7 ms·
Some neurons are active when adding, others when subtracting
- kensai 5y agoFascinating! I wonder if multiplication/division is just a combination of these neurons or again some other.
- JackFr 5y agoIt's not. This is garbage research. Nine participants took part in a study where they were prompted to do mental arithmetic adding or subtracting numbers between 0-5 while wired up with ultra-fine electrodes measuring the how frequently 585 individual neurons fired while completeing the task. I presume at that point the data were mined for a publishable result. What they came up with was that by selecting a very small subset (~%5) of the neurons they measured they were able to tease out a result that certain neurons 'encode addition or subtraction'. Is this real? Maybe. It's in now way explanatory. It doesn't offer any sort of model hypothesis or predictions worth testing. It's really a waste of time.
- heurisko 5y agoI wonder if it is also plausible that these neurons are not showing as active for calculation purposes, but instead active as they are triggering the human emotion to loss aversion. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Loss_aversion https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Loss_aversion
- 323 5y agoLoss aversion has a bit of a reproducibility problem, as stated even in your link. https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s00426-018-1013-8 https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s00426-018-1013-8 https://osf.io/en9qj/ https://osf.io/en9qj/
- barrenko 5y agoIdiotic concept.
- heurisko 5y ago> In Comments > Be kind. Don't be snarky. Have curious conversation; don't cross-examine. Please don't fulminate. Please don't sneer, including at the rest of the community.
- candlemas 5y agoI want to know what happens when you are asked to pick a random number. How does the brain work that out?
- 323 5y agoIt's well established that 17 is the most random number between 1 and 20. https://www.livejournal.com/poll/?id=961998 https://www.livejournal.com/poll/?id=961998
- jcims 5y agoQuick consultation with GPT-3 on the subject. Q is me A is the computer. — Q: What is the most random number between one and 20? A: 17 Q: Why do you say that? A: Because it is impossible to know for sure which number will come up when you roll a die or draw a card from a deck. Q: So why did you pick 17? A: It is just as likely as any other number to come up. Q: But I specifically asked for the most random number. What is the most random number? A: There is no such thing as the most random number. Q: Then why did you say 17? A: Because it is as random as any other number. Q: OK then, what is the least random number between one and 20? A: 1
- 323 5y agoWe wanted artificial intelligence, but what we got is artificial stupidity :)
- ozzmotik 5y agostupidity is just misapplied or developing intelligence. can't have one without the other lol
- jacquesm 5y agoStupidity beats insanity by a large amount.
- galaxyLogic 5y agoIt's an old saying that: Having opinions is great, because opinions are already half intelligence. But come to think of it, is there any AI which has "opinions"? Wouldn't that take AI closer to human intelligence?
- pwdisswordfish9 5y agoIt would have been strange if brain activity looked exactly the same while performing different tasks. I mean, for once we might actually have some evidence for dualism.
- csee 5y agoAny way to see what's going on inside one of these neurons while it's spiking for a particular calculation problem
- floxy 5y agoWhat about adding a positive number to a negative number?
- firebaze 5y agoThis is only true for a large subset of people, I'd bet 80:20 on :)
- Taniwha 5y agoit's not surprising of course - if only because most addition and subtraction involves small sets of disjoint memorized number facts
- 323 5y agoNot that surprising. For humans, unlike for computers, adding and subtracting are different concepts. Think about how most people would transform "-3 + 7" into "7 - 3" and only then compute, because it's easier to "reverse" the operation than work with negative numbers.
- jimmygrapes 5y agoI'd be interested to see what difference, if any, there is in people who learned addition and subtraction in fundamentally different ways. Number line vs counting grids, pattern based, mental imagery, etc.
- ganzuul 5y agoAnd one is learned after the other. If you learned the same thing twice, it would probably not show up as two things.
- andbberger 5y agoIt's not that surprising, but not for that reason (to a neuroscientist). While the circuit implementation for subtraction is non-obvious, the circuit implementation for addition is and with Dale's 'law' in mind, even without knowledge of the subtraction circuit it is a very reasonable hypothesis that it would be implemented by a different circuit than addition.
- air7 5y agoI haven't read the article, but isn't such a statement tautologically true? Because neurons exist in all abstraction levels of the thought process, if you compare any two distinct processes, you're bound to find (by the fact that they are distinct) some neurons that fire during one and not the other.
- delusional 5y agoI don't think we know what the abstraction level of neurons are. It seems reasonable to assume that it's at the level os individual thought processes, but trying to prove that assumption might lead to interesting results.
- epgui 5y agoPeople cling very hard to the idea that humans (or human "consciousness") are somehow special, and not at all like a computer. It will take a very long time to break this idea.
- kfarr 5y agoThis just in, complex systems with multiple parts use subsets of these parts for specific actions!
- sva_ 5y ago> if you compare any two distinct processes, you're bound to find (by the fact that they are distinct) some neurons that fire during one and not the other. I would doubt that. It depends on what neurons fired before it. The neurons firing before it might drastically change context. It doesn't seem like a single neuron is responsible for a single piece of information, it is rather an emergent phenomenon of combinations of neurons firing. But I'm speculating.
- lorenzfx 5y agoThe PI was also involved in an earlier study [1, 2], that found "Jennifer Aniston neurons", i.e., neurons that get activated when the proband gets shown an image of Jennifer Aniston, but not activated when shown the image of another celebrity. It's probably not that surprising, that other cells are active during other specific activities and inactive during others. Anyway, it's fun seeing my old institute featured on hn. [1] https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4210637/ [2] https://sci-hub.st/https://doi.apa.org/doiLanding?doi=10.1037%2F0033-295X.117.1.297
- amelius 5y agoHow precise can this technique determine which neurons fire? Are we really talking about individual neurons, or more about large groups of neurons?
- wallscratch 5y agoThere are a few techniques: Patch clamp recording: you are literally sticking a needle into a single neuron and measuring it’s activity EEG/MEG: using electrodes to measure activations of many thousands or millions of cells
- amelius 5y agoOk, but I guess that recording which neurons fire when the subject is performing certain tasks does not fall into the category of "sticking a needle into a single neuron".
- bayesian_horse 5y agoI'd rule out patch clamp. That would be too difficult and slow. It sounds like they have very sensitive electrodes that are either very close to individual neurons, and then they shift those around, or they have a lot of those sensitive electrodes and compute the location of signal sources in 3D space. The latter would be a lot more economical.
- momenti 5y ago
- cat_plus_plus 5y agoAnd some multiply by dividing
- analog31 5y agoAre we talking integers or IEEE floats?
- bayesian_horse 5y agoI'd say it's pretty obvious that would be the case. It's how a neural network or a "brain" in general has to work. More remarkable is to actually find those neurons and differentiate them from all the others. Preferably without too much damage...