6 ms·
A huge problematic deficiency of 1Password is that it lacks literal multi-line text field types. The items in its database let you define custom fields for the
by DonHopkins 5y ago
A huge problematic deficiency of 1Password is that it lacks literal multi-line text field types.
The items in its database let you define custom fields for them, but there is no literal multi line text field. There's a "File" type, but you can't simply define fields with multi-line text values. However, every item has exactly one built-in "notes" field, but that's actually styled markdown text. And you only get one. And its name is always "notes".
It would obviously be extremely useful to be able to define an arbitrary number of arbitrarily labeled multi line text fields that are not interpreted as markdown text.
It boggles my mind that 1Password doesn't support this. What were they thinking??? It makes it a real pain in the butt to store ssh keys and certificates and a lot of other types of information in 1Password.
A single markdown "notes" field just doesn't cut it. It's not as if it's technically challenging or a security risk. It already has a "notes" field, so just turn off the "rich text" feature and allow me to make my own! I would have thought it was a pretty obvious and often requested feature, but as far as I can tell, it's impossible!
- varenc 5y agoAs one datapoint: I’ve used 1P for 11+ years, have over 1200 items in it, and I’ve literally never lamented the lack of multiline fields.
- rco8786 5y agoSimilar here. I've never even considered it something I might want
- tksb 5y agoWhile I agree about the specific ask for multiline support (and the decade plus hourly usage of 1p), it's abundantly clear that things are slipping with regards to the core product. For awhile there were no public links to any downloadable desktop apps for macOS while they pushed web + subs + and the MAS version. These days I'm just delighted when 1password doesn't open a totally different browser when invoked from the active one.
- CodeRhoades 5y agoNot sure what you mean. The non-MAS version has always been available directly from the downloads page. https://1password.com/downloads/mac/ https://1password.com/downloads/mac/
- varenc 5y agoTotally agree there are many other frustrating things with 1P. I’m still self-hosting my vault locally and I hate that someday they’re going to force me to switch to their cloud based options. Just on my list of issues lack of multiline support is near the bottom.
- wtetzner 5y agoI believe you can attach files, so that might be an option for keys/certs.
- DonHopkins 5y agoHave you tried actually using that in practice? It's extremely clumsy and inconvenient, requiring a whole lot more pointing and clicking and waiting and typing to attach the file, look at its contents, copy its value, or even edit it, than a simple multi-line text field would require. And in the common case that the text is only on my clipboard, for example if I copied it from a web page or shell, then I have to go to all the effort of first saving it locally into a file somewhere in the file system, before laboriously navigating to it again with 1Password (often having to wait for my USB hard drives to spin up again as my Mac is frozen for 50 seconds showing the file dialog that scans all the attached storage devices) and finally adding it as a file attachment. And then after all that extra busy work, the plaintext secret file now is floating around unencrypted in my file system somewhere, which is exactly what I didn't need.
- solarengineer 5y agoI store all my ssh keys as attachments. All my ssh keys are passphrase protected as well. When I do download the keys, it isn’t much of an everyday activity either I do not need to keep transferring ssh keys regularly to my Mac- it is either a one time or a set up related activity. 1Password is just fine for storing ssh keys as attachments. Have you considered writing to them to ask for what you need?
- chipotle_coyote 5y agoI support your request for basically making the "notes" field for 1Password entries into a field type, so you can have multiple ones. Having said that, I admit I generally haven't missed them for the use case of SSH keys, even though I do occasionally store those in 1Password -- I use the Secure Notes feature for that. Copy the key to the clipboard with "cat ssh.key | pbcopy", make a new Secure Note, paste. I suppose it hadn't occurred to me to do anything else in part because, well, I can't -- but also because I don't think of these as username/password combinations, I think of them as "SSH for server foobar," and the search feature works perfectly well for that. This is arguably a workaround instead of the ideal, but I actually use Secure Notes pretty frequently. WiFi base station passwords, recovery keys, personal access tokens, stuff that in general doesn't fit the "web site with username and password and possibly 2FA key" model I'm fairly sure I started this before 1Password even had a "Notes" field.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- doliveira 5y agoWow, I was thinking of leaving KeepassXC for 1password but that is very much a deal-breaker. The UI isn't as pretty or well-thought, of course, but at the very least there aren't as many limitations
- DonHopkins 5y agoUnfortunately for me it was the kind of a thing that I didn't notice until I'd actually paid for a license and started using it. Then I tried to put my ssh public and private keys in there, and hit the wall. It's such an obvious feature that would be so easy for them to implement, it made me feel like it must be possible and super-obvious to most people, but I was just too dumb to figure out how to do it. (No, pressing shift-return in a single line text field doesn't work. And pasting multi-line text into a text field replaces newlines by spaces, thank you.)
- 1123581321 5y agoUse the SSH key entry type. Multi-line works and you can store both public and private.
- terabytest 5y agoCould you share a little bit about what you'd want to use this for? (I'm part of the 1Password design team)
- minitoar 5y agoHe already said. Private keys, certs, etc.
- judge2020 5y agoSame for things like recovery codes / recovery phrases, although I'm not sure how highly i'd rate a security posture of keeping a password, a 2fa code generator, and recovery codes all in the same entry in a password manager.
- 1123581321 5y agoPrivate keys and certs are multi-line. Just tested the secure note and ssh key entry types.
- sbarre 5y agoIf you're in here collecting feedback, I would second this request for the same reasons (keys, certs, other structured text I wish I could just copy/paste easily from the UI). Been a happy paying customer since 1Password v4, but I agree this seems like an easy win.
- DonHopkins 5y agoSSH keys have both a private and a public file. The private file is multi-line text. I don't like putting the private key in the notes field, because its name is still "notes" (but I'd prefer the label be the key's file name), it's actually markdown formatted text, not literal text, and what if I still want to write a note, but I've already used the notes field for the key? HTTPS certificates including multiple certificate chains, and private keys, and those are all multi line files. And each part should go into a separate clearly labeled multi line field. And I don't want to be forced to write a copy of my server's ssh key into a local file on my laptop in order to attach it to a 1Password file field, and remember to delete it quickly before Time Machine backs it up for posterity. Right now I am forced to concatenate all my certificates and keys into the "notes" field, and write the file name before each part, and put blank lines between each file, which is terribly inconvenient and error prone. I also put a multi-line list of all the user names and passwords that I set up on a server. There are millions of other reasons why anyone might want to use a multi line text field beyond ssh keys and certificates, just use your imagination. My question is why wasn't this obvious feature supported from day 1, like I fully expected it to be with I bought a 1Password license? Why did I have to find that out for myself the hard and disappointing way, because I never noticed a section in the 1Password manual or promotional advertisements about why 1Password made the decision not to support multi line text fields. I'd love to know the reasoning behind that decision. [Edit in response to "Maybe I don’t understand, but couldn’t you use the notes section? Wrap whatever you need in triple backticks to create a code block?":] I PAYED for 1Password, and the company I work for standardized on it and requires we use it, so I kind of expect not to have to jump through those kinds of pointless hoops with a commercial product. I should be able to select-all/copy/paste without meticulously selecting just the right text character-by-character. The time I waste doing just that would pay for a yearly subscription to a better product.
- auslegung 5y agoMaybe I don’t understand, but couldn’t you use the notes section? Wrap whatever you need in triple backticks to create a code block?
- minitoar 5y agoMaybe I have an ssh key and notes. With this setup I can only do 1.
- barbazoo 5y agoWould a profile work here where you can define arbitrary fields?
- auslegung 5y agoI store my ssh keys, with notes, in the same note. I wrap the ssh key in backticks and put the relevant notes above or below the key. Granted I can't just triple click to select the entire note then copy, I have to interact with it more to copy it, but I very rarely copy my ssh keys. Like once every few years when I'm setting up a new machine. So maybe you're copying them more than I am and it's more of an issue
- ljm 5y agoI believe on other fields you can click on them to copy their values. With the notes field you have to select the part of the notes yourself and copy that. And probably can't filter for them as easily too.
- bonoboTP 5y agoThen why not file attachments? You may want to store a JPEG there too, for some reason.
- beermonster 5y agoI guess because you have to extract it to local file system in order to use it and that makes it exposed.
- FBISurveillance 5y agoA paying customer for 5+ years, still miss this feature daily.