9 ms·
> Now a lot of programmers have started to see Apple as evil. Not me (caveat: I worked at Apple). Clumsy is the word that comes to mind with regard to their ha
by JKCalhoun 5y ago
> Now a lot of programmers have started to see Apple as evil.
Not me (caveat: I worked at Apple). Clumsy is the word that comes to mind with regard to their handling of the AppStore. I see little or no evil intent
> Their fundamental problem is that they don't understand software.
That's a bold statement.
I'll be more nuanced. My impression is that Steve Jobs treated 3rd party software on "his devices" as a necessary inconvenience. He preferred the software he had a hand in, the software developed in house.
To me that is enough to explain Apple's approach to the AppStore.
- mandeepj 5y ago> Their fundamental problem is that they don't understand software. then in the same breathe, please tell me who understands it.
- Kye 5y agoOn the other hand, their Windows software is universally bad. The ending of Safari for Windows probably means they recognize this to some extent. My guess is they rely heavily on the quality of their libraries and tooling to make good software on OS X and iOS, and they struggle on Windows since it's an alien world. So maybe it's accurate to say they do understand tooling, and that negates the need to understand software as long as they stick to a world they control.
- pram 5y agoI realized this with Quicktime 7 and Quicktime X. X is my favorite media player, and yet the experience with 7 on Windows was like a time machine back to the shittiest parts of the 90s.
- DonHopkins 5y agoYou thought Quicktime 7 was bad? How about Quicktime 4.0 (released on June 8, 1999)? It took a few versions and a lot of hubris to get Quicktime 4.0 Bad. http://hallofshame.gp.co.at/qtime.htm http://hallofshame.gp.co.at/qtime.htm >Interface Hall of Shame - QuickTime 4.0 Player -
- JKCalhoun 5y agoHa ha, that is the shittiest part of the 90's right there.
- sillysaurusx 5y agoIt served its purpose. Back in 2009, iTunes on Windows was fantastic.
- NikolaNovak 5y agoI think that is not a universally agreed upon statement. Checking my receipts, at that time I paid significant money to 3rd parties to sync my iPods to PC without iTunes. It was massively over bloated for what I needed it to do, UI was behind, and once installed it refused to uninstall itself. (and same continues today. My wife has recognized the sound coming from my office when, every few months , I try to copy photos from my work-mandated iPhone to my windows pc. It's a few hours of screaming, then I give up) It's tricky. If they don't provide key software for Windows to work with their hardware devices, they'll be blamed for it and called an evil proprietary company (which, fair enough. Just let me plug it as USB storage if you want to avoid that particular reputation :). On the other hand, if they make their crucial software on Windows half assed, some people like myself at least, will be wary of touching anything Apple with 10ft pole. It May be that working strictly in Apple ecosystem makes for better experience, but that's not my world so I'm not tempted to dip my toes in any more than I have to).
- kodah 5y ago> My impression is that Steve Jobs treated 3rd party software on "his devices" as a necessary inconvenience. He preferred the software he had a hand in, the software developed in house. I'd say this is the struggle of every big firm. I like and contribute to open source, but I will almost always prefer whatever is built in house because the ease to influencing it's development to satisfy my needs is orders of magnitude smaller. Secondarily, when we build software outside of our host domain (as a business) it breeds innovation. Thanks for layering some context on top of PGs thoughts.
- TrinaryWorksToo 5y agoWhat's the difference between evil and negligent clumsiness?
- giantrobot 5y agoIntent.
- conception 5y agoIntent? Someone who’s evil probably can’t be convinced what they are doing is harmful, since they did it out of greed and selfishness. Someone who’s just incompetent can get better. Not that I think apple falls particularly in either category but there’s a difference, the ability to realize and change.
- elpakal 5y agoYou snuck the word negligent in there
- TrinaryWorksToo 5y agoI did, and that's why I don't think intent is a difference. It's malicious compliance which does have intent, imho.
- usefulcat 5y agoFor the party on the receiving end, maybe nothing.
- amitmathew 5y agoI agree - clumsy is a great way to describe their approach. In my many negative experiences with the review process, I never got the sense that there was evil intent. In the end, it's clear the business as a whole doesn't care about third-party developers - they fulfilled their goals of commoditizing their complements and rode that wave to enduring success. I do wonder how many amazing products and companies never got started or failed because of their fickle and Kafkaesque review process and their 15-30% revenue cut. For me personally, I've had to nix several business ideas and product features because it was too dependent on Apple's whims. But that's just Apple being Apple. What really blows my mind is how Google blindly followed Apple. Google could have carved out such a valuable market. No developer fees! Clear and consistent review process! No taking 30%! Instead they blindly walked into the ditch with Apple. Talk about a lack of vision...
- throwaway2048 5y agoYep, Google completely ignored why platforms like the PC beat the Macintosh to begin with
- scarface74 5y agoIsn’t Android the same Pyrrhic victory that Windows was for PC Makers? All of the market share but none of the profit? No PC maker is making any real money selling PCs just like no Android manufactures are making real money. At least MS made some decent money on Windows. Google has to pay its competitor Apple more than it makes on Android if you extrapolate what came out during the Oracle lawsuit.
- ido 5y agoDid they though? Apple is today by far the most profitable computer manufacturer.
- spicybright 5y agoWe call it a ditch, Google execs call it good returns.
- enos_feedler 5y ago
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- ineedasername 5y agoSteve Jobs treated 3rd party software on "his devices" as a necessary inconvenience. That only explains Apple's approach until Tim Cook became CEO. They've had more than a decade to evolve behind that mindset. The iPhone is more than 5x older now than it was when PG wrote this article. Jobs can't be blamed for much anymore. If Apple is still stuck in his vision of apps on iOS, that's on them now.
- masklinn 5y ago> That only explains Apple's approach until Tim Cook became CEO. Jobs’ decisions (if not necessarily his decision making process) are very much part of the company’s DNA, pretty much all the executives remain Jobsian picks. Plus it’s hardly been a failure in the market, and it’s not like direct competitors are disrupting the status quo, so from a business perspective what’s the incentive to change? > The iPhone is more than 5x older now than it was when PG wrote this article. And it’s never been more successful. Apple’s market cap’s grown by more than an order of magnitude since that essay.
- the_gipsy 5y ago> My impression is that Steve Jobs treated 3rd party software on "his devices" as a necessary inconvenience. That feels "evil" pretty fast, for someone trying to get his software published. Software that only works on their platform, that you could only develop with hardware they supplied.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- seanalltogether 5y ago> Clumsy is the word that comes to mind with regard to their handling of the AppStore. I see little or no evil intent The emails between Steve, Eddy and Phil seem to say differently. https://9to5mac.com/2020/07/30/internal-emails-show-how-an-amazon-ad-prompted-steve-jobs-and-phil-schiller-to-block-in-app-purchases-of-kindle-books-on-ios/ https://9to5mac.com/2020/07/30/internal-emails-show-how-an-a...
- bloqs 5y agoNever assume villany where stupidity is sufficient
- clusterfish 5y agoClumsy stupidity doesn't make you into the most valuable company in the world.
- jjtheblunt 5y ago(caveat: i too worked there) i think what you wrote matches my experience, is basically perfectly said.
- xunn0026 5y agoThat's a very... generous take. On my 1st London iPhone dev meetup there was a single representative from Apple: a biz dev guy! He asked a single question, when I commented the review process is annoying (compared to anything we had back then). So, in retrospect, Apple encircled the whole ecosystem from the get go and wanted 120% of all the money that could be extracted. And they executed on it rather flawlessly.
- jarjoura 5y agoI partially agree, evil is such a hyperbolic word. However, Apple and its rank and file during the Steve Jobs era believed 3rd party developers to be rather incompetent, and 3rd party software could never live up to the beauty that Apple itself could create. (I also worked at Apple) If it somehow proved Steve Jobs wrong and some indie company made popular beautiful software, Apple would bend over backward to acquihire them, sell off (read. kill) the product, and get them making beautiful software for Apple. Of course, back then, it was a dream for so many to get noticed by Apple and end up working there. Don't try to minimize the bad faith moves from Apple by calling them "clumsy". SJ (and proved through documents released from the Epic trial) absolutely treated everything as a zero-sum game and was exceedingly ruthless in getting what he wanted. On the one hand, yes, the iPhone App Store was just an expansion of the iTunes/iPod platform they had started and found worked well. Yes, it also simplified, what at the time, was an insanely complex web of mobile app markets that carriers themselves didn't truly understand the potential of. All would have been fine if they approached it with an open mind and listened to feedback. The main issue and feelings of "evilness" that so many people express about Apple, is that they so quickly used the App Store process as a weapon against anything that showed signs of stealing market share away from them. For example, around the start of the iPad, so many interesting book store startups launched, (ie. comic books, out of print books, etc.) and I loved it. However, SJ wanted his iBooks platform and through draconian changes in App Store policy, shut them all down over night. Sorry, but there's nothing clumsy about that that. It was very intentional, and very much directed at Amazon's Kindle, regardless of who got hurt along the way. Developers tried, repeatedly, to give feedback about ways to improve the App Store, time and time again. Instead, Apple closed feedback forums, canceled Q&As at WWDC, and followed up with more App Store policies against speaking out and essentially made it a privilege to work with them. I loved woking there, I really did, but we shouldn't minimize these feelings of evilness that so many developers express. Their intuitions are right and they deserve to get as much visibility for their pain as possible. Keep in mind that essay was coming from the perspective of a VC who was dealing with a lot of his startups struggling with the App Store and him trying to get Apple to listen. If that meant being dramatic with words like Evil, so be it, but in the end, surprise, it didn't really do anything heh.
- grishka 5y agoI'm an Android app developer. But, naturally, I have some insight into what my iOS colleagues do. Every iOS developer I know views the app store as an asinine hurdle that they have to clear, standing between them and their users. They never see it as something helpful. They certainly never see it anything like the way Apple's marketing portrays it. The process of releasing an update is stressful because you just never know whether they'll reject your app over something minor that you consider perfectly normal or even intentional. Oh, you fixed a critical bug? Too bad, we've typed the word "sex" into the search field and turned the safe search off, and naked people came up. You have to change your ToS to disallow that for us to consider approving your update.
- ksec 5y ago>I see little or no evil intent Evil in its absolute form rarely exist. Most evil are created by those who think themselves as so righteous. My definition of evil includes hypocrisy. Most of these so called "clumsiness" has been here for years. Most of the current strategy of services revenue growth started in 2014. We are coming close to a whole decade. I think we have given enough benefits of doubt to Apple. I have been suspicious of Google even in 2005 when they started building their own browser, it took the whole world 10+ years to turn their view from media darling to privacy invading company.