3 ms·
One could criticize of the very notion of progress. It hinges on a tacit assumption there is some destination toward which all civilization will inevitably conv
by marginalia_nu 5y ago
One could criticize of the very notion of progress. It hinges on a tacit assumption there is some destination toward which all civilization will inevitably converge. It's really difficult to motivate why that would be.
- api 5y agoProgress is like "wellness." If you have a bleeding gunshot wound, you are not well. But if there is nothing obviously wrong, are you well? If half your population is malnourished and lacks basic services like banking and these statistics improve, that's obviously progress. It's much harder to pin down what progress would be for a country like the USA or Switzerland.
- marginalia_nu 5y agoThis still assumes that countries naturally will evolve banks and populations inevitably become well fed through some nebulous process. It's really not possible to appeal to something like darwinian evolution, as it really only cares about memetic propagation and fitness to the current environment. I'm not saying that these things aren't good, I'm questioning how it's possible to motivate the notion that it is inevitable for civilizations to converge to have these things. If it isn't, then I think we should come to terms with the fact that we think other countries are backwards because they are different from us, and we think the reason they are different is that they haven't thought things through yet. This is perhaps not a fashionable line of reasoning, but my point is that just ignoring what hides behind the notion of progress doesn't make it go away.
- darebak 5y agoIf I understood your argument correctly than it applies more to the Amish than to poor countries because some things are definitely a sign of progress, like ending malnourishment, supplying shelter and curing basic diseases. Where I agree with you is that not every progress is progress to everyone, for example the above mentioned Amish usually refuse medical treatments in old age but are open to it when they are in the productive age. Would it be progress for them to undergo cancer treatment when they are 80? Maybe, maybe not. Is it progress when they get clean environment for childbirth? Definitely.
- marginalia_nu 5y agoProgress toward what?
- darebak 5y agoWell being, lower stress and suffering.
- marginalia_nu 5y agoRight, didn't we already have that as paleolithic times? No pollution, can just forage for a few hours and then mostly chill. Seems these cavemen have progressed farther than we have.
- imtringued 5y agoThat works until your population has grown so much your people start illegally logging protected forests for slash and burn agriculture because they have nothing to eat. The conventional solution is natural predators for population control. We have to do population control in our head.
- darebak 5y agoThat's a myth of a noble savage, a lot of prehistoric people died in childhood, childbirth, from broken bones, had no safety etc.
- marginalia_nu 5y agoPrehistoric people died as many times a lifetime as contemporary man. What they didn't have to worry about was mortgages, inflation, losing their jobs, the destabilizing political situation in Eastern Europe, global warming, QAnon, the vanishing bees, health insurance, and so forth.
- darebak 5y ago
- saghm 5y ago> One could criticize of the very notion of progress. It hinges on a tacit assumption there is some destination toward which all civilization will inevitably converge. I don't see this as being obvious. I can write integers that are progressively larger and larger without converging on some final value, so why should progressing society have to have a convergence value? I think the assumption that societal progress implies convergence says a lot more about the worldview of the person with that opinion than about progress itself.
- marginalia_nu 5y agoIt's the word progress itself that carries the connotation of a destination. A boat adrift at sea isn't making progress even though it's changing its position at random. A ship crossing the ocean toward a port is making progress, and that progress is measured not in how far it is from its origin, but how close it is to its destination. If it takes a circuitous path, it hasn't made more progress, it's merely taken longer.
- saghm 5y agoObviously this is getting a bit into the weeds, but from looking up the word "progress", that doesn't seem to necessarily be the case. Merriam Webster gives almost the opposite as its first definition: "to move forward : proceed", and "proceed" says "to come forth from a source : issue". It seems pretty well established that progress can also mean to _come from_ a distinct place rather than only meaning arriving at a distinct place. I agree that it can sometimes mean a convergence will occur, but it also sometimes doesn't, so any assumption of that definition in terms of societal progress would be reflected by the reader.