10 ms·
Missouri governor’s office responsible for teacher data leak
- ttyprintk 5y ago
- aftbit 5y ago>Prof. Khan is not white. What does that have to do with anything? Even if Prof. Khan was white, they would still not be in violation of any laws, and any advancement of the case would still be malicious prosecution.
- ttyprintk 5y agoGovernor Parsons is controversial because he imposes a religious test on appointments. Maybe he saw the surname Khan and it lit up for him.
- vmception 5y agoThere is a more clearer pattern of an incompetent state going after a pentester than there is a race-based one, typically given that the demographics of domestic computing enthusiasts have/had been of one race, with everyone else in single digit percentages. So even with the history that supports the observation of harsher punitive reactions to people not white, it doesn't seem relevant here. This is just an embarrassed state shifting its responsibility because it is easier, when accountability is harder.
- ceejayoz 5y agoIt's a pity there'll be no sanctions for what seems to be a fairly clear case of defamation.
- JumpCrisscross 5y ago> It's a pity there'll be no sanctions for what seems to be a fairly clear case of defamation Would a journalist have a legal claim for defamation against the Governor? Seems like a stretch.
- woodruffw 5y agoOf the four necessary conditions for defamation, they'd likely have the most trouble showing the "damages" condition (since both the journalist and the newspaper have been thoroughly repudiated throughout the entire affair).
- ceejayoz 5y agoThe bigger issue is probably the "actual malice" requirement as both the Governor and the reporter are public figures; it'd depend on what you could find in the Governor's emails etc. It's unfortunate that a public figure - and that's a fairly loosely defined status - can be defamed pretty much at will.
- woodruffw 5y agoThis would need to be decided by an actual court, but I'm not sure if the reporter would qualify as a "public figure" for the purposes of an "actual malice" test, since a "public figure" is generally either (1) an elected official, or (2) the unelected public representative of an elected official. There is additional lower court jurisprudence for "involuntary public figures" (the canonical example being a private citizen who receives public attention for an act of heroism), but that test hasn't been developed fully and it's unclear if it would even apply here (since the name of the reporter hasn't featured prominently in other reporting). (The "public figure" nature of the Governor or his office also doesn't apply here, since he's the accused defamer and not the defamee.)
- ceejayoz 5y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Public_figure https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Public_figure > A person can become an "involuntary public figure" as the result of publicity, even though that person did not want or invite the public attention. A person can also become a "limited public figure" by engaging in actions which generate publicity within a narrow area of interest. For example, [jokes about] ... Terry Rakolta [an activist who spearheaded a boycott of the show Married ... with Children] were fair comments ... within the confines of her public conduct [and] protected by Ms. Rakolta's status as a "limited public figure". Celebrites have a hard time suing for defamation due to their status as public figures. The reporter in this case likely qualifies as an "involuntary public figure" due to the coverage of all this, and might be a public figure just by being a reporter.
- froggertoaster 5y agoI live in Missouri and am a Republican and can safely say - I did not appreciate Parsons going on a political witch hunt.
- long_time_gone 5y agoIn light of the actions of the previous Governor [1], does it make you re-think your party affiliation? [1] https://www.nbcnews.com/politics/congress/eric-greitens-former-missouri-governor-who-resigned-amid-multiple-scandals-n1261785 https://www.nbcnews.com/politics/congress/eric-greitens-form...
- froggertoaster 5y agoWhat should I be instead, a Democrat? The answer to your question is no. Why on earth would I change my party affiliation based solely on the actions of two members of the party? I'll also add, other than this small stain, Parsons has been good. No major changes or upsets. It's boring here in Missouri politically, and I like that.
- dekhn 5y agoYou shouldn't. You might want to write a letter to the governor expressing your concern at his lack of acumen, but beyond that, I wouldn't do anything.
- criley2 5y agoIt's strange that you say "why on earth would I change my party affiliation based on the actions of two members" as if those two members weren't the two highest elected members of the state party. It's like if the CEO and Chairman of the board of a corporation were embezzling funds and someone replied "Why would I change my opinion of a company based on two random employees?" I think you did that because it's pretty obvious why someone might sour on an organization whose highest leaders continued in a pattern of bad behavior. In fact, quite the opposite of your claim here, I think it would be common sense to change your opinion on an organization based on a pattern of misbehavior by its top leaders. The reality of modern American politics, though, as I think you demonstrate as do most people, is that Negative Partisanship is the only factor at all that matters. The people on "your team" can do anything at all, because "the other team" is worse. This is the sentiment that drives all American politics at the state and federal level.
- bogrollben 5y agomy my my how the turntables
- _fat_santa 5y agoI remember reading the original story and it was bananas. Parsons kept doubling down and all of us were just sitting here going "oh this is not going to end well for him". And here we are...
- toomuchtodo 5y ago“The lady doth protest too much.” led us exactly where one might predict it to. Never change Missouri politics. You get what you vote for.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- houseofzeus 5y agoAt the end of the day though, what are the actual consequences for him?
- nimbius 5y agogreat question. since Missouri is one of a handful of states that are both heavily gerrymandered and impose strict limitations on the freedom to vote, its politics effectively mimic a gerontocratic autocracy....rule by an opaque council of elders elected under such limited conditions and terms they are effectively appointees. its unlikely he will face any meaningful repercussions for attempting to scapegoat the press.
- caymanjim 5y agoThere are no consequences beyond egg-on-face. I think that's as it should be. He said something stupid and reactionary, from a place of ignorance, likely parroting what some underling of his said. Now he looks silly, the news gets to carp about it for a cycle, and we all move on. This is as things should be. No one was materially hurt by his ignorant claims. Journalists are (or at least should be) thick-skinned enough to handle whatever inconvenience resulted from this, and now they get to publish their followups. Schadenfreude is its own reward.
- kenjackson 5y ago> “We are grateful to the member of the media who brought this to the state’s attention,” was the proposed quote attributed to the state’s education commissioner before Parson began shooting the messenger. Why do we have so many people in politics that seem so hellbent on trying to attack people and find malice in what they do? I don't know much about Pasrson, but I hope this is not his standard MO.
- duxup 5y agoI suspect if a lot of your platform is scapegoating to start with it is SO EASY to just use that when anything you don't like happens / makes you look bad. Even things that don't really make you look bad... (early on this wasn't even thought to be the governor's office fault directly). That's the danger in scapegoating and etc it's so easy to do for everything. Hugo Chávez had a regular national TV show in Venezuela where he would call up his own government officials and berate them and sometimes fire them on live TV. It's a scary viral like thing if you think to do it for everything.
- carrja99 5y agoFrom Missouri, it is his standard MO
- extra88 5y ago"MO" is everyone's standard Missouri.
- andrewflnr 5y agoConvincing people that your opponents are evil is an effective way to get them to vote for you.
- b112 5y agoPoliticians live and die by attacking opponents reputations, instead of the message. The public, sadly, cares more about not the job done, the track record, but instead on appearances. I once saw a Canadian politician mocked for his haircut. Another for the way he spoke. Not how well they did their job. So yeah, someone says something bad about a politician, well... we keep hiring people that are better at attacking appearances, not policy.
- duxup 5y agoI think you can be a good governor and not know much about technology. I think you can be a good governor and even possibly be ... not smart. You just need to be able to find good people to listen to. In fact some folks told him it wasn't the reporter's fault early on. It seems Mike Parson is the first two, and incapable of the last. Sadly it seems he does all this at the expense of good governance and the people of Mussouri in order to target people he doesn't like.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- kasey_junk 5y agoThis wasn’t targeting people the governor didn’t like, this was a direct attempt to punish publication of a story that showed him in a bad light. The intent was the chilling effect and the governor got what he wanted. The reporter, subject matter expert & newspaper all had to be involved in a criminal investigation and incur all the costs that go with it. This was a direct attack on a free press using the full menace of the state and there are unlikely to be an repercussions for it. Quite the opposite there are members of his constituency that believe that the press are enemies and deserve this treatment.
- duxup 5y ago"people he doesn't like" I use the idea of that generally in a way that IMO fits your description as well. Reporter, newspaper, another politician, even an institution, any could fall into that category IMO. While I don't doubt the seriousness of his actions regarding attacking / threatening the press, I think for guys like him he would be happy to target anyone / think that kept him in power.
- TheOtherHobbes 5y agoI see it as another example of a basic clash of cultures - between someone who is competence-oriented, and someone who is status-and-hierarchy oriented. They're speaking different languages and seeing different things. Parsons - like many politicians - sees situations exclusively as status and power plays. So when someone with low status says "This is broken", of course he goes on the attack. It's inconceivable in his world that someone might be trying to warn him about a real problem that needs to be fixed. At best he sees it as an attack on his position, at worst he turns it into a mini-campaign he can use for political gain. The fact there was a real problem is irrelevant and invisible to him. It's simply not something that interests him.
- romellem 5y agoThe [(redacted) report][1] is worth reading for yourself. Not only does it detail that pretty much everything was done "by the book" on the journalist and researcher side, but just how ridiculous the governor's reaction was. The interview with Dr. Khan, the University of Missouri-St. Louis professor who helped verify the original vulnerability, he discusses another time when a Missouri State government website had a different vulnerability, and how the reaction was different: I asked Dr. Khan if this type of flaw was something commonly seen. He indicated this was a common problem. He advised in 2016, he wanted to verify his voter registration, so he Googled "check voter registration" on his smart phone. He stated he clicked on the Missouri Secretary of State's website and as soon as the page loaded, he observed the page was loading through "plain http." [...] [T]he website was indexed in Google in this way, so anyone who Googled the Secretary of State's website, would be routed through that link. [...] [H]e emailed the Chief Security Officer and advised them of the problem and the fix for it. He stated he received an email thanking him for reporting the issue and was advised they would correct the issue. [1]: https://s3.documentcloud.org/documents/21271820/redacted-information-for-sunshine-request.pdf https://s3.documentcloud.org/documents/21271820/redacted-inf...
- the_only_law 5y agoSorry for the tangent, but am I the one who finds it’s odd that this was done by the Highway Patrol? I understand that the scope of that agency probably operates outside of just the highway, but I thought most states had other law enforcement agencies that would seem more appropriate.
- mikestew 5y agoWhen I lived in Indiana, the Indiana State Police (which most residents would consider to be the equivalent to "highway patrol") investigated a lot of things that had nothing to do with patrolling highways. I imagine this situation works the same, but with poor labelling ("highway patrol" serving more like "state police" in at least some situations).
- 5y ago
- joshstrange 5y agoThe fact that the governor will probably face no repercussions from this sickens me. It's bad enough that our elected officials aren't capable of grasping basic tech concepts but this stinks of a coverup or at a minimum shifting the blame from his own office who was responsible for the data leak (for a decade!!!).
- kodah 5y agoWhat is there to cover up? The existence of a bug? That seems trivial. It sounds like the guy is a confident idiot.
- joshstrange 5y agoYou don't find it suspicious that the governor's office directly oversaw the group that made the mistake and then were so quick to point at the reporter as the one responsible? I sure do and the governor's office clearly doesn't deserve the benefit of the doubt in this case.
- kodah 5y agoNo, it's a bureaucracy. Bureaucracies are dumb by default, but very effective at seeking representation. The other side of that is subject matter expertise, otherwise called a technocracy. A functioning government needs bureaucrats in charge with technocrats that report to them; this forces a balance of the efficacy of a technocracy while avoiding the inherent marginalization technocrats are prone to. To me, it sounds like the guy is a bureaucrat who surrounded himself with other bureaucrats rather than SMEs. Something needs to change for sure, but I don't think it rises to the level of conspiracy that folks are brooding about. Edit: Most of this take is based on my experience in the military in both highly bureaucratic organization as well as very dynamic organizations that had differing structure.
- magikaram 5y agoAs a Missourian, and former Education sector employee, the handling of the situation shoes how terrible Parson is as a governor, and how even after the past two scandals, whether it be the opposing candidate, no one will pull him out of office.
- RegW 5y agoPasser by: "Oy mate! D'you know you've left your stable door open?" Parsons: "You sire are a horse thief. You shall hang for this."
- giaour 5y agoDid the governor incur any civil liability? In light of this report, it's hard to see his press conference as a defensible use of his powers and bully pulpit.
- dang 5y agoRelated past threads: Prosecutor won't charge reporter who uncovered database flaw - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30318208 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30318208 - Feb 2022 (121 comments) The governor of Missouri still doesn’t know how websites work - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29752259 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29752259 - Dec 2021 (21 comments) Reporter may be prosecuted for using “view source” - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29737412 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29737412 - Dec 2021 (163 comments) Reporter who told Missouri officials of website flaw did 'nothing out of line' - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29098289 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29098289 - Nov 2021 (190 comments) Gov. Parson releases video attacking newspaper for viewing HTML - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28980855 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28980855 - Oct 2021 (26 comments) Gov Parson pushes to prosecute reporter who found security flaw in state site - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28946392 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28946392 - Oct 2021 (525 comments) Governor vows criminal prosecution of reporter who found flaw in state website - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28866805 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28866805 - Oct 2021 (678 comments)
- cronix 5y ago> “A hacker is someone who gains unauthorized access to information or content. This individual did not have permission to do what they did. They had no authorization to convert or decode, so this was clearly a hack.” So, "view page source," a built in browser function since forever (not even considering various built in inspectors), is illegal according to this very smart politician. That's basically all that was done here, on a publicly accessible website.
- thr0wawayf00 5y agoThis scandal is a perfect example of how our political discourse is failing. We cannot simply talk about government budgets and taxes in simple binary terms. We have to accept that the government needs to spend some money in order fulfill basic functions like protecting sensitive data because anybody that does good work in IT demands far higher pay than what you typically earn in the private sector. I see this all the time. If billionaires and venture-backed firms are the only ones that can reasonably attract and retain technical talent, we will never solve this problem. The IT pay disparity between the public and private sector is staggering and with inflation, who's gonna take a 60-70% pay cut to work in a public IT job?
- netizen-936824 5y agoIt might help if we didn't have the least competent people possible in positions of power
- thr0wawayf00 5y agoOversimplifying the problem to deflect from the underlying issues only serves the interests of those that enable scandals like this in the first place.
- peatmoss 5y agoCouldn't agree more. Having lived overseas really drives home the feeling that fixation on more vs. less is rather crude. In a lot of ways, it feels like the Ron Swanson schtick from Parks and Recreation: if you're anti-government, you strive to get in power so that you can run government badly, thus proving that government is bad and that we should drown it in the bathtub.
- bbertelsen 5y agoThe initial charges against the journalist could have been subterfuge to divert media culpability over recently acquired oversight privileges. I'm not suggesting that teachers aren't tech literate but perhaps there are some that will only remember the first headline, "journalist hacked me". Teachers unions also tend to vote in blocks.