4 ms·
Tokamak fusion can only ever be far more expensive, per watt and per watt-hour, than existing fission. Fission is getting more expensive all the time.
by ncmncm 5y ago
Tokamak fusion can only ever be far more expensive, per watt and per watt-hour, than existing fission. Fission is getting more expensive all the time.
- chmod775 5y ago> Tokamak fusion can only ever be far more expensive, per watt and per watt-hour, than existing fission. Why?
- ncmncm 5y agoThe energy flux density in the most compressed plasma imaginable is orders of magnitude less than in fissile uranium. So, to match power out, it has to be big. Really, really big. And a fusion reaction chamber is a much more expensive affair than a fission pile: super high-tech materials and construction, enormous magnets (blasted by the hot-neutron flux output), piping for thousands of tons of melted lithium that have to be replaced (by robots! because super radioactive) every couple of years as the neutrons destroy them. The (radioactive) lithium itself, and containment for if it breaks out of the piping. Continuous processing of the lithium to extract synthetic tritium for fuel. Heat exchangers for lithium to a working fluid that won't pick up radioactivity, and more heat exchangers from that to water for steam. And then the usual steam turbines, which demand regular, very expensive maintenance. Cooling towers to condense the steam, after. A hundred billion dollars estimated for one several GW plant, and decades for construction. Meanwhile, solar and wind get cheaper every year, with no bottom in sight. The longer they take on fusion, the less competitive it gets, and it starts out way behind, with no possibility of ever catching up.
- _0w8t 5y agoThis was with previous designs of fusion reactors. Read about proposed Ark and currently constructing Spark reactors. By using stronger superconductive magnets it was possible to reduce the size of the plant by order of magnitude. Spark even has a chance to get to Q>1 before ITER and it’s chamber is less than 2m in diameter. Plus it is possible to replace its parts without disassembling the whole reactor. [1] - https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/SPARC_(tokamak) https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/SPARC_(tokamak)
- ncmncm 5y agoThat might be nice if they had solutions to the other problems not addressed (see above). But operating it will necessarily still be enormously more expensive than solar or wind, which cost practically nothing. Somebody with one leg can do a lot better in a race than somebody with none, but that is not the measure to consider when the competition is with two-legged runners. (Hint: they win.)
- _0w8t 5y agoIn Europe after the last autumn when for months there were little wind and cloudy sky there is a realization that energy based purely on renewables will require much bigger storage and much more solar or at least significantly more expensive solar that works under clouds. Doable, but cost is non-trivial. So if any of fusion startups can make operating plant within the next 20 years, it can be used. But if that takes longer, then I agree that large-scale fusion will not happen.
- pfdietz 5y agoLong term darkness/calm is solved with hydrogen. Europe has plenty of underground geology suitable for mass hydrogen storage (it's just like natural gas is stored.) Most of the energy still would go directly from solar/wind to the grid, or through efficient batteries, so the low round trip efficiency of power to gas to power doesn't matter much.
- gmueckl 5y agoIf hydrogen is produced from electricity at scale, it won't be used for energy storage. It'll get sold to chemical plants first. They'll pay good prices.
- pfdietz 5y agoYes, surely that will be a major market. It just makes the case easier for renewables, as that's a major source of dispatchable demand that can smooth variation in renewable output without having to pay a cost for turning it back to electric power later.
- Aeolun 5y agoI find it hard to believe that people would be seriously researching this if we already knew there could never be any sensible commercial application. More likely we just don’t know the way to make it viable yet.
- ncmncm 5y agoIn some hypothetically possible world, policy choices are based the best reasoning from the latest information. We, alas, live in this world, where policy is mainly a product of history. The H bomb legacy looms large here. We are in the position of the person whose car keys were lost somewhere, but we are looking only under the D-T fusion streetlight because we can't see anywhere else.
- marcosdumay 5y ago> So, to match power out, it has to be big. Really, really big. Fusion has all of the characteristics of something you'll want to do if you are in space. Add to that the fact that its fuel is much easier to acquire than fission and that solar isn't available everywhere and you have a winner. Meanwhile down to Earth, yes, most likely it will never be an important energy source.
- pfdietz 5y agoI must strongly disagree, particularly for DT fusion. DT fusion reactors would be very heavy. ARC, for example, would have the weight of a couple of US WW2 destroyers. DT fusion delivers its energy as heat. A fission reactor would be far smaller, simpler, cheaper, and more reliable. You might make the case for advanced fuels, but that likely means you have to get 3He from somewhere. I suspect beamed power will beat even advanced fuel fusion in all missions in the future (a weak prediction as I will not be around to see.)
- Paradigma11 5y agoBut you dont need a lot of fuel for fission and you also need many other things to keep a ship/station running. Isnt fuel in the ballpark of just one of many consumables that you need?
- ncmncm 5y agoFission-powered ion propulsion is the best mature tech we have. In space, the fission doesn't need containment, or even much shielding if it is far enough away from the rest of the ship. In the cloud tops of Titan, Venus, Saturn, Uranus, or Neptune, a nuclear power plant may be as simple as a naked pile suspended near the bottom of a big fabric tube with wind turbines at the top. The radioactively-heated, buoyant air inside holds it up, and, escaping through the turbine, generates power. (Enough is held back so it stays up.) Perhaps surprisingly, gravity is almost Earth-normal on all four planets. Perhaps more surprisingly, the temperature at a not unreasonably-high pressure is also close to Earth-normal (except on Titan). But getting back to orbit from any of the last three would be very, very difficult, so such a reactor would only ever power robots. Getting back to orbit from Titan is easy. From Venus, it is pretty hard; and once in orbit you would need to refuel to get anywhere else.
- rob74 5y agoI'm not that familiar with the subject, but this phrase sounds suspiciously like the 1943 IBM executive saying there is a market for only five computers in the world - i.e. it completely discounts technological progress. Of course, this progress has been painfully slow until now, but comparing it with fission is still unfair - fission is well-researched and it getting more expensive is tied to the inherent dangers of radioactivity (and the ever more complicated measures which try to mitigate them), and the costs of spent fuel storage.
- ncmncm 5y agoFission getting more expensive is tied to the very lucrative fully-legal corruption industry. Once a fission plant construction project is started, the money starts flowing, and is practically impossible to stop. If it is ever finished, the money would stop, and nobody actually involved wants that ever to happen, at least not until their kids graduate college. So the project blows through deadline after deadline, and cost overruns pile up without limit, until somebody manages to pull the plug. Once it looks like the money will stop regardless, there is some incentive to deliver a reactor; we saw that in Finland recently. South Carolina is the more typical cancellation after billions are spent, except in that case with a few indictments. Normally nobody gets indicted, and nobody ever has to give any money back.
- hallway_monitor 5y agoWow this is brutal but feels like it's correct. What a frightening state of affairs. Is the construction industry really so corrupt? Is government and industry unaware or unwilling/unable to detect this earlier and stop it?
- hunter-gatherer 5y agoI spent some fair amount of years as both a government employee in DoD and then some years as a defense contractor amd I can tell you the military industrial complex is a real thing. In my contracting days I worked with a handful of DoE engineers that were more familiar with reactor projects and as I understood it, reactor peojects basically follow the same type of workflow as any big DoD prohect. So OPs comment is much in line with my understanding of the issue. It is an unfortunate state of affairs.