30 ms·
There is no way in hell this ad was actually written to attract people to VR. This is, like, the dystopian version of VR. The physical world crumbles around us
by bee_rider 5y ago
There is no way in hell this ad was actually written to attract people to VR. This is, like, the dystopian version of VR. The physical world crumbles around us as we live in a poor digital rendering of our nostalgia. Somebody must have been super psyched that Facebook was huffing their own farts so hard that they didn't realize this was a critique of their vision.
- germinalphrase 5y agoA better version of that story would really sell the addictive escapist appeal matched with the social incentives of participation (and maybe - more subtly - the coercive disincentives of non-participation) while allowing the dystopian reveal to happen gradually.
- bee_rider 5y agoThat would be better, but I think they've done about as well as they could while still convincing management that it is an ad.
- landhar 5y agoAnd the irony is really strong here since the term “metaverse” was coined in the context of a dystopian version of VR.
- kadoban 5y agoWas it? I thought it came from Snow Crash, and the VR in that book is generally a pretty nice part of that world IIRC.
- fknorangesite 5y ago> the VR in that book is generally a pretty nice part of that world Yes, that's the point: the metaverse in Snow Crash may be pretty nice, but the world outside the metaverse fucking sucks. That's the dystopia.
- kadoban 5y agoAh, understood. I read your original wrong then.
- woodruffw 5y agoThis comment[1] from a previous thread on the "metaverse" has stuck with me: there are real, living people who think that the world of Ready Player One is a valid aspirational goal, and some of those people work on projects like this. [1]: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28930355 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28930355
- bseidensticker 5y agoYou know what's worse than the world of ready player one? The world of ready player one where there is no VR. I don't think creating fully immersive VR is inherently bad.
- woodruffw 5y agoIt's been a decade since I've read it, but my recollection is that the book tightly conjoins the success of VR to the crumbling of the world's institutions and societies: there's a positive feedback loop between VR escapism and not tackling the world's problems. I'm not sure that "fully immersive VR" is intrinsically bad, at least not any worse than our current less immersive digital world. But it's not hard to see how VR can make a bad situation worse.
- seanw444 5y agoI'd argue that people would have more incentive to fix their real world if they hadn't had a fake one to escape to.
- bseidensticker 5y agoTrue, but you can use that argument against most forms of entertainment. Books, movies, video games, DND, sports, etc... VR is just another thing people can do in their leisure time. Everyone here is freaking out "oh no, Facebook is going to make something so entertaining society will collapse". I would be so proud of myself if I created something so entertaining society collapsed, lol.
- phs318u 5y ago
- rabite 5y agoThe problem is that the physical world crumbling around us is something that we can all see with our present eyes. That now those of us who live outside of East Asia are in the middle of a plunge into the abyss is plain as day. Simple things like visiting a grocery store or driving down the streets of ones childhood home are extremely alienating things that generate nothing but loathing and regret. Nobody is selling any solution better than escapism than this, and indeed, most people who say we should restore society to the standards of the times where we were building material prosperity and social fabric are called all called all sorts of pejoratives, banned from the workplace and financial services, and even subject to violence by mobs and militias that the state seems to either ignore completely or sometimes nod and winkingly support. All of society screams to you to shoot dope and put on the headset, and no other alternatives are given.
- vba616 5y agoI haven't seen any of this stuff. The only thing that worries me a little is the cars without license plates.
- rabite 5y agoYou haven't seen any of this stuff? There's been multiple frontpage articles on HN alone about financial institution based censorship. The Canadian government is gloating in public about banning people from the banking system and getting them fired from their jobs in the past week. I am absolutely stunned you haven't heard about any of this happening.
- vba616 5y ago>There's been multiple frontpage articles on HN alone I was replying to your original comment, focusing on the real world around me. You wrote "the physical world crumbling around us is something that we can all see with our present eyes" And "Simple things like visiting a grocery store or driving down the streets of ones childhood home are extremely alienating things that generate nothing but loathing and regret" I live on the edge of a small American city (roughly 1 million greater urban area) where it's only a few miles between downtown and the suburbs so I do errands anywhere in the vicinity. Early in the pandemic, it was the suburban grocery stores that had significant numbers of people who seemed pushy, vaguely angry at the world, and maybe 1/4 of them not wearing masks. I was more comfortable going to the inner city grocery store because everybody was wearing a mask and keeping their distance. Not that I was particularly paranoid about the virus, just because it felt less hostile and less crowded. The scariest thing I've seen there was a pickup truck plastered Florida-style with graphics and lettering about somebody's paranoid fantasies, vendettas, and politics. It straight up looked like someone who might randomly murder you if they learned you worked for state government because they think the governor is some kind of evil dictator coming to take their guns. I don't see my neighborhood crumbling. Haven't been to my "childhood home" but I don't think anything in particular has happened to the street it's on.
- barbacoa 5y agoYou could have done this commercial very differently in a way that would have made it feel much less unsettling: Garage band breaks up as members move away to start jobs/families. Band gets back together and plays in VR to large audiences. The fact that no one at Meta recognized how deeply dystopian the commercial was, leads me to believe dystopian is part of the plan.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]