8 ms·
What American Mental Health Care Is Missing
- haspoken 5y agohttps://archive.is/QSLpX https://archive.is/QSLpX
- ziggus 5y agoThis article does a decent job of summarizing some of the issues that face the mentally ill and pointing out that psychiatry without strong community support is almost useless. However, it's really just a subtle ad for a book, which probably just reiterates the same points in greater detail via lots of anecdotal data and case histories, points the finger at the government for not spending more money on programs designed to support the mentally ill within their communities, and doesn't provide any further concrete solutions. Hasn't this same book been written over and over again?
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- crawfordcomeaux 5y agoI agree with this perspective. Absent from this article is the recognition that the absence of all these things is rooted in American culture that is inherently uncaring, eg. Hyperindependence instead of interdependence, puritanical moralizing instead of compassionate listening, scientific certainty instead of intellectual curiosity, silent/vocal denials and blame-shifting instead of acknowledgment, engagement, accountability, and responsibility. Oh, and financial anxiety and racism. Where are the leaders talking about how they got over their financial anxiety (instead of patching/feeding it with more money) or how they're renouncing whiteness? White-body supremacy started with the lie that there are white bodies, yet even social justice warriors will try to shame me into keeping it going, instead of acknowledging people who think they're white need to stop practicing the lie if they want to get anywhere past the racism of the day. We can use white privilege to help those who don't pass for white while refusing to base our identities on literal lies. I also see these things as endemic to academia, especially in the sciences, and regard them as roots of our current replication crises, alongside capitalistic pressures.
- MWParkerson 5y agoAs the article points out, access is a huge issue. Also a culture that criminalizes rather than treats. Guess we can thank Reagan for that omnibus budget reconciliation that gutted the MHSA
- MWParkerson 5y ago[flagged]
- Loughla 5y agoThis is always missing from the arguments. Sure mental health treatment and agencies are notoriously underfunded, understaffed, and underpaid. But Mostly we have a society that views those with mental health struggles as 'less than' and not fully adults, because they can't support themselves in some fashion and contribute to the GDP (from a very 10,000 foot view). We can pay for support all we want, until society at large stops viewing these people as burdens, it's not going to really fix anything.
- s1artibartfast 5y agoTo to be fair, a big part of the solution is recognizing these people as burdens, and deciding who will carry that burden and how. The idea that some of these people will ever be self sufficient is equally a challenge.
- lazide 5y agoIgnoring that many folks in this place are not only burdens, but severely incapable of handling themselves in a way normally required for adults doesn't help the situation either. It's a sliding scale, and one that people can show up on at different points on every single day. Ignoring that a specific individual can and or is spending all or most of it in a place that would have them dead in a week without external help, or injuring innocent bystanders, just makes the problem worse. With medication and lack of compliance, some very bad cases could get from perfectly functional to that state in a day or less.
- 5y ago
- easton_s 5y agoproperty missing can not be found on undefined: americanMentalHealthCare
- ganzuul 5y agoThe issue of mental health is not new. We are interested in plant wisdom, but we are not plants and to heal we need people. http://thespiritscience.net/2014/06/16/what-a-shaman-sees-in-a-mental-hospital/ http://thespiritscience.net/2014/06/16/what-a-shaman-sees-in... What if we have it all wrong? I do love the hopeful perspective this article has.
- subpixel 5y agoThe father is on the money. I have a schizophrenic family member. It costs six figures annually to keep them in a facility - which is designed to handle a completely different type of disability - and off the street. It’s dumb luck that this facility accepts them and cares for them despite a lot of drama and irregularity. Many others have shown them the door. It’s even dumber luck that the money exists to pay for the care. If an American or someone they love winds up with a similar affliction, the chances of finding such a disaster-averting outcome are close to nil.
- rkk3 5y agoYeah, I don't know how the author can be so flippantly optimistic about existing treatment options. The system is not set up to help people get better. The medications, which have the "best track record". Have an NNT of 5-10, severe side effects, and are so strong you risk rebound psychosis if you ever stop taking them. I think they really just help the institutions to manage patients in perpetuity.
- tcj_phx 5y agoGood essay, though it's a little tilted towards the 'medical model' of mental health treatment. I appreciate the 'insight from epidemiology': "Health care itself explains only a small fraction of health outcomes. Much of what we need for better outcomes is fundamental, but it is not part of health care. Social factors [...] are much more important for health outcomes than your specific diagnosis or health-care plan." I've commented somewhat extensively about my friend's struggle with the mental health industry. They've decided she's a chronic psychotic who requires anti-psychotics for the rest of her life. A year after she was formally misdiagnosed by the mental health industry I found videos on my phone from ~2 weeks before that 2015 hospitalization. I think my videos prove that my friend's supposedly-chronic condition can be entirely explained by substance abuse. The tragedy of "American Mental Health Care" is the use of palliative drugs, when the various causes of the various diagnoses have actually been figured out by researchers. Science knows exactly how stimulants harm the metabolism [0]. The symptoms of mental illness can usually be explained as a metabolic problem - sometimes caused by substance abuse, sometimes by diet, always exacerbated by 'stress'. Emotional stress is the most important drain on the body's metabolism. I have a bunch of references from books about stress - went to the ASU science library to read a book referenced in Gabor Maté's In The Realm of Hungry Ghosts [1], and found a discussion of how 'stress' contributes to psychosis. [0] My comment/quote/submission: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18211048 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18211048 - "I learned from a Hacker News comment/submission a while ago that cocaine causes its harm by shredding the mitochondria. [searching] Ahh, found it, this one:" https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10956058 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10956058 [1] https://www.google.com/books/edition/In_the_Realm_of_Hungry_Ghosts/Oew75Hp8XP4C https://www.google.com/books/edition/In_the_Realm_of_Hungry_... In 2018, after her treatment center perpetrated fraud on the District Court, my friend got annoyed about how all the new clients at her treatment center were getting cheek-swabbed. She herself had not been cheek-swabbed when she was sent there 2 years before, and asked to have this genetic test. It revealed that she is a poor methylator, who cannot turn the provitamin folic acid (commonly used to fortify food as it is shelf-stable) into Vitamin B-9. She said that adding L-Methy-Folate to her routine was like flipping a switch from "depressed" to "not-depressed" [1]. [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27990331 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27990331 (also some good responses to my comment - search for 'histamine') The Supreme Court of the United States is going to be considering my petition soon. I'm optimistic that it will be one of the handful that they grant. All I'm asking is for them to order the district court to hold the evidentiary hearing that is required by the case law. (I'm currently working on a write-up of my experience for https://MadInAmerica.com https://MadInAmerica.com, using some tips from HN moderator dang.)
- treis 5y agoThis seems like a culture/economy wide problem. Like in my local city they're running fewer buses due to staffing issues while planning to spend $130 million on a BRT line and billions more on other capital projects. There's a huge bias towards the big bang/silver bullet solution and against the simple/mundane but effective solution.
- lazide 5y agoIt's a lot harder to graft the simple/mundane solution, and you don't get high priced consultants going around wining and dining the decision makers for it either.
- JSavageOne 5y agoI've been to 43 countries, and nowhere have I seen such a blatant abundance of mentally insane homeless people than SF, LA, and NYC. The problem is so bad that I believe it should be considered a national state of emergency, and international embarrassment. It's one of the reasons I left NYC after 5 years, and many others are as well. I'm not going to pretend like I know what the solution is, but it starts by actually addressing it as a serious problem, which the U.S has not done. I guess politicians thinks it's normal for mentally insane homeless people to be shouting to people on sidewalks everywhere, and assaulting and even murdering random pedestrians? [1] For anyone who hasn't left the U.S - this isn't normal anywhere else in the world. What a shame that the wealthiest country can't manage its cities. [1] https://nypost.com/2022/02/13/woman-stabbed-to-death-inside-nyc-apartment-cops-say/ https://nypost.com/2022/02/13/woman-stabbed-to-death-inside-...
- jdlyga 5y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Deinstitutionalisation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Deinstitutionalisation
- bastardoperator 5y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mental_Health_Systems_Act_of_1980 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mental_Health_Systems_Act_of_1... Thanks Reagan...
- api 5y agoIt wasn't just Reagan. It was also a reaction against the sometimes very real abuses and problems of the institutionalized mental health industry. A film called One Flew Over the Cuckoo's Nest help publicize the issue and generated a strong reaction against the idea of institutionalization in the US. Problem is instead of reform they just shut down the entire system. Now we have loads of people on the street who really do need continuous professional help.
- closeparen 5y agoInstitutionalization is a kind of arbitrary detention; left-leaning civil liberties types were against it too. I'm not an expert on this time period but the story I learned is that by the time Reagan defunded the hospitals they were already mostly empty, having lost the authority to hold all but the most extreme cases.
- DoreenMichele 5y agoThe article has an excellent conclusion: Health care itself explains only a small fraction of health outcomes. Much of what we need for better outcomes is fundamental, but it is not part of health care. Social factors (your zip code, not your genetic code), lifestyle (how you live, not how many medications you take), and livelihood (your work, not just your wealth) are much more important for health outcomes than your specific diagnosis or health-care plan. I was suicidal for decades. I rarely feel suicidal anymore and it's like a bad habit, a mental tic that occasionally comes back when I'm having an excessively stressful day. Eating and sleeping are usually the way to make that stop. There are two main components to mental health: physical health and social factors. To whatever degree a mental illness is treatable with medication, it can be viewed as a physical ailment with somatopsychic symptoms. But even if you can genuinely cure the physical roots, you still need to deal with negative social patterns and "habits" (for lack of a better term) that may remain after the physical roots are resolved. If you can do both things, you can actually resolve it. It's a better article than a lot I've seen. I find this piece encouraging.
- sjg007 5y agoI recently read "Unwinding Anxiety" by Dr. Judson Brewer. He's a psychiatrist and explains the habit part of negative behaviors very well and provides an approach to "unlearn" these bad habits.
- ncmncm 5y agoI was astonished when I encountered suicidal ideation as a coping strategy: "It's not so bad, I could always kill myself." Humans never fail to violate preconceptions.
- abeppu 5y agoThis focuses on the American problem, but the phrasing makes it sound like other places do better. What lessons or practices can we borrow from mental health care in other countries? Short of building a large single-payer system (which I'm guessing the US will continue to refuse to do), how do other countries make care accessible and affordable?
- lazide 5y agoIt's complicated, unfortunately. :( Many places actively hide the problem in various ways, or ship folks off to 're-education camps' from which they may not come back, or classify it so it doesn't show up so much. America seems to be pretty unique in that it lets it all hang out, front and center, and has a bunch of social activists groups running around publicizing the issue without gov't or society telling them to sit down and shut up. It also has a much worse problem, also due to the socioeconomics of how the country exists (imo), and the legal structures and social disconnectedness of it's various urban and rural areas.
- cm2012 5y agoIf other first world countries don't have this problem, what do they do? Let's just copy the ones who do it best.
- lawn 5y ago"Copy the socialists/communists? Over my dead body!"
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]