22 ms·
FAA says 5G could impact radio altimeters on most Boeing 737s
- luibelgo 5y agoOriginal press release https://www.faa.gov/newsroom/faa-statements-5g https://www.faa.gov/newsroom/faa-statements-5g
- sschueller 5y agoIs this a failure of the FCC to properly hand out frequencies?
- mulmen 5y agoYes. They knew the dangers but the telcos wanted frequency. So the FCC attempted to undermine the aviation industry group that actually knows how radar altimeters work. Blancolirio covers this in several videos, although his take is more nuanced than mine. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=942KXXmMJdY https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=942KXXmMJdY
- atkailash 5y ago
- tempnow987 5y agoAbsolutely garbage reporting. The FAA / Boeing have no right to the frequencies in question. Even worse, they were given guard bands the size of their entire allocation which is ridiculous, and it still wasn't enough.
- mulmen 5y agoJuan Browne is an ex-military and current commercial pilot. I trust him to explain how radar altimeters work and what they are used for.
- Sanzig 5y agoWhile this should have been better studied before the spectrum was allocated, it's not really the fault of the FCC. These radar altimeters have very wide front-ends, as as a result are highly susceptible to out-of-band emissions. The radars are allocated from 4.2 to 4.4 GHz, so the bottom edge of the radar altimeter band is 200 MHz above the top end of the 5G band in question (3.98 GHz). The fact that these radar altimeters are susceptible to out-of-band interference that is literally further away in the spectrum than the width of their entire allocation is IMO an engineering failure. Yes, spectrum management (rightfully) tends to err on the side of not forcing the incumbents to make modifications to existing systems. However, better filtering would resolve this issue and it is shocking that the engineers who designed them didn't foresee that other services would eventually be allocated in adjacent bands. Avionics is often NRE dominated, they couldn't have sprung for a cavity filter? Or if that was too expensive, designed more headroom in the LNA before saturation and filtered the out of band signal with a crystal or SAW filter at IF? Rejecting out of band that far away is not rocket science. I don't think it's unreasonable in this case to temporarily suspend the rollout and give the aviation industry a deadline to fix its radars, but it should only be temporary. Any other radio service would be told to take a hike if it keeled over due to out of band interference that far away.
- jandrese 5y agoThis seems like Boeing trying to get the government to cover their butt because they did shoddy work on the altimeters. They were allocated spectrum for the equipment and then built a system that monopolized frequencies well outside of the allocated spectrum. I completely agree that Boeing needs to issue a recall order on all affected hardware and provide a fix. This should be painful, it is basically punishment for trying to cut corners on safety equipment.
- kube-system 5y agoDoes Boeing even make the radio altimeters?
- jandrese 5y ago
- mdasen 5y agoYes and no. Many other countries are using C-Band, but often under slightly different conditions. Some countries licensed frequencies that stop significantly farther away from the spectrum used by radio altimeters. Some countries have mandated lower power levels for C-Band. Some countries have created larger exclusion areas around all airports (rather than the smaller, temporary exclusion areas around some airports in the US). Some countries have mandated a downward tilt for C-Band antenna panels (nationwide or in areas around airports) so that the transmissions aren't going go up as much (but a downward tilt also limits the transmission range which is bad for wireless carriers). I think one of the big things in the US is that anything that makes C-Band harder to work with makes it hard for 2 of the 3 wireless carriers to compete. T-Mobile has a lot of 2.5GHz spectrum that it has been using to launch high-speed 5G services. Verizon and AT&T had been waiting for their C-Band spectrum to be usable to launch their high-speed 5G services. In Europe, if all carriers are facing the same restrictions, it's a level playing field. In the US, if Verizon and AT&T face restrictions that T-Mobile doesn't face (for most of its spectrum since it's 2.5GHz and not C-Band), that doesn't offer a level playing field. I think it's also more contentious in the US because we have a much more suburban and rural population. Transmission distance is really important in the US because people expect to get modern services even in low-density areas. Verizon built its business on the idea that you should expect excellent wireless coverage even in places that have virtually no people. I think another part of it is that the FAA is often very cautious and it seems like they didn't coordinate well with the FCC in voicing their concerns early on enough. The FAA does have a web page on C-Band (https://www.faa.gov/5g https://www.faa.gov/5g) which is their official stance on the subject. They cite "Lower power levels, antennas adjusted to reduce potential interference to flights, different placement of antennas relative to airfields , and frequencies with a different proximity to frequencies used by aviation equipment" as reasons why the C-Band situation in the US is different from that in other countries. Is the FAA being too cautious? Maybe. Ultimately, no one wants their business plans disrupted. Airlines don't want to see issues that delay landings. Verizon and AT&T don't want to see things that delay their ability to provide fast 5G service.
- jjtheblunt 5y agois this a failure of the lobbying system, with Qualcomm funding something in their interest which is contrary to aviation interests? (I mean that i do not know the answer)
- jamesdwilson 5y agoAdd it to the list of reasons to not get on a 737
- alkonaut 5y agoMost 737s are among the safest planes ever built (because they aren't MAX). Whether or not the MAX will live up to the safety record of the previous gen going forward is yet to be seen.
- jacquesm 5y agoGoing forward? You don't get to wipe off a chunk of the graph that you don't like, the crashes that happened and the flights that happened without crashes are all part of the MAX safety record (oh, and that goes for the 'rebranded' version as well).
- alkonaut 5y agoNo one is wiping. By “going forward” I mean that if the corrections prove working then for each flight hour the safety record improves in the sense of accidents per flight hour. The MAX safety record is terrible because there are many incidents per flight hour. Not because there are many incidents. It needs to fly about 10M flights per fatal accident to be catching up with the 737 NG.
- eric__cartman 5y agoThe Boeing 737 design was introduced 50+ years ago and is still used (albeit not in 50 year old planes) today in a multitude of airlines for passenger travel. That said the 737 MAX fuckup is something that neither Boeing, or the many worldwide air travel regulatory institutions should be forgiven for. But that doesn't make the 737 design itself bad. That particular iteration, due to Boeing's attempt undertake Airbus and falsely sell the planes to airlines as a drop in replacement with zero extra training needed unfortunately resulted in deadly crashes. The people that decided on that should be charged on the deaths that occured because of their greediness.
- Damogran6 5y agoIs this last month's news or something new?
- ameminator 5y agoWow, this along with potential interference problems in weather radar [0], it's obvious the FCC bungled allocating the 5G spectrum. What a shame that they gave into industry pressure over other practical considerations. However, it doesn't surprise me that the FAA, which allowed the Boeing 737Max fiasco, is back here coming to Boeing's defense. What happens when 2 captured regulators collide? Edit: added spacing and changed "radio" to "radar" for clarity [0] https://www.npr.org/2019/07/02/737919100/forecasters-caution-5g-will-interfere-with-gathering-weather-data https://www.npr.org/2019/07/02/737919100/forecasters-caution...
- vmception 5y ago> What happens when 2 captured regulators collide? When moneyed interests compete it becomes the same as their being no moneyed interests An average case outcome Not obvious what would happen here though, just a general reality that mostly undermines the “rich shadow organization controlling everything” idea
- dogleash 5y ago>When moneyed interests compete it becomes the same as their being no moneyed interests No. That's very incorrect. For example: Moneyed Interest #1 wants A & B, Moneyed Interest #2 wants A & Not-B. It's entirely possible that Not-A is a bad business model, but is also in the interest of the citizenry at large to have Not-A be law.
- vmception 5y agoOk, you’re right they can have niches and get their model regulations
- LeoPanthera 5y agoFor clarity, "weather radio" is usually used as the name for the broadcast service operated by the NOAA on 162MHz. This remains unaffected. You are describing the 23.8GHz radar used by satellites.
- purplezooey 5y ago
- Clubber 5y agoWe should starve the beast but keep taxes so we can pay for the overspending over the last 40 years. Why feed the beast when it just does whatever the donors tell it. It's no longer our beast.
- ugjka 5y agoIs 3.7-3.98 GHz range somehow particularly useful for mobile operators?
- mdasen 5y agoIt's not that it's particularly useful so much as it's available. The FCC has been clearing spectrum because more spectrum means that carriers can offer faster 5G services. Mid-band spectrum (in the 2.5-6GHz range) is particularly useful because it offers a good combination of range (measured in miles) while still having a decent amount of spectrum available and the possibility of things light higher-order MIMO to offer capacity gains. Millimeter-wave spectrum (in the 20-50GHz range) has lots of spectrum available, but its range is often in the 50-300 foot range. It's also important to realize that because we're talking about a radius, when we turn that into a circle the difference gets magnified. A 1 mile range means covering 88M square feet. A 100 foot range means covering 31,000 square feet. 53x more range turns into 2,800x more area covered. Initial 5G networks in the US often used 5-20MHz of low-band spectrum (below 1GHz). This does have some utility as 5G NR is marginally more efficient, even in low-band spectrum. However, deploying with 100-200MHz of mid-band spectrum offers the kind of huge gains that offer 10x (or even more) data speeds. https://assets.weforum.org/editor/SPPQ747R8Fd63ilAo4xvfjMNFUCJQ5-jI9T_YyLQ4OU.jpg https://assets.weforum.org/editor/SPPQ747R8Fd63ilAo4xvfjMNFU... There isn't really a lot of spectrum that hasn't been allocated so it's often a game of figuring out who you can move for the least cost and most benefit. They chose to move C-Band satellite operators (at a cost of billions). Previously, the FCC freed up spectrum in the 600MHz range by having TV broadcasters relocate from UHF channels above 37 to lower channels.
- enos_feedler 5y agoSo what kind of settlement do we anticipate as compensation to Verizon and AT&T for allowing them to bid and purchase spectrum and then not allowing them to capture value from that spectrum, post-purchase? Seems like a slam dunk for a hefty payout of some kind.
- InitialLastName 5y agoYou could pull it directly out of the pockets of the aircraft manufacturers who had years of opportunities to flag and fix these issues, too.
- enos_feedler 5y agoYes. C-band and it's usage for 5G didn't just turn up yesterday. Even if they do get payouts they will just it to give every customer free Apple/Samsung stuff.
- p_l 5y agoIn "aviation time", they turned up yesterday. Allocations everywhere else either are further away from radar altimeter frequencies, or follow similar mitigations to those proposed by FAA... for the very reason that aviation world was involved from the get go. But FCC selling allocation all the way to 3.98GHz with no mitigations happened very recently, while there are still worries (that are being verified) that 400MHz guard band might be not enough in case of transmitter failure.
- Ftuuky 5y agoAlmost don't want to fly on Boeings ever again...
- haggy 5y agoThe article body and headline are (of course) at odds IMO. The headline is very much "doomscroll" material while the article points out that interference could basically manifest as having to rely on secondary systems and protocols to land. If I'm missing something then happy to be corrected :D
- jandrese 5y agoAirline accidents almost never have a single cause. It requires multiple failures to align before you have disaster. Malfunctioning radio altimeters could be one of those factors. That said, this is Boeing's fault. They need to clean up their act ASAP, and it seems like they've been banking on the FCC covering up their mess and are now running around with their hair on fire. A reasonable stopgap may be to simply not allow 5G towers to use the frequencies ranges in question within some radius of an airport (20 miles?) for a few years until Boeing fixes the problem.
- jreese 5y agoA 20 mile radius of any airport likely covers a significant portion (60-70%) of all urban/suburban population. They might as well just give up on that spectrum at that point.
- mcguire 5y ago""5G interference could adversely affect the ability of aircraft to safely operate," said the bosses of Boeing and Airbus Americas, Dave Calhoun and Jeffrey Knittel, in a joint letter to US Transportation Secretary Pete Buttigieg. ""Airbus and Boeing have been working with other aviation industry stakeholders in the US to understand potential 5G interference with radio altimeters," Airbus said in a statement." https://www.bbc.com/news/business-59737194 https://www.bbc.com/news/business-59737194
- ChicagoBoy11 5y agoAnyone know what that interference would look like in a cockpit? Would it be immediately recognizable as something wholly inaccurate in the radio altimeter (or even no reading whatsoever) or is there the chance that it produces an ever so slightly different reading? The opposite, of course, being the far worse scenario.
- kube-system 5y agoAs I understand (not a pilot but just interested in aviation), these altimeters are critical for use during low visibility landings, to determine when it may be safe to continue landing, or when they must abort landing (e.g. if they can't see the ground yet because of fog) Being wholly inaccurate or no reading may be equally dangerous if it happens at the wrong time.
- tempnow987 5y agoThe idea they can have this type of interference low to the ground in a landing situation (when the reflected power is high) is a total failure on behalf of boeing. I can't even fully get my head around the physics that would get you an issue with even normal filtering, much less what once should be able to do on an airplane with high fixed costs and safety of life factors. Amazing they can't do GPS as a cross check on indicated altitude over a terrain model.
- vel0city 5y ago> Amazing they can't do GPS as a cross check on indicated altitude over a terrain model. I mean they could, but they skimped out on just getting a halfway decent filter for frequencies 200MHz away from their signals what are the odds they'd pay for that.
- tjohns 5y agoNo, they really can't. At least not until GBAS is rolled out. GPS is notoriously unreliable for altitude data. GPS altitude is used for LPV approaches, provided you also have a WAAS correction signal, but those require higher weather minimums than the Cat II/III approaches that you'd use a radio altimeter for.
- luxuryballs 5y agoWhy do we even need 5G it seems like there’s always something, whether real or tinfoil, risks and unknown risks, so at one point do we decide that what we have is good enough? Is there not any room in the regulatory world for “better safe than sorry”? At some point we could maybe just stop adding new energy waves to the sky. It’s like the Wi-Fi router thing, it’s to the point where I’m going to need to buy a big piece of land to live on just so I don’t have 50 different Wi-Fi networks bombarding my house 24/7. I mean they say it’s safe to have a Wi-Fi router but did they study having 50 at once?
- doikor 5y ago> Why do we even need 5G Ever tried to use 4G in a crowded place? Network congestion is the main reason.
- Johnny555 5y agodid they study having 50 at once Wifi signal drops off with the square of your distance from the radio. So if you feel safe sitting 5 feet from your own router, you're only getting 1/25th as much signal from your neighbor's router 25 feet away (well, almost certainly less since it's going through walls, windows, etc). (some factors can change this, like if he has a high gain directional antenna pointed directly at you, you could see more power from his router than from your own) So unless you're sitting in a Wifi router store surrounded by wifi routers, you're not getting irradiated by 50X more power even if your computer can see 50 wifi networks around you.
- vkou 5y ago> Why do we even need 5G it seems like there’s always something, whether real or tinfoil, risks and unknown risks, so at one point do we decide that what we have is good enough? Because it consists of non-ionizing EM waves, the risks of which are very well understood. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=i4pxw4tYeCU https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=i4pxw4tYeCU And if you're concerned about the amount of non-ionizing EM waves in your environment from these 50 wi-fi networks, you should never go outside, since the sun is constantly blasting you with ~1,000,0000 GHZ-frequency electromagnetic waves, at an energy flux of ~1300 watts/square meter. It's half a dozen orders of magnitude more[1] energy than those fifty wi-fi networks are putting out. They aren't even a rounding error. The only thing the 5G 'controversy' reveals is that the public is happy to listen to people who don't know anything, as long as they are being told what they want to hear. [1] Not just more energy, more dangerous energy. Solar radiation, unlike 5G, is actually ionizing. Those radiation waves carry enough energy to break molecular bonds in your body.
- tyingq 5y agoSomewhat amusing that the radio altimeters in 737-200 models aren't affected, while all others are. The 200 models entered service in the late 1960s.
- flerchin 5y agoI figured that meant that the 200s don't have radio altimeters.
- tyingq 5y agoNo, they do have them. Here's the actual text, so it's only some of the 200's that are unaffected: "Based on Boeing’s data, the FAA identified an additional hazard presented by 5G C-Band interference on The Boeing Company Model 737-100, -200, -200C, -300, -400, -500, -600, -700, -700C, -800, -900, and -900ER series airplanes, except for Model 737-200 and -200C series airplanes equipped with an SP-77 flight control system" And the SP-77 does include a radio altimeter...apparently a nicely selective one. https://public-inspection.federalregister.gov/2022-03967.pdf https://public-inspection.federalregister.gov/2022-03967.pdf
- United857 5y agoMaybe I'm missing something obvious but why just Boeing? Does Airbus use a different band and if so, why doesn't Boeing switch to solve the problem?
- ummonk 5y agoBoeing’s receivers are picking up radio signals well outside the band allocated to radio altimeters - they got away with this until now because the nearby bands were unused.
- reincarnate0x14 5y agoFrom my understanding, Boeing's radars will receive a much wider band than Airbus', combined with most other countries allocating 5G spectrum further away from the expected radar frequencies. They could switch but it would involve massive effort and possible recertification of the airframes.
- p_l 5y agoBoeing and Airbus (and others) buy radar altimeters from the same vendors. It just happens that Boeing finished checking out a bunch of configurations that they have sold in the past against interference from 5G under FCC allocation (AFAIK they previously checked against setups allowed in other countries), and published results. Airbus and others are also performing extra tests now.
- p_l 5y agoBad reporting, simply. This issue hits ALL PLANES that use standard frequency radar altimeters. Including Airbus, Bombardier, Cessna, Learjet, Dassault, etc. What happened is that aside from trying to put limits on transmission characteristics for C-band near airports, there is a concerted action to verify how the many different models of radar altimeters interact with 5G interference. This is a report on configurations sold by Boeing, from Boeing, as they went over all configurations they've sold of specific types.
- fshbbdssbbgdd 5y agoI don’t know much about aviation or electrical engineering, and I’m wondering if anyone could help me understand something. It seems like the telecom and aviation industries (along with the FCC and FAA) disagree on a question of fact: does 5G equipment interfere with radio altimeters? There’s a way that the FAA could convince me, and probably all the politicians. Shoot a video with a radio altimeter and some 5G equipment where the radio altimeter malfunctions. Put it on YouTube. Do a press release. This seems like an obvious step if the underlying issue exists. Any reason they haven’t done this?
- ethbr0 5y agoMy guess is that RF interference is not binary. So the question is not "Does 5G equipment interfere with radio altimeters?" but rather "Could 5G equipment ever interfere with radio altimeters, under any set of feasible conditions?" Which is a harder question to answer, but how seriously we should (and usually do) take air safety.
- moonchrome 5y agoIf you can't reproduce those conditions in an artificial scenario setup to exaggerate the effect - how are they feasible ?
- bluGill 5y agoThe question isn't can you reproduce it in an artificial setup, the question is can you do it in the real world? I can think of a lot of ways to cheat in the lab (turn the power to 11...) that create situations that in the real world wouldn't happen and so I wouldn't worry about it. However that doesn't change the fact that if you can recreate it in the real world I'm really worried.
- markmark 5y agoHere's the RCTA report where they reproduced those conditions and showed they were feasible: https://www.rtca.org/wp-content/uploads/2020/10/SC-239-5G-Interference-Assessment-Report_274-20-PMC-2073_accepted_changes.pdf https://www.rtca.org/wp-content/uploads/2020/10/SC-239-5G-In... The way you test this stuff is get a rad-alt and inject known amounts of RF and see how much is needed to give false readings. Then you go and measure how much RF you'll see in the environment and see if it exceeds those levels. Here's a choice quote from the summary: "In the worst case, the safe interference limit for the fundamental emissions is exceeded by over 47 dB, and the safe interference limit for the spurious emissions is exceeded by over 27 dB."
- fancyfredbot 5y agoIn Europe there are Boeing 737s and 5G C band radio masts. I'm guessing the laws of physics are the same in Europe. So I'm confused. What are they doing differently there? Why don't the US do the same thing?
- dcdc123 5y agoEU C-band rollouts are 200Mhz lower than in the US, making for almost twice as much gap between them. That said, EU is still starting to get worried [0] after some tests showed malfunctioning equipment can cause interference. [0] https://strandconsult.dk/blog/5g-is-suddenly-a-flight-safety-concern-amid-rapid-network-roll-out-in-the-us-strand-consult-investigates-with-leading-eu-spectrum-and-public-safety-communications-expert/ https://strandconsult.dk/blog/5g-is-suddenly-a-flight-safety...
- DocTomoe 5y agoWe (Europeans) use other frequency bands for 5G: 700 MHz, 1.8, 2.1 and 2.7 GHz. That's comfortably far away from the 4.2 GHz band radio altimeters use. Why the US decided to use 3.8 GHz for their 5G, only God knows.
- stingrae 5y agoIt is a poor design on the part of the altimeter designers. 200MHz should be plenty far away.
- mcguire 5y agoOr poor design on the part of 5G transmitter designers?
- snovv_crash 5y agoThe problem is the altimeters listening outside of their band, not the transmitters speaking outside of theirs. 200Mhz is an eternity away. You can fit all of the 2.4GHz WiFi/Bluetooth/whatever unlicensed band in that.
- FrameworkFred 5y agoI'm no expert, but why can't we just add some regulation that says the insurance carriers will be responsible for any liability beyond 2024 (or whatever) and that they're free to charge whatever they want based on the make and model of the altimeter in use on the plane?
- rtkwe 5y agoWhy not make something safe instead of trying to end run an economic incentive to safety? Airplanes are one of the safest per mile form of transportation in the US because we regulate the actual safe flight instead of playing economic games to get companies to act safely.
- FrameworkFred 5y agoI'm suggesting this may be a viable alternative given that this has been a known potential issue for quite some time now and the aviation industry appears to be dragging their feet on replacing the faulty gear. It seems to me premiums that approach or exceed the cost of an upgrade would encourage them to get moving on the fix. On the other hand, maybe it makes more sense for insurance carriers to simply refuse to assume liability for flights on airplanes with altimeters that are known to have issues with 5G tech. That approach seems to work for discouraging new construction in floodplains.
- kube-system 5y agoInsurance is generally a reverse-looking science and does a really bad job at proactively measuring risk. You save more lives by having an engineer analyze potential problems with the plane before it crashes, than you do by waiting for one to crash so an actuary can count it.
- LatteLazy 5y agoSorry to rant, but... I drives me nuts when people use "could" in this context. 5G has been in development for over a decade I think. It's been deployed in the real world since 2019. So what the fuck have the FAA and FCC been doing in that time? You would have thought someone would have actually determined whether 5G can interfere with one of the most popular commercial aircraft? Really? No one checked? No one asked? This has been a mainstream news story for 4 weeks. And no one at the FAA or FCC has put a 5G antenna next to an 737 and even tried check? No one has put together pilots logs or looked at aircraft systems logs? And in that time presumably 100s of 737s have taken off and landed and flown over these? At this point, we know 2 things: It's very unlikely this an issue or we'd have seen a lot of serious incidents probably including an actual crash AND we need a federal organisation that manages aircraft safety and another for communications including EM spectrum to avoid inference and we don't actually seem to have either. I work with trading tech. Nothing complex or amazing. Just money, nothing safety critical. Sometimes things break or we have bugs. I can say a lot of things to my boss when something goes wrong, I can't say "It could be a massive problem, but I haven't bothered checking despite having 4 weeks to at least start" so I don't really know.
- sgc 5y agoI see their statements as indicating that they do know in fact there are failure modes that will occur some of the time. When you use could in this context, it's to indicate that it won't happen in all circumstances, not that you don't know if it can happen at all.
- LatteLazy 5y agoThat's what gets me: they don't seem to know. Or at least they don't want to say? If they know there is an (intermittent, occasional) issue then ground the planes. Don't announce it, but cryptically and then do nothing and wait for a few 100 deaths. If they know there isn't a problem then shut up. And if they don't know, why the fuck don't they know after (at least) 4 weeks of testing. Can't they at least say all tests fine or 99% of tests fine or we crashed 4 planes but maybe the test pilots were just bad?
- 5y ago
- metacritic12 5y agoThere seems to be evidence that there's just a turf war going on: https://www.wsj.com/articles/pete-buttigiegs-5g-crash-landing-airlines-wireless-carriers-steve-dickson-faa-fcc-11641337368 https://www.wsj.com/articles/pete-buttigiegs-5g-crash-landin... Overall it seems like the FCC was trying to be innovative, while the FAA's precaution in fact is the malaise that's been infecting all of US government: overapplication of the precautionary principle, that any risk, even if small an theoretical, is worth stopping change for (but not asymmetrically for motivating change).
- theYipster 5y agoWhen it comes to commercial air transport, you don't want the FAA to take a different approach to safety. Aviation works today because of its safety culture.
- f3rnando 5y agoDont blame it on the waves
- oplav 5y agoVery anecdotal, but a flight my wife was on 3 weeks ago returned to the terminal before takeoff and had to switch planes because of an altimeter malfunction. The pilot cited it was because people didn’t turn off airplane mode.
- thamer 5y agoIf the page says that "you have reached your article limit": http://archive.today/a4pso http://archive.today/a4pso
- protomyth 5y agoAINdebrief recently had a podcast episode (#46 for January 31, 2022) on this subject. https://www.ainonline.com/podcast/aindebrief/aindebrief-episode-46-january-31-2022 https://www.ainonline.com/podcast/aindebrief/aindebrief-epis... In this episode, AIN contributing editor Mark Huber explains the 5G C-band interference issue that can affect aircraft radar altimeters. He explains how we even got into this situation, why there is the potential for the 5G wireless networks at Verizon and AT&T to interfere with radar altimeters, what the FAA is currently doing to temporarily ease the problem, and what can be done long term to solve this issue.
- eftychis 5y agoMaybe, dare I say, Boeing should go back to following the spectrum guidance. Is it going to move to the THz channel next and start complaining about visible light? The information is all over the place (https://ecfsapi.fcc.gov/file/101041916430138/GN%20Docket%20No%2018-122_A4A_Support_01032022RAA_FINAL.pdf https://ecfsapi.fcc.gov/file/101041916430138/GN%20Docket%20N...) I would flip their argument on its head and state that as altimeters are that critical, make sure they follow the spec to the letter. It's, like other commenters said, as if your neighbour sends you an eviction notice for your own house because you are next to him. 5G has taken a tremendous amount of effort and multiple years of work -- people have spent a decade on this. Boeing decided to not follow the spec. I think I will switch to Airbus. ;) tl;dr: if Boeing can not keep inside a spectrum for the altimeter what else have they "cheated on?"
- p_l 5y agoAirbus has the same issue. So does Bombardier. So does Dassault. Using the eviction notice metaphor , this is a developer building a stadium with sound system rocking your walls every night, because someone sold them a parcel too close for noise abatement.
- eftychis 5y agoPlease see the other side: For instance https://www.5gandaviation.com/ https://www.5gandaviation.com/ Could you please (I am asking out of curiosity) provide information about other companies? All I find are about passed tests. Your example metaphor is good I agree! The developer of the stadium here are the radio altimeters' manufacturer in question. The 200 Mhz gap between bands had been known. They just didn't want to: a) fix their leakage b) buy the "neighborhood" ie the band. They had multiple chances over more than 10 years now. And now they use the FAA to bail them out. We have the expectation, especially whoever flies and uses altimeters directly, that they will be extremely robust. From what I have seen so far a lot of corners have been cut. P.S. Wouldn't you double think before flying with some equipment that your undergraduate self (EE) would design better? Pay for more band, not with our lives. P.S.2 Here's a quick article about Boeing FAA required changes https://www.aviationtoday.com/2022/01/26/faa-requires-boeing-747-8-777-flight-manual-changes-address-5g-c-band-radio-altimeter-interference/ https://www.aviationtoday.com/2022/01/26/faa-requires-boeing...
- intrasight 5y agoAs is often the case, this will be an issue for the lawyers to battle over. The airlines have basically claimed squatters rights to those frequencies owned by 5G carriers.
- nwallin 5y agoIf I understand this correctly, the FCC has allocated the 4.2GHz-4.4GHz band for radar altimeters. The FCC has also allocated the 3.7GHz-3.98GHz band to 5G. It turns out that the radar altimeters, as manufactured, use spectrum outside their allocated band, down to and including part of the 3.7GHz-3.98GHz 5G band. Am I missing something? If a rancher buys a plot of land from 34.42°N to 34.44°N to graze his cattle on, but in actual fact grazes his cattle all the way from 34.37°N to 34.47°N. Then a farmer buys a plot of land from 34.37°N to 34.398°N to grow wheat on. Does the rancher still get to herd his cattle down to 34.39°N to feed his cattle? The cattle have to eat, after all, and cutting down the grazing land by 30% could cause some cattle to starve to death. And the rancher has a vested financial interest in ensuring his cattle are well fed, and that wheat is good eating. And the rancher has always been grazing his cattle there, what right does the farmer have to till the soil on the racher's grazing land? And we, the American public, have the right to buy beef. Why should the farmer purchasing 34.37°N to 34.398°N interfere with my ability to buy a steak? Does any of this make any sense to anyone? Unless there's additional information I'm unaware of, it seems as if the design and/or manufacture of the radar altimeter is not fit for purpose. Using 3.7GHz to 3.98GHz for 5G doesn't break the radar altimeters; the radar altimeters are already broken and must be fixed or grounded, because the equipment is broken and unsafe. If 5G equipment is emitting outside of its allocated 3.7-3.98GHz spectrum then the FCC needs to drop a brick on that of course.
- ddod 5y agoI can't say if it's right or wrong, but in relation to your specific example, there are "adverse possession" laws that grant legal rights to the occupier of land in the US.[1] [1] https://www.nolo.com/legal-encyclopedia/neighbor-built-fence-over-the-property-line-does-own-land.html https://www.nolo.com/legal-encyclopedia/neighbor-built-fence...
- buescher 5y agoIt's the receiver, so it's more like, you're asserting your right to leave your door wide open on a street that is suddenly much more busy. De facto possession of spectrum was heavily litigated in the early days of radio. There basically is none (not legal advice!), essentially no one has a claim on spectrum in the USA that is not assigned or regulated by the FCC. You have to sign away any claim to spectrum from before the establishment of the FCC to get a ham license or similar radiotelephone licenses. Nobody is around anymore that was operating then anyway. The language is blandly bureaucratic but in context that is what it means: "The Applicant/Licensee waives any claim to the use of any particular frequency or of the electromagnetic spectrum as against the regulatory power of the United States because of the previous use of the same, whether by license or otherwise, and requests an authorization in accordance with this application." There is probably some similar language in the applications for other licensed bands.
- mcguire 5y agoDo they mean radar altimeters? "That would result in "increased lightcrew workload while on approach..." Who wrote this?
- amelius 5y agoProbably another case of Boeing execs choosing the cheapest solution instead of the most robust one. And now society has to pay for it, again.
- anfilt 5y agoI see a lot people blaming boeing here? These sensors radar sensors were made before even the FCC allocated the 5G spectrum. Let's also not forget 5G equipment will emit outside of its assigned spectrum even with a buffer zone between frequencies. Especially when you consider the harmonics. Now each order of harmonic gets weaker from primary frequency. As for these altimeter sensors anyone have a datasheet for them? Quite curious what the recommended noise floor for these are?
- manquer 5y agoAll equipment can emit outside the allocated frequencies, which is why you have band pass filters . FAA is really the problem not Boeing, like any company they only did the bare minimum required to get certification . Had FAA they mandated stronger specs initially or at-least forced Boeing to upgrade in the last 10 years this was being discussed and allocated, this won't be a problem. That will be expensive for Airlines(grounding loss of revenue) and Boeing (recall,certification and upgrade) nobody wants to foot the bill so FAA kept delaying . Time and again we have seen FAA favor the industry even at the cost of lives (like with 737-MAX grounding) so this is not all that surprising from them
- anfilt 5y agoWe are talking about radar here the receiver will be receiving weak signals that are reflected. They may also have slight shifting in frequency due to reflection and the doppler effect. The noise floor is much lower for radar than communications. A radar receiver also will generally read a wider frequency band than communications. 200Mhz between frequency bands may seem like a lot for communication purposes, but that is not necessarily true for radar. Also you can't make a perfect band pass filter, also for radar the band your going to be filtering is gonna be wider to begin with. Also all transmitters will emit higher order harmonics of the primary frequency, if the broadcast power is high enough those harmonics could very well be above the noise floor of other frequencies.
- manquer 5y agoThere are altimeters which already are being used including by Boeing which perfectly pass the required specs. Nobody including FAA / Boieng are claiming technically it is impossible or will take very long to develop. The FAA is only calling out 737s after clearing them in this statement . They had said on 20th Jan "Airplane models with one of the 13 cleared altimeters including all Boeing 717, 737, 747, 757, 767, 777, 787, MD-10/-11; all Airbus A300, A310, A319, A320, A330, A340, A350 and A380 models" [1] and now backtracking They had adequate time to plan and roll it out to affected planes and they have not for the same reason telecom and FTC are upset -- money . Airlines/Boeing/ FAA do not want to foot the bill of this upgrade. Telecom companies spent $70 Billion on the spectrum and delays are costing them so they are upset. --- [1] Jan 20, 2022: https://www.faa.gov/newsroom/faa-statements-5g https://www.faa.gov/newsroom/faa-statements-5g
- clement12 5y ago[flagged]
- dboreham 5y agoThis entire thread seems to be about guard bands and filter roll off rate. But my question is: why does the altimeter blindly rely on received signal strength (basically: AM)? Surely it should correlate the received signal with the previously transmitted signal modulated with some PN sequence or some more fancy code? I'm an EE but not a radar expert, but I had the distinct impression going back decades that this is how radars work (at least military ones), among other reasons to thwart jamming. Fwiw feeding false returns to enemy radar has been a thing since 1939. Simply saying "oh there's a bit of noise, let me assume it's the ground talking" seems quite stupid even before the big bad 5G came along.
- paulmd 5y agoa large chunk of it likely boils down to "digital signal processing would have been a top-of-the-line military capability in 1970 when the aircraft were designed, and the onerous recertification process ensures that the cheapest outcome is always to just re-use the system and never mess with it". There's no incentive to mess with a working system, and a huge cost. do remember we're talking about commercial aircraft where software updates are still deployed on 3.5" floppies. it's difficult because obviously this is not a domain where "move fast and break things" is an option, I certainly see the benefits of a conservative engineering culture. But the 737 MAX situation already happened as a clever end-run around not being able to touch anything, and not being able to touch anything is more broadly killing general aviation (small aircraft). Extremely few aircraft have been certified since the 80s when the new regulations went into effect, it is very expensive and difficult. And at some point that boils down to encouraging "the wrong fix" or simply ignoring problems. these aircraft have defective radar altimeters, they are unable to function properly with a guard band over twice the size of the original design spec. The other problem here is regulatory capture - these aircraft shouldn't be in the air at all with a radar altimeter that is so dangerously defective. The right fix isn't "just let aircraft manufacturers ignore certification requirements when it's convenient", it's to come up with a level of certification that promotes a culture of engineering safety, but basically the FAA is just letting boeing keep dangerous planes in the air because it would be a mess if they didn't.
- 5y ago
- Shadonototra 5y agothey went from: - 5G is bad because it is a Chinese tech and they can spy on us to - it interfere with our equipments Looks like they learn, instead of admitting they are behind china in telecommunication tech, they now push the idea that it just is making our "old btw" tech unusable Nice, the Western culture!
- throwaway473825 5y ago5G isn't a "Chinese tech", especially not in the US where Huawei is banned.
- Shadonototra 5y agothanks capitalism, the market doesn't want humankind to advance and transcend, how sad
- zugi 5y agoCan anyone find any sources indicating whether this interference has been tested or measured? The FCC decided to auction off the 5G spectrum for fast data usage almost 5 years ago, one would think there'd be a study or experiment or two since then. Several months ago when the grumbling got loud, all the articles seemed to talk about "potential" interference, and despite the FAA having an $18 billion annual budget, and Boeing and Airbus and airlines having bigger budgets than that, and having almost 5 years notice, I got the distinct impression that no one had bothered to do any tests. But they took to the media to raise the alarm about "danger" instead. I'm actually hoping to be proven wrong here - please point me to some experiments or test results!
- tjohns 5y agoYes, the RTCA did a study back in 2020 which identified the interference from 5G towers was outside tolerance for the aircraft equipment: "The extent of the RF interference is summarized by the worst-case exceedance of the safe interference limit of radar altimeters by expected 5G signals in the 3.7–3.98 GHz band: 14 dB for commercial transport airplanes, 48 dB for business, regional, and general aviation airplanes, and 45 dB for helicopters. Further, the impacts are not only limited to the intentional emissions from 5G systems in the 3.7–3.98 GHz band, but also the spurious emissions from such systems within the protected 4.2–4.4 GHz radar altimeter band directly. In this latter case, the worst-case exceedance of the safe interference limit is 28 dB for business, regional, and general aviation airplanes, and 12 dB for helicopters." https://www.rtca.org/wp-content/uploads/2020/10/SC-239-5G-Interference-Assessment-Report_274-20-PMC-2073_accepted_changes.pdf https://www.rtca.org/wp-content/uploads/2020/10/SC-239-5G-In...
- zw123456 5y agofinally, one person who read it.. but really, it's the phones on the plane that are the problem, because they are closer.
- zw123456 5y agoya, been posted many times and ignored of course https://www.rtca.org/wp-content/uploads/2020/10/SC-239-5G-Interference-Assessment-Report_274-20-PMC-2073_accepted_changes.pdf https://www.rtca.org/wp-content/uploads/2020/10/SC-239-5G-In...
- eftychis 5y agoExample from the other point of view: https://www.5gandaviation.com/ https://www.5gandaviation.com/
- theYipster 5y agoCTIA is a lobbyist organization, whereas the technical assessment done by the aviation industry was done by a research consortium. The aviation industry has produced data to show 5G is a problem. What data has CTIA shared to prove that it's safe? To date, they haven't shared any.
- eftychis 5y agoThus, the other point of view. To extend the resource list, this (https://5gamericas.org/wp-content/uploads/2021/07/Mid-Band-Spectrum-and-the-Co-Existence-with-Radio-Altimeters.pdf https://5gamericas.org/wp-content/uploads/2021/07/Mid-Band-S...) is a comprehensive analysis.
- zw123456 5y agoI have previously posted this previously: https://www.rtca.org/wp-content/uploads/2020/10/SC-239-5G-Interference-Assessment-Report_274-20-PMC-2073_accepted_changes.pdf https://www.rtca.org/wp-content/uploads/2020/10/SC-239-5G-In... which is the complete report you can read for yourself that the FAA based their "concerns" on. But, if you read between the lines, or at least my read on it is... The wireless telcos agreed to pay the Incumbent Earth station operators to vacate the spectrum, the Airlines are a little cash strapped after the pandemic lock down, so, they figured why not stick our hand out and see if we can get a little cash out of the telcos. Just my take on it, but reading the RTCA doc, the whole thing is completely baseless. But, having said that, here is something to consider, the primary concern raised by the RTCA is not so much the base stations themselves, which are far away and hence, not an interference source, it is the phones on the plane as it lands, which are much closer to the radar antenna which is in the ass end of the plane (the lowest point on take off and landing). If a phone is on in the plane it will drag the call along, if you turn down the BTS's around the airport this compounds the problem because the dynamic power control of the phone will power up in an attempt to hold the connection. In Europe, they have been using this same spectrum for a long time with no problems, so in the U.S. we are doing the opposite and turning down BTS's near airports. So do the opposite of what works elsewhere in response that actually aggravates the exact problem being raised. In other words, the best thing is to leave BTS's up near the airport so the phones, closer to the radar antenna, will not interfere, like what works in Europe, so the phones don't increase power. So, we are doing the opposite.
- irrational 5y agoThe only solution is to repair or replace the radio altimeters, right? The only question is, who is going to pay for it, right? The FAA could mandate that all aircraft with “faulty” radio altimeters are grounded until repaired or replaced. That would force the airlines to pay for the fix. Or, the government could offer to go halfsies on the fix since it was the FCC that allocated the 5g spectrum.
- Diesel555 5y agoIf anyone cares how this is impacting aviation rather than the likely more appropriate debate of if this should impact aviation... It stops an airplane from landing in a 93 foot range of weather, if the clouds are between 107 feet and 200 feet above the runway (okay at one airport for one approach for one runway - but it's likely +- 50' true at most places, see below). In bad weather certain aircraft rely on their radar altimeter to help guide them to the runway. It gives them an altitude they can use to decide to abort their approach that is more accurate than air pressure combined with their inertial system. This below link shows that within a given distance of 5G they are not allowed to rely on their radar altimeter for those approaches. http://www.alpa.org/resources/aircraft-operations-radar-altimeter-interference-5G http://www.alpa.org/resources/aircraft-operations-radar-alti... > When operating in U.S. airspace, the following operations requiring radio altimeter are prohibited in the presence of 5G C-Band wireless broadband interference > Instrument Landing System (ILS) Instrument Approach Procedures (IAP) SA CAT I, SA CAT II, CAT II, and CAT III Below is the link for the S-ILS RWY 36 for DFW that requires SA CAT II. At the bottom you can see "RA 107/12" which means the airplane can fly down to 107' on RA (Radar Altimeter) without seeing the runway. At 107', if they don't see the runway environment, they must abort the approach. This approach assumes a working Radar Altimeter. The 5G NOTAMS effect this approach. https://resources.globalair.com/dtpp/globalair_06039I36LSAC2.PDF https://resources.globalair.com/dtpp/globalair_06039I36LSAC2... Below is the NOTAM for DFW affecting approaches. With this NOTAM an aircraft cannot execute the above approach, so if the weather is between 107' and 200' (the minimum for a regular ILS without RA), then they are not allowed to land at that airport - where before the 5G NOTAM they could. This is the narrow band of bad weather conditions in which the 5G affects approaches at DFW for that runway, 93 feet. In the NOTAM you will see the above approach "ILS RWY 36L (SA CAT II)" listed and "PROCEDURE NA [not available] EXC [except] FOR ACFT [aircraft] USING APPROVED ALTERNATIVE METHODS OF COMPLIANCE DUE TO 5G C-BAND INTERFERENCE PLUS SEE AIRWORTHINESS DIRECTIVES" > FDC 2/3758 (A0495/22) - IAP DALLAS-FORT WORTH INTL, DALLAS-FORT WORTH, TX. ILS RWY 17C (SA CAT I), AMDT 11B ... ILS RWY 17L (SA CAT I), AMDT 7 ... ILS RWY 18R (SA CAT I), AMDT 8A ... ILS RWY 35C (SA CAT I), AMDT 3 ... ILS RWY 35R (SA CAT I), AMDT 4B ... ILS RWY 13R (SA CAT I - II), AMDT 9B ... ILS RWY 17R (SA CAT I - II), AMDT 23D ... ILS RWY 18L (SA CAT I - II), AMDT 3 ... ILS RWY 31R (SA CAT I - II), AMDT 15 ... ILS RWY 17C (CAT II - III), AMDT 11B ... ILS RWY 17L (CAT II - III), AMDT 7 ... ILS RWY 18R (CAT II - III), AMDT 8A ... ILS RWY 35C (CAT II - III), AMDT 3 ... ILS RWY 35R (CAT II - III), AMDT 4B ... ILS RWY 36L (SA CAT II), AMDT 4 ... PROCEDURE NA EXC FOR ACFT USING APPROVED ALTERNATIVE METHODS OF COMPLIANCE DUE TO 5G C-BAND INTERFERENCE PLUS SEE AIRWORTHINESS DIRECTIVES 2021-23-12, 2021-23-13. 19 JAN 05:00 2022 UNTIL 19 JAN 05:04 2024 ESTIMATED. CREATED: 13 JAN 05:05 2022
- bux93 5y agoSo, Boeing produces faulty airplanes (again) and the FAA is OK with that (again)?
- mikewarot 5y agoThe meta of it is that some time ago, it was decided that just letting the FCC manage spectrum allocations, as they have since 1934, wasn't good enough. The decision was made to "sell" chunks of the spectrum for exclusive lease for various chunks of time and geography. This was a horrible decision, because those fees are, in effect, a tax, that will inevitably be passed on to the users. On top of that, it provided the incentive to take what was a reasonable separation that protected aircraft navigation bands from other users, and sell that space off. On top of that, the FCC/FAA didn't bother letting the rest of the world know this was going to happen, even though they had YEARS to do so. Thus, the current mess. Signals are popping up where the equipment currently in use was never expected to tolerate them. It's putting lives in danger.
- zurvania 5y agoAnyone know the radar altimeter make and model? I can't seem to find anything when I do a search. All that pops up is the aircraft model number. Aren't the altimeters manufactured by companies like Honeywell. There should be a datasheet on the model available somewhere