8 ms·
AI generated faces are more trustworthy than real faces say researchers
- fvdessen 5y agoCould it be related to the fact that the average of multiple faces is perceived as more beautiful than each individual one ?
- tomcam 5y agoI think that's exactly it
- jollybean 5y agoThat's my hunch as well. Averaging evens out the oddities, likely creating a subtle bit more symmetry thus beauty thus trustworthiness.
- cjbgkagh 5y agoGANs are pretty good at not averaging as that is fairly easily spotted by the discriminator. It would assume the training set is biased to more attractive (who make better subjects for photos) so it would generate unattractive people at a lower probability than exists in real life. To do it properly you’d have to pull the real examples from the model training set and I didn’t see where they did that.
- ckrapu 5y agoThey are better than most VAE models at not averaging, but they may still not be covering the entire data distribution. That would probably imply that the underdispersed samples are closer to the average. We don’t have great metrics for figuring out how complete that coverage is.
- tqi 5y ago> People cannot distinguish between a face generated by Artificial Intelligence - using StyleGAN2- and a real face say researchers, who are calling for safeguards to prevent “deep fakes” ... The results revealed that synthetically generated faces are not only highly photo realistic, but nearly indistinguishable from real faces and are even judged to be more trustworthy. I dunno maybe instead of being worried about deep fakes we should be worried that in 2022 people still believe it's possible to judge "trustworthiness" based on nothing more than a headshot. Where was this even published, the New England Journal of Phrenology?
- alar44 5y agoCongratulations, you've missed the point entirely. No one is trying to literally judge how trustworthy the people actually are. I'm not sure how you got confused there.
- jollybean 5y agoExcept they literally judging trustworthiness, so there's that. What part of 'they are judging trustworthiness' do you not get? It's not an abstraction, that's what they are doing.
- alar44 5y agoThey literally aren't. They are asking which faces look more trustworthy. People think the AI faces look more trustworthy. Whether they are right or not (how could they be???) isn't the point.
- Talanes 5y agoThis conversation feels like there's just a slight disconnect between what "trustworthy" means. It's either an intrinsic quality that one possesses, or it's an external quality created by outside perception. It either means you are actually worthy of trust or that others find you worthy of trust. Or, at least, I had both definitions rattling around in my head, and had to think through which one I actually believed is correct. Sample size of 1 and all that.
- jollybean 5y agoWe know what 'trustworthy means', it's not an extant perception. We know exactly what we're doing when we estimate trustworthiness from a particular attribute. The particpants may or may not know some of the faces are AI, it's besides the point. 'Estimate how well a football player's career will go from a photo'. It doesn't matter if the photos are real or not - it's an understanding of which characteristics we use to estimate trustorthiness, assent knowing their actual trustworthiness.
- sennight 5y agoNewsflash: the fitness function still makes models more fit! Also, renowned scientist Neil deGrasse Tyson recently announced his latest and greatest discovery: photoshopped magazine covers sell better - finally giving purpose to what was previously thought to be a purely ritualistic removal of skin blemishes from photos of fashion models.
- 11thEarlOfMar 5y agoIt would be fun to have this system generate alternate families. Provide my photo, then have it generate a 'family' photo with me, my parents, wife, and 5 kids ages 3-12.
- Wistar 5y agoPerhaps it could also generate family getaway locales backgrounds, Disneyland, the beach, Grand Canyon, etc.
- userbinator 5y agoThe more interesting question is how long until people recognise these generated faces because they are "too real", and how long until AI starts deliberately making faces imperfect?
- adventured 5y agoYou're decades late on that. The AI is already deliberately making the faces imperfect. That's one of the early things you'd focus on when building systems like this.
- djohnston 5y agodecades late seems harsh, have we actually been generating faces for 20 years? i think im losing sense of time.
- worldsayshi 5y agoThis is all interesting but I fail to see that the risk for fraud is significantly elevated due to deep fakes. It has always been easy enough to make plausible material that "proves" something. To avoid fraud you need to be wary of the source and weight the new information based on previous interactions with the source by you or by people that you trust. Nothing is really new in this context right?
- leppr 5y agoWhat's new is the democratization of falsified images, not their existence. Nowadays, local police investigating a small crime would never doubt the veracity of photo or video evidence. If they are provided video evidence of someone committing a burglary, they won't do advanced analysis on the image before sentencing the person. This won't fool the FBI investigating the murder of a minister, but many authorities with less resources have to rely on video evidence. Very soon, anyone will be able to fabricate incriminating evidence with little effort. Unless tools catch up, this could become a serious problem.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- tsumnia 5y agoI think the "trustworthiness" dimension can be a little questionable. The Discussion section does bring this up - "This may be because synthesized faces tend to look more like average faces which themselves are deemed more trustworthy". In a sense, the model produces faces with less detail (or "average" looking faces). However, if you look at all the faces, they are "high quality" headshots. Would generated faces of, say, mugshots still produce higher levels of "trustworthiness"? Not to place any type of judgement on the individuals with a mugshot, but you would be generating a vastly different type of face.
- jimmygrapes 5y agoThere are a lot of public mugshot databases out there. Has anyone trained a facial generation model on them exclusively yet? I would try myself but it's nowhere near my field and I have no idea where I'd begin.
- kyle_v 5y ago
- peterbonney 5y agoMy broken-record reaction to headline-worthy research findings: The past decade of social science research publication has proven that provocative-sounding results should be considered fraudulent until the underlying data has been published, and then (assuming the data passes muster) should be regarded with skepticism until independently replicated with a fresh data set.
- terrycody 5y agoSo except thispersondoesnotexist.com, we have no way to use the same quality AI as stated in the paper, right?
- IgorPartola 5y agoOk so this is not exactly on topic and mostly humorous but I was just having a conversation with someone about how when the USSR had their program for trying to breed domesticated foxes the foxes eventually started having fluffier ears and bigger eyes and in general started looking cuter, even though the breeding selection was for human friendliness and not these factors. So as we “domesticate” AI maybe it’s becoming more cute to lull us into feeding it? :)
- jdrc 5y agoI mean, you could use training to train the AI to generate faces that seem more trustworthy so yeah, they should be more 'trustworthy'. And i m sure people will use this 'trustworthiness' for all the good reasons, right