21 ms·
Confessions of a Bitcoin Widow
- eimrine 5y agoVery long (close to unreadable) story about how I have lost few hundred bux on QuadrigaCX
- pseudolus 5y agoIt's an excerpt from the book "Bitcoin Widow: Love, Betrayal and the Missing Millions" by Jennifer Robertson with Stephen Kimber [0]. The CBC ran a story that provides an overview of the whole debacle [1]. [0] https://www.amazon.com/Bitcoin-Widow-Betrayal-Missing-Millions/dp/1443463906/ref=sr_1_1?crid=LCV2HN73YH6T&keywords=bitcoin+widow&qid=1644936280&sprefix=bitcoin+widow%2Caps%2C64&sr=8-1 https://www.amazon.com/Bitcoin-Widow-Betrayal-Missing-Millio... [1] https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/nova-scotia/quadriga-widow-jennifer-roberston-gerald-cotten-1.6318955 https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/nova-scotia/quadriga-widow-je...
- keithalewis 5y agoThere is no "i" in denial.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- 3vidence 5y ago"i" not in "denial" -> False.
- fknorangesite 5y agoI heard "gullible" isn't in the dictionary, either.
- ceejayoz 5y ago> So much money rolled in so fast that they occasionally ended up with huge piles of cash on their kitchen counter. Seems like that'd be a red flag, considering it's a digital currency.
- onion2k 5y agoAt the beginning one of Quadriga's products was an ATM that people could use to deposit cash and get BTC in return. It's just about plausible that they emptied the ATMs and took the money home occasionally. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Quadriga_Fintech_Solutions https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Quadriga_Fintech_Solutions
- coldtea 5y ago>It's just about plausible that they emptied the ATMs and took the money home occasionally. What kind of business with ATMs "takes the money home"? Even if it's totally legit, it's also totally insecure - they could be robbed at any time. Money in such quantities are not takes to the home and stacked the kitchen top, they are deposited to banks - by armored guards in vans.
- lupire 5y agoa Crypto company whose founding principle is "not banking"
- allannienhuis 5y agoI know some people that used to run a number of those 'private' atms you'd find in gas stations, etc. They regularly drove to the various machines to fill them up with cash, driving an old pickup truck and carrying around 30-50k in 20$ bills in a brown paper bag. Security by obscurity I guess.
- onion2k 5y agoIt's undoubtedly completely stupid, that's a given, but if your husband runs a company that deals in large amounts of cash (like one that runs ATMs), then it's plausible that seeing piles of cash on the kitchen counter might not be an immediate red flag.
- matheusmoreira 5y ago> Cotten possessed the only key to the online vaults where his customers’ investments were supposedly stored. This is very important. Due to strong cryptography it's safe to assume the cryptocurrencies can't be moved without the secret key. What happens if the owner of the key dies? My father asked me about this once and I had no answer. Something to really think about. We currently think of secret keys as expendable. Compromised or lost? Just make a new one. Nobody shares or inherits keys, everyone has their own set. The dead won't be encrypting or signing any messages and there is generally no reason for anyone to retain the ability to impersonate them. Traditional key discipline relies on the assumption keys are worth nothing. All this goes out the window when these are the keys to assets worth thousands, millions. A new key discipline needs to be developed.
- maerF0x0 5y agoThere are also key escrow solutions like https://keys.casa/ https://keys.casa/ (i'm sure there are many many others, please add yours as a reply!)
- nathias 5y agoyou make a paper wallet and you can pass it on as inheritance
- scotty79 5y agoOn the other hand ... What's wrong, if your wealth distilled to the limits of abstraction dies with you? If you haven't shared it with anyone, why would anyone get it? If you didn't trust anyone with the keys to it while you were alive, why should anyone have it?
- Victerius 5y agoThis is only tangentially related to the headline, but do you think divorce courts in the future will grant divorcing spouses half of their partner's cryptocurrency holdings? Certainly, if someone were to transfer the bulk of their investments into crypto to avoid sharing, that's an evasion mechanism the courts would be interested in countering.
- adrianmsmith 5y agoThis is already the case. I mean you can't hide your cash by buying houses or yachts or shares in a company. So crypto is no different - it's an asset owned by you. If the courts don't know about the crypto that's another thing, but that's just the same as moving your money into an offshore account and not telling anyone. It's physically possible, but isn't legal as a way to get out of paying what you owe.
- pseudolus 5y agoThe New York Times just ran a story about this very issue - "Divorcing Couples Fight Over the Kids, the House and Now the Crypto". [0]. [0] https://www.nytimes.com/2022/02/13/technology/divorce-bitcoin-crypto.html https://www.nytimes.com/2022/02/13/technology/divorce-bitcoi...
- kkielhofner 5y agoThis will be very interesting (but likely not). People have tried to hide assets from tax authorities, spouses, creditors, etc for thousands of years. I'm a little surprised (or not) at the naivete of the cryptocurrency community "It's digital" "It's anonymous" "It can't be seized or controlled by the government". Sure, as though these extremely experienced professionals and very powerful institutions are going to read a tweet from one of the crypto maxis and just throw their hands up and say "It's on the internet, I guess there's nothing we can do about it". These groups are very, very good at what they do. They've seen it all and even if it's XMR (or whatever) with the proper motivation they will find it (and you). Very, very few people and organizations have the full skill set required to evade these authorities.
- dogman144 5y ago
- amelius 5y agoI didn't read the whole story, but did he just lose the keys that gave him access to his property? How is that a "facade"?
- ZetaZero 5y agoHe died, and the widow didnt have the keys.
- ceejayoz 5y agoQuadriga was doing more than just shitty key handling. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Quadriga_Fintech_Solutions https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Quadriga_Fintech_Solutions
- sva_ 5y ago> According to Jennifer Robertson, Cotten's widow, he died on 9 December 2018 while travelling in India. > Cotten's will was signed 27 November 2018, twelve days before he allegedly died. It left Robertson the entire C$9.6-million estate and named her as the trustee. Yeah, that seems slightly fishy. > A C$100,000 trust fund will provide lifelong care for Cotten's two chihuahuas in case of Robertson's death. That's heart-warming.
- conductr 5y ago> Yeah, that seems slightly fishy. Updating your will before a big trip to the other side of the world just seems responsible. No idea what he was doing in India, or what part he was visiting, but it could certainly be considered dangerous and sounds like a smart trigger/opportunity to update your estate docs. Everything else this guy was involved with might seem fishy, but this does not
- thebean11 5y agoHe supposedly died of Crohn's disease though. I can't imagine anyone traveling across the world to India of all places in the throes of a Crohn's flareup..
- nathias 5y agothe funds are sifu
- ngc248 5y agoFunds are SAFU https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DelF6zEHXpE https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DelF6zEHXpE
- JohnJamesRambo 5y agoPeople need some backstory on this one. We aren’t even sure he is really dead and I wouldn’t be surprised that this book and story is a way for her to distance herself from the very reasonable suspicions on her. https://www.bbc.com/news/world-us-canada-50751899 https://www.bbc.com/news/world-us-canada-50751899 https://www.vanityfair.com/news/2019/11/the-strange-tale-of-quadriga-gerald-cotten/ https://www.vanityfair.com/news/2019/11/the-strange-tale-of-...
- s5300 5y agoThis dude is 100% alive. Death due to Crohns related whatever at that age is extremely rare, especially when they mention he was otherwise young and healthy (if I misread or am misremembering about the otherwise healthy part, correct me) & somebody with that sort of money, that also spends $90k at a La Z Boy to furnish a house, would be 9001% on top of any possible thing that Crohns could do to him. Guarantee he’s alive & he otherwise would’ve gotten away with it if they went with a story of any other medical condition that can lead to sudden death. (I realize this may sound insensitive to those with or knowing somebody with Crohns. I have Crohns :P)
- luciusdomitius 5y agoI don't know why this is downvoted. I also have Crohn's and it is word-for-word true. Sudden death of Crohn's is something I cannot imagine and I've been trying for good 5 minutes now.
- giarc 5y agoI'm cherry picking a stat from this article, but it doesn't appear totally out of the realm of possibility to die from Crohns. It is well accepted that Crohn's disease is associated with a small but real risk of death. Population based reports from Sweden,1,2 Denmark,3 and Italy4 indicate that Crohn's disease patients have a higher mortality rate than expected, although at least one notable exception from the UK demonstrated survival similar to the general population (table 1 1). https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/labs/pmc/articles/PMC1856159/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/labs/pmc/articles/PMC1856159/
- luciusdomitius 5y agoI am really curios - how does an exchange never materialise any trades and people don't notice? Also, as a fellow Crohnie - how do you "suddenly" die of Crohn's?
- jVinc 5y ago> how do you "suddenly" die of Crohn's? Why do you want to know? I know a doctor in India who can help arrange that if you need this kind of service. He's not cheap though. /s
- reso 5y agoThe trades did clear on the exchange, and withdrawals were forthcoming until December 2018 when Gerlad disappeared. Gerald didn't steal all the crypto, he just stole some of it, but because he stole crypto instead of cash, when the price spiked, his debts increased much faster than he could pay them.
- atdrummond 5y agoI coded out during an operation to repair a ruptured intestine that was a complication of Crohns. I was also told if I had waited even a day more that the sepsis from the rupture could have killed me. It's definitely possible.
- GamerUncle 5y ago>The walrus defending people that seem to be quite obviously criminal Colour me surprised This is a hit piece on crypto written with the facade of trying to defend a "widow"
- mdasen 5y agoI'm kinda surprised that police don't get warrants for death threats. Sites like Reddit and Facebook collect lots of data. Even if someone is trying to be anonymous, they can likely connect it to a person. Some people might be able to mask their trail, but the vast majority can't. It just seems surprising that no one seems to actually investigate and prosecute those who make death threats online. I'm not saying that people should lose anonymity online in the vast majority of cases, but when people are making death threats and even coordinating and conspiring to harass someone with death threats and potential real-world harm, it seems like police should be getting warrants for things like IP addresses, device IDs, browser fingerprints, phone numbers, and other anti-spam information that sites are using. I know some people know a lot about how they're being tracked online, but most people don't. If there are hundreds of people posting death threats, most probably aren't hiding who they are well. Prosecuting even a few seems like it would deter a lot more. How confident are you that you aren't leaving a trail? I'm not saying that people should be generally worried about leaving a trail, but when it comes to death threats that can turn into actual murder people seem oddly confident that no one will track them down - despite all we know about how good platforms like Facebook are at figuring out who we really are. It's not like police aren't asking for huge warrants from people like Google. Google has said that they're getting a huge number of geofence warrants - "hey, give us a list of everyone who has been in this geographic area." That seems way more problematic than "hey, there has been a criminal assault (death threat) and we want all identifying information you have on this account that committed the assault." Again, I'm not saying that the person behind the account should instantly be found guilty (accounts can be hacked and such), but it seems to offer a much more precise avenue of getting to bad people than a geofence warrant with a lot fewer privacy implications. > I contacted Facebook. The best the company could suggest was to block trolls from future posts Facebook knows who these people are. They could ban them from FB/WhatsApp/Instagram. It's weird because they seem like the type of thing you'd want to ban for SPAM/harrassment. It seems weird that the response from sites and police seems to be: there's nothing we can do. These are the same sites that figure out things voting rings for anti-spam reasons. These are the same police that vigorously want to prosecute someone for stealing $20. But when it comes to death threats (that can turn into actual murder), they seem to think "that seems like a minor inconvenience compared to SPAM or someone stealing $20."
- joshuaheard 5y agoI have an envelope in a fire safe in my house that says, "Open on Death". In it is a list of all my accounts and passwords. My computer password, my phone password, everything. I use a password manager, so it's an easy thing to print the list of passwords. If I were to die, anyone could pick up that envelope and have the literal keys to my kingdom. It also contains all my estate documents, like a will and other things. I have emailed my family and told them the location of the safe. The fire safe also contains original paper documents like deeds and birth certificates.
- throw123123123 5y agoI would not say this online, my man.
- dylan604 5y agoOr if your house was burgled, and someone took that envelope before you died, you'd be in a world of hurt. Especially now that anyone that reads HN knows your secret. The amount of details some people post online just boggles me.
- anonporridge 5y agoSeems like there should be a market for N of M key encrypted post-death documents. e.g. have a 3 of 5 key that can decrypt this document with all of your personal secrets. 1 key for yourself, 2 with loosely connected family members, and 2 with different attorneys that have legal obligations to only use the key on your verified death and as specified by your cleartext will. This kind of scheme would be highly resistant to failure, since if any one key gets lost, you can discard and regenerate the ciphertext with new keys, and possibly change the secret information (e.g. passwords) if you're worried about future compromise. It's also highly resistant to collusion since it would require a malicious family member or attorney to collude with at two other parties against your will in order to compromise your secrets, all while not knowing exactly of what value those secrets are.
- notreallyserio 5y agoFWIW fire safes only protect their contents for a short period of time (IIRC typically under a few hours). You may want to make a backup and store it in a bank vault or similar.
- giarc 5y agoThese statements seem to counter each other. >They acquired property, bought yachts and planes, travelled to exotic destinations. >Robertson, online posters insisted, was conspiring with Cotten, who’d faked his own death and was hiding in some extradition-free backwater until they could rendezvous and live happily ever after. Seems like they already lived the good life, why fake your own death which only complicates things more.
- samhw 5y agoBecause it was a Ponzi scheme, according to that theory. If you're running a Ponzi scheme - as Madoff demonstrates - your good luck and your good life tend to run out. The theory is that he faked his death when the music was about to stop.
- michaelt 5y agoImagine you've stolen $200M and you're living the good life, but cops and victims are starting to catch up with you. If they catch you, you'll lose all the money and get sent to jail. If you fake your death, you can keep all the cash you haven't spent, and avoid jail.
- giantg2 5y agogiantg2 Has been marked safe from... Rich people problems. Why is this a story?
- samhw 5y agoPlease go back to Reddit with your semi-literate blurtings - we're trying to have an interesting conversation here
- giantg2 5y agoAnd my question is why is this a story? How is this interesting? It's seems the problem in the article doesn't apply to most people, even in this community. Nor is it new.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- fatih-erikli 5y agoThe story sounds super fictional to me.
- snarkerson 5y agoIt's a bookvertisement.
- HashBasher 5y agoThe title is grossly misleading. Bitcoin had nothing to do with any of this. It should be `Confessions of a Scammer Widow`. Cotton was scamming before bitcoin even existed.
- dangerface 5y agoTLDR, spent all the money not caring where it came from now that she knows she still doesn't care about anyone but herself. She has three houses with scammed money no interest in selling them and returning the money.
- webkike 5y agoWhat are you talking about it? She returned nearly all of it
- dangerface 5y agoIm confused the article said she couldn't return the crypto because she was locked out of it but still has the three houses she bought with that money? How is that returning nearly all of it? That word "nearly" is doing a lot of lifting.
- CryptoBanker 5y agoPlease read the article
- languagehacker 5y agoThere's a great podcast about Cotten called Exit Scam. I'm not entirely convinced that Robertson is an unwitting party to this. My guess is that the author did what she could to endear herself to Robertson to gain exclusivity on certain aspects of the story, but it comes off as more of an apology than it probably needs to be.
- nativeit 5y agoFor the last seven years, I've run a tiny one-man I.T. consultancy with barely a dozen consistent clients--they're all great clients, but I am in no way the pinnacle of dynamism--and even I have a "hit by a bus" insurance where I assigned a friend and local I.T. professional with the responsibility and capability to take over if anything happens to me. He would have access to my I.T. documentation platform, password manager, and has met each of my clients' principal contacts. To think someone could run a financial institution in this way with anything less than bad intentions is laughable.
- JimWestergren 5y agoIt was not clear in the article. Is there cold wallets that belonged to Quadriga with a lot of value with lost passwords?
- PavleMiha 5y agoThe article seems to state there wasn't a lot of value in the cold wallets.
- JimWestergren 5y agoYes: "Ernst and Young had managed to identify six Quadriga cold wallets so far but had found almost nothing inside any of them." But could it be possible that there exist other unknown cold wallets with a lot of value with lost passwords?
- thematrixturtle 5y agoIt seems more likely that there exist other wallets with a lot of value, whose password is known by their living owner, Mr Cotten.
- chasing 5y agoSummary: "I knew the money was stolen, and all I wanted to do was press 'reset' and keep all of it. But they wouldn't let me. I didn't like giving the money back, but I did learn a valuable lesson about how I enjoyed being rich."
- moralestapia 5y agoWell ... she's not a "Bitcoin Widow", she's a Fraudster's Widow, so I don't know what she expected. Also, I find it quite disingenuous for close relatives to claim ignorance when rackets like this fall apart (like Madoff's wife purported innocence). I don't think anyone in the world knows you better than your husband/wife, not even your parents/kids.
- nwah1 5y agoThat is merely the difference between someone involved in a ponzi scheme and someone who started one.
- knorker 5y agoVery interesting article. This kind of thorough investigation really shows how math was never the missing component in monetary policy and economic exchange. The idea that we could replace Ernst & Young (for example) in this saga with math is pretty clearly wrong, since they were needed even though this already was cryptocurrency. So if you replace banks, courts, auditors, and all this "old money" with math, but you still need the banks, courts, auditors, and all the "old money" companies, what was the point?
- vmception 5y agoFunds are Sifu Anyone here following the drama with Wonderland where a cofounder of was doxxed as a QuadrigaCX cofounder when the team applied for an exchange listing and did KYC? Nobody is ever going to doxx again at this rate.
- bredren 5y agoIf this condensed version of the Harper Collins Canada book is genuinely intended to create sympathy for this person, it fails.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- threshold 5y ago
- socialdemocrat 5y agoThe internet brings out the absolute worst in people. They can rant about the worst things and find like minded people. Truly disturbing. I was in crypto for a while but I also easily see how it has fostered a terrible culture.