8 ms·
Google lowered its salaries in North Carolina. Now workers are protesting
- binarynate 5y agoUnpaywalled: https://web.archive.org/web/20220218180545/https://www.washingtonpost.com/technology/2022/02/18/google-raleigh-hbcu-salary/ https://web.archive.org/web/20220218180545/https://www.washi...
- mattlondon 5y agoThis whole approach of paying what the local market offers, rather than what the job is worth kinda sucks. It strikes me that these sort of practices where employers share salary data with each other with the aim of keep salaries low is pretty sketchy and shady. A load of companies get together with the aim of making sure they don't pay a penny more than anyone else etc. In finance salaries and bonuses are to rocketing to attract and keep talent, yet in tech all the companies get together and basically implicitly agree not to compete. It is a shame that this appears to be legal. I guess we can vote with our feet/keyboards. How would a union work here if the company just turn around and say "sorry - your members are already at the top of the rate in this market. Our policy is not to pay more than the market rate. End of discussion."? You could move to another company, but they also only pay market rate etc.
- ketzo 5y ago> A load of companies get together with the aim of making sure they don't pay a penny more than anyone else etc. Are you referring to a general suspicion you have, or a specific case? Because this is categorically illegal, and has been punished before [1] to the tune of $415 million. [1] https://www.latimes.com/business/technology/la-fi-tn-tech-jobs-settlement-20150903-story.html https://www.latimes.com/business/technology/la-fi-tn-tech-jo...
- abhorrence 5y agoLots of companies engage third party companies that give "industry averages" or "comparable company averages". The company pays them with dollars and also their own average pay information. None of the companies are explicitly getting together and saying "let's keep pay at this level", but there's definitely some fishy stuff going on.
- ghaff 5y agoSince forever, there has been a huge industry of essentially information middlemen who act as a conduit for information companies can't directly ask a competitor for and wouldn't be given it if they could. Totally outside of the HR realm, when I was a computer system product manager pre-Web, we had a consulting firm that we paid way too much money to and when we were going to have a product launch, we asked them to, yes, fax us data sheets on various products we were positioning against. Later, there was another firm that collected pricing information which we needed for our pricing proposals.
- muro 5y agoThe companies will call it differently - they all share salary data with a third party, which for a discount shares numbers (probably aggregated by role, experience etc) back to the all those companies. Thus, they do "research" to understand the market rate, which they then use for salary negotiations.
- kenave 5y agoThey would just strike, no?
- ketzo 5y agoWhat would they be striking for? Collective bargaining is just that – a bargain. At the end of the day, the goal is to come to some kind of agreement. I guess the answer is that, assuming the union were national, they would try to set nationwide salaries and enforce them across the board.
- lozenge 5y agoImplicitly agree? They explicitly colluded once already. Expect a fine for their current behaviour that's a tenth of the money they saved, in ten years time.
- charcircuit 5y agoThere are sites like levels.fyi where employees can work together to also see what companies are paying.
- CaveTech 5y agoYou will never be paid what a job is "worth". You will (in aggregate) always be paid what the market demands. Value creation needs to be >> value extraction. I don't believe many companies can compete with Google on salary. Paying "market rate" is well... market rate. The discussion would in fact end there, because if you could easily seek employment for more than that elsewhere then it would no longer be the market rate. The alternative is to settle for the same or less elsewhere which brings into perspective that Google is no more wrong than any other employer.
- ghaff 5y ago>I don't believe many companies can compete with Google on salary. Paying "market rate" is well... market rate. In my broader circle, I see a lot more movement towards the likes of Google than away from--and most of the latter are senior people who don't need the money (or really didn't click with the job). Most companies that can will do creative things to snag or hold onto the people they want but I expect that most people who can land a Bay Area-salaried Google etc. position will just take that if money is the deal-breaker. Because most companies won't match in general.
- falcolas 5y ago> You will never be paid what a job is "worth". Unless you're in sales, a major league sport, or a C-level position. Then you're paid according to the "value" you bring to your team.
- CaveTech 5y agoYou're not. I hold a C level position, I create more value than I capture. These positions are not loss leaders, the organization (in aggregate) ends up ahead.
- seanmcdirmid 5y agoEven in sales and C-level positions and in major league sports, you are still getting paid based on demand (and supply) for your talent. They are going to pay as little as possible for the value you provide, but at the top talent has a much better negotiating position.
- matwood 5y ago> This whole approach of paying what the local market offers, rather than what the job is worth kinda sucks. What is the job worth? Outside of sales (or dealing with money directly like finance), it becomes hard to pin an exact $ value on the worth of a particular job. The reality is, almost all salaries are market based. What I expect to see over time as more companies move remote, is for the salaries to normalize to a country/region market which means less money in SF, but more if someone lives in the south.
- enriquto 5y ago> What is the job worth? Total profit divided by the number of employees?
- chrischen 5y agoThat’s a very generous way to calculate it, but that is not market rate.
- falcolas 5y agoOf course it's not the market rate... it's generous after all.
- lupire 5y agowhat about contractors and vendors?
- BeetleB 5y agoSo, everyone gets paid the same?
- enriquto 5y agoIt's just an approximation, which should be correct up to an order of magnitude. I guess it's alright if there's a factor of 5 between the highest and lowest paid employees.
- UncleMeat 5y ago> How would a union work here if the company just turn around and say "sorry - your members are already at the top of the rate in this market. Our policy is not to pay more than the market rate. End of discussion."? The union could organize a strike and demand different policies. Choosing not to work is the one piece of pressure that employees can leverage. Of course if you ask politely it won't change things. AWU does not yet have the scale to really make that happen yet, though.
- pjc50 5y ago> How would a union work here if the company just turn around and say "sorry - your members are already at the top of the rate in this market. Our policy is not to pay more than the market rate. End of discussion."? Then you have to change the market rate by withdrawing supply. That's essentially how strikes work. Sure, if they can sack everyone and find and onboard several hundred programmers overnight at the same rate, it's not going to work. Tends not to be that easy. Of course, the main reason programmers are already paid quite well is that the supply is short and the market rate is pretty high.
- NikolaNovak 5y ago>> This whole approach of paying what the local market offers, rather than what the job is worth kinda sucks. I mean, it does and it doesn't. In my limited experience, it works both ways almost exactly the same percentage of time. - Developers who want to move and work remotely in low cost areas but want to keep high salary - Employees of any kind who move to a bigger city and want cost-of-living wage increase, even though their job is the same Further more, "What job is worth" is so incredibly dependent on the market, I don't even know what other feasible (as opposed to theoretical) definition there may be. "Paying what the local market offers" and "what the job is worth" might as well be synonyms in a practical sense. OTOH, Anybody who wants to say we should pay salaries based on global market, should be aware that vast vast vast majority of developers worldwide get tiny fraction of SV salary. Even up here in frozen Canada, I have zero understanding of the salaries HN team members post. My understanding is that UK is similar - and that's without going to Easter Europe, or any other continent.
- BeetleB 5y ago> rather than what the job is worth kinda sucks. Outside of things like sales, no one knows what your job is worth. Not you, and not your employer. It's incredibly hard to figure out how much your contributions affected the bottom line. Your accomplishments are dependent on many other employee's efforts. There's no good way to disentangle that. That's why everyone just looks at the market value.
- kodah 5y agoGeographical pay in any industry with a geographically stable product pricing is wage suppression. If the product is a SaaS offering and it is sold from state to state for the same price then employees in each of those states should get the same amount of money for their work. Companies should not get to hand $300k in RSU's plus a $200k salary to someone in Mountain View, CA and only offer $150k in cash benefits plus a dental plan to someone in Texas. This contributes to the problem that I colloquially call state-to-state income inequality.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- kar5pt 5y agoI dont know when or how people got the idea that salaries are based on what a job is "worth" (a perfect tautology). Standard econ theory would predict salaries are based on supply and demand like everything else, not some metaphysical property called "value". If you don't like that, you need an economic system that doesn't base people's incomes on the market.
- seanmcdirmid 5y ago> I guess we can vote with our feet/keyboards. If Facebook or Apple offer more money than Google in North Carolina, isn't that what would happen? If Google is already the top, and is just offering less than it is in other markets, it's not like they have much competition for top talent. Actually, it also works out that someone might be able to get a position at Google in one market and not another because more open headcount is available in the former market...and I don't think many people would complain about gaming the system that way.
- foogazi 5y ago> I guess we can vote with our feet In this case, both options are available: switching employees or switching to a city with higher pay
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- jaredklewis 5y agoHas it ever been common to pay people by the value they create as opposed to their replacement cost? It’s a market. You can create millions in value but if someone else can create the same value and will take the job for $100k, why not just hire them?
- phendrenad2 5y agoMeh, the alternative is Google closes their North Carolina office and moves back to Mountain View. You're right, it does suck, but you can't have it both ways.
- jjav 5y ago> This whole approach of paying what the local market offers, rather than what the job is worth kinda sucks. Yes, it kinda sucks. The alternative though, seems worse. It's nice to be able to move to a low cost area and still have a very good salary vs. local cost of living even if it is lower than in silicon valley. It's also nice to be able to live in silicon valley or NYC and get a living wage (much higher since it's needed). What's the alternative? Same pay scale everywhere? Sure, but it won't be the silicon valley scale. It would be based on the lowest cost of living location the company cares to cater to, making it impossible to live in silicon valley. That's worse.
- crims0n 5y agoThis isn’t unique to Google, same thing happened to me. Working for a name brand technology company in Atlanta, but am located remotely in the Raleigh-Durham area. My pay scale is “corrected” for the difference in markets and am payed a good 20% less than my Atlanta counterparts. By my calculation though, the cost of living in Atlanta isn’t near 20% higher than Raleigh-Durham… so not sure what else is factoring into that descrepancy.
- globalise83 5y agoThey presume you have a weak bargaining position and will accept a lower salary for want of alternative opportunities.
- dvdhnt 5y agoI worked for a consultancy when covid started. They decreased salaries in case the economy tanked. They also started recruiting in cheaper places like Colombia. Low and behold, salaries were never brought back to pre-pandemic levels.
- patorjk 5y ago> The company set up an internal calculator for workers who left the expensive areas of San Francisco and New York to calculate how much their pay would be cut if they did not return If you moved based on what the calculator said and then they cut your pay that's pretty messed up. I don't think the workers should expect to be paid the same as higher cost of living areas, but transparency in how these calculations are made should be available to them (especially if the rates can change year-to-year).
- khc 5y agofrom the article, google isn't lowering anyone's existing pay, but is lowering future new stock grants
- UncleMeat 5y agoEntire teams were relocated to the Raleigh-Durham area. People were told that they'd get a 15% pay cut to salary but instead got a 25% cut to both salary and equity refreshes. No other location in the country was cut in this manner.
- abofh 5y ago> I don't think the workers should expect to be paid the same as higher cost of living areas Why not? You're paid to create value for your employer. If (and let's handwave and say if) you're creating the same amount of value in location A as location B - why shouldn't _you_ get to pocket the difference in the cost of living? I'm all for arguing about value creation by having spontaneous meetings and interactions that are easier when people are relatively closer together - but cost of living should have no bearing on what an employer compensates you for my labor - your ability to create value is literally the only thing that should matter.
- takk309 5y agoCan't the reverse be argued? Why should they pay you more than the value of your work just because you live somewhere expensive?
- dvdhnt 5y agoThe end of the article explains "going to the south for cheaper labor". Definitely agree. My only concern about maintaining pay across the world -- does it contribute to inflation in those areas? Would this be bad for the areas? Or does it help by adding revenue?
- birdyrooster 5y agoThe people who weren’t willing to move out of their small towns are almost defined by their aversion to risk and must settle for less. Why wouldn't corporations take advantage of this?
- s3r3nity 5y agoAh yes - clearly I have "risk aversion" & "settled for less" because I don't want to live in a city that _literally_ has a problem with human shit on the streets in 2022 vs. other states that are willing to actively recruit workers like me with 0% income taxes, plenty of land to buy, among other benefits. Take the L and the downvote.
- birdyrooster 5y agoNot sure what you are talking about. Been watching too much Fox News?
- ketzo 5y agoThe current back-and-forth over regionally-adjusted pay for workers is one of those arguments where I truly find it very difficult to come to a conclusion. On the one hand, the logic of the employees is pretty irrefutable: why should anyone be paid less money for the same work, just because they have a different zip code? On the other, it's hard for me not to agree with the employers' basic arguments. In a capitalist sense, they're gonna pay what they need to, nothing more: market-based pay is just that. PR aside, they're running a business. Probably the argument that makes the most sense to me in favor of pay adjustments is that a worker making a Bay Area salary in North Carolina is effectively being paid more than their SF-based-counterpart, because while the nominal value of their compensation is the same, the NC worker's purchasing power is much higher. In one view, they are (almost!) literally being paid more. But I just can't get over the very basic logic of "same work, same pay." It seems deeply, critically unfair to me – and beyond unfair, it seems like a quick way to make anyone outside SF feel "lesser-than." I don't know. Does anyone have links to convincing arguments you've read one way or the other? I think this really is a kind of unsolved question, and one that is only growing in importance with remote work.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- will_walker 5y agoThis is a great analysis. I'd also add that the value of being able to work in-person is not zero - some roles can go fully remote, but things like user research are much more difficult to conduct remotely (particularly with hardware). Finally, the reason the Bay Area / NYC cost the most are because they attract on the whole, highly qualified talent. It's not unexpected that the salary scales would be where the senior, high performing talent is implicitly located.
- geodel 5y ago> But I just can't get over the very basic logic of "same work, same pay." Well when same people are taking advantage of not only cheap goods (housing and all) but also cheap services, they may have some slick sounding arguments on their side but not some moral high ground for equal pay. > I don't know. Does anyone have links to convincing arguments you've read one way or the other? There can't be any. Unfairness against one's self feels visceral but against others it is mostly along "Well they don't work in IT industry so they are different" or even better "Well this schmuck could go ahead get ML PhD and earn million dollar/year. No one is stopping them."
- softwarebeware 5y agoWow, this looks bad whether or not you accept the argument that the same work should result in different pay based on location. Let's say you still accept that pay should be "market-" (location-) based. It still looks like Google is targeting their black and brown employees with lower pay.
- btilly 5y agoSo Google aimed to hire more people in North Carolina so that they would hire more blacks. And now they are lowering salaries there. Which will disproportionately hit blacks. Guess what this does to pay equity between races within Google?
- pinephoneguy 5y ago
- drsnow 5y agoThey cannot possibly be this short-sighted could they? What is their rationale??
- anon23anon 5y agoare these jobs mostly replacing hard drives and what not when they go bad at the server farm?
- exolymph 5y agoIt's not like the people making these decisions care about racial pay equity as an end in itself, they pursue these moves so the wokest 10% of employees keep their discontent to a simmer instead of drumming up lawsuits. Counterproductive doesn't matter until it affects PR + recruiting. Meanwhile, cheaper labor, that's something the people managing P&L do care about...
- ReadEvalPost 5y agoOn one hand they cut my base salary by 25% when I went remote in AZ, but on the other I'm paying 35% less in housing to own a 3 bedroom house instead of renting a 1 bedroom apartment. I get the annoyance but there's something to be said about being grateful about the overall purchasing power increase.
- mabbo 5y agoYou're worth that 25% more though. The value you provide is not based on your location. You deserve better.
- anon23anon 5y agodis viewpoint be silly
- deltree7 5y agoyour worth to any innovative firm is definitely based on where you are located. On an average, Long Run, By collaborating with Silicon Valley minds, in-person, you'll generate more value than sitting Remote or hanging out in North Carolina. These would have been never been possible if Jeff and Sanjay were remote https://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2018/12/10/the-friendship-that-made-google-huge https://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2018/12/10/the-friendship...
- UncleMeat 5y agoAnd Jeff and Sanjay wouldn't be like L11 or whatever ridiculous level they are if they hadn't achieved those things. There are already mechanisms for rewarding innovation and impact. Maybe remote workers will be less innovative and have less impact. That should be addressed in performance reviews, not through assumptions.
- misslibby 5y agoIs this the new variation of value theory of labour? Workers are just market participants, competing with other workers. One way they can compete is by lowering their living costs, so that they can get by for less and afford to offer their services for lower rates. Likewise companies compete and try to make their products more affordable. This is how we arrived at the situation of extreme surplus in Western countries. Not by some entity (or internet commentators) setting arbitrary price points for things.
- 908B64B197 5y agoI don't get why cost of living is factored at all. The biggest expense is typically housing. And if you bought the house, it means the biggest expense is... building equity into an asset you can sell afterward. Keep in mind the engineer who purchased a 2 million house in Palo Alto can sell it for two million, and then move to Ohio to a much cheaper house purchased in cash. The reverse isn't true. Now, let me tell you a little secret. These "official prevailing wage calculators" are all "corporate policy from HR" and aren't real. There are a lot of engineers that have special deals with their organizations and keep the same salary bands, no matter what HR says. Just make sure you are at a profit center.
- jefftk 5y ago> I don't get why cost of living is factored at all. It isn't. It's cost of labor, not cost of living. "How much do we have to pay you to keep you from switching to a plausible competitor." (Disclosure: I work for Google, speaking only for myself)
- UncleMeat 5y agoIn most cases I agree, but in this case it is BS. There is no planet where the cost of labor in Raleigh-Durham is lower than in REMOTE-NC (or REMOTE-WY). Folks in REMOTE-NC didn't get their equity refreshes adjusted down. The people in Raleigh-Durham did. The Raleigh-Durham office pays less than literally every other location in the US. Also a Googler.
- jefftk 5y agoI agree that this is broken, but that's an unrelated issue? Cost of living in Raleigh-Durham is also not lower than REMOTE-NC. Instead, the problem is inaccuracy in estimating cost of labor. That is, they are trying to base it on cost of labor and failing.
- lotsofpulp 5y agoIf that is true, then google will have bet wrong, and will suffer from people quitting who found better opportunities and need to increase pay to entice others. If people do not quit, then Google’s bet was correct.
- sremani 5y agoAny throwaway account from Google current or former higher ups can chime on this? I can think of one reason is to be keep employees in few locations concentrated to get some political leverage. Mr.Senator from CA, if you are doing this X, there are 50K of our employees in the State of CA paying taxes so we may have to move them to AZ kind of lobbying. May be some tax rebates or other incentives from state or city. Google wants to maintain a certain strength in certain states -- if their workforce is diluted across US - they may not have these kind of levers. So, they are using COLA based pay to get people to move to their favorite location(s). Or it could be down right -- hey employee X will be paying $10K in less taxes -- how about we get $8K of that. May be petty or may be not!
- dleslie 5y agoAs a Canadian developer who frequently works for or with Americans, my entire career has been one where I'm acutely aware that my American coworkers make significantly more than me for the same level of responsibility. Yah, it stinks. The alternative is moving to the valley; it used to be that the calculation was in the tune of a 30% pay raise or similar, but nowadays it's likely closer to a 2x or 3x difference in pay. I have no doubt that those working in North Carolina, or in similarly "remote" areas, will find their wages stagnate as well.
- ketzo 5y ago> will find their wages stagnate as well. I think the passport makes a pretty huge difference. The barriers to moving from North Carolina to California – while high – are nothing compared to the process of immigrating to the United States (at least from everything I've ever read about that process).
- __turbobrew__ 5y agoCanadian citizens can pretty trivially acquire a TN visa to work as a software engineer in the US. Your living situation is less secure on a TN visa compared to permanent residency however.
- dleslie 5y agoThe passport really isn't an issue, at all. I know a great deal of people who have moved south and have only heard of trivial issues related to border crossings, and never issues with residency and work permits. Being a tech worker from Canada makes the USA a fairly open market for your skills. But as will likely be similar for individuals from North Carolina, my anchor to this geographic location is the social and familial network that my family relies upon. Moving to another geographic location is appealing, and a great option, when young and lacking in responsibilities; but I'm quite hesitant to uproot my children and wife, placing them far away from their friends and extended family, in order to live in a location that lacks the qualities that makes raising a family here so appealing.
- natpalmer1776 5y agoI'm probably the tiny minority here, but I think this is a great thing. There are simply too many competing factors for me to refine my reasoning into an argument that is impervious to casual pedantry, however the gist of it is that I believe tech workers are becoming far too entitled. I keep seeing numerous comments about unionizing to demand fair pay and treatment, and yet the individuals who would form these proposed unions are (almost) all pulling above 100k annual salary (base) which leaves me with a bad taste in my mouth. The median household income was $67k in 2020. That means 50% of all families, potentially with both adult members actively working, earned just over half of what your typical software engineer earns.
- ketzo 5y agoHonestly... I tend to agree. In a nation with such massive wealth inequality, in a city where people are living in tents under highways, I see people complaining about $300k TC as a "lowball offer." From an individual perspective, I get it: why wouldn't you want to strive for the maximum you could possibly get? People are motivated by money, that's fine. But man, it sure feels like the guillotines should be coming out pretty soon.
- lupire 5y agoengineers make over $100K? managers make over $1M. Owners make over $1B. Why are you fighting for them?
- ketzo 5y agoThat is very clearly not what OP is saying, and you're picking a strawman fight. OP is not arguing that Bezos is totally and completely deserving of his billionaire status. They're just saying that it feels a little gauche to bitch and moan publicly about losing 10% of your 200k compensation in a time where 60% of Americans are living paycheck-to-paycheck. Maybe those workers do deserve more! Maybe much more! But man, it's hard to not feel a little tone deaf. Obviously, this is only one small facet of a large and complicated discussion. No one is "fighting for" managers and owners here. The OP isn't even explicitly anti-union! Just pointing out the "bad taste."
- outside1234 5y agoIf you don't like the pay, vote with your feet. I suspect the reason pay is lower in North Carolina is that not enough people are switching employers - this is what helps the market find the equilibrium point in terms of pay. And clearly Google isn't paying too low - people are taking the jobs after all.
- xiphias2 5y agoBoth changing jobs and protesting are market discovery processes, but protesting is less disruptive, as people already know the code base, which is good both for them and for the company.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- extr 5y agoI would be interested to hear the arguments that posters here would make if they were in charge of a firm that did analysis and found that they were paying labor costs in gross excess of the market rates needed to retain employees. How would you justify that to shareholders? Put it another way. You are a firm that needs steel as an input. You can buy identical steel for $1000/ton from supplier A, or $800/ton from supplier B, who saves on costs by locating their steel mill in a cheaper geographic area. Would you say, actually, that's not fair to supplier B, "same steel same price"? No, of course not. An even better (more direct) example is that of offshore IT labor costs. I would expect anyone here arguing for "same job same pay" would support equal (100% of SV pay) for any offshore labor their company employs, all else being equal with respect to individual labor output. I get that people aren't used to thinking of themselves as participants in a market for their labor. But unless we want to do a revolution or something I don't see this going away. In fact, it's only going to get worse, because as remote work becomes more and more normalized the competitive advantage of "locality" will erode entirely and you'll be competing in a global labor marketplace, with potentially much slimmer margins. Disclaimer: I'm someone who recently joined a large tech firm and saw my salary location-adjusted pretty significantly. It still blew away my previous compensation with local firms.
- jbay808 5y ago> Put it another way. You are a firm that needs steel as an input. You can buy identical steel for $1000/ton from supplier A, or $800/ton from supplier B, who saves on costs by locating their steel mill in a cheaper geographic area. Would you say, actually, that's not fair to supplier B, "same steel same price"? No, of course not. I'd expect that you wouldn't go on buying $1000 steel from supplier A?
- dkobia 5y agoIs it unreasonable to think that the market will pay what the market will bear? Surely you can’t expect that the ability to work from anywhere wouldn’t come at a price? Ultimately people will vote with their feet, get replaced by what is now a much greater talent pool and this cycle will continue until an equilibrium is found. I suspect that the sad outcome will be the rise again of places like San Francisco and Seattle.
- abernard1 5y agoI find the whole argument moot long-term. As a long-term non-SF tech worker, companies are going to move out the Bay Area whatever they do. Scenario A: they pay less but receive the same quality of workers (and no, Bay Area folks you are not especially talented compared to the national or global pool.) Scenario B: they pay the same, and pull much more senior people many of them could not afford in a higher cost of living environment. Scenarios A and B both rapidly push labor outside of the Bay Area. Frankly, this is irreversible at this point.
- frankish 5y agoI think requiring physical presence in an office justifies differing salaries based on geographic location. I think remote employees are the only reasonable scenario for same work, same pay. There are real quality of life implications for living in an expensive city. Companies that want a physical presence there should pay a premium for it because employees should have the option to live close to their office as a default option.