7 ms·
They are forever smashing this or that record, on the verge of break-even, on track to producing free energy without nasty radionuclides. But it is always a con
by ncmncm 5y ago
They are forever smashing this or that record, on the verge of break-even, on track to producing free energy without nasty radionuclides. But it is always a con. If they ever do get Q high enough to make energy production conceivable -- it will need Q > 100, when said and done -- a Tokamak reactor will cost 10x much as the equal-grade fission reactor, and cost >10x as much to operate. As fission reactors are today not competitive, and get less competitive by the day, power from Tokamak fusion will not ever be lighting up your house. That is not a bad thing: solar and wind are wholly up to the task, and just need building out. The more there is, the cheaper it gets.
The only reliable product of the hot-neutron fusion research industry is dishonesty.
There is also aneutronic fusion, that might actually have a future, even if only in space: If we are ever to operate in the outer solar system, something of the sort will be needed. Unfortunately it gets almost no money.
- joss82 5y ago> The more there is, the cheaper it gets. This also applies to nuclear fusion (and, BTW, fission) reactors.
- ncmncm 5y agoTokamak fusion can only ever be far more expensive, per watt and per watt-hour, than existing fission. Fission is getting more expensive all the time.
- chmod775 5y ago> Tokamak fusion can only ever be far more expensive, per watt and per watt-hour, than existing fission. Why?
- ncmncm 5y agoThe energy flux density in the most compressed plasma imaginable is orders of magnitude less than in fissile uranium. So, to match power out, it has to be big. Really, really big. And a fusion reaction chamber is a much more expensive affair than a fission pile: super high-tech materials and construction, enormous magnets (blasted by the hot-neutron flux output), piping for thousands of tons of melted lithium that have to be replaced (by robots! because super radioactive) every couple of years as the neutrons destroy them. The (radioactive) lithium itself, and containment for if it breaks out of the piping. Continuous processing of the lithium to extract synthetic tritium for fuel. Heat exchangers for lithium to a working fluid that won't pick up radioactivity, and more heat exchangers from that to water for steam. And then the usual steam turbines, which demand regular, very expensive maintenance. Cooling towers to condense the steam, after. A hundred billion dollars estimated for one several GW plant, and decades for construction. Meanwhile, solar and wind get cheaper every year, with no bottom in sight. The longer they take on fusion, the less competitive it gets, and it starts out way behind, with no possibility of ever catching up.
- _0w8t 5y agoThis was with previous designs of fusion reactors. Read about proposed Ark and currently constructing Spark reactors. By using stronger superconductive magnets it was possible to reduce the size of the plant by order of magnitude. Spark even has a chance to get to Q>1 before ITER and it’s chamber is less than 2m in diameter. Plus it is possible to replace its parts without disassembling the whole reactor. [1] - https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/SPARC_(tokamak) https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/SPARC_(tokamak)
- ncmncm 5y agoThat might be nice if they had solutions to the other problems not addressed (see above). But operating it will necessarily still be enormously more expensive than solar or wind, which cost practically nothing. Somebody with one leg can do a lot better in a race than somebody with none, but that is not the measure to consider when the competition is with two-legged runners. (Hint: they win.)
- _0w8t 5y agoIn Europe after the last autumn when for months there were little wind and cloudy sky there is a realization that energy based purely on renewables will require much bigger storage and much more solar or at least significantly more expensive solar that works under clouds. Doable, but cost is non-trivial. So if any of fusion startups can make operating plant within the next 20 years, it can be used. But if that takes longer, then I agree that large-scale fusion will not happen.
- pfdietz 5y agoLong term darkness/calm is solved with hydrogen. Europe has plenty of underground geology suitable for mass hydrogen storage (it's just like natural gas is stored.) Most of the energy still would go directly from solar/wind to the grid, or through efficient batteries, so the low round trip efficiency of power to gas to power doesn't matter much.
- rob74 5y agoI'm not that familiar with the subject, but this phrase sounds suspiciously like the 1943 IBM executive saying there is a market for only five computers in the world - i.e. it completely discounts technological progress. Of course, this progress has been painfully slow until now, but comparing it with fission is still unfair - fission is well-researched and it getting more expensive is tied to the inherent dangers of radioactivity (and the ever more complicated measures which try to mitigate them), and the costs of spent fuel storage.
- ncmncm 5y agoFission getting more expensive is tied to the very lucrative fully-legal corruption industry. Once a fission plant construction project is started, the money starts flowing, and is practically impossible to stop. If it is ever finished, the money would stop, and nobody actually involved wants that ever to happen, at least not until their kids graduate college. So the project blows through deadline after deadline, and cost overruns pile up without limit, until somebody manages to pull the plug. Once it looks like the money will stop regardless, there is some incentive to deliver a reactor; we saw that in Finland recently. South Carolina is the more typical cancellation after billions are spent, except in that case with a few indictments. Normally nobody gets indicted, and nobody ever has to give any money back.
- hallway_monitor 5y agoWow this is brutal but feels like it's correct. What a frightening state of affairs. Is the construction industry really so corrupt? Is government and industry unaware or unwilling/unable to detect this earlier and stop it?
- hunter-gatherer 5y agoI spent some fair amount of years as both a government employee in DoD and then some years as a defense contractor amd I can tell you the military industrial complex is a real thing. In my contracting days I worked with a handful of DoE engineers that were more familiar with reactor projects and as I understood it, reactor peojects basically follow the same type of workflow as any big DoD prohect. So OPs comment is much in line with my understanding of the issue. It is an unfortunate state of affairs.
- pfdietz 5y agoActually, fission power plants have shown a distressing lack of good experience effects. They got more expensive as more were built, not less expensive.
- vlovich123 5y agoFission did keep getting cheaper up until FUD about accidents and explosions caused regulations that strangled it (that and overblown fears about proliferation of nuclear weapons).
- pfdietz 5y agoYeah, like all those whiners complaining about how first generation BWR containment was totally inadequate. Never mind what happened at Fukushima, right? /s
- vlovich123 5y agoThe amount of accidents and their severity does not line up with the disproportion strangling the technology has experienced at the hands of regulators. If we go down that road, all coal plants should be shut down long ago as they’ve been responsible for more radiation-caused deaths than all nuclear deaths combined (including due to the bombs if I recall correctly). That’s not even counting the deaths they’ve caused through air pollution. Heck, nuclear is still competitive with solar and wind in terms of deaths/MW produced. And this is all the more stark considering nuclear designs stagnated 60 years or so ago. If we hadn’t divested from that technological path we’d have drastically cheaper and safer nuclear energy today and global warming potentially wouldn’t even be a problem.
- ClumsyPilot 5y ago> fission reactors are today not competitive, and get less competitive by the day No, we are just incompetent idiots. This has nothing to do with fissions and everything to do with degradation of contruction and practical egnineering skills - now it takes 30 years and 100 billion dollars to make a small railway in California. Victorian England or China could do this without much trouble. The english-speaking western nations have definitively and measurably degraded - every time an airport or a port or any major piece of infrastructure needs to be built, its a source of drama and infighting for 30 years. A nuclear powerplant is just a big construction project, and nations that can build a railway without a fuss, have demonstrated their ability to build a reactor without a fuss. We are going to have to fix this if we don't want to decline into barbarity in the next 100 years. We can trade and launder the world's money and stocks but we can't build a bridge. Eventually the physical really will catch up to us "cough climate change', and you can't bribe laws of nature. Sure you can 'cheat' by buying pre-built solar panels and wind turbines made in China, but you will have to build storage for them, the only proven viable storage is large scale hydro, so you are back as square one. I have a suspicion that the layer of our society responsible for management and oversight of these projects, both in government and private sectors, is much more inconpetent than that of rival nations, and maybe that's an area to explore.
- sdesalas 5y ago> This has nothing to do with fissions and everything to do with degradation of contruction and practical egnineering skills - now it takes 30 years and 100 billion dollars to make a small railway in California. Victorian England or China could do this without much trouble. Not to mention over-regulation driven by a general lack of political will. Its easier to win some votes by bashing nuclear than stand by it, even if it is the most likely alternative for baseload power in a carbon-free energy mix.
- ncmncm 5y agoIt is much simpler than that: fission is mature tech; its cost is not on the way down. Solar costs are still in free fall, wind almost as much so. The cheaper those get, the less competitive fission gets, just standing still. The corruption tax on fission projects just exacerbates its structural problem.
- criley2 5y agoSolar and wind are not and likely will never be "wholly up to the task" unless you install about 4X as much as you need, which is quite the tall order and certainly changes the numbers. You might say "solar is cheaper per MW than fission" but someone planning your local grid sees "I need to setup 4X the solar MW that I do fission, and I need a battery solution as well" and the numbers look very different. A great example is Germany over the past year had uncharacteristically low wind for months and months on end, dropping power generation by as much as 30% for the year from that source. The result? They burned A LOT of gas and coal. A LOT. The reality is that power use doesn't necessarily follow the sun or the wind, and so buildouts of those technologies need to be done at extreme multiples of baseline need to account for entire seasons of low output (or just burn hydrocarbons...). You have to build your wind and solar to support a hypothetical 10 or 50 year minimum production, and just overproduce at all times. This is why baseload nuclear generation will remain a fantastic choice for nations for decades to come, even at a higher price. Nuclear runs at night. It runs when the wind is still. It runs and runs and run no matter what, providing consistent and predictable power. For every MW generated by nuclear, you need about 4 produced by solar/wind, to achieve the same up-time and reliability. And that's before we discuss the ecological concerns of one tiny little nuclear facility versus dozens of square kilometers of solar/battery builds out to match it. If our society abandons fission in favor of solar/wind only, it will be to our detriment
- Retric 5y agoBase load isn’t an inherent advantage it’s strictly worse than dispatchable power unless it’s cheap, and Nuclear isn’t that cheap. Which is a problem because excess wind and solar makes Nuclear power economically worthless for much of the day. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dispatchable_generation#/media/File:Renewables_need_flexible_backup_not_baseload.png https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dispatchable_generation#/media... Subsides could make up the difference for nuclear as could vastly increased nighttime prices. PS: It’s only when your looking at islands like say Hawaii where you want that kind of massive overproduction. Across larger areas you never see 100% production from everywhere at the same time, but you also don’t see minimum production from everywhere at the same time.
- 5y ago
- dreamcompiler 5y ago> solar and wind are wholly up to the task, and just need building out. This. Every time I read a fusion "breakthrough" story I imagine the history books of the year 3000: "Back in the early 21st century, they spent billions trying to build a star on Earth, when there was a perfectly good one in the sky that produced 1000W per square meter that they could have used for free."
- zaphar 5y agoWe do not have enough energy storage capability to rely completely on Solar and Wind yet. Both are intermittent producers so to get truly reliable power from them we need storage capacity. There are projects that promise to meet that need but positioning solar and wind as all we need is not a true statement.
- pfdietz 5y ago> We do not have enough energy storage capability to rely completely on Solar and Wind yet. How is this an interesting argument? Of course we don't have things before we build them. That's true of nuclear power plants, too. We can likely build out storage faster than NPPs, with more aggressive cost decline with cumulative production.
- dahfizz 5y agoI put numbers in another comment, but this isn't a "just build some more batteries" type of problem. The scale of storage needed completely dwarfs our current production capacity. This problem cannot be solved in the near future, with current production/technology.
- ncmncm 5y agoIt is dishonest to pretend batteries are the only viable storage method.
- idiotsecant 5y ago>We can likely build out storage faster than NPPs First, this is yet to be determined. Even assuming it is true, which I'm not sure it is, The problem is not limited to storage - you also need massive transmission system upgrades that will cost on the same order of magnitude as an Apollo program. I think in the long term it should certainly be done, but pretending that the cost of solar and wind power is the cost of solar panels, or even the cost of solar panels + storage is not comparing apples to apples.
- Angostura 5y ago> But it is always a con. I think you should rephrase that, because it's pretty insulting to researchers who have been working incredibly hard on taking steps towards Fusion. I think the phrase you were grasping for is: "I doubt it will ever be economically viable".
- ncmncm 5y agoThe con is in calling every last incremental improvement a "breakthrough". No, you didn't break through anything. The only upcoming breakthrough is the plasma eroding a hole in the chamber wall.
- pfdietz 5y agoBe fair. It's the relativistic electron beam from a disruption that's going to do that, not the plasma itself. :)
- garyrob 5y ago"They are forever smashing this or that record, on the verge of break-even, on track to producing free energy without nasty radionuclides." Hacker News comment in late 19th century: "They are forever making flying machines have a little more lift, on the verge of break-even, on track to enabling free flight without nasty immediate crashes. But it is always a con.... The only reliable product of flying machine research is dishonesty."
- wpietri 5y agoOh? By your logic, we shouldn't say negative things about perpetual motion machines, as they keep getting better and who knows what the future holds! The truth is that people both over- and under-estimate what can happen in the future. You can't use simple-minded heuristics either way; technoutopianism is at least as dangerous as blind opposition to change.
- Intermernet 5y agoWe have currently demonstrable laws of physics stating why perpetual motion can't be achieved. We have a visible universe of examples of fusion. Not saying that fusion power on earth is viable (I personally think that it is), but it's disingenuous to compare it to perpetual motion.
- pfdietz 5y agoI think the obstacles to practical, competitive fusion power, particularly DT fusion, and especially the mainstream approach of JET/ITER, are so great that calling investment in it "the economic equivalent of perpetual motion" is not far off.
- wpietri 5y agoGood thing I didn't compare fusion to perpetual motion, then. I was pointing out that his too-simple approach could be easily misapplied, and picked an especially obvious negative example to counter his especially obvious positive one. At this point we just don't know whether fusion is like airplanes or whether it's like perpetual motion. Unless you are proposing building an actual star, the existence of stars tells us approximately nothing about whether a fusion-based power plant is economically achievable in our lifetimes. I think it's an interesting idea and I'd love to see it happen. But I think it's important to be realistic in our discussion of it.
- orthecreedence 5y ago> That is not a bad thing: solar and wind are wholly up to the task Exactly! If we just used every last drop of fossil fuels we had to build, ship, and constantly replace solar and wind generators (and do the same for the massive battery arrays we'll need), nuclear will be a distant memory. > fission reactors are today not competitive ...because price =/= cost. Fission is the least costly form of energy generation, but our economy is too worthlessly opaque to realize the true cost of building all those beloved solar panels. If we got price and cost more in parity, nuclear would be the painfully obvious choice. Markets fail yet again, I suppose. > The only reliable product of the hot-neutron fusion research industry is dishonesty. I can agree with you there. Every few months there's a "breakthrough!!" article where Qtotal is still < 0.01...cool, that's helpful...
- pfdietz 5y ago> Fission is the least costly form of energy generation This has ceased to be true.
- hinkley 5y agoWhen these things become viable they’re likely to be competing with battery storage systems for cheap power to start and restart the reactors. Though I suspect they’re likely to form partnerships, those partnerships will end up being profit sharing and blunt the prospects of such a plant.