3 ms·
Student loans are a horrible idea then, because plenty of students choose degrees with very crappy earning potential anyway. Most of them manage to deal with t
by zozbot234 5y ago
Student loans are a horrible idea then, because plenty of students choose degrees with very crappy earning potential anyway. Most of them manage to deal with their debt burden one way or the other, but the for-profit college population has a harder time doing that.
- core-utility 5y agoYes, you're hitting the core of the problem. Loan issuance should be based on ability to provide a career with a return that can reasonably pay the loan. No bank would issue a loan for a major with crappy earning potential, so why does the government?
- azth 5y agoLoans (interest bearing ones) have been a known parasitic and immoral practice for thousands of years as they're prohibited in the three major religions (Islam Judaism, and Christianity). The sooner we get rid of for profit loans the better.
- chii 5y agoNot all loans are parasitic - and i dont care for morality arguments since different cultures and belief systems produces different moral systems, and hence not a very objective method of measurement. Loans that produce higher profit than the interest payment is a good (aka, non-parasitic) loan. The student loans _could_ be good, or could be parasitic - it depends on the degree. Unfortunately, because of gov't guarantees and backing, the risk of the loans is offloaded to the taxpayers, but the profits taken by the private institutes. This is what makes it parasitic in most cases. If a private entity is not willing to make the loan, then the gov't shouldn't either. Then naturally, only the non-parasitic loans would be given.
- azth 5y agoThe only non-parasitic loans are those given at 0% interest, which is inline with the three religions. Of course the follow up question is how would you run a bank or business that profits from loans? The answer is: you don't. Society is strictly better off without such parasites. There are other ways for true risk sharing such as paying someone with a business idea cash in exchange for a portion of his business. If it succeeds, both parties benefit, if it doesn't, both parties lose. > and hence not a very objective method of measurement. It is very possible to measure the outcome of such system. Look at our current financial system today how corrupt it is, and compare it to the financial laws that Islam defines and the financial health of the resulting societies in each. Wall St would have to be shut down because of the immoral and parasitic practices it engages in (shorting, selling what you don't own, options, selling debt for debt, loans and mortgages, money printing (we know who's in bed with the fed) etc. etc.). The problem is that people keep believing they can patch the system to make it work out, but in actuality, the system only benefits a select few at the top, while everyone else suffers. The end is not going to be pretty when it all comes crashing down.
- imtringued 5y agoAncient egypt had grain banks. Grains tend to spoil at a rate of 2-4%. A loan with 0% interest is actually profitable because you get fresh grain with no loss at the end. You don't have to worry how to store your physical wealth. Money lets us pretend that society must pay the cost of spoiled grains by replacing them with fresh grains free of charge. So people must constantly raise prices or stop working.
- imtringued 5y agoIn principle there is nothing wrong with loans. The problem is that people can simply hold cash for free. They demand +x% (liquidity preference) on top of the guaranteed 0% so the market interest rate never actually falls to zero. Central banks have to simulate negative interest rates via quantitative easing it is completely backwards.
- azth 5y ago> In principle there is nothing wrong with loans. Interest free loans, yes. Interest bearing loans? They're immoral and parasitic. > The problem is that people can simply hold cash for free. Islam solved this with Zakat.
- imtringued 5y agoThat would require a demurrage currency to eliminate liquidity preference.
- mcv 5y agoNetherland used to give students a small monthly stipend instead of a loan. In the 1990s, they changed it to a loan, but now talks are that that was a bad move, and it should go back to being a stipend. Free or cheap education seems to be a far better idea than enormous loans to pay for overpriced for-profit colleges. Education is not just about earnings potential; it's also an investment in society as a whole. A society with a well-educated population is better off than one without. Although expensive education that doesn't provide any job prospects is kinda pointless, and those definitely do exist.
- rayiner 5y ago> Education is not just about earnings potential; it's also an investment in society as a whole. A society with a well-educated population is better off than one without. Citation needed. The prosperous America you live in was built by generations where the vast majority of people hadn't gone to college. When Intel was founded in 1968, only about 10% of the population had four or more years of post-high school education. When Apple was founded in 1976, that number was still under 15%. Since then it seems we've hit diminishing returns. 35% of the population has a college degree, but that just means your receptionist has a college degree, where previously they would have been a high school graduate. Waiters and bartenders are more likely to have a bachelors degree today (about 15%) than the general population was back when Intel was founded. Does that make us better off?
- bradlys 5y agoWe’ve also not become a nation of manufacturing. What’s your point, dude?
- rayiner 5y agoThe jobs of the future never materialized. Receptionists are doing the same thing they always did. People use more computers now, but literally children can use computers. I’d even argue that our service-oriented economy requires even less education and intellectual horsepower than the manufacturing and construction oriented economy of the past. I strongly suspect our economy would continue to run fine if half the people who go to college now never went (and we banned the practice of requiring college degrees as a threshold filter for people who have their shit minimally together).
- bko 5y agoThere's a bit of selection bias. For profit colleges often target people who are not able to go to public schools for whatever reason. Might be convenience or specialty. For instance those N month training courses to be a paralegal or whatever are pretty good on face value. The alternative isn't a 4 year college degree. I also remember looking into basic college courses around 10 years back (I already have a degree) and found literally no options that weren't in the middle of the day. Zero. This was in the entire City University of New York (CUNY) system too, not some small school. So public school courses isn't really an option if you're working full time.