17 ms·
Pedestrian deaths spike in U.S. as reckless driving surges
- taylodl 5y agoMy observation over the past year has been people are disregarding traffic laws more and more. The light is red? No worries! I'll just go through the intersection. And that's for traffic going straight! We've always had the problem of the left-turners slipping a car or two through after the light has gone red. Now it's 3, 4 and sometimes even 5! I'm now starting see people just go through red lights, treating the light like a 2-way stop. People never used to do that kind of stuff before, at least not in my neck of the woods. Oh and lane drift! Holy crap! People can't stay in their lane anymore. That's gotten a lot worse! I too was thinking this was caused by the lockdown but now I'm not so sure. My state never locked down too hard in the first place and we've been largely "fully open" since last Spring - yet the driving has gotten worse. I was talking to my insurance agent about it and they said the number of accidents is skyrocketing. Great - so we have increased insurance premiums to look forward to which of course will be blamed on "inflation."
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- gameswithgo 5y agoIn Austin Texas we have an absurdly well marked crosswalk on the way to the elementary school, to a close approximation nobody has ever stopped to let us cross. Our daughter was nearly killed once, so far. It seems so many people in America are so fat now they don’t imagine people would ever walk, so they drive without regard for pedestrians and active hostility towards cyclists and park in the way of sidewalks, making walking or riding bikes to school seem so scary and unpleasant that few kids do it anymore, leading to more fat Americans who would never imagine walking. It is really depressing.
- _dain_ 5y agoCan you link to this crosswalk on Streetview? I have a mental image of the kind of crossing you're describing and I want to see if it matches with the reality.
- Simon_O_Rourke 5y agoWhen I lived in LA, it was downright dangerous to try and cross a road as a pedestrian. I once ended up on some guy's hood who decided that red lights just didn't apply to him. No major harm done thankfully, but if he'd have been going any faster I wouldn't be here today.
- wffurr 5y agoLike WALL-E except the hover chairs weigh 3000lb and can go 80 mph.
- unicornfinder 5y agoTo be fair I think the problem isn't just the people but how the roads and infrastructure is designed in the US. It's very anti-pedestrian.
- thex10 5y agoTo reconcile this with the parent comment... yes. Crosswalk markings, however bold and bright, alone are insufficient to make an intersection safe for pedestrians.
- Semaphor 5y agoThat is cultural. In Germany, crosswalks are very much adhered to.
- sillyquiet 5y agoSince pedestrian deaths are 'surging', its gotta be down to something that's changed, not a factor that's been constant all along, right?
- gbtw 5y agoTransport cost are too high forcing people to use alternatives like walking.
- donkeyd 5y agoWhy do you need to look for such far fetched explanations when you can clearly see massive amounts of people texting while driving? I drive quite a lot (for European standards) and I've seen the amount of people holding phones increase massively. I can recognize it from a mile away by the way people are driving.
- ghaff 5y agoAnd for that matter, people texting while they're walking across the street with earphones in. I honestly don't even feel comfortable wearing earphones when I'm walking in the woods much less on a city street.
- amcoastal 5y agoIts just where you live. Welcome to large cities. You can move to more hospitable parts of the country where people still have basic respect for people. The politics in the South sure have annoyed me, but dealing with the public (i.e. people who you don't know) in everyday life is miles different compared to living in NY, CA, FL, TX etc.
- sokoloff 5y agoThe first time I saw opposite direction traffic stop to show respect to a funeral procession (common in the South), I was very confused.
- Kye 5y agoIt's more you trade sets of respects and disrespects. Small towns are great as long as you conform to a narrow set of socially conservative expectations. The south isn't all bad, but the bad escalates faster than in other places the further you are from a major highway.
- amcoastal 5y agoDefinitely agree with this sentiment. My perspective on receiving more respect in the South probably has a lot to do with being a redneck looking white guy.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- cianmm 5y agoI’m in Ireland and there is a signposted pedestrian crossing that cars routinely ignore in a park near my house. A good technique, I’ve found, is point your phone at them as you prepare to cross. It seems to scare them into stopping. Normalisation of dangerous driving is a global phenomenon where car culture reigns.
- kmlx 5y agoelevated pedestrian crossing is the solution here. used across London with great effect. anyway, there are many ways to calm traffic.
- Aeolun 5y agoWe used to have lovely speedbumps every 50 meters or so in our neighborhood. Can’t drive fast if it’ll make your car fly.
- masklinn 5y agoSuch active traffic calming measures can be combined with more passive ones (lane narrowing, visual obstructions) to create a psychological slowdown effect in addition to the physical ones. This works especially well combined with pedestrian and cycle passthroughs and such, including to avoid “drive-through” neighbourhoods without having to make the neighbourhood entirely impassable and a pain in the ass to residents.
- ghaff 5y ago>including to avoid “drive-through” neighbourhoods without having to make the neighbourhood entirely impassable and a pain in the ass to residents. I suspect that Google Maps and the like have worsened the level of driving through residential neighborhoods as they route you through a maze of residential streets to save (in theory) two minutes.
- masklinn 5y ago
- usrusr 5y agoIn the age of Peloton and other indoors-only fitness trends, being fat is no requirement at all for hostility towards any means of outdoors transportation that isn't a Very Large Wheelchair.
- throwaway894345 5y agoI forget where this was, but I recall seeing video of police crossing on a crosswalk undercover and whenever a vehicle would fail to yield a cruiser would appear and pull the offender over. I would like to see a lot more of this. In Chicago, people have always blown red lights at speed right in front of parked police cars because they know police won’t do anything (and I’m not even sure if the police are allowed to do anything—allegedly they can’t chase suspects unless they believe they are a threat to society, and I’m not sure that includes “reckless driving”). The article didn’t mention it, but I also wonder if this (like the surge in violent crime) is driven in part by changes in policing following the BLM protests (e.g., police make fewer traffic stops for fear of finding themselves in an incriminating situation).
- _dain_ 5y ago>I would like to see a lot more of this. The problem is, it doesn't scale, especially in a city as big and violent as Chicago. It only works so long as police keep their foot on the gas (so to speak); they minute they let up on traffic enforcement (because of competing priorities) things will get worse again. If one person speeds, that person is an idiot. But if everyone speeds, the road engineer is an idiot. A systemic problem like this is a result of poor road design, not individual deviant drivers. Police should not be burdened with the responsibility of ensuring safety in a system that is unsafe by design. The roads need to be redesigned so that drivers naturally feel unsafe at high speed.
- lotsofpulp 5y agoTraffic circles / roundabouts would go a long way.
- dboreham 5y agoPlenty of roundabouts here in Montana.
- throwaway894345 5y agoAs it stands, Chicago has police cars all over the place (in every neighborhood I’ve lived in anyway) often just sitting there parked and by my estimation there’s close to zero traffic enforcement, so we certainly seem to have a lot of capacity for maintaining this sort of enforcement and I suspect it would be like introducing a few wolves into a national park—it doesn’t take much enforcement to drive significant, broad changes. > A systemic problem like this is a result of poor road design, not individual deviant drivers. In many cases, I agree that there is a systemic problem at play, but these cases tend to be highways (i.e., no pedestrians) and the issue is politicians setting speed limits which traffic engineers understand to be unsafely low for the road’s design (the safest speed being that which 85% of drivers would naturally drive if unencumbered). And it hardly matters how engineers design the road because politicians will always respond to a vocal minority who argue that the limits should be lower. However with respect to streets (i.e., places where pedestrians belong) rather than highways, the issue is only systemic with respect to enforcement—many other parts of the country (or even the same places with different enforcement) have similar streets but drivers are better behaved. Which isn’t to say that there isn’t room for improvement everywhere, but only that the issue isn’t “Chicago has stupid street engineers”.
- efitz 5y agoHow exactly did you get to “the cause of reckless driving is fat people who don’t walk everywhere?” Show your work. In most places in America walking is not a practical mode of transportation because of distance; it’s miles from your house to the grocery store, for instance. If you live in a city this might not be obvious to you but half the country lives in the burbs or rural areas. Separately, it would be nice if we had more sidewalks, but they are financially unsustainable in low density areas. Separately, the US does have an obesity problem, and exercise would help, but the biggest issue by far is dietary sugar/carbohydrates.
- goodpoint 5y agoNo. Distances are high because of low density. Sidewalks are financially unsustainable because of low density. People are obese also because they don't walk because of low density. Low density is caused by car culture pushed by car manufacturers and oil companies.
- collegeburner 5y agoBecause I don't want to live in some 3x3 postage stamp with close neighbors and people peering in and no yard, let alone an apartment sharing walls between people. Screw high density, I've lived in it and it sucks. Oh and I am extremely fit, obesity is bad choices not "car culture".
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- goodpoint 5y agoYou should visit other countries.
- MrBuddyCasino 5y ago> Separately, it would be nice if we had more sidewalks, but they are financially unsustainable in low density areas. What makes sidewalks expensive to maintain, relative to roads? > the biggest issue by far is dietary sugar/carbohydrates This is not clear. See this highly fascinating series on the obesity epidemic: https://slimemoldtimemold.com/2021/07/07/a-chemical-hunger-part-i-mysteries/ https://slimemoldtimemold.com/2021/07/07/a-chemical-hunger-p.... Other suspects are HFCS and seed oils.
- maxerickson 5y agoI'm pretty sure lots of car-first/car-only people are not fat.
- burlesona 5y agoMoved to Austin during the pandemic, and my experience has been the same. It feels very dangerous to walk or bike anywhere, even in residential areas, because of the aggressive drivers. Even when I’m driving, the pervasive road rage here is much worse than anywhere else I’ve lived (including 3 other major cities). It’s been a real disappointment.
- op00to 5y ago
- aww_dang 5y agoI'm all for cycling, but as a former bike messenger this take feels a bit extreme. The obesity crisis is real and people should get out and be more active. No matter how many concessions are made, most people are just unable to get over the lack of inertia and start cycling. Even if we allow for a hypothetical safety utopia, comments here will cite sweating as a deal breaker. I understand and empathize with beginners who are not acclimatized to cycling on a busy road. However it doesn't change the fact that you have to start somewhere and build your comfort levels. Pragmatically, this is the more important self-fulfilling dynamic. If you don't start building your skills and instead blame drivers... There are hostile drivers out there. After decades of riding (sometimes wildly irresponsibly) I can only count on one hand motorists who were actively trying to run me over. In those cases the sentiment was mutual and we had already exchanged words or otherwise escalated. Would have been easy to avoid. Contrast this to the cultural/class rhetoric against pickup-truck drivers. As a self-appointed expert in the domain, this doesn't ring true for me. It fits better with the theme of Internet hyperbole and media alarmism.
- bdauvergne 5y agoWhat exactly is the problem with sweating ? The rest of the world sweats without thinking about it.
- aww_dang 5y agoWhatever problems may exist can be easily resolved by showering and changing clothes. They can be further minimized by dressing appropriately.
- analog31 5y agoSomehow it's perceived as a norm that you can't arrive at work, a restaurant, or the store, with any amount of sweat on you. There's a bit more to it than this, of course. Most American cities have more extreme climate, longer commutes, and more hills, than in the northern European cities that are held up as the gold standard of cycling culture, but people ride bikes in southern Europe too. In turn, this makes it "necessary" to wear special cycling garb, change, and shower when you arrive at work. Vanishingly few workplaces provide a convenient place to shower and change. But I ride my bike to work year-round in a city that gets (for instance) about 10 degrees hotter than Amsterdam, and I manage it.
- pinephoneguy 5y agoSomeone in Indiana honked at me for using a crosswalk yesterday thinking I was supposed to yield to them for some reason. I think people from rural areas and suburbs just aren’t used to driving in smaller streets.
- sethammons 5y agoI and colleagues used to have to cross a moderately busy street in Orange County, CA. A marked crossing section a block from the train station. I was routinely honked at and vehicles would swerve around. I started carrying a strobe flashlight and would glance it towards fast moving cars. This usually slowed them down but pissed them off more. Not blinding them mind you, just a flash. Sooooo put out that they will have to slow for up to 20 seconds.
- _dain_ 5y agoCan you show me this crosswalk on Streetview? I'm trying to get an idea of the kinds of environments people are talking about in this thread (I'm non-American).
- sethammons 5y agoHere is the exact intersection. It looks safer than it is (or was, I've since moved far away). https://www.google.com/maps/@33.7878268,-117.8588114,3a,75y,72.64h,88.76t/data=!3m6!1e1!3m4!1sUVDQOb0I-hmAlddL6IX-lg!2e0!7i13312!8i6656 https://www.google.com/maps/@33.7878268,-117.8588114,3a,75y,...
- _dain_ 5y agoThat doesn't look safe at all. Five lanes! And you have to cross them all in one go, with no signaling!!! My goodness. Such a thing would never be constructed here (UK)*. There would be, at minimum, a protected pedestrian island in the middle, so that in crossing you only need to look in one direction at a time. Almost always a set of pedestrian-controlled traffic lights too. In the Netherlands they might even go a step further and put in a continuous sidewalk (i.e. the surface the pedestrians walk on remains at the same level as the sidewalk, so that cars have to rise onto it like a speedbump). Here is an example comparable to yours: a 4-lane major road intersecting perpendicularly with a 2-lane minor road. Pedestrians have controlled crossings across the major part, and protected islands so they never have to cross more than two lanes in one go: https://goo.gl/maps/MYbcyPgQZD1PMAL69 https://goo.gl/maps/MYbcyPgQZD1PMAL69 This design is standard everywhere. And it isn't even optimal (it doesn't accommodate cyclists very well). *If you searched high and low across the country you might find a counterexample or two, but the fact remains that this kind of junction is thoroughly alien to the British built environment.
- salawat 5y ago...Hate to break it to you, but that's just Austin. Don't know what it is; but Travis County brings out some of the worst driving habits in people.
- aurizon 5y agoIn Toronto there are paid people with fluorescent traffic warden clothes and signage who attend all crosswalks and traffic light for the student travel periods, AM, Noon, PM. Other times they have walk buttons that start flashing lights and an overhead banner (flasher lighted)
- palijer 5y agoAnd that still doesn't seem to stop reckless driving from killing pedestrians. The only thing that will slow drivers down is when they feel unsafe themselves, or have a risk to their vehicle. Adding signs or automatic fines doesn't do anything. You need narrower streets utilizing actual traffic calling techniques. It's such a sad sight to see signs with a "traffic calming zone" sign, but absolutely zero traffic calming done. It'll be a wide open street, we'll paved, no trees right against the road or bollards in the middle or speed bumps. Watching this video feels like an alternative reality that never happened and it seems great. https://youtu.be/bAxRYrpbnuA https://youtu.be/bAxRYrpbnuA
- aurizon 5y agoYes, good video. Canada and the USA has this demonic granting of speed rights to drivers. They could put in automatic speed traps on all street, with a fine by mail of a small amount, say $10 = a nuisance, but as they pile up the constant nag by mail, with a forced full payment to renew the plate will have a coercive enduring affect. It is important to keep it small - with a caveat. You are allowed to go yo court. If you challenge in court = higher tier of fines + time wasted burden. After a few months most will comply. Now manned speed traps have huge fines, huge police/court $$ burden. Cops tied up at speed traps prevent no crime, just fine a few people/day as the ticketing process at the street level is very slow. Automatic radar speed traps are fast. People hate them because they also have huge fines = lobby politicians a lot. The small nominal fine will get compliance without the same amount of lobbying and other pushback,
- edmcnulty101 5y ago> It seems so many people in America are so fat now they don’t imagine people would ever walk, As a fat person and I think I can take the liberty to speak on behalf of other fat people, you are absolutely correct. So be sure to please get out of the way and stay out of the way. Another good option is to go to the city council and have them rope off areas of the town for pedestrians only, if you want to be safe.
- giantg2 5y agoAre you actually in the crosswalk when people don't stop? I imagine most people don't know the law this well, but... the vehicles don't have to stop unless you have at least one foot in the crosswalk in most states. So they could just be assuming you are letting them go, or they're jerks.
- sjg007 5y agoLet your local police department know, they will gladly sit there and ticket offending vehicles.
- op00to 5y ago> America are so fat now they don’t imagine people would ever walk It's got nothing to do with obesity. The personal auto is the US government-dictated and subsidized default transportation method. Anyone not using a personal auto is "less than". In other words, if you're walking, you're a subhuman.
- pwr-electronics 5y agoI briefly worked in one of the statistically worst states for bicycle safety, but I was still surprised to learn how many older people fantasized about running over cyclists, or had a "they probably deserved it" attitude whenever a cyclist was struck by a car. One time, a couple of coworkers were riding single file in the generous shoulder of a wide nearly empty multi-lane road in the early morning when they were both run over from behind in a hit and run. One had to have his spine fused. I still saw the same attitude of contempt, even from coworkers who otherwise liked them. I switched to mountain biking after that.
- tim333 5y agoStrange really - I've never figured what that's all about, speaking as a driver who has no problem with cyclists.
- pwr-electronics 5y agoIt's a culture war topic.
- tim333 5y agoAh. Not seen so much of that in London though in the comments section of the Daily Mail some people rant about cyclists. Guess it's more seeing them as an enemy tribe rather than them actually cluttering the road. In London the bigger aggression issue I've seen is cyclists having a go at pedestrians which also puzzles me a bit if less so.
- notacoward 5y agoFraming your argument in terms of "fat people" weakens it considerably. There are plenty of lazy skinny people too, and the biggest problem is people's sense of entitlement. Pitting pedestrian/cyclist entitlement against driver entitlement is IMO less effective than treating transportation as a matter for sharing and cooperation instead of competition. As competition, non-drivers will always lose. And no, I don't think that's right, but the universe doesn't care what either of us thinks is right.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- stetrain 5y agoWell that correlation can work in the other direction too. What if poor US urban planning has led to sedentary lives where walking to places like grocery stores, parks, or transit is unpleasant, inconvenient, or impossible. So we sit on our butts and drive our cars everywhere, which means more lanes and more parking lots which in return keeps things farther apart and less walkable. People who are never pedestrians perhaps have reduced empathy for being one, and being in a big metal car vs passing in-person on the street leads to less personable reactions (ie road rage). And car-focused infrastructure decisions lead to more dangerous interactions between fast traffic, pedestrians, and cyclists. The tiny bit of time I have spent in some dense european-style walkable neighborhoods left me feeling much more a part of the neighborhood and like I would be a much healthier person in general living in such a place long term.
- stetrain 5y agoAnother piece to this is that being able to drive a car is in many parts of the US considered essential to being able to work, buy groceries, etc. Which I think leads to lax driver training and enforcement. Suspending someone’s license is potentially destroying their livelihood. Whatever the cause, our driver training, enforcement, penalties, and general respect for piloting a vehicle in a safe manner seem lower than many European countries.
- thaway2839 5y agoIt is indeed a vicious cycle.
- kilotaras 5y agoThat's why I'm a big advocate for infrastructure changes. The expected behaviour should be the most comfortable one. Raised crossings[1] or deliberate narrowing [2] forces people to pay attention and slow down. [1] https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Raised_Crossing_In_Panmure_Auckland.jpg https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Raised_Crossing_In_P... [2] https://www.google.com/maps/@51.5376862,-0.1105682,3a,75y,197.58h,88.28t/data=!3m6!1e1!3m4!1sn8HgwzyCZJqzkIxuwRnE4Q!2e0!7i16384!8i8192 https://www.google.com/maps/@51.5376862,-0.1105682,3a,75y,19...
- Beltalowda 5y ago> It seems so many people in America are so fat now they don’t imagine people would ever walk, so they drive without regard for pedestrians and active hostility towards cyclists and park in the way of sidewalks, making walking or riding bikes to school seem so scary and unpleasant that few kids do it anymore, leading to more fat Americans who would never imagine walking. It is really depressing. In my experience the mentality that drives this is "the road is for cars, you should not be here at all". You see this not just in the US where the infrastructure is extremely car-centric, but also in e.g. New Zealand. With smaller roads people seem to instinctively understand that it needs to be shared, but with larger roads this understanding seems to go away.
- everyone 5y agoSome of the psychological theories they have to explain the figures sound like a bit of a stretch to me. I dont see how they could test or prove them. In other countries the pandemic + less driving has resulted in less deaths, as one would expect. The bigger safer cars theory seems like a valid one to me. There is data supporting this theory in general, that when people are given safer cars they drive more recklessly. Also there is a significant measurable difference between the US and other countries in the size of cars.
- nerdponx 5y agoRegardless of how badly designed roads in America are and have been for decades, what I have noticed during the pandemic is that antisocial selfishness has become a valid way to behave, so people no longer attempt to suppress their antisocial selfish tendencies. I believe this was already in motion under Trump. He himself exemplifies antisocial selfish behavior. It's his entire gimmick. His election and his words/actions as president affirmed the validity of those feelings in people. The pandemic just accelerated the phenomenon. I think people might even see antisocial selfishness as a kind of individual affirmation of freedom, a personal protest against the perceived tyrannies of modern life. And I don't think it's limited to specific political or cultural groups, because there are antisocial selfish people everywhere. And so this manifests in people being rude to servers, blowing traffic lights, etc. I think it's the same reason people buy SUVs that aren't specifically work vehicles for rugged terrain. It's a conspicuous and continuous self-aggrandizing affirmation of one's individual greatness and strength. Not to be too dramatic, but it seems a bit like we are regressing as a society to animal kingdom behavior. Politeness is dead!
- imglorp 5y agoYes, and I think some of the media directly drove the "outrage economy" and profited from it. You get a little blip of adrenaline getting angry about something for a second and you get accustomed to it. Then you get accustomed to getting it from being angry. Maybe aggressive driving is part of that elevated adrenaline addiction: as you go about your day you need little doses from other places like the gas pedal.
- jbotz 5y ago> it seems a bit like we are regressing as a society to animal kingdom behavior Hey, on behalf of my animal brethren, I resent that! ;-) Seriously, while nature can seem cruel --- red in tooth and claw --- there also exists in nature a definite "politeness", i.e. the context for aggression is well defined (for example, predator-prey, maintenance and challenge of group hierarchy, defense of territory) and outside of that context violence is generally avoided. Humans, both primitive and civilized, are among the more aggressive of animals and in particular display aggressive behavior with less reason or provocation than most species. To some extend civilization actually makes this worse; it's easier to act aggressively when the aggression is less likely (because of existence of laws and police) to turn into deadly violence, and violence is less likely to be deadly because of hospitals and antibiotics. Otherwise I agree completely with you. In particular, I also suspect that Trumpism has done more harm to polite civilization than Covid.
- samwillis 5y agoMirror without paywall: https://archive.ph/5wWDC https://archive.ph/5wWDC
- totetsu 5y agoMirror mirror of the paywall, it's the archive of them all.
- mcdonje 5y agoUS infrastructure is focused around cars. People don't walk much because cities are spread out for wide roads meant for cars, highways, and parking lots. That makes the distances less walkable. Bikes don't have safe dedicated lanes in many places. Many cities eschew trains because they would rather put another lane on a road because of traffic jams. However, because of induced demand, and the infrastructure forcing everyone into cars, the traffic jams happen anyway. So it's a cycle that makes cities ever more built around cars. We need more trains, light rail, subways. As those become more entrenched, the city reshapes itself around them. Train stops become areas of development, which brings more things closer to people without needing cars.
- trinovantes 5y agoIt's pretty sad pedestrian deaths were lower pre-pandemic because cars were stuck in traffic and couldn't go fast enough to be letal
- pinephoneguy 5y agoAlso urban areas tend to get destroyed very quickly because of the culture the media and politicians connected to it push to the people living there (a Marxist oppression ideology with no categorical imperative so why not steel? There’s nothing you can do to improve things.) As soon as decent transit and walkability shows up everyone leaves.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- aeharding 5y ago> We need more trains, light rail, subways. I'd argue we simply need more walkability, and to place shops and destinations closer to people. Public transit is great, but is not an effective way to fix our auto-centric land use. In Strong Towns this is discussed. Transit should come to enhance and solve the transportation needs of already great, walkable places. Transit should not be created to try to induce great places.
- mcdonje 5y ago
- dhbradshaw 5y agoHere's kind of a weird hypothesis worth at least considering: Record pricing for used cars suggests that there's a car shortage. Ironically, less cars and less driving could lead to 1. Faster driving because of clearer roads, and 2. More walking. Combine those and it wouldn't be surprising to get more auto-pedestrian accidents. One test would be to compare changes to car accidents with changes to pedestrian accidents. Reckless driving should bring both up. More pedestrians should only bring the latter up.
- Ottolay 5y agoIt's a known hypothesis. Additionally when there is less traffic, drivers feel safer and are more likely to tune out by checking their phones, etc. The book,Confessions of a Recovering Engineer(1), talks about this. (1) https://www.confessions.engineer https://www.confessions.engineer
- thaway2839 5y agoThe Not Just Bikes Youtube channel consistently points out how Dutch street design focuses on making driving seem "scarier" to lower driving speeds as a safety measure. These aren't ridiculous measures. These are sensible measures such as eliminating one way lanes where possible (people tend to drive much faster in one way lanes), not having car lanes that are excessively wide, having level crossings for pedestrians, which means it's the cars that see a bump in the road, etc.
- chiefalchemist 5y ago2. More people walking who rarely walked before. The point being, when possible, you should walk facing into traffic. I see people, often enough, walking in the road with traffic. Experienced walkers tend to know this.
- ghaff 5y agoI thought this was something everyone learned when they were quite young.
- 5y ago
- samwillis 5y agoHere in the UK they have just changed the Highway Code (the rules that given all road users, including pedestrians) so that pedestrians have ultimate right of way in almost all cases. It’s the opposite of the situation in the US, a pedestrian in the UK can cross the road anywhere and I believe cars have to stop and make way. It’s going to be interesting to see how it effects accident numbers, I’m worry it may actually make accident numbers go up. https://www.gov.uk/government/news/the-highway-code-8-changes-you-need-to-know-from-29-january-2022 https://www.gov.uk/government/news/the-highway-code-8-change...
- tim333 5y ago>a pedestrian in the UK can cross the road anywhere and I believe cars have to stop and make way. Speaking as a UK driver (and pedestrian) - no, that's not really the case. At least not that pedestrians have right of way. I mean cars will hit the brakes to avoid killing you but I wouldn't recommend relying on that. The only place they changed the right of way recently is at turnings with 'give way' markings as shown in your link.
- was_a_dev 5y agoI agree, it's ok to change the Highway Code but the infrastructure also needs to change to reflect it. A contradiction leads to uncertainity, which leads to accidents
- iso1631 5y agoThe ruels haven't changed, the guidance has just been updated to better reflect the rules
- paulcole 5y agoIt doesn’t matter who has the right of way if car drivers don’t give a shit — which is the case in the US.
- gilbetron 5y agoThe small US city I live in made such a change, it we had several pedestrians get hit in the first year or so because drivers aren't used to it, can't see people very well, and pedestrians just figured everyone would now just stop. We changed the laws to restrict it to only crosswalks and added in a ton of new crosswalks. Even then, it was still a problem because pedestrians don't realize when someone can see them. If the are in the shade of a tree on a bright day, they can't be seen. There was a lot of learning and training to be done (some of it dumb), but now things are ok. "Crossing the road anywhere" is quite dumb, I think, and I guarantee you'll see a spike of pedestrians getting hit for a while. Just because you can legally do it doesn't mean it's a good idea.
- evancoop 5y agoI did not see this data placed alongside the number of traffic fatalities. Our intuition is that the new work-from-home/social-distance world leads to fewer cars on the road. Fewer cars mean higher speeds and possibly, less attentive drivers given the empty lanes. Increased pedestrian fatalities would align with this simple explanation. A little searching suggests that in the latter quarters of 2021, traffic fatalities fell (https://www.nhtsa.gov/press-releases/traffic-fatalities-estimates-jan-sept-2021#:~:text=The%20fatality%20rate%20for%20the,2021%20declined%20compared%20to%202020 https://www.nhtsa.gov/press-releases/traffic-fatalities-esti....) Before we jump to the explanation of angrier drivers (harder to verify or disprove), can we explore the simpler possibility?
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- T3OU-736 5y agoI found this article a bit... odd. Not the particulars of the case. Rather, what sounds like ready excuses and what read like an almost utter lack of individual responsibility. Yes, agreed, the lockdown measures aren't fun, and yes, they mean doing things which are uncomfortable (masks), or not doing things we want (gatherings, restaurants, all other restrictions). But how is that different from just being a member of civil society? That smells like... BS. Though, the "salience saturation" concept sounds like one of the reasons for which people in the MIL world take up smoking.
- nverno 5y agoThis article seems pretty misleading. Looking at the historical trends [1], there were more pedestrian deaths per year 50 years ago. And that is before taking into account that the population has doubled since then! There is clearly an uptick in recent years, but this nyt article is trying to hard to hype it up. Coming off historical lows, around 10 years ago, the percentage yearly increase can sound more shocking than it is- same thing when crime rates reach new lows and then bounce back a bit. 1. https://www.iihs.org/topics/fatality-statistics/detail/pedestrians https://www.iihs.org/topics/fatality-statistics/detail/pedes...
- CalRobert 5y agoI suspect the number of miles walked has fallen quite a lot in the last 50 years. Like talking about how so few children are killed cycling to school without noting that close to no children cycle to school, compared to decades past.
- thaway2839 5y agoThe uptick is real. It's an uptick despite reduced driving. A 45% increase in deaths per mile driven is no joke. Further, you're also ignoring advancements in medicine, emergency services, healthcare systems, rules (e.g., cities in the US have drastically reduced max speeds), safety focused street design changes, etc. that mean that the odds of a pedestrian dying have reduced in general. Comparing broadly to 50 years ago is not very useful.
- throwaway0a5e 5y agoReduction in miles doesn't proportionally reduce exposure to pedestrians. The bulk of the mileage reduction has been people's commutes and your average commute is dominated by limited access pedestrian free roads.
- nverno 5y agoDid you look at the pedestrian deaths graph/100,000 at the bottom of that page? It's not just 'broadly to 50 years ago', the number of deaths has been decreasing, or pretty steady that whole time. Anyway, it was more just the way it was written that was annoying, like the author was trying to pull a fast one on the reader, cherry-picking stats to make a point.
- sandworm101 5y agoBut i thought that with the push towards shorter commutes werent we also seeing more pedestrians? More pedestrians = more oppertunities for accidents. We cannot get to conclusions about trending driver behaviour before a proper analysis of the underlying statistics. Also cellphones. 5g = better connectivity on the move = more distracted people driving/walking = more accidents?
- aurizon 5y agoThere is a concept in kinetics, the 'mean free path', which refers to the distance a particle travels before it hits another. With Covid = fewer cars on the road = longer MFP = higher speeds for the 'mean drivers' before they hit someone. Holland has found that the true solution is separate bike paths with dimensional hindrances so cars cannot traverse them. Here in Toronto the road stripes were found ineffective - 2000 pound concrete walled earth filled square rectangles commanded instant respect, and also serve as planters. There has been a renaissance of biking here and the government is responding - they could do better with an increase of one way streets that would allow more segregated bike paths.
- jpm_sd 5y agoI live in a dense, walkable Boston suburb that is served by the MBTA commuter rail. But it's also full of "Masshole" drivers and adjacent to a couple of high-traffic major highways. I've observed a sharp increase in impatience and road rage, both on our 25 mph city streets, and on and off Rtes 1 and 93, in the last 2 years. Not to mention ever-more inattentive driving with eyes on phones. It's pretty alarming. I don't let my kids bike around the neighborhood anymore, I'm worried they will get hit. It does feel like the one-two punch of [Trump + pandemic] has led to people feeling more entitled to let their rage and impatience out in public. I don't know how we recover from this as a society?
- ghaff 5y agoI somewhat hesitate to anecdata this in the same general area. But... For a time, I might have been inclined to put it down to people just weren't driving and had "forgotten" how. But I think that's hard to argue for at this point. I've nearly got run off the road on a merge or had a horn blown at me followed by a pass on the shoulder because I was apparently only going at the speed limit multiple times in just the past month or two. Boston area driving has been quite aggressive forever. But I don't think I've seen it this actively bad/dangerous as it has been the past year or two. (And a number of people I know have said likewise.)
- hervature 5y agoAs someone who has driven quite extensively in SF, LA, NYC, and Boston, I don't know why Bostonians are adamant that their traffic and drivers are as bad as these other cities. My #1 frustration with Boston traffic is how "polite" drivers are. Multiple times, I've had the last car in a string of cars stop at a green light to let me turn left which is probably the most infuriating/stupid thing you can do. What I will say is that Boston has a unique set of infrastructure that involves many lights and convoluted intersections (Davis Square - where 7 streets meet) where you are absolutely punished in terms of time and so I think people definitely push it around these intersections. That being said, I biked 2 miles as my commute this entire fall from Somerville to Cambridge and never encountered anything noteworthy.
- stirbot 5y agoWhile this driver appears to be facing homicide by vehicle charges in addition to fleeing the scene, it is very common in the US for a driver to kill a pedestrian and face no criminal charges or loss of driving privileges as long as they stop and dial 911. While out walking I often think of a quote from a Freakomomics podcast that goes something like 'the best way to get away will killing someone in the US is to hit them with your car'. The high rate of pedestrian deaths is a result of policy regarding road design, pedestrian infrastructure and lenient criminal charges. The driving culture is also to blame. Driving is a god given right. Cars equal freedom, and the bigger the better. Pedestrians are a nuisance and cyclists are the enemy. Vehicles sold now are too fast for their intended purpose. You can buy a Toyota Camry with 300 HP and a 0-60 time of 5.1 seconds. Twenty years ago that was Porsche 911 territory. The upcoming Hummer EV touts a 3.0 second 0-60 and weighs in at 9000 lbs. Insane
- astura 5y agoThis guy is facing vehicular homicide charges because he was driving an unregistered not street legal ATV and fled the scene. Probably also because he has a history of motor vehicle infractions too. If he were driving a legal registered pickup truck, and didn't flee (and wasn't impaired at the time) it would probably be a moving violation. It also seems to me really rare that a hit-and-run driver is ever caught. It pains me to say it but it almost seems rational to flee the scene if you were drunk.
- alistairSH 5y ago100% agree. As a cyclist, I try to stay up on local road design, planning, etc. We design our roads for maximum throughput of cars, without much consideration of other road users. 25mph roads are usually wide enough to safely travel 50mph or more. Trees are removed, which reduces the driver's sense of speed. Crosswalks are an afterthought and signaled crosswalks are a rarity outside urban cores. Bike lanes get introduced alongside 50+mph traffic with no separation. It's amazing we don't have more deaths. And disgusting we don't do better at designing safe roadway for all people.
- giantg2 5y ago
- edmcnulty101 5y agoWhy is this a reckless driving question and not a reckless pedestrian question?
- dncornholio 5y agoBecause pedestrians have the intrinsic motivation of not wanting to die. This question baffles me because where I'm from, hitting a pedestrian or biker with your car, the car driver is almost always 100% liable. And it works. Cars don't want to hit cyclists or pedestrians because they don't want to pay, and cyclists/pedestrians don't want to hit cars because they want to stay alive.
- dqv 5y ago>Because pedestrians have the intrinsic motivation of not wanting to die. Do they? Where I live, at night, no one ever wears reflectors, save a few cyclists. It seems like people don’t think about this at all. You’re walking around at night and someone driving a car doesn’t see you until it’s too late. I think there is some merit to asking the question about how pedestrians can be safer. I’m happy to practice what I preach and wear reflectors at night but it seems that pedestrians are ignorant about their visibility. You can only be so safe driving a car, it’s not feasible to drive 5mph everywhere you go.
- dncornholio 5y agoWhere are you walking around where a car might hit you though? Are there no sidewalks? Infrastructure needs to be build around pedestrians and cyclists. The youtube channel "Not Just Bikes" shows how it can be done.
- ghaff 5y agoWhen I drive in Cambridge, I find people dressed in dark clothes constantly darting out to cross streets at random locations at night. As a driver am I alert and keep my speed down? Absolutely. But many pedestrians and cyclists absolutely behave recklessly.
- CalRobert 5y agoDrivers are the leading cause of dead kids. But for some reason we completely ignore it, while focusing on gun violence (which is also bad, to be clear). I really don't know a solution aside from moving to a country that's better designed. The US seems too far gone. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ul_xzyCDT98 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ul_xzyCDT98
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- iso1631 5y agohttps://www.advisory.com/daily-briefing/2018/12/21/child-death https://www.advisory.com/daily-briefing/2018/12/21/child-dea... The researchers found that motor vehicle crashes were the leading cause of child deaths in the United States, comprising about 20% of all deaths among children in 2016. The chief reason for the crashes was cell phone use by drivers and pedestrians, the researchers found. Firearms were the second leading cause of deaths among children and adolescents in 2016, according to the researchers. Overall, there was a 28% relative increase in the rate of firearm deaths among U.S. children, likely driven by a 32% increase in firearm homicides and a 26% increase in firearm suicides, the researchers said. They found that the odds of a child being killed by a firearm are 36 times higher in the United States than in other high-income countries. About 16 children per 100k die each year in the US https://datacenter.kidscount.org/data/tables/22-child-deaths#detailed/1/any/false/1729,37,871,870,573,869,36,868,867,133/any/286,287 https://datacenter.kidscount.org/data/tables/22-child-deaths... In the UK for comparision it's about 10 per 100k https://stateofchildhealth.rcpch.ac.uk/evidence/mortality/child-mortality/ https://stateofchildhealth.rcpch.ac.uk/evidence/mortality/ch... I'm not convinced the US focuses on either gun violence or deaths from cars
- dncornholio 5y agoFunny thing is, The Netherlands used to have infra that looked more like the US once, but we almost completely rebuild all the infrastructure in our towns and cities during the 80's. It's not too late, it 'just' needs a lot of investment. The biggest problem is US culture around cars and mobility IMO. Better public transport is a nice start.
- cochne 5y agoTotally anecdotal, but I have noticed a huge uptick of drivers running red lights and stop signs in my area in NY. I have been wondering the reason.
- jeffbee 5y agoThe new thing in Berkeley and Oakland, as of about 2 years ago, is people will pull up on my right at stop lights, as if they are going to turn right, but then they just run the light instead.
- ghaff 5y agoNear my house, I have one of those horrid stoplights where there are two lanes that immediate narrow down to one lane. I've lost track of the number of times recently when drivers will not take their turn merging and turn it into a game of chicken. I've taken to just assuming the car in the other lane is going to cut me off.
- giantg2 5y agoSituations like that make me miss my caprice. Slow speed, I have the right of way, my car isn't worth anything. Go ahead, hit me.
- tetsusaiga 5y agoIt's funny, if you look in my comment history, I just made the same observation the other day. Anecdata, and all that, but it's interesting that so many people are noticing this.
- blinkingled 5y agoAnecdotally it seems to match my (and my Nextdoor neighbors') experience. As if reckless driving wasn't enough making the cars noisier is another thing that is bothersome. People buying old cars and putting money in them is yet another recent trend everywhere that even I've participated in. It's fun to pass time trying to fix older cars.
- sharikous 5y agoHere in Israel the most reckless drivers are food delivery scooters. They don't respect traffic laws, including red lights. And the pandemic has really increased their numbers.
- snird 5y agoThat's because they are paid per delivery, incentivizing them to go as fast as possible with no regards to the law. An the companies sending them will have no repercussions if the police will stop the delivery guys - making the companies care less and even encouraging this behavior.
- Steltek 5y agoYou got the same behavior from Uber drivers. They'll park wherever is closest to their fare, regardless of whether it blocks traffic, because if they don't, the fare gives them a 1-star rating. Cousin was a city cop. If he told them to move, they'd seriously just ignore him. Now ask yourself if you're going to ticket this guy and possibly suspend his livelihood when everyone else is doing it with virtual impunity? It's a messed up system.
- tim333 5y agoThough that isn't really a safety issue. Traffic congestion and bad parking is a different type of problem. In parts of London they deal with the bad Uber pickups with cameras that record it and send a parking ticket in the post.
- sporkland 5y agoAt least they are incentived by their own vulnerability to not hit or be hit by things. As opposed to your average modern car which has made the operator of an automobile super safe at the expense of pedestrians, bicycles, etc.
- jimmyvalmer 5y agoThe legal driving age for men should be raised to 40. Problem solved.
- Beltalowda 5y agoTaking average statistics of a population group and applying them to individuals is pretty much the description of discrimination. And anecdotally, I've met plenty of bonkers female drivers, too. Including two who tried to run my bicycle off the road because they felt that cyclists should not be on the road (in both cases, I was in the cycle lane).
- rahulnair23 5y agoMany causes have been put forward for this. However, I'm not sure the all safety aspects here have been well understood. Here in Dublin, Ireland the few weeks immediately after the lockdowns where horrendous for driver behaviour and aggression. It took a while till behaviours were back to the norm. It was almost as if people needed to get reacquainted with it.
- mywittyname 5y agoThat gives me hope that things may calm down in the USA.
- sbate1987 5y ago