10 ms·
I think you also need to consider just what is meant by “computer science”. Is it programming? My daughter is studying comp. sci. right now and there seems to
by criddell 5y ago
I think you also need to consider just what is meant by “computer science”. Is it programming?
My daughter is studying comp. sci. right now and there seems to be a ridiculous amount of math and math proofs and very little programming in her program (she’s still in her first year). The spend a considerable amount of time proving stuff using big-O (and theta and omicron etc…) and surprisingly little time applying those ideas.
I think what you wanted (and what should be offered to everybody) is a course designed to teach programming and programming concepts.
- weaksauce 5y agocomputer science is not programming though it often involves doing that. it's a math degree with many different topics all related to computing and math. So yeah if they wanted to learn how to program java that's a completely different track. they generally don't teach you much programming or other practical things at a university track. you need to know it but it's ancillary to the degree.
- l33t2328 5y agoA computer science degree isn’t a math degree any more than a physics or chemistry degree is a math degree. Classes like Computer Organization, Operating Systems, Networking, Databases, Software Engineering Fundamentals, the first year programming sequence, etc. could hardly be considered math courses.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- thorajeu83 5y ago
- weaksauce 5y ago> Classes like Computer Organization, Operating Systems, Networking, Databases, Software Engineering Fundamentals, the first year programming sequence, etc. could hardly be considered math courses. so a math degree has to have every single course be a math course? do they not take literature? Networking had me prove the theoretical limit of networks using calculus and other things, databases had us using relational algebra and other proofs... it certainly wasn't `select * from users;` kinda course. it's a math degree at least at my university and most reputable ones it is. are all classes 100% pure math? no of course not but the emphasis is math.
- mcguire 5y agoComputer Science degrees also require literature. And some math, but not all. But then UT Austin may not be a reputable university, computer science-wise. [Certainly, they've redone the curriculum since I was there, and I don't like what they've done.]
- l33t2328 5y agoAnd a physics class will have you prove facts about momentum using calculus. A chemistry class may use basic elements of group theory, and it won’t be a “pour this chemical into that beaker” kinda course. They’re not math degrees, and neither is CS. The emphasis isn’t math in a CS program at any reputable university; the emphasis is computer science.
- fredophile 5y agoThe University of Waterloo, which came up elsewhere in the comments, is one of the top CS universities in Canada and gives out B.Math degrees with a CS major. When you say, "the emphasis is computer science" what exactly does the term "computer science" mean to you? I'm not trying to be a jerk here. I think the term "computer science" covers several related, but distinct, disciplines so it's helpful to know exactly what the other person is referring to.
- salamandersauce 5y agoMy databases course was very much a "select * from users" kinda course. Oh there was a little bit about good practice for relational DBs and what not but I wouldn't call it a math class. Obviously this is going to depend on your school, program, etc. I took a lot of math and CS besides my discrete math CS course and algorithms I wouldn't really call them math courses any more than I would economics or chemistry. Sure there's math sometimes but it's not the focus. General electives like a math major having to take a literature course is very different from a core required piece of the major being literature.
- weaksauce 5y ago> My databases course was very much a "select * from users" kinda course. to be frank that doesn't sound like a very rigorous school for computer science... that sounds more like an information science curriculum instead of a proper computer science one. I'm talking university of california style learning or the equivalent.
- fredophile 5y agoTheoretical computer science predates modern computers by decades. Everything else is just implementation details.
- l33t2328 5y agoTheoretical computer science is such a small portion of computer science that it’s a bit of a joke to pretend it’s most of the field.
- fredophile 5y agoIn the post I originally replied to you mentioned a bunch of classes. Each of them, with the possible exception of software engineering, is a small portion of computer science. You could spend your whole career as a programmer and never touch a database or networked code. Even though theoretical computer science might be a small part of CS, everyone needs to use it to some degree even if they don't realize it. Can I compute X? That's theoretical computer science. Is algorithm A faster than algorithm B? Theoretical computer science again. You also compared CS to physics and chemistry which is a bad comparison. Physics and chemistry don't have an equivalent foundation to theoretical comp sci. I'd also argue that comp sci isn't a science at all. What I do on a daily basis as a programmer is closer to plumbing than it is to science.
- mcguire 5y ago"Physics and chemistry don't have an equivalent foundation to theoretical comp sci." Either that's not true, or there are an awful lot of physicists and chemists out there wondering why they took so many math courses.
- fredophile 5y agoPhysics and chemistry use math but are not math. You can't point to an area of math and say "this is physics" or "this is chemistry." There is no chemistry without chemicals. There is no physics without physical processes. In contrast, there are areas of what we now call computer science that are math and predate computers.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- ska 5y ago> A computer science degree isn’t a math degree any more than a physics or chemistry degree is a math degree. 1 of these things isn't like the others. There are places where theoretical physics and applied math are put together, and places where CS is put with math. Upstream comment mentions Waterloo, where CS is as far as I know still part of the math faculty (e.g. multiple departments), not engineering. In that specific sense, every CS degree they give is a math degree - but other places give B.Math also. This isn't just pedantry, the reason is that the boundaries are pretty fuzzy, and don't really work with the sort of absolute line you are hoping to apply.
- ghaff 5y agoIt depends on the school to a significant degree. At some schools, CS is associated with the math department. At others it's in the engineering school and may even be some variant of a CS/EE degree.
- Retric 5y agoComputer science is programming the same way structural engineering is construction. The goal is to be able to efficiently solve non trivial problems.
- vkou 5y agoNo, a compiler is to programming as what construction is to structural engineering.
- mcguire 5y ago"It is the most common way of trying to cope with novelty: by means of metaphors and analogies we try to link the new to the old, the novel to the familiar. Under sufficiently slow and gradual change, it works reasonably well; in the case of a sharp discontinuity, however, the method breaks down: though we may glorify it with the name "common sense", our past experience is no longer relevant, the analogies become too shallow, and the metaphors become more misleading than illuminating. ... On the historical evidence I shall be short. Carl Friedrich Gauss, the Prince of Mathematicians but also somewhat of a coward, was certainly aware of the fate of Galileo —and could probably have predicted the calumniation of Einstein— when he decided to suppress his discovery of non-Euclidean geometry, thus leaving it to Bolyai and Lobatchewsky to receive the flak. It is probably more illuminating to go a little bit further back, to the Middle Ages. One of its characteristics was that "reasoning by analogy" was rampant; another characteristic was almost total intellectual stagnation, and we now see why the two go together. A reason for mentioning this is to point out that, by developing a keen ear for unwarranted analogies, one can detect a lot of medieval thinking today." -- https://www.cs.utexas.edu/~EWD/transcriptions/EWD10xx/EWD1036.html https://www.cs.utexas.edu/~EWD/transcriptions/EWD10xx/EWD103...
- Retric 5y agoI didn’t use an analogy, that requires comparing dissimilar things. Some comparisons are just literally true, for example Honda vs Acura is the same as Lexus vs Toyota. Their both high end car brands owned by a parent company that also puts out mass market cars. That’s a description of strategy not trying to extract meaning from caparison between dissimilar things.
- closeparen 5y agoComputer Science at my school had two branches, theory and systems. Discrete Math and Algorithms are just two classes out of ~17 in a major. They are the two theory classes everyone takes, but there's a whole world beyond that even in the theory track. It continues to be baffling that people on Hacker News think Algorithms == Computer Science. Personally, when I chose electives I chose systems electives: Operating Systems, Databases, Networks, Programming Languages, Graphics, etc. In these classes the bulk of the work consisted of programming in C.
- gmadsen 5y agoprogramming languages is pretty theoretical. Or at least if taught from a logic and lamba calculus view point. I suppose it could be systems if you are building a compiler or vm, but that to me is different that programming languages.
- closeparen 5y agoWe wrote some programs in lambda calculus, but I mainly remember working on an ML interpreter. Type checking, exceptions, free variables, etc.
- mcguire 5y ago"Historically, ML was conceived to develop proof tactics in the LCF theorem prover (whose language, pplambda, a combination of the first-order predicate calculus and the simply-typed polymorphic lambda calculus, had ML as its metalanguage)." -- https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ML_(programming_language) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ML_(programming_language)
- sporkland 5y agoAs with most CS stuff there's the standard split here: type theory, languages and grammars and pumping lemma on the theoretical side and recursive descent, lex/flex/yacc/bison, programming language exposure lisp, prolog, assembly, etc on the practical side. Dominance frontiers and register allocation algorithms were some of the places where they really started to intersect for me. I guess also regular languages, regular expressions and balanced parens is another place where they intersect.
- dekhn 5y agocomp sci is not programming- it's mathematics that is useful for computing. It's also not a science...
- barkingcat 5y agoan exercise of "write a function in Java that factors a quadratic." is neither computer science nor programming. The course described doesn't seem to match your description of comp sci either. Which matches my experience of a technical course in Waterloo. They need to update their pedagogy.
- saurik 5y ago^ This is the best comment of all the various replies, as it directly addresses the actual content of the thread: it wasn't that "oh no I had to spend so much time learning the mathematical basis of computer programming and I just wanted to throw together a shopping cart in Ruby" it was "most of my time was wasted learning about the task I was given as the goal of the program--which happened to be math but could have been something inane like the physics of a roller-coaster--instead of about the meta-task of how to actually analyze, automate, or implement arbitrary tasks".
- baq 5y agoThe problem is, people don’t learn well when they’re taught general things and are told to specialize on their own. People learn best from examples and then generalize using their general purpose jumping to conclusions machine called the brain. I agree simple math problems may not be the best exercises to program, but the point is you should be doing a lot of such specific (but diverse) exercises to get the general idea.
- feoren 5y ago> ridiculous amount of math and math proofs ... [vs.] a course designed to teach programming and programming concepts Math, big-O, and proofs are programming concepts. If you want a shallow understanding of whatever programming languages and frameworks are in vogue this year so you can be handed down constrained requirements in a code mill where you are evaluated on how many lines of code you write per day, take a coding bootcamp. But know that after a few years your skills will be out of date and you will have a hard time keeping up with the field. If you want to solve hard problems that haven't been solved before, pay attention to that math and those proofs. I'm honestly just sick of people complaining about CS degrees for not spending enough time teaching React JS or Ruby on Rails. CS degrees are for people who want to solve problems that are actually hard and new. Seriously, do we ever hear physics majors complaining that they have to learn all this math that they're never going to use, in order to study the foundational cosmology of the universe? Why don't they just show me how to work the damn telescope!?
- peterangular 5y agoThis is exactly why I think the distinction between computer science and computer engineering is incredibly important.
- chaosite 5y agoYeah, Computer Engineering is that twilight area between Computer Science and Electrical Engineering where you care that your algorithm is PSPACE-complete but also need to know how it's affected by parasitic capacitance, right?
- anfilt 5y agoLol made me laugh, that is one way to say it.
- anfilt 5y agoI went to school for computer engineering. It's a hybrid of EE and CS. It's not a not a programming only degree.
- jacobolus 5y agoComputer science is a (poorly named) branch of mathematics. Expecting it to primarily teach programming practice per se is like expecting a biology degree to consist primarily of practical medical training. (Of course CS is helpful for programming, just as biology is helpful for medicine.)
- criddell 5y agoThere’s more than one type of program. Some schools have developed CS programs that follow an engineering-type syllabus.
- dlsa 5y agoI've taught 10 year olds to program. I have no idea where this need for complex math and that supposed requirement in programming comes from. Those kids have built all sorts of things. Non-trivial things. They haven't even studied algebra yet.
- analog31 5y agoAs others have mentioned, CS is not programming. My mom taught programming at a community college. I learned programming in high school. I think that some of the paradoxes of CS vs programming have to do with a single academic discipline trying to serve conflicting needs, such as: 1. Teaching programming to students who have never programmed before. This is handled differently by different fields. For instance math majors are expected to have a fair amount of high school math in the bag before starting college, but psychology majors have rarely taken psychology in high school. 2. Students with an actual interest in CS itself as a field of study. 3. Students who know that they want to get a college degree in something but are hoping for a career in programming. 4. Competitive students who know that CS is the "hot" major right now. And high school guidance counselors are pretty much in the dark about it. On the other hand, every college major teaches you more stuff than you will use at your first entry level job. "Why do we need to learn this" is a constant refrain. For instance most engineers will never use their college math after college. For me, way back in 1982, I skipped CS altogether and studied applied programming by majoring in math and physics.
- another_story 5y agoComputer science is not programing, though. Programming is the tool used to do computer science in the same way a science lab is filled with tools to do science. You have to learn the underlying CS principles.
- spiffytech 5y agoThere are lots of "computer science is not programming" comments here, which I agree with - it's a theory curriculum, and there's a reason universities now offer a separate degree in Software Engineering. But my experience was that you can get a long ways into a Computer Science degree before anyone tells you that you're studying the wrong thing for career prep. It reminds me of a student I saw who was in Electrical Engineering because he wanted to be an electrician. The university was happy to take his money, and nobody told him he was in the wrong place. It's important for teenagers to have guidance when choosing the educational path that's right for them. I know that at 17 I was extremely ignorant about Computer Science vs Software Engineering vs Computer Engineering. They all sound the same when you're inexperienced, just know you like computers, and don't know anyone who understands the difference.
- Izikiel43 5y agoThe course is computer science, not computer engineering. Comp Sci is mostly about algorithms, data structures, big O, graphs and proofs. Programming is secondary. Source: Comp Sci major
- ajijwww 5y agoThis is the greatest folly of people getting into programming. When I was in school for CS the dropout rate was precipitous basically until your junior year. This is a good thing in my opinion. The truth is computer science is the science of computation not how to perform specific computation. General CS education follows the line of most STEM degrees, minus the degree for more advanced math like PDEs except when you're in a specialized scientific computing sub-degree. We all had to take 3 semesters of calculus, 2 semester of discrete math, and one semester of probability. ALL of these are important to various fields of CS. Programming is rarely discussed. Most ABET programs give you one to two semesters warm up and that's the last time you see programming except for a few elective courses. Programming is a means to an end for a CS major. Once your algorithm is verified mathematically on paper you head over to the terminal to implement it and play around. Programming first then designing is like a mechanical engineer building a car and then drawing the blueprints. The vast, vast majority of computer science even today can be done on paper (with enough paper, of course). programming is a means to an end. If you want to be a programmer get a job out of high school because it takes virtually nothing except drive to succeed. Getting a CS degree for the purpose of being a programmer is like getting a mechanical engineering degree to be a machinist. Sure, you can do machining. Just like you can do programming as a CS major. But the CS degree is so, so, so much more than programming. Everything your daughter is learning w.r.t. math, logic, proofing, etc is CRITICAL to the generalization of ideas into algorithms that are language and implementation dependent. A mathematically verified pure algorithm can be implemented anywhere, by anyone, at any time not unlike a complicated math formula. This is why the weed out is a good thing. People who just want to be programmers leave the program and become programmers. No sense in wasting time in a CS degree if your aspirations are to become <language> expert.