that did hiroshima or nagasaki. But we each have our own history books I guess.
- mupuff1234 5y agoDon't most of us work in environments that are basically a variation of a dictatorship? As a species we're quite accustomed to a having an alpha male\female\etc make the calls. I think all of us are just a few steps in the wrong direction from a dictatorship.
- kingkawn 5y agoFeudalism lives on in all spheres other than narrow semiannual popularity contests.
- mertd 5y agoNo. Dictatorship means someone else holds absolute power over the basic rights of all subjects including their right to live. There is no equivalence with a corporate org structure. I don't know how the two can even be confused.
- nautilius 5y agoAlso, your boss won't shoot you, or lock you and your family away when you give your notice.
- brabel 5y agoThis is a response from someone who tries really hard to not understand the point. OP said corporations are * a few steps away * from dictatorships, they did not confuse the two. If you don't understand that a few steps away does not imply it's the same thing, you need to reflect on your skils as a reader.
- vinay427 5y ago> Only a few countries have been electoral democracies for a long time. Eight countries — Canada, Finland, Iceland, Ireland, New Zealand, Sweden, the United Kingdom, and the United States — have been electoral democracies for a century or more. And according to this data, just two countries have been electoral democracies even longer: Australia and Switzerland have been democracies since the mid-19th century. Am I missing something? By which measure was the US (and possibly another among the first eight in this list) not an electoral democracy for as long as Australia and Switzerland? All three had significant restrictions on suffrage, with Switzerland particularly regressive in this regard in the late 20th century. EDIT: I was thinking of Iceland as well, which has a very reasonable claim to be the oldest (continuous and current) democracy along with the US and possibly the Isle of Man, depending on how democracy is defined.
- peeters 5y agoI'm currently reading through the source here for the same answer: https://pdfs.semanticscholar.org/e09f/417c2d78b48fb100bea6dd728d95cb481c01.pdf https://pdfs.semanticscholar.org/e09f/417c2d78b48fb100bea6dd... Sliding back the US and Canada flipped from electoral autocracy to electoral democracy in 1921. > In electoral autocracies, on the other hand, the chief executive is dependent on a legislature that is itself elected in de-jure multiparty elections (in parliamentary systems), directly elected alongside a separately elected legislature (in presidential systems), or a combination of both (in semi-presidential systems) I'm not sure what happened in 1921 to flip the U.S.. I think 1920 was the first election that allowed women to vote? But as you say, why that isn't counted against Switzerland I'm not sure.
- pclmulqdq 5y agoThat could be related to the direct election of senators rather than their appointment by states. The change happened around that time. Of course, Canada still has an appointed senate, so I'm not sure what the distinction is.
- lapetitejort 5y ago
- newaccount2021 5y ago
- erlklkj45k 5y agoMaybe Europe should be spending more money on defense rather than socialism. The US should absolutely leave and defund NATO of which we pay the vast majority for.
- zeruch 5y agoWe don't pay the majority of it and we gain a considerable amount of leverage for it.
- erlklkj45k 5y agoIs this not a factual comment? Why should my tax money be used to pay for European defense when they won't pay for it themselves?
- politician 5y agoRussia has 6000 nuclear weapons and 100 million people. The US has ~5000 nuclear weapons and 300 million people. It's in the interest of the US to see the Russian nuclear stockpile reduced by strangling its economy. Russia's demographics are already in a nosedive. Europe has been largely demilitarized with the US providing protection. It would be a strategic blunder for the US to abandon its position in Europe to Russia.
- n4r9 5y agoThe US funds about 16% of the running costs. Accounting for GDP, this is less than many other countries. HTTPS://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-44717074
- bpodgursky 5y agoThat's not the right measure. That's of "running NATO" itself ($2-$3B, for training missions etc), which is pocket change compared to the actual defense budgets. And the US far, far dominates actual national defense spending, which is what matters for collective defense. It's the $700B the US spends on defense that backs the NATO defense commitment, not the couple billion spent on training missions.
- swayvil 5y agoThe obvious question is, "What does the transition from democracy to dictatorship look like?" I mean if the rich guys own everything anyway. Do they ramp up authoritarian reasonings to justify policies? Do they just stop trying to justify?
- politician 5y agoIt seems to look like tacit control of the press giving way to overt public directives to the press.
- swayvil 5y agoWell that sounds familiar. Some emails were posted here just a few days ago. Fed and facebook discussing propaganda strategy.
- ModernMech 5y agoAutocracy revolves around the ego of the autocrat. Usually the autocrat’s message is something along the lines of “I alone can solve all your problems, and your problems are because of those people”, where “those people” are usually some minority ehtnic, national, or religious group. Obviously not all of the problems in the world are due to these people. Therefore autocracies are heavily invested in obfuscating the truth, gaslighting populations with propaganda, takeovers of national media, and jailing or execution of dissidents. After all, you can’t have people going around saying the autocrat is not the solution to everything and “those” people aren’t the one and only problem. People might start to get ideas. Thus the downward spiral begins. This is why autocracies are unstable. They require an ever shifting narrative about why things are so bad. The real reason things go to shit under autocracies is because no one in charge is invested in solving real problems. The problems that autocracies aim to solve are made up to incite people and to appease egos. They aren’t evidence based because following the evidence would reveal shockingly that the autocrat doesn’t have all the solutions.
- marcodiego 5y agoIn Brazil, dictatorship created problems by lack of planning with fast urbanization for 21 years. During the rule, they kidnapped and killed dissenters. When social and economic problems were about to explode, they handed the government and the country entered a democratic period. To this day there are people who blame democracy for the problems that exploded after the dictatorship ended and spread lies about the dictatorship being a better time. Elections of 2018 was partly a result of this thought. My best counter argument is: "Are there more democracies among developed or underdeveloped countries? Are there more dictatorships among poor or rich countries? We can see that dictatorships are more related to empoverishment and democracies are more related to development." I think something similar happens in Chile.
- hdesh 5y agoThe source for this analysis comes from V-Dem project. Specifically related to India, the V-Dem results are highly questionable. Their results have been rebutted point-by-point in this (paywalled) piece [1]. I will highlight one aspect of the questionable results from the analysis about India. There's a "Clean elections index" in the V-Dem project which is about absence of registration fraud, irregularities, election violence etc. Interestingly India's clean elections index score keeps sliding downward after 1998. Note that India was under officially declared emergency from 1975-77 and an election was held in 1977. The V-Dem clean election index doesn't reflect this phenomenon. India adopted the electronic voting machines (EVM) sometime between 1998-2001. Before using EVM, paper ballots would be used for elections. It is well documented [2] that EVMs have helped ensuring freer and fairer elections. Anecdotally I would remember so many incidents of booth-capturing (described in [2]) and re-elections due to irregularities, prior to the EVM era. [1] - https://swarajyamag.com/ideas/an-analysis-of-the-v-dem-data-on-the-decline-of-democracy-in-india-reveals-interesting-insightsabout-v-dem https://swarajyamag.com/ideas/an-analysis-of-the-v-dem-data-... [2] - https://www.brookings.edu/blog/up-front/2019/04/05/indias-electoral-democracy-how-evms-curb-electoral-fraud/ https://www.brookings.edu/blog/up-front/2019/04/05/indias-el...
- random_ind_dude 5y ago>swarajyamag A right-wing website that's extremely sympathetic to the current right-wing government in India is how you rebut V-Dem's classification of India as an electoral autocracy.
- hdesh 5y ago
- legalcorrection 5y agoDemocracy is rule by the class of people who control public opinion—by the puppeteers—not rule by the people.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- TheCoelacanth 5y agoWhat's the preferable alternative? It's not perfect, but democracy is undeniably better at serving the interests of average people than any other alternative that I'm aware of ever being tried on a large scale.
- legalcorrection 5y agoThe Chinese government has been incredible for the Chinese people (not all of them, but most of them). Democracy with much more limited suffrage is probably more appropriate for the Western man, but we are ideologically closed to that option.
- oldsecondhand 5y ago> The Chinese government has been incredible for the Chinese people By what metric?
- tshaddox 5y agoI’m a different commenter, but if I had to guess I’d say primarily by the metric of starvation.
- aeternum 5y agoThis can be true but also better than all other alternatives.
- swagasaurus-rex 5y agoDemocracy can also change things by popular vote. Something top down forms of government prefer to ignore.
- yalogin 5y agoThe politics threads on HN are very revelatory for me. I always thought the HN crowd is very analytical, logical and knows how to understand data and reason with it. In that sense these threads are more disappointing than some random interactions on reddit or twitter.
- stingraycharles 5y agoEven analytical, logical people make interpretations; politics is prone to many different reasonable interpretations, and it’s often difficult to establish facts, so you see a vast variety of opinions. I think generally speaking political discussions are discouraged on HN for this precise reason.
- brabel 5y ago> I always thought the HN crowd is very analytical, logical and knows how to understand data and reason with it. Did you arrive at that conclusion driven by observation and evidence? If so, then that means you notice this behaviour only on the politics threads. Now, ask yourself: are people here really not behaving analytically and logically only when it comes to politics, but you only happen to notice that when it comes to politics? Or maybe you only think that this happens in politics because you have an unreasonably emotional reaction to truly analytical points of view that contradict your political view points?
- watwut 5y ago> Did you arrive at that conclusion driven by observation and evidence? If so, then that means you notice this behaviour only on the politics threads You second sentence does not follow from first one. It is quite possible for HN to have that behavior in more then one topic while OP making the first observation in politics.
- zamadatix 5y agoI'm having a brain fart on the word/phrase to describe this but it'd be really interesting to see how "split" accounts are when commenting on the technical articles vs fluff articles. It may well be different groups commenting on certain posts often and others not as often giving a strong rise to a real difference in tone/analysis. There may not be things like "subreddits" here but that doesn't inherently mean you can pick a random political topic and expect the same userbase is participating. This wouldn't rule out the above, both reasons can coexist even, but it'd add to the understanding significantly.
- Simon_O_Rourke 5y ago
- marcodiego 5y agoAccording to the graph, Brazil is a democracy since 1987. Actually, after the 1964 coup, our first civil president was appointed in 1985 but first general direct elections only occurred in 1989.
- marcosdumay 5y agoBrazil being Brazil, it's very hard to pick a number. We can argue endlessly about what a mess the process was, and if the results did reflect the electors wishes. But the people did elect delegates, that met and decided on a president. Formally, that is a perfectly valid election (that started by 82, and only really ended in 87 - that's an entire mandate duration with the delegates not really deciding on it).
- ricardoplouis 5y agoAs a country that strips away voting rights from felons, it's arguable that we still don't have a democracy until all citizens are guaranteed the right to vote.
- AniseAbyss 5y agoSomeone said something really interesting that stuck with me "in the US land votes" Perhaps one day NYC will secede and tell Wyoming to go fuck themselves.
- russellbeattie 5y agoI sorta loathe this sort of revisionist history. Especially the type which casually tries to wipe out 200+ years of American democratic history by simply saying, "Yeah, but it wasn't a real democracy." So cliche! There's just too many pedantic definitions, technicalities and arbitrary choices which make any sort of analysis like this arguable in soooo many ways. Just one glaring example: The US has "technically" been a Democratic Republic since our Constitution was ratified in 1789. But Boston, where I grew up, was founded in 1630, 159 years earlier. Massachusetts and other states implemented various democratic systems that continued through the founding of the Federal government. Putting the line at 1789 doesn't tell the full story because the states of the United States are all pseudo-nation states and existed decades before the Union, and I will bet many exist nearly unchanged after the Union is dissolved some day as well. One could also argue that after the English Civil War, the king was mostly a figurehead and that the Parliament was actually a form of representative government that was copied by the Americans, and that we were basically throwing a hissy fit for having to pay our fair share of taxes and not really rebelling against tyranny. In fact England had been electing representatives to Parliament since the 1500s. And that's totally a valid way of looking at it. The point stands. Anyways, I feel that the American pride in the fact that we're the first "real" democracy (for whatever definition of real you want) is well founded *without any caveats*. Our ancestors could have done better, and so can we!