22 ms·
Germany shelves Nord Stream 2 pipeline
- SideburnsOfDoom 5y agoAs was remarked a few days ago: The UK is denouncing dependency on Russian fossil fuels, and Germany is denouncing dependency on Russian money. We'll know that they're serious when it's the other way around, and they act on it.
- raxxorrax 5y agoThat is not remotely pulling the plug. This is "thinking about it" again. They already stopped accreditation a few weeks ago, otherwise it would already transport gas as the pipeline is already filled. They just say that they have officially stopped the process which they more or less already did. I think in a year it might come online again if the news cycle is on another topic. Overall it will be much more expensive for Europe than for Russia. Who do you think will profit the most if gas prices hike?
- bobthechef 5y ago
- jquery 5y ago> Overall it will be much more expensive for Europe than for Russia. Markets disagree here. The ruble tumbled as well as the main Russian index, 500% more than the USA/Europe did. Russia has a lot to lose.
- gerikson 5y ago<<Erst kommt das Gas, dann kommt die Moral>>
- xcambar 5y agoGood pun of Brecht's words, but how do you connect both here?
- unchocked 5y agoRecertification now goes through a Green energy minister. This is pretty much pulling the plug.
- jebronie 5y ago"green" in so far as having a history of helping the construction of LNG terminals to import american gas.
- tjansen 5y agoStill much better than lignite...
- oytis 5y agoThe point is German Green party has the most anti-authoritarian external political stance of all, and have been opposed to Nord Stream II from the very beginning. They might exchange it for compromise on something else, sure, but will have to explain it to their own party members.
- raxxorrax 5y agoNot against shale gas which is worse than natural gas. They opposed it because of environmental concerns of fossil fuels. It would be much better to just get gas from Russia, which we did for several decades.
- belorn 5y agoI think the one that will profit most is China, being the remaining trade partner in a much similar way when most of the world imposed sanctions against north Korea. At the same time this will reduce the impact on prices, since as long China is connected to the global economy then the global supply will still increase when they buy from Russia. There will be costs associated with transportation for EU, be that from China (as a middle man for Russia) or Canada/US.
- CRConrad 5y ago> I think the one that will profit most is China If nothing else, is anyone keeping a very sharp eye out for what's going on around Taiwan or in the South China Sea, now that everyone's attention is on the Russian Kim's Ukrainian adventure?
- dragonelite 5y agoSo you're saying the germans will drive german cars designed in germany but made in China.
- thematrixturtle 5y agoChina is not a gas exporter, or do you mean that they can buy Russian gas more cheaply now? In any case it's Qatar and other Arab states that produce LNG are the ones who'll be laughing all the way to the bank here.
- eatonphil 5y agoI don't think China benefited per se (let alone profited) by being the only one with economic ties to North Korea. As I understand it it's a pretty parasitic relationship. China's reason to help North Korea is more so political and territorial than economic.
- davrosthedalek 5y agoIt also guarantees them exclusive access to rare earth deposits in North Korea, I thought that was also a major point. They certainly have interest in a stable NK, not a "Maybe I press the red button today" NK.
- _ph_ 5y agoIt is dead for all purposes unless the political climate changes radically. Whatever the Russian plans for a gas supplier to Germany were, they are limited to what the existing pipelines can deliver. I hope, we can reduce the dependency on Russian gas quickly, even if it means the additional effort of shipping LNG from the US or other sources. Mid-term it should be highest priority to get rid of fossil fuels as quick as possible.
- DeathArrow 5y ago>Mid-term it should be highest priority to get rid of fossil fuels as quick as possible. This line of thinking double prices to gas, natural gas and electricity in the last year. Please stop it!
- jaegerpicker 5y agoThis line of thinking is the only hope of not further destroying the planet! We need renewables to replace fossil fuels ASAP.
- nmehner 5y agoHow does renewable energy double the gas price? That does not make any sense.
- CRConrad 5y ago> Mid-term it should be highest priority to get rid of fossil fuels as quick as possible. What Germany needs to do, stat!, is to undo its moronic decision to scrap nuclear power. It's not as if the North Sea is very prone to tsunamis. And most of Germany's nuclear plants were probably not even all that close to the coast. Let's just fervently hope that any plants already decomissioned can be re-comissioned ASAP.
- zx85wes 5y agoIt's been dead for a very long time. It's a carrot that Russia was never going to get. If Scholz is smart (which I doubt) he'll restart/keep open the nuclear power plants and cut taxes on gas/electricity for households to neutralise the price hikes.
- Maxburn 5y agoYes, it impacts the people far more than the state.
- PinguTS 5y agoBecause Poland let the long term contracts run out and also got cheered up for this by the US to not depend on Russia, Poland is the one who buys on the spot market. The German companies buy from Gazprom under the umbrella of the cheap long term contracts and now are selling to Poland. The German companies order from Netherlands way much more then in previous years (almost double), because of long term contracts, that Netherlands has to fulfill. Here you have the companies, which are really profiting. It is not so much Gazprom as you may think.
- p_l 5y agoWith Poland, it was more due to internal political need to be seen as hard on Russia (and please look the other way as we buy coal from Donbas). Another leg of that strategy was buying LNG from USA, which turned out to be American companies buying russian gas in St. Petersburg ¯\_(ツ)_/¯ With the contracts, the current ruling coalition sold people the idea that they "got back" money from Gazprom over high prices of long-term contract when spot gas prices were lower. This, indeed, led to a considerable refund - but also meant we don't have guaranteed gas prices anymore, and now spot prices are much higher than they were when they renegotiated out the long-term contract ¯\_(ツ)_/¯
- raxxorrax 5y agoI think Poland expected more support for such a decision but they basically just cut their own flesh with that. Ironically the relationship between Russia and Poland is worse than between Germany and Russia. Post-war politics seem to have a larger impact.
- cheaprentalyeti 5y agoHow can it be Ironic? It exactly matches the relationships in the first couple years of the second world war: Germany and Russia had the Molotov-Ribbentroff Pact, and the parts of Germany and the Soviet Union that used to be a country called Poland Just Had To Put Up With It.
- p_l 5y agoGermany (or rather "Prussia", given that unified Germany is relatively new thing) and Russia had been much more friendlier with each other than their relationship with Poland, for considerable stretches of history. To the point that at times it's talked as "traditional german-russian friendship". On completely unrelated note is that our (Polish) current government is beyond stupid, voided long-term contracts during a period of cheaper gas prices, and is now forced to buy at spot prices for more than it saved on the long-term contract (also lots of political capital being involved between govt and opposition).
- jebronie 5y agoWell, thats what happens when a bunch of transatlantik stooges of Klaus Schwab get into office.
- Friday_ 5y ago
- jebronie 5y agoThe point is to make the people happy that got the current batch of sociopaths into office.
- _ph_ 5y agoGas is one of the few large sources of income in Russia. Reducing the gas trade is one of the few really direct sanctions possible. Even if it comes at a price, it is way better than to start shooting.
- cute_boi 5y agoThis is a reason sanctions don't work as people expect. China will simply buy those valuable gas. I do acknowledge that there would be transportation costs. In the end, Europe will suffer more and China will be happier. And, currently, with the price hike on gas, I think the EU will face more problems. Geopolitics is not a game of morality, rather it's a game of logic. China, the US, and Russia seem to be playing very well. This is also one reason why India is not saying anything against them. The only victim I see is Europe.
- _ph_ 5y agoThe gas deal with China is only a fraction of what Europe buys at the moment.
- ovi256 5y ago> China will simply buy those valuable gas With what pipeline ?
- pmontra 5y agoIf China is not dumb (it isn't) they will pay that gas a fraction of what Europe is paying it, "or keep it underground." Unless they want to subsidize Russia against the USA. Europe doesn't matter. Every crisis shows that's only a geographical expression (I'm European.)
- tiku 5y agoThanks Germans. Paying our gas bill will be fun here in the Netherlands.
- eitland 5y agoNorwegian here. We are probably already raking in millions extra today as prices soars, but if there was a referendum vote tonight and if could vote to not take advantage of the situation but rather help fellow Europeans that would be my vote. I guess I am not alone.
- another_why 5y agoHow noble. What about poor European countries, will you pay for their gas too? Or they will pay for your opportunity of being "noble"?
- mcv 5y agoThat's what he's saying: help other countries instead of raking in more money.
- another_why 5y agoWhich countries? Higher prices for gas will rise prices for everything, food including.
- eitland 5y agoI meant all European democracies I think, temporarily[1] until we get this mess sorted. [1]: In the long run oil and gas prices should probably increase until solar and nuclear power become very profitable.
- another_why 5y agoI wasn't trying to make it subtle, but it's not a topic of the discussion and talking about it will take too much time. Though in a long enough dispute, it eventually goes to the basics and false beliefs, nothing to undermine there.
- chrisseaton 5y agoRemember like a week ago when the Germany navy said the idea that Russia wanted to invade Ukraine was nonsense? Fools.
- morsch 5y agoA month ago. And the guy who said it was fired a day later.
- _ph_ 5y agoIt wasn't the German navy, it was the ranking admiral which had been removed from office immediately, as there was a strong disagreement with his statements.
- chrisseaton 5y ago> It wasn't the German navy, it was the ranking admiral It he doesn't speak for the Germany navy then who does? Were the navy's intelligence reports wrong or was he briefed wrong or does he not believe his own intelligence people? What if he'd been still been in charge now? Would he still deny it was happening? All possibilities point to something extremely foolish going on. Absolutely bizarre situation. I wonder what he says now.
- Bud 5y agoThis honestly just isn't that significant. Germany's navy, and indeed, German military forces generally, are not relevant to this crisis and will play basically zero part in it. So all of this analysis and blame-gaming you're trying to do just are not of much import.
- chrisseaton 5y agoI wonder what contingencies the Germany navy is planned for and capable of handling, if they couldn't even get their heads around this being a possibility?
- a0-prw 5y agoThe accreditation process was already halted, so nothing new has happened. Nord Stream 2 will eventually deliver cheap gas to Germany. This is just political theatre. Wait till Russia stops sending gas through Ukraine and paying Ukraine billions for the privilege (a move that can be easily justified from the Russian side as 'counter sanctions'). Then you'll hear the Germans scream XD
- _ph_ 5y agoOne of the the connections to Russia that kept giving diplomacy a base is, that Russia always was a reliable supplier with gas, as was the Sovjet Union even during the cold war. Equally, Europe is a good customer. Fundamentally such trade is good for both sides. Nord Stream 2 was strictly speaking never needed, a lot consider it rather a strategy of Russia to be able to cut off Ukraine without severing their trade with Germany. As a consequence, a lot of people in Germany considered North Stream 2 a strategic mistake. Putin already was playing with the gas supply as the signed contracts were fulfilled, but no extra gas was offered, even if Russia could have made some nice profits, unless North Stream 2 became operational. Cutting gas below the existing contracts would be a whole different step of escalation.
- chasd00 5y agoMy thought was Russia would retaliate by just turning off the gas supply period. Then I was wondering who could hold out longer, Russia or Europe? I didn’t know until this article and comments that Nordstream 2 was already effectively on pause. I kept waiting for something about the situation to pop up here where I could get opinion and info from actual grownups vs the rest of the internet.
- ghostwriter 5y agoNord Stream 2: The $11BN Megaproject That's Dividing Europe https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pzbxGYBY5M8 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pzbxGYBY5M8
- thehappypm 5y agoRussia doesn’t want to piss off Europe. They’re far better off having Europe depend on their gas.
- Bud 5y agoPutin has placed his bet on the flop, and Biden and NATO have now called it and re-raised. (This wasn't done by Germany in a vacuum.) Now we get to see if Putin will double down.
- credit_guy 5y agoHere's some quick numbers I just googled to understand the big picture. This pipeline has an annual capacity of 55 billion cubic meters. It's the same capacity as the Nord Stream 1, which is already in operation. If Germany was truly meaning business, they'd stop Nord Stream 1 the moment Russian boots enter Ukrainian territory. But let's leave that aside. 55 billion cubic meters translate to about 0.6 billion MWh. The price today for natural gas Dutch TTF futures is EUR 78/MWh [1] , so that translates in about 40 billion EUR per year. It has been as low as EUR 13 and as high as EUR 165 over the last 2 years. It's quite likely that Russia would make a profit even at the lower range, so the 40 billion EUR/year is pretty much pure profit for them. [1] https://www.theice.com/products/27996665/Dutch-TTF-Gas-Futures/data?marketId=5350859&span=3 https://www.theice.com/products/27996665/Dutch-TTF-Gas-Futur...
- deepsun 5y agoThere are multiple alternative options, land based, as well. NS2 doesn't really change the pricing.
- ianai 5y agoMore informative might be: some price sensitivities around LNG, and how changing supply may affect price.
- credit_guy 5y agoIt would be more informative, but it’s much more difficult to estimate that. If you have a quick way to do it, feel free to add to the conversation.
- hajile 5y agoNordstream 2 has sanctions against it in the US and has for several years now. Work on the pipeline stopped an hour or two before they were signed into law (by the allegedly pro-Russia Trump). Like Biden always does, he just ignored the bi-partisan sanctions passed by congress because it'll be too late by the time the courts get done (Biden subverting the system to help Russia get what they want) This is important because Ukraine said quite a while ago that sanctions of Nordstream 2 would go a long way toward preventing war[0] Meanwhile, the Democrats spent a morning last week waxing eloquent about the evil of the filibuster only to use the filibuster that same day to stop a bi-partisan set of Nordstream 2 sanctions from passing because it was just under the requisite 60 votes. [0] https://www.reuters.com/business/energy/ukraine-us-not-too-late-stop-russian-pipeline-2021-08-31/ https://www.reuters.com/business/energy/ukraine-us-not-too-l...
- scotty79 5y agoThat's dumb. What they should do instead is tax the gas that will flow through North Stream 2 to be as expensive as the one going through other routes and transfer this tax directly to Ukraine budget as aid let's say for the next 30 years, irrevocably. And possibly partially to Poland because it has very similar concerns but to a lesser degree than Ukraine.
- likecarter 5y agoI don’t think imposing a complicated tax structure is very compromising or intimidating towards Russia.
- scotty79 5y agoIt should be extremely simple tax structure. It's not about intimidation. Nord Stream 2 intention was to make it way more profitable than other routes so Putin can freely mess with countries those other routes go through. By firmly taxing whatever comes out of NS2 you nullify it's attractiveness for consumers. And giving Ukraine this much money would strengthen it economically so they can adavance faster towards western standards of living and western culture, further from Russia influence. Losing two provinces that are basically huge coal mine populated with people speaking other language is not that painful if you can progress towards western knowledge based economies fast.
- aenis 5y agoUkraine is still a kleptocracy. The money would be largely stolen. Also, there is no such thing as "irrevocably". Ukraine had just such irrevocable security guarantees granted when they agreed to let go of their nuclear inheritance. There is no way to stop a determined despot via diplomacy or economical pressures. Putin is trying to replicate the first few years of Hitler's intimidation blitz and the world would do well to not appease him in any way.
- scotty79 5y ago> Ukraine is still a kleptocracy. That's true but it's true of any country to one degree of another. European union has a lot of mechanism for preventing misapplication of funds it awards to countries. > Putin is trying to replicate the first few years of Hitler's intimidation blitz and the world would do well to not appease him in any way. That's pure BS straight from the mouths of propagandist of USA military industrial complex that Putin is godsent enemy that justifies their existence with zero risk. Putin just wanted to grab for himself a new coal mine which two republics of eastern Ukraine really are. He just repeats scenario from Georgia (the one near Russia) .
- Loic 5y agoMy personal opinion: All this Ukraine stuff is also supported by China. I bet they are ready to buy Russian oil and gas to compensate even if this costs them more than getting them from the open market. Why? Because this is a wonderful test drive to check how the West (sorry for the approximation) is reacting to a country theoretically supported by the West being invaded by another one. For me, the next one on the line is Taiwan.
- major505 5y agoI don't think china is too happy about this separatist support since this sets a precedent for territories they consider separatists like Taiwan.
- gjsman-1000 5y agoYes... and no. These are separatists who are operating with the support of Russia, and are (obviously) puppet states for Russia now that Russia is going to be sending "peacekeeping forces" within their territory. I don't think China would have any objection to separatists of any nation who wanted to spread communism and get Chinese backing. Actually, the fact that there aren't Taiwanese separatists for China is probably a disappointment.
- thinkindie 5y agospreading communism - LOL. China might spread their very own version of capitalism, which considering the amount of millionaires and the growing inequalities within China is far from any version of communism.
- tomp 5y agoI really don’t understand this logic. Or rather, it’s easy to turn it around. Russia’s claim is basically, “this is ethnically Russian population speaking Russian”. That’s exactly the same claim that China could make about Taiwan.
- 5y ago
- vanilla-almond 5y agoA related report from the BBC (published a few days ago): Europe gas prices: How far is Russia responsible? https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/58888451 https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/58888451 Some key points in the BBC article: - Russia supplies about 40% of the EU’s natural gas imports. Most of the rest comes from Norway and Algeria. - Russia sends gas to Europe through several main pipelines - such as the Nord Stream, the Yamal-Europe and the Brotherhood (see the map in the article). - Overall, Russian gas exports to Europe have been decreasing over the last couple of years - down 32% in February this year compared to February 2020. One factor - during the pandemic - has been falling demand as economic activity shrank. Stocks of gas across Europe have been depleted, which in turn is driving up prices. - Gazprom, Russia's majority state-owned energy company, supplies gas to Europe under two different arrangements: 1. Long-term contracts often lasting from 10 to 25 years. 2. "Spot" deals or one-off purchases for a fixed amount of gas. - It is understood that Gazprom met its obligations to European buyers last year under these contracts. - "Spot" sales don't appear to be happening in any significant quantity, going by data from Gazprom's own electronic sales platform. - The International Energy Agency's executive director, Fatih Birol, has accused Russia of reducing gas supplies to Europe for political purposes. - Gas storage across Europe is well below the 10-year average, with levels currently at about 75% of storage capacity, according to Gas Infrastructure Europe data.
- croes 5y ago>This leads to the conclusion that Gazprom is supplying the volumes... under its long-term contracts - but it is not providing additional volumes beyond those contracts," says Jack Sharples, of the Oxford Institute for Energy Studies. Question is, was gas ordered? I doubt anyone delivers without order. According to Gazprom the orders came only february 2nd.
- another_why 5y agoIf I remember right, they refused to sign a new contract with Russia and tried to buy it spot as a matter of "economy"
- wukerplank 5y ago
- baybal2 5y agoFYI, Nord Stream 1 is still operational
- danjac 5y agoGermany's problem is that it really wants to be Switzerland - rich, neutral, outwardly virtuous yet totally amoral. Unfortunately its history and geography make that impossible.
- nix23 5y agoNeutral and amoral bites each other. Germany wants to be the leader of europe...yet no one else wants that....understandably.
- MagnumOpus 5y agoGermany politicians desperately don't want to be the leaders of anything. Given the country's GDP, tech prowess and population, they could be a military and espionage powerhouse far exceeding the UK or France, even rivaling Russia; but historical and political reasons make them tread softly and prefer throwing money at problems (e.g. paying off other countries to join the EU through the CAP, or sending FDI or aid to emerging Europe and Africa) rather than to bully countries using cyber attack or spec ops or even more hardline trade/sanction policies...
- nix23 5y ago> Germany politicians desperately don't want to be the leaders of anything. Oh look where the corrupt Flinten-Uschi sits: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/President_of_the_European_Commission https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/President_of_the_European_Comm... https://www.politico.eu/article/ursula-von-der-leyen-biography-career-inconvenient-truth/ https://www.politico.eu/article/ursula-von-der-leyen-biograp... And yes they even give free submarines to Israel and help the NSA to spy on other European country's....what a lovely nation. >rather than to bully countries Greece want's to have a word with you then.
- mlatu 5y ago> The decision comes as Europeans grapple with record-high power bills, driven in large part by a gas supply shortage. an artificial shortage made by private investors. the russians are selling the gas as per contract, but because it is cheaper than what you can get on the spot market, some idiots are making a quick buck by selling the cheap gas for the spot market price. well, something like that https://blog.fefe.de/?ts=9fb268bf https://blog.fefe.de/?ts=9fb268bf
- foepys 5y agoBe aware that Fefe is very pro Russia and repeatedly stated that he thinks that Russia is defending itself against Western aggression. He also made fun of multiple people who said that Russia would invade.
- Semaphor 5y ago> He also made fun of multiple people who said that Russia would invade. Nah, he now switched to explaining why it was expected and Putin had no other choice. I still can’t tell if he has been going crazy in recent years, or if I simply never realized how much bullshit he writes.
- mlatu 5y agoi am very aware that he is using his brain to process the news he ingests instead of merely copying what he reads
- CRConrad 5y agoHaving looked around the blog for just a bit, it's utterly obvious that he "is using his brain" to be a total fucking Putin troll. Figure out for yourself what that makes you for posting that characterization of him.
- mlatu 5y agoyeah, he is what is called a "putin versteher" someone who gets why putin would act like he does im just saying that it is in nobodies interest to only accept western views as valid i can totally see how NATO's continuance and the veto against russia joining might be perceived as a persistent middle finger towards russia. My opinion: the only reason why the NATO persists to this day, is to bully russia. The west could have changed their tone along the way, but no. there needs to be a threat, otherwise nobody would need antimissile shields around russias borders. there needs to be someone to point all those weapons at. Apparently humanity needs a common aggressor, I hope there will be an alien invasion of world ending proportions, otherwise I doubt we will ever get our shit together and overcome our differences.
- dustinmoris 5y agoAm I the only one who thinks that the reality of this crisis is a lot more nuanced than what Western media shows us? Same as with Taiwan. It's an island off China and rebels flew there at some point and started to govern Taiwan as if it was theirs. China always insisted that Taiwan is part of China but because they never used military force to put an end to the game which those rebels played on that island it became harder for China to maintain the premise that Taiwan is in fact still part of China. Obviously the West has HUGE incentives to keep Taiwan seperate from China so will only portray one side of the story and the longer China was doing the objectively speaking right thing (not using force to exercise their right) the easier it is for the West to peddle the idea that Taiwan is in fact not part of China. It's almost like the West has been intelligently exploiting the good will of the East and I do feel like there is a lot of that going on between Ukraine and Russia as well. Unfortunately there are no objective sources of news anymore and it's hard to really get a well balanced overview of the crisis. When I read on Wikipedia that for instance more than half of the Ukraine was not in favour of the Euromaiden protests, or other minor facts which shine a slightly different light on everything I am curious how much did the West contribute in stirring the crisis like we know they did in other countries in the world (Cuba, Middle East, Arab Spring, etc.)
- pydry 5y agoI find comparing RT, BBC and al jazeera gets a fairly complete picture on this crisis. All three will emphasize things others dont. It doesnt elucidate everything though. E.g. it's not clear from this who really killed the minsk protocols though.
- enriquto 5y ago> Same as with Taiwan. It's an island off China and rebels flew there at some point That's a subjective way to put it, isn't it? You could also say that "rebels" took all of mainland China and Taiwan is the last remaining standoff of the "true" China.
- dustinmoris 5y agoDisagree. Objectively speaking this is not how it works and never has worked in history. The winner takes it all, that's how it worked across the globe in all other territories across the world. EDIT: Also this argument if completely flawed because Taiwan has no leg to stand on. The only reason why it existed the way it has for so long is because China has actually been nice and not exercised its power. If China was to move troops into Taiwan next week there would be no actual opposition apart from fake outrage in the West, same as what happened with Hong Kong. HK was always part of China historically and the West initially agreed a deal with China to be allowed to have a base there and as time has moved on they thought they could infiltrate from within HK to make the independent and make it a US proxy state, but China, just like Russia now probably, has remained firm to the original roots of HK and now re-exercised their right claim over it and as we have seen the West has done nothing abou tit because they know they 1. cannot and 2. have no real right.
- Helmut10001 5y agoGermany has run on 60% Wind power alone in January and February so far, even exported energy to France (because their nuclear power is in bad shape) and Poland (coal power plants are just too expensive). Just another motivation to get rid of the old power sources as soon as possible. North Stream 2 never made sense.
- chess_buster 5y agoThis is correct in regard of electricity, yes.
- ben_bai 5y agoAnd electricity is about 21% of the total energy consumed. There is also heating 49% (which is basically all gas and oil) And Mobility 30% (which is basically all oil)
- Helmut10001 5y ago45,8% of new buildings in 2020 had heat pumps, which are most efficient for turning electricity into heat. There are ~1,3 Million heat pumps in Germany currently, which is about 7% of all buildings. Of course, all of this could have been faster without the debate for nuclear (even if - we would not build new nuclear plants at this point, so the discussion is without meaning) and the postponement of renewable energy.
- synotna 5y agoGermany needs gas thanks to years of anti-nuclear, which is why we have 4x+ the carbon output for electricity of "nuclear is in bad shape" France The only way Germany is getting rid of coal & gas is if France builds enough nuclear to power and heat Germany
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- tiborsaas 5y agoInvesting into heat pumps is probably a good idea today.
- stevespang 5y ago
- CSMastermind 5y agoIf they really cancel the project that's a much harder stance than I expected Germany to take.
- dgellow 5y agoThe project isn't cancelled, its certification is halted indefinitely.
- CRConrad 5y agoAnd more significantly, its predecessor Nordstream One hasn't been dismantled or blown up, nor even temporarily shut down. It's merrily pumping along, simultaneously serving and reinforcing Germany's dependence on Russian gas.
- another_why 5y agoIf there were real plans to sanction people responsible for invasion, they should've sanctioned russian billionaires - cancel their residence, close their companies, liquidate their property, freeze their money in banks, forbid travel. But this looks like they are taking EU money to pay to US gas fracking companies
- phkahler 5y agoDid you ever notice that in Chess (a game of kings) you never actually capture the opposing king, you just back him into a corner and call the game over. All other pieces on the board are actually captured and removed.
- another_why 5y agoDid you ever notice that it's not chess?
- vorpalhex 5y agoRussia has had it's billionaires sanctioned back in 14/15. Most of them now use the Russian banks to do their business (and those banks are not subject to sanctions and will misrepresent who they are doing business for). The next step is to close the loophole and target the Russian banks as a whole, which will have consequences for non-billionaores in Russia too.
- another_why 5y agoIf you believe in a fairy tale that no one knows whose money going where, in 2022, then yes, sounds very reasonable. Scary Russian billionaires fool poor Europeans by acting through banks, aha. Are you trying to find an excuse for EU and US to NOT take any means to do what they threaten to do? This is bullshit.
- DaedPsyker 5y agoIt seems that banks are the new target for the UK. https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-politics-60476137 https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-politics-60476137 London is one of the key centers for global banking. That said, I can't imagine Russian billionaires don't have means to shelter funds, nested shells in some offshore bank I'd imagine.
- jug 5y agoI'm a bit worried about the EU consequences by this, given our already high inflation rate and energy prices being very influental in that regard. However, they assure us this won't be overly bad although there will be short-term consequences. A winner is obviously USA with the shale gas production but I'm sure EU will diversify in otehr regards as well. Altogether this feels like a painful but important step for a healthier energy supply in the future.
- modo_mario 5y ago>I'm a bit worried about the EU consequences by this, given our already high inflation rate and energy prices being very influental in that regard. The existing pipelines have much more capacity. Nordstream just serves as a tool to take a bargaining chip away from Ukraine. The pipeline isn't actually scrapped, stuff is just halted. Additionally Russia didn't resupply it's storages in Western Europe much last year and we can now see why. If Ukraine starts using it's bargaining chip i imagine we'll see those pipelines used real quick. A bigger issue is the growing demand with multiple countries scrapping nuclear powerplants without replacement. >A winner is obviously USA with the shale gas production but I'm sure EU will diversify in otehr regards as well. Whilst I've heard that before as well as talks about LNG terminals....the US barely registers as a supplier behind Algeria, Qatar, Libia, Nigeria,... It's not exactly cheap to transport across the atlantic.
- Normille 5y ago
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- karpierz 5y agoAnyone have thoughts on how this all pans out? I think that the only way out is that Ukraine cuts off its arm to save the head. It acknowledges the territories as lost, and consolidates what it has left. But I'm not sure how they do that without: 1. The current leader losing legitimacy, and likely resigning. 2. Opening the door for other parts of Ukraine to split off. 3. Opening the door to Russia to meddle in other parts of Ukraine/other nearby states to encourage them to split off. I don't see Russia backing off in the near future; they've held onto Crimea for the last 8 years without blinking. I don't see NATO involving itself militarily. If a US soldier dies defending Ukraine, I think that enough people will ask "why are we shedding American blood for something that has nothing to do with us?" I don't know that economic sanctions will be enough. We've been doing that for years, and nothing's changed. I don't know that providing weapons to Ukraine will be enough. While the Russians may lose soldiers in the coming months, I've heard that a lot of soldiers come from isolated parts of society (and so the people who mourn them aren't going to be able to organize political resistance).
- CodeGlitch 5y ago> I don't know that economic sanctions will be enough Plus gaining territory = more access to raw materials and labor. Perhaps that's Putin's plan?
- kshacker 5y agoA lot of people (on Reddit) are calling SWIFT expulsion as the lever. Also the nord stream 2 seems to be inoperational shutting down number 1 would have shown seriousness. So I don't know the endgame but I think the west has levers it is too chicken to use.
- davrosthedalek 5y agoI am quite happy that both sides are "too chicken" to use all the levers. Some involve putting in long strings of digits and turning keys at the same time. If the only way to survive for Russia is a full out war, we all lose. In that sense: Freezing outside assets might be better to convince the Russian oligarchs to find a peaceful solution: They get their assets back if they can find it. I think Putin being pressured internally by them is probably the best way out of this. On the other hand, taking outside assets away, or impacting income streams, and a peaceful solution doesn't have the upside anymore. The assets are gone, missed income is gone, and future income is uncertain. They might then support more military action. Out of vengeance, or because they see a better future in there.
- diimdeep 5y agoU.S. to be world's biggest LNG exporter in 2022 [0] “Approval of additional LNG exports from Freeport LNG furthers this Administration’s commitment to promoting American energy, American jobs, and the American economy. Further, increased supplies of U.S. natural gas on the world market are critical to advancing clean energy and the energy security of our allies around the globe. … for molecules of U.S. freedom to be exported to the world” [1]. "The Iron Curtain of the 1940s and ‘50s was ostensibly designed to isolate Russia from Western Europe – to keep out Communist ideology and military penetration. Today’s sanctions regime is aimed inward, to prevent America’s NATO and other Western allies from opening up more trade and investment with Russia and China. The aim is not so much to isolate Russia and China as to hold these allies firmly within America’s own economic orbit." [2] [0]: https://www.reuters.com/business/energy/us-be-worlds-biggest-lng-exporter-2022-2021-12-21/ https://www.reuters.com/business/energy/us-be-worlds-biggest... [1]: https://www.energy.gov/articles/department-energy-authorizes-additional-lng-exports-freeport-lng https://www.energy.gov/articles/department-energy-authorizes... [2]: https://www.counterpunch.org/2022/02/11/americas-real-adversaries-are-its-european-and-other-allies/ https://www.counterpunch.org/2022/02/11/americas-real-advers...
- gruez 5y ago>"The Iron Curtain of the 1940s and ‘50s was ostensibly designed to isolate Russia from Western Europe – to keep out Communist ideology and military penetration. Uhh what? If I remember my history class correctly, it was the east that built the berlin wall and had emigration restrictions, not the other way around. The wikipedia article confirms this. "The term symbolizes the efforts by the Soviet Union (USSR) to block itself and its satellite states from open contact with the West and its allied states. " >[2]: https://www.counterpunch.org/ https://www.counterpunch.org/ >"It has been described as left-wing.[3][4]" Oh, figures.
- diimdeep 5y ago>The Iron Curtain of the 1940s and ‘50s - here is more as a metaphor. >The Berlin Wall was a guarded concrete barrier that physically and ideologically divided Berlin from 1961 to 1989.
- yessirwhatever 5y agoTitle seems to be inaccurate, pipeline is not cancelled, it’s shelved.
- throwawaygjdbsj 5y agoI'd be less worried about gas prices and more worried about palladium. 44% of the world supply comes from Russia.
- parasense 5y agoEconomic consequences should be more than just NordStream. RU is both strong, and fragile in terms of economics. Their energy exports are strong, so that is clearly the biggest target. But depriving them import/export of non-energy stuff would probably cause significant economic impacts. However, the RU economy/society is resilient to contraction, being a quasi-commie society.... One only need look to North Korea for an example of how economic sanctions function, and dysfunction.... The RU is large enough to sustain a level of economic sanctions. If the western world only has economic consequences, well clearly that's a gambit RU is willing to accept. A new cold war will take decades to play-out.
- zzleeper 5y agoBut what are the options? - Don't do anything AKA appeasement? Then Russia will keep on invading countries (Georgia Ukraine), fostering enclaves in other countries (Moldova) and maybe even annexing Belarus (who is one mistake away from that). Also, remember how appeasement usually worked in the past... - War? Then you end up with WW3 By depriving as many resources as possible for Russia, you are limiting the scope they have to keep funding their huge armies. Maybe it won't help that much, but it's better than the alternatives.
- nikolay 5y agoSo, US is happy. I wonder if Germans would be. Germany and all EU countries are US puppets. I really don't know why EU needs US. To me, the one reason I don't like my own homeland, Bulgaria to be in EU (just like more than half of my compatriots don't according to polls) is the dependence on US. We were part of the Soviet Union, so, we replaced one dependence with yet another, even worse, I would say. Being in NATO, we have foreign troops on our land - it never happened during USSR! Just like with USSR, we have almost no say in EU politics! Today, Germany sacrificed the interest of its own people to please America! At the end, all this conflict is thanks to Biden who started the Euromaidan by pouring money into the opposition and media, and continued to press Ukraine knowing that Russia had to do something. I'm not a fan of Putin, but given the way America is doing its foreign politics, I feel he's needed to balance one evil with another type of evil. Unfortunately, the EU has no balls! And it's sad!
- CRConrad 5y ago> We were part of the Soviet Union, so, we replaced one dependence with yet another, even worse, I would say. Bulgaria was part of the Warsaw Pact, not of the Soviet Union. Maybe you should bone up a bit on recent history, before so confidently spouting off on it? Your current views seem woefully unfounded in actual reality.
- nikolay 5y agoSorry, I meant to say the Soviet Bloc.
- lostmsu 5y agoYeah, dependence is bad. Everyone should be growing their own food, and generating their own energy, and making their own smartphones. The basis of your point is not grounded in reality since the dawn of civilization.
- nikolay 5y agoWell, why is America dictating Germany that Nord Stream 2 should be cancelled? If you've watched even what publicly was shown on the TV, America is telling Germany what to do - like Germany is highly-dependent on the US somehow! Pathetic!
- rurban 5y agoSo we are back at the https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nabucco_pipeline https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nabucco_pipeline project, which Russia killed a few years ago.
- jquery 5y agoGood for Germany. More economic pain to come Russia’s way if they continue to be an aggressor. I think this aggression has exceeded Putin’s worst case cost calculations already. NATO was supposed to fracture under the pressure. Instead Biden and the other leaders brought NATO together, totally united against Russia. And now even other countries like Finland are floating trial balloons of joining NATO. This is just a disaster for Russia.
- simonblack 5y agoAs Dirty Harry would say "Go ahead. Make my day." Are the Germans dumb enough to shoot themselves in the foot, or what? Goodbye German industrial competitiveness, and Hello to China taking over those German markets.