3 ms·
The coal price [0] is completely out of control. When there is that much money on the table, it is impossible to have any impact by buying a company and shuttin
by roenxi 5y ago
The coal price [0] is completely out of control. When there is that much money on the table, it is impossible to have any impact by buying a company and shutting down coal fired plants early.
AGL is more at risk of shutting their coal plants down because they can't afford the coal than because of any boardroom activism by M C-B.
Although I would be buying coal mines if I had that sort of money. Not to shut them down, but to get rich.
[0] https://www.barchart.com/futures/quotes/LQ*0/historical-prices?orderBy=contractExpirationDate&orderDir=desc https://www.barchart.com/futures/quotes/LQ*0/historical-pric...
- yakshaving_jgt 5y ago> Although I would be buying coal mines if I had that sort of money. Not to shut them down, but to get rich. …If you're rich enough to be buying coal mines, aren't you already rich?
- ZeroGravitas 5y agoI don't understand what you are suggesting, doesnt high input prices for coal-fired electricity and an energy company using less of it both move in the same direction? Cheap coal would seem to be more of an issue for his takeover plan.
- jillesvangurp 5y agoCoal plants are indeed doing a great job of making themselves extinct around the world. The problem is countries like Australia where they manage to defer that inevitability through government handouts, protectionist legislation, and overtly anti renewables policies. High prices help. Unstable prices help more. Coal mines are going to have a tough time dealing with rapidly dropping demand and making the necessary investments to keep on operating. Though prices are high, that's mostly because of competing mines not managing to survive. Nice for the ones that remain; but opening a new coal mine would probably be an investment that would be problematic mid to long term. Either way, Atlassian speeding things up a little might have a positive impact. Either way, the Australians could do more to nudge their country towards being a bit less dependent on burning stuff to keep their ACs going. It's not that hard. Most of their cities are close to oceans (with lots of wind power) and the continent is well known for having a lot of exposure to sun light throughout the year. Also, it does not have much of a winter even in places like Melbourne and Adelaide on its South coast, which have a latitude (37 degrees South) that is comparable to that of places like California (Santa Cruz), Northern Africa, etc. in terms of amount of sun light.
- dkjaudyeqooe 5y ago> it is impossible to have any impact by buying a company and shutting down coal fired plants early. AGL is responsible for about 8% of Australia's greenhouse emissions. The buyer's claim is that AGL is unable to make the transition quickly because they lack capital and say they'll be investing 20 billion. https://www.smh.com.au/politics/federal/q-and-a-can-mike-cannon-brookes-plan-to-close-agl-s-coal-plants-work-20220221-p59yek.html https://www.smh.com.au/politics/federal/q-and-a-can-mike-can...
- mistrial9 5y agocoal prices in s/New Castle/newcastle/ -- what is this?? can someone say why the price of coal in bulk appears to have raised 3x in 2021? bonus for why that chart shows numbers in the future without apparent change in typesetting from current (real?) numbers
- verelo 5y agoOdd side note but i see they’re spelling it “NewCastle” which prompted you to make it two words. I assume it’s in reference to the Newcastle coal port? Can anyone confirm. I grew up in the town, so the spelling caught my eye.
- wcoenen 5y agoChina's electricity consumption surged in 2021. There has been 14% more electricity produced by coal plants. Domestic coal supply has not kept up, so imports of coal and gas into China went up and prices increased. https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2021-09-27/why-china-is-facing-a-power-crunch-and-what-it-means-quicktake https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2021-09-27/why-china...
- wcoenen 5y ago> bonus for why that chart shows numbers in the future without apparent change in typesetting from current (real?) numbers These are the current prices for "futures". The date is when the coal will be delivered. As the delivery date nears, the price for the contract will converge to the spot price (assuming there is a spot market). For the dates in the past, the price shown is the last price before trading of that futures contract was halted.
- aussiegreenie 5y ago>Not to shut them down, but to get rich. The large thermal coal producers in Australia eg Whitehaven or Yancoal probably have a nett negative worth at this moment. Yes, they are currently selling coal for a high price but that will not last more than 2-3 years. Then the mines are worthless and you have a huge clean up bill. Using most DCF models the mines are worth nothing or less.
- Nasrudith 5y agoThe coal price being out of hand is what kills demand long term. It isn't like prohibition where taking it off the market is a subsidy to drug smugglers.